12 Video Games Created By Accident

Bioshock's genius was an accident.

bioshock game
2K

It's interesting how some of the most influential and popular aspects of gaming weren't meant for this world.

Fog was inserted into Silent Hill, not to build tension, but to hide processing limitations. Stealth was never meant to play a part in Metal Gear. Space Invaders created the concept of a difficulty curve by mistake!

But it gets weirder. There have been times where developers devised a video game... without meaning to. At first, it might be hard to wrap your head around such a statement. How can a developing team spend months on a gaming project without realising it? Were they being mind-controlled??

It may sound silly, but it does happen. (Not the mind-control part.) Sometimes, developers will stumble upon a cool mechanic while playing around with software, encouraging them to create an entire game around it. In the eleventh hour, developers might decide to revise central characters, plot lines, levels, or the genre itself. Games can be tweaked so often, the finished product has no resemblance to how it started.

Even though many games on this list went on to great success, their existence was an accident.

12. DOOM

Doom Aliens
Microsoft / Sega

It's genuinely challenging to comprehend how influential Doom was, not just to the gaming community, but to the whole world. In 1995, Doom wasn't just the best-selling game, but the best-selling software. (It even outsold Windows 95.) Some people bought a PC solely to play this masterful FPS. Certain businesses reprogrammed their computers so Doom couldn't run, because employees kept playing it instead of working!

And yet, Doom could've been very, very different. Shortly after id Software was formed, co-founder, John Romero, convinced his team to work on a grisly monster-filled shooter called Green and Pissed. (It was a working title.)

As the project started taking shape, id Software realised it had many similarities to James Cameron's movie, Aliens. Believing they could turn the game into a movie tie-in, the developers tried to cut a deal with 20th Century Fox.

When these plans fell through, id Software rejigged everything, turning the project into a new IP called Doom. When you think about it, the busted deal worked out for everyone, since it gave id Software far more freedom with the game, allowing them to create the most influential first-person shooter of all time.


11. Ninjabread Man

Ninjabread Man
Data Design Interactive

In Ninjabread Man, our crumbly hero must protect his tasty homeland from a horde of evil (but delicious) cupcake monsters.

On the surface, Data Design's game looks like a cute little platformer. But save for the witty title, Ninjabread Man is irredeemably awful. Because it suffers from relentless glitches, unresponsive controls, and an unbearable frame-rate, it's borderline unplayable. Also, you can beat the whole thing in 15 minutes! The developers put so little effort into Ninjabread Man, you'd swear they didn't want to make it.

Technically, that's kinda true. Ninjabread Man started off as the third instalment in Zool - a 2D platformer for the Amiga. Though this gremlin from the Nth dimension was once regarded as Sonic's rival, he quickly vanished into obscurity.

Hoping to revitalising the property, Data Design showed a tech demo of Zool to Zoo Digital Publishing, who own the rights for the character. Zoo wasn't impressed by the pitch, urging them to reject Data Design's offer.

Since the project was too far into development to pull the plug, the developers reworked Zool 3 into a new IP, Ninjabread Man.


10. Super Smash Bros.

Super Smash Bros. Dragon King Prototype
Nintendo

Considering Super Smash Bros. could've been nothing more than a gimmick, it's bizarre how it became the best-selling fighting series ever.

Although Smash Bros. owes its success to its unique combat system and precise controls, its the branding that turned into it a towering success. The fact you could play as Pikachu, Sonic, Solid Snake, and dozens of other iconic characters helped cement Smash Bros.' legacy.

I mean, could you imagine how Smash would've turned out if it had ZERO recognisable characters?

Weirdly, that was the original idea. Back in 1998, Masahiro Sakurai was working on a four-player co-op fighting game called Kakuto Gemu Ryou (which translates into "Dragon King: The Fighting Game.")

When future Nintendo president, Satoru Iwata, had a look at Dragon King, he thought it was too generic. To make it leave a bigger impression, Iwata suggested replacing the combatants with Nintendo characters.

