12 Biggest Missed Opportunities In Gaming History

P.T. could've been the one, the all, the EVERYTHING.

SILENT HILLS pt
Konami

Thanks to the wonderful world of video games being one of the most lucrative of all entertainment mediums, there are always thousands upon thousands of ideas being given the green light, getting cancelled, receiving funding or otherwise passing in and out of the ether. The vast majority eventually find their way into being in some form or another, but there are plenty industry decisions, storyline possibilities and more that completely miss the mark.

And I do mean, completely.

We gamers are a fickle bunch, rather like a more far-reaching, never-forgetting continuation of the high school mentality that means if you mess up, we'll never let you forget it. A bad ending? A botched launch? It doesn't matter. If your game is markedly bad in any respect, that's a reputation tarnished forevermore.

So, whether it be a spectacular misreading of the tea leaves or a creative endeavour that went down like a led balloon once the general public got involved, here are the 12 biggest missed opportunities this industry has ever seen.


12. No Man's Sky

No Man's Sky
Hello Games

The world's first 'open-galaxy' game, No Man's Sky would - thanks to endless computational algorithms and formulas - generate around 18 quintillion planets, all unique, all bursting with specific lifeforms, sights to see, caves to plunder and mysteries to unravel.

We'd be able to meet up and see each other, though it would be a rarity, and occasionally we might even partake in a space dogfight or two, pillaging the rewards for ourselves as we work towards building a better ship, a better suit and a better chance at survival.

At launch, none of these things came true. It was revealed through data-mining that the code necessary for players to meet didn't exist, you saw the same 'types' of creatures within a few hours of one another, what was at the centre of the universe was a giant reset button - it just went on and on.

In fact, it was summed up best, in this elegant video:


11. Pokémon GO

Pokemon Go
Nintendo

Sometimes the stars align just to collide and create a black hole, as not only did we have No Man's Sky being a colossal misfire, but Pokémon GO went from being a bonafide social phenomenon, to losing millions of followers in the following months after launch.

And why? Because Niantic removed the game's tracking feature - the literal core component that let you catch Pokémon in the wild. It was down to a number of third-party sites hacking PoGo's guts to create real-time maps of where all the creatures were, which the developers just didn't think was very sporting.

Niantic would take months to implement anything of a workaround, all the while we suffered server outages and bad connections across the board. It didn't stop millions enjoying what Pokémon GO was SUPPOSED to be (because when it did work, it was outstanding), but the app's rise and fall took place across a total of around six weeks.

It hurts to see potential that phenomenal go to waste.


10. Star Wars 1313

star wars 1313
Disney

Telling the story of a young Boba Fett on Coruscant, Star Wars 1313 was set to be the stuff of dreams. There's also the fact it looked absolutely stunning, the footage that came out of E3 2012 still holding up perfectly today with fantastic environmental effects, character models and a high production value throughout.

Combat was set to to apply the Gears of War stop n' pop cover system to great effect, having laser fire whiz over your head at every opportunity.

Anyone who played the excellent Jango Fett-fronted Star Wars: Bounty Hunter - a brilliant blaster in its own right - will remember just how much fun the genre can be within the Star Wars universe, and combining standard third-person combat with things like dragging enemies over cover and engaging in Uncharted-style platforming sequences had mouths watering on both sides of the fan-fence.

Sadly, despite tons of positive press, 1313 was cancelled along with every other in-progress LucasArts project when Disney bought them out, relegating the idea to the "Maybe it'll show up at an E3 some day" bins of pure speculation.


9. The Xbox One

Xbox One
Microsoft

Microsoft are in the weirdest position right now. Having come off the back of the generation-dominating 360, employing a team of newbies to develop the Xbox One - resulting in a cataclysmic failure of epic proportions - and scrabbling to stop their brand falling into total disarray for the last three years, they face an industry climate that just might not welcome the Scorpio whatsoever.

