12 Most Overrated Video Games Of 2017
Come on, they're not THAT good.

"Overrated" is admittedly something of a nebulous term when it comes to entertainment critique, as it can so often be a lazy substitute for "I hyped myself up too much" or "this game just isn't for me."
However, these 12 video games, some of the most acclaimed and talked about from the last 12 months, had their esteem unquestionably blown out of proportion throughout 2017.
Whether lauded as Game of the Year contenders or merely praised as great games, each of these titles fell short of the over-enthusiastic praise, and while the majority of them are at least good games, critics and players alike got a little carried away with their plaudits.
You'll probably disagree with at least a few entries on this list, and that's the beauty of opinions, but even if you're a strong proponent of any of these games, you might want to think long and hard about whether or not they really deserve all the hyperbole and fanboy foaming...
12. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy

Uncharted: The Lost Legacy was a fun, well-paced adventure romp which benefited hugely from its gorgeous visuals and the chemistry between leads Chloe and Nadine.
However, it's also ultimately a sprint through the series' greatest hits and not a great deal more, with monotonous gunplay being peppered amid the far more entertaining platforming, exploration and puzzle-solving sequences.
Asav is also one of the series' lower-tier villains, and a lot of the action beats felt effectively recycled from prior entries into the franchise.
It's a fun game that's sensibly shorter than the bloated, overlong Uncharted 4, but given the praise it received, you'd think it brought something truly fresh and unique to the table. It's an enjoyable rental, a popcorn blast you'll mostly forget a week later, and that's basically it.
11. Friday The 13th: The Game

From the player response to Friday the 13th: The Game, you'd think it was a well-engineered asymmetrical video game that had scored solid critical acclaim.
Unfortunately, though the appeal of playing as Jason Voorhees speaks for itself, Friday the 13th's glitch-filled, repetitive gameplay loop quickly sours after a few hours, and you might've eventually found yourself resorting to team-killing just to liven things up a bit (though not anymore, because a patch eventually removed TK-ing completely).
The game scored a middling 61 on Metacritic, which is honestly much more than it deserves considering how cheaply it's clearly been assembled, no matter that it's evidently made by people with a real love for the franchise.
There's definitely a version of this game which could be worthy of the fandom it enjoys, but in its present state, it's a depressingly janky mess.
10. Sonic Mania

Sonic Mania is proof perfect of how lowered expectations can boost a game's esteem far beyond what it really deserves. The first majorly acclaimed Sonic game in many years, Mania is a highly enjoyable love letter to classic Sonic, though should really be docked a few points for borrowing far too generously from its better instalments.
The vast majority of the game's levels are "remixes" of stages from the earlier, better games in the series, ensuring it ultimately takes a safer, lazier approach than actually crafting a full suite of engaging new levels.
Sega is as aware as anyone of the pull of nostalgia, and they cynically exploited that to a highly successful degree with this game. It's not that Sonic Mania is in any way a bad game, but did it really deserve such giddy praise?
Also, the obnoxious save system - which hurls you all the way back to Act 1 if you get a Game Over - is infuriating in a 2017 release.
9. Super Mario Odyssey

Now, there is no doubting that Super Mario Odyssey is a great game, perhaps even an excellent one, but if you go by its Metacritic score of 97, it's one of the best video games of all time. It's great fun and all, but...really?
Where to begin? The camera has its issues, the motion controls are more irritating than fun, certain gameplay elements feel repetitive (especially the boss fights), the Broodals are irritating, co-op could be better, it's arguably overly reliant on nostalgia, and just where the hell is Luigi?
Odyssey is a flawed but highly enjoyable game, yes, but from the near-universal acclaim it's received, you'd think it was doing something truly remarkable and unique with the Mario formula, which it ultimately isn't.
8. Pyre

It's fair to say that expectations were high for Pyre coming out of the gate, considering it came from Supergiant Games, the developers behind the brilliant Bastion and Transistor.
To their credit, Pyre is a bold mix of RPG and sports game, melding whimsical adventure elements with a rugby-like battle-sports mechanic that's incredibly alluring...at least at first.
Unfortunately, after a few hours, the sheen quickly wears off and Pyre simply feels too shallow and repetitive, with limited interaction throughout the game's lush world.
It's certainly not a bad game, but given its status as one of 2017's most overlooked gems, you'd hope for something a little more involved with greater depth below its gorgeous surface.
7. Horizon Zero Dawn

For many, Horizon Zero Dawn isn't just the best PS4 exclusive released in 2017, but the best new IP for any platform over the past year.
It is a beautiful, highly entertaining open-world action-adventure game, that much is clear, but ultimately, protagonist Aloy is far more appealing than the plot and gameplay surrounding her.
There is a masterpiece of a game within Horizon bursting to emerge, but it's hampered by woefully repetitive quests, laughable voice acting and facial animations, and a surprisingly dull narrative that's doled out in thoroughly uninspired fashion.
Battling robots is awesome and the game is an absolutely eye-melting experience played in 4K, but it's far too beholden to open-world bloat to be a truly excellent title, and the sequel desperately needs to improve its myriad flaws.
6. L.A. Noire Remastered