Worried Nintendo overallwouldn't be on board with this idea, Sakurai took Iwata's advice behind the company's back! When he presented his project to the higher-ups, they were surprised to see their mascots beating the crap out of each other.

Fortunately, they loved the presentation, and gave Sakurai permission to incorporate Nintendo characters. With that, Super Smash Bros. was born.


9. Fighting Force

fighting force
Eidos

After Streets of Rage 3 was released, fans could've never anticipated they would have to wait a quarter of a century for a sequel. Considering SOR was a cornerstone for beat 'em ups during the 90s, you'd think Sega or some other development team would get cracking with Streets of Rage 4 sooner.

But here's the thing - they technically did.

Core Design pitched a new Streets of Rage instalment directly to Sega's CEO, Bernie Stolar. Annoyingly, the proposal was dismissed, since Stolar never heard of the series... despite being in charge of the company who created it.

Instead of giving up, Core Design decided to craft their own beat 'em up called Fighting Force. Despite not having SOR's branding, there was a lot of hype for this title, since it was made by the same guys behind Tomb Raider.

Unfortunately, this Streets of Rage clone was ripped apart for its repetitive gameplay, uncreative character designs, and the fact it was clearly a Streets of Rage clone. In hindsight, it was a blessing Fighting Force wasn't an official Streets of Rage follow-up, as it would've tarnished the franchise's reputation.


8. Banjo-Kazooie

Banjo Kazooie
Microsoft

Banjo-Kazooie is a 3D platformer where the titular bear and bird must defeat an evil witch and rescue Banjo's sister.

When you hear that premise, you would NEVER believe it started off as a SNES title called Dream: Land of the Giants, centred around a boy, a dog, and a parrot battling pirates.

Not only was the stories chalk and cheese, the style and genre were completely different as well. Rather than being a platformer, Dream was envisioned as an isometric RPG. By using ACM technology, Dream would've had graphics akin to Donkey Kong Country, but to a higher degree.

When Rare got their first glimpse of Super Mario 64, they realised 3D platformers were the future of gaming, compelling them to turn Dream into a similarly-structured title for the N64. Believing a human character looked too generic in three dimensions, Rare changed Dream's protagonist into a rabbit.

After a few days, they reworked the lead character again into the backpack-wearing bear, Banjo. Although the developers wanted Banjo to be agile like Mario, they thought an acrobatic grizzly would look weird. After some brainstorming, Rare decided to give Banjo a partner, a bird called Kazooie, who would pull off the more nimbler techniques.

When you look back, the only thing Dream and Banjo-Kazooie had in common was... they were both games.


7. The Legend Of Zelda: Link's Awakening

Link's Awakening
Nintendo

Since every Legend of Zelda spends years in development, you'd safely assume each character, mechanic, and area is examined and reworked meticulously. As such, it doesn't seem feasible for a Zelda game to come by chance.

And yet, that's what happened with Link's Awakening. Kazuaki Morita, who worked on the first two LoZ instalments, was hired as an object programmer on A Link to the Past. In his spare time, he would use a Game Boy development kit to tinker with another Zelda-like title.

Because this was an unsanctioned project, Morita never thought his little hobby would materialise into anything major. As such, he inserted many non-Zelda traits into his game, including the Chain Chomp from Super Mario and Wart from Doki Doki Panic.

When Nintendo saw Morita's work, they knew it had potential, and so, agreed to release it as an official Legend of Zelda. This instalment, which became Link's Awakening, was a financial and critical success, winning two Golden Joystick Awards and spawning a 3D remake in 2019, which was also met with universal acclaim.

Not bad for something that started off as a pet project.


6. Star Fox Adventures

Star Fox Adventures
Nintendo

During its inception, Star Fox Adventures had no connection with... um...Star Fox. Originally, it was a new IP called Dinosaur Planet, which was set to be released on the Nintendo 64.