Because after all, do you know anybody on this Earth that bought a PS4 Pro?

It comes back to the current generation's consoles never having the power where it counts from day one. Sony were able to paper over this rather large crack with solid marketing and the occasional exclusive, but Microsoft - after going in hard with all the 'Kinect-controlled TV is the future' bullpoop - have slowly bolted features back onto the Xbox One, hoping to the Lord himself that the tides eventually turn.

To some degree, they have. The Xbox One S is a more solid machine on the hardware side, yet its dashboard is still a total mess. Still, alongside the PS4 - which now has Uncharted 4, Nioh, Ratchet & Clank and more - there's the realisation that once we see the pivot into supporting the Scorpio, the Xbox One might be the biggest console failure since the Wii U.


8. Shenmue

Shenmue game
Sega

The world's first triple-A game, Shenmue was given a bank-straining budget reported to be $70 million, though creator Yu Suzuki would later state the figure was closer to $47 million. Either way - and despite still selling over a million copies - the game just couldn't quite make the big time.

Whether it was the stilted voice acting - something standards had been raised on thanks to the likes of Metal Gear Solid - the awkward combat or plethora of distracting minigames that ruined its overall focus, Suzuki's team appeared to prioritise everything other than fun gameplay loops and replayability.

Shenmue was a bold, somewhat necessary step for immersion and controllability in video games as a medium, it's just a shame all that work and solid critical response couldn't translate into a worthwhile reputation.

Here's to Shenmue III, because who knows what the hell that's going to like in the end.


7. Mass Effect 3's Ending

Mass Effect 3 ending
Bioware

Possibly the worst video game ending of all time - if we take hype, expectation and lying to the public into account - Bioware's trilogy-capper of a finale remains a blot on the otherwise five-star Mass Effect franchise.

Coming after years of speculation as to just how the grand tale of Shepard, his crew and humanity versus the unstoppable threat of the Reaper invasion would go, we were told it categorically wouldn't be "an A, B or C ending".

And do you know what they gave us? A raw, straight-up, absolutely bonafide 'A, B, C ending'.

Quite literally the same scene with a smattering of coloured filters applied to create different-looking explosions, the feedback was so cataclysmically negative, Bioware issued free DLC to quell the backlash, lost almost every key employee who worked on the project as they all abandoned ship in the years that followed, and stayed away from the Mass Effect name for almost half a decade until things finally simmered a little.

Whether Mass Effect Andromeda turns everything around is quite simply whether or not this franchise makes it out of 2017 alive.


6. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5

tony hawk's pro skater 5
Activision

You thought Pokémon GO encouraged us to leave the house? Tony Hawk's had millions of gamers taking up skateboarding from scratch, watching the X-Games, looking into Tony Hawk's career and knowing the difference between a kickflip and a Benihana.

Naturally, with great sales power comes a great many sequels, and Mr. Hawk would lend his name to any number of spin-offs, ranging from plastic skateboard accessories to Jackass stunt-infused prank-a-thons. When it was finally announced that the Hawkster was returning to a numbered instalment - the first in 13 years - we thought both he and Robomodo would just play to the age-old formula, and all would be well.

Oh, how wrong we were.

THPS 5 immediately felt dated, and releasing in the same year as Metal Gear Solid V and The Witcher 3 didn't help matters. Adding a new 'instant-drop' button that also doubled as your grind was pure insanity, leaving Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5 do to about as much for your childhood as the new Ghostbusters reboot.


5. Metal Gear Solid V's Story

metal gear solid V phantom pain
Konami

The gameplay of MGS V? Absolutely, 100% spectacular, a genuine new benchmark for open-world interaction, complete with some of the best graphics seen this generation.

The story though? Eeesh. And I'm one of the biggest Metal Gear fans around.

Sadly, come the close of The Phantom Pain, behind the scenes infighting between Hideo Kojima and Konami was too much, forcing a schedule that left an ending with a number of plot threads dangling in the open air.