When L.A. Noire Remastered was first announced for PS4, Xbox One, Nintendo Switch and PC, it was met with a chorus of enthusiasm, as many presumably forgot just how tedious Team Bondi's 1940s-set noir action game really was.
Though L.A. Noire arrived back in 2011 on a tidal wave of hype, it ultimately fell far short of the mark due to its repetitive, tiresome detective gameplay, awful driving and shooting mechanics and bloated 20-hour campaign. It scored shockingly positive reviews from critics at the time, though its esteem has fallen somewhat in the years since release.
The remaster makes these flaws glaringly apparent once again, yet the game still received mostly strong notices from the gaming press and fans alike. Needless to say, those playing the game for the first time last year or revisiting it with rose-tinted glasses may have been surprised by just how much of a slog it really is.
There are moments of greatness, sure, and the voice acting is beyond reproach, but with so many appealing elements, L.A. Noire really should've been so, so much better.
5. Rime

Every year there are a handful of indie games that want to be the next Journey or Limbo but ultimately fall far short of the mark. Rime is one such effort, a seemingly beautiful, poignant exploration adventure game, but despite its admirable 80 Metascore, it was one of 2017's most dull and uninspired indie disappointments.
With simplistic puzzles, chore-like gameplay, inconsistent visuals and an airless narrative, Rime didn't even begin to deserve the praise it received. It is a shockingly superficial creation and a prime example of how not all "minimalist" indie games translate to thought-provoking experiences.
And let's not even get started on that dumpster fire of a Switch port...
4. What Remains Of Edith Finch

With an impressive Metascore of 88, Giant Sparrow's What Remains of Edith Finch is the big indie darling of 2017, an intriguing "experience" of a game that's nevertheless a little too piecemeal to be genuinely great in its own right.
Many will disagree, clearly, but considering how long the game spent in the oven, coming five years after the studio's previous effort The Unfinished Swan, it's fair to say that many fans were expecting a much larger and more expansive title.
Clocking in at only around two hours, Edith Finch told a poignant story at a premium asking price, considering we live in an age where the "price of a movie ticket" analogy no longer holds water with VOD services like Netflix changing things up.
It's a heartfelt, gorgeous game at times, but you'd be well within reason to have expected a more substantial title after five years in development.
3. Tekken 7

Once upon a time, the Tekken franchise could do little wrong, but in recent years, its relevance has declined, and Tekken 7 is only the latest, sad indication of that fact.
The game leaves a sour taste from the outset, what with its painfully malnourished story mode, which is laughably piecemeal, especially when compared to the full-fat story mode of, say, Injustice 2.
The core gameplay is fine enough, but where's the sense of fun and personality that defined the second and third game in the series in particular? The franchise has lost its groove, yet even considering how low-effort the game feels, it still snagged a bafflingly respectable 82 Metascore.
2. The Legend Of Zelda: Breath Of The Wild

Don't go grabbing those pitchforks just yet. There is little point disputing that The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild is a terrific game and well-deserving of its myriad Game of the Year awards, but things got a little out-of-hand when so many rushed to deem it not only one of the best games ever made, but perhaps even the very best video game ever.
As gorgeous as it looks and as satisfying as the moment-to-moment gameplay is, there are undeniable issues: the weapon degradation mechanic is infuriating, the story is nothing, too much of the core gameplay loop feels repetitive, the combat is disappointingly simplistic and the open-world feels oddly empty at times.
It's a testament to the game's overall thrall that it can overcome most of these flaws and still deliver an excellent experience, but the number of outlets that jumped to award the game 10/10s and call it an Earth-shattering game-changer was nothing short of ridiculous.
1. PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds

And finally, we come to probably the most influential video game of 2017, but also the most disappointing. PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds popularised the Battle Royale video game with its much-imitated big-scale 100-player mayhem, but it's also plagued by a litany of technical issues which hold it back from realising its full potential.
Even with it being officially released at the end of last year, PUBG is still rife with bugs and horribly optimised for even well-oiled PCs, to say nothing of the botched Xbox One launch. That even meaty rigs can struggle to play the game above 30 FPS is infuriating for a game that, at its core, is so much damn fun.
Ultimately, though, many may simply opt to jump to the less-demanding thrills of any one of its numerous imitators, most popularly Fortnite, which is free-to-play, more visually appealing than PUBG (with its more cartoonish style) and actually runs worth a damn.
Perhaps one day PUBG will be whipped into workable shape for a wider audience, but at present it doesn't nearly begin to live up to its incredible potential (at least for those without a rig powerful enough to brute-force good performance out of it).
Which 2017 video games do you find the most overrated? Shout them out in the comments!