Despite the fact MGS V was sold as the 'missing link' between the older canon and the new, fans expected to see the advertised "Downfall of Big Boss", which in the actual game, was nowhere to be found.

In the end, everything from swapping out David Hayter for Kiefer Sutherland to Quiet's implementation, the insane resurrection of Colonel Volgin and the lack of a proper ending compounded to make The Phantom Pain the weirdest instalment in MGS' history for all the wrong reasons.


4. Gotham By Gaslight

Batman gotham by gaslight
DC

One of the coolest potential projects in gaming history, at one point we were set to get a Batman set entirely in an old-school steampunk setting.

Developed by Day 1 Studios and based on the original novel by Brian Augustyn and Mike Mignola which sees Batman take on Jack the Ripper, it got as far as the prototype stage, only to be canned as it can only be assumed Warner Bros. prioritised Rocksteady's output instead.

Looking to play much like the Arkham titles eventually would, Gotham by Gaslight would also incorporate a one-button toggle for slow-motion, allowing you to plan various moves and 'think like Batman' in any given situation, before dominating foes with a slew of modified weapons.

Every aspect of the game was assembled from the ground-up to be a far more original take on the Bat - especially in the gaming realm - and it remains that a steampunk, clockwork Dark Knight would be extraordinary.


3. The 'Nintendo PlayStation'

Nintendo Playstation Original Console
Sony

It's hard to imagine a world where Sony and Microsoft are one, but way back before the PlayStation even existed, creator and visionary Ken Kutaragi was working with Nintendo to produce a hybrid 'Nintendo PlayStation' - something that would've no doubt gone on to rule the medium forevermore.

Sadly, the project fell apart when the two parties couldn't agree on how such a system would split its revenue (being it would play Nintendo cartridges and Sony's own CDs), leaving gamers to speculate on a world where the likes of Crash Bandicoot and Mario co-exist in the same universe.

To be fair, competition has bred excellence as Sony, Microsoft and Nintendo strive to impress because their contemporaries are doing the same. This is easily one of the biggest missed opportunities in gaming, but one that worked out for the better.


2. P.T.

silent hills
Konami

Announced anonymously during an E3 conference, P.T. may have just been a tech demo, but in just a couple of hours of exploration, world-building and outright terrifying scares, this precursor to Silent Hills became the stuff of legend.

And why? Because outside of the immaculate tone, we had both Hideo Kojima and Guillermo del Toro collaborating on all sorts of monster designs and project ideas, alongside The Walking Dead's Norman Reedus heading up the lead role.

After Konami decided they were more interested in Pachinko machines than video games, Silent Hills was cancelled and removed it from the PlayStation Store in the end, meaning this collaboration is doomed to live on in the hard drives of those who downloaded and kept it at the time.

Maybe some day we'll get a Kojima/Del Toro collaboration, but sadly, it will never be under the Silent Hill branding.


1. The Wii U

nintendo wii u
Nintendo

Here's the thing with the Wii U: It's actually a pretty awesome system - one that you can play from your couch without even turning on the TV, as the console will beam everything to the tablet for a variety of titles. It's backwards compatible with Wii games, can play all sorts of old-school Nintendo classics - including a healthy SNES library - and is home to some of the finest HD remakes of all time (The Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker, anyone?).

That said though, Nintendo did absolutely f*ck all promoting these features. Instead they seemed content for the masses to think the Wii U was an add-on to the Wii, whilst letting its considerably healthy catalogue of titles fall by the wayside.

For all intents and purposes, yes, its Gamepad is very clunky, but it's still a satisfying and enjoyable system to get to grips with - one that lets you build up one hell of a library of games from across Nintendo's legendary back catalogue.

Maybe the Switch will do it better, but considering even that already has its problems, we'll have to wait and see.

--

What do you think are the biggest missed opportunities in gaming? Let us know in the comments!


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.