Lead developer of Rare, Kevin Bayliss, explained how the game was meant to centre around a tiger called Timber, who had been transported to a prehistoric world. Over time, the developers repurposed Timber for Diddy Kong Racing, and had him replaced with two main protagonists, Sabre and Krystal. According to head programmer, Phil Tossell -

"You could actually swap at any time between the two by speaking to Swapstone characters. Originally Krystal also had a sidekick character called Kyte - similar to Tricky in the final game, but a pterodactyl that could fly. The story was also quite different."

After Dinosaur Planet was revised for the Gamecube, Star Fox creator, Shigeru Miyamoto, looked at the beta to see how it was coming along. When he noticed the similarities between Sabre and Star Fox, he convinced (or forced) Rare to turn Dinosaur Planet into a Star Fox instalment, much to the developers' dismay.

So, if you wondered why Star Fox Adventures feels like two games smushed together, it's because that's exactly what it is.


5. ZombiU

ZombiU Game
Ubisoft

ZombiU was a first-person survival horror, originally released for the Wii U. The game was similar to the House of the Dead series, but with more emphasis on elaborate means to dispose of the undead. Not only could you shoot the flesh-eaters to death with a good-old fashioned pistol, you could whack them with a crowbar, a crossbow, a shovel, or a cricket bat.

Throughout your playthrough, you're sure to see more zombies than you can shake a stick at. But there are two things you definitely won't see - aliens and Raving Rabbids.

As hard as it is to believe, that's how the project got the ball rolling. The original game, Killer Freaks from Outer Space, would have the player fighting extraterrestrials resembling the bucktoothed bunnies. Although the Rabbids were removed early in development, their small size was incorporated into the aliens.

While playtesting, the developers ran into two major problems. Firstly, blasting at tiny aliens wasn't satisfying, and since this game was originally released on the Wii U, the player had to keep checking the GamePad and TV screen almost simultaneously, which was exhausting, since these creatures moved so fast.

The developers realised these issues could be resolved by making the enemies slower and larger, resulting in transforming the aliens into zombies.


4. Tekken

Tekken PlayStation Box Art
Tekken PlayStation Box Art

Virtua Fighter may have been the first 3D fighting game, but Tekken was responsible for rocking the genre to its core. Because of its tight and diverse combat mechanics, Tekken was the first game to give Street Fighter or Mortal Kombat a run for their money.

But since it's on this list, you know Tekken was envisioned as a different kettle of fish. Now, when one says "a game was created by accident", they usually mean it started one way, but ended up as something else.

But Tekken is different, since it was never intended to be a game to begin with! Originally, Tekken's beta was created by Namco to test 3D character models and texture mapping.

After Namco hired Virtua Fighter designer, Seiichi Ishii, they thought they could turn the project into a fighting game called Rave Wars, rivalling the soon-to-be released Virtua Fighter 2.

To ensure the game stood out over its competitor, the roster was filled with extremely distinctive combatants, including Jack the android, King a luchador wrestler, and whatever the hell Yoshimitsu is.

Weeks before release, the title was changed from "Rave Wars" to "Tekken", and the rest was history.


3. Devil May Cry

Devil May Cry 1
Capcom

To delve into the origins of Devil May Cry, we need to first look at Resident Evil 4. Even though this game is regarded as a masterpiece, it's a miracle it saw the light of day. Its development was so chaotic, four versions of the sequel were discarded.

The first incarnation revolved around superhuman called Tony, who was endowed with heightened agility, speed, and strength. To show off Tony's skillset, producer, Shinji Mikami, felt it would be better to remove the fixed camera angles and pre-rendered backgrounds, which were staples in the survivor horror series.

Over time, the developers thought the gameplay had become so bombastic, it had little resemblance to Resident Evil. Rather than scrapping it, the project was reworked into a demon-hunting hack-and-slash called Devil May Cry

But that's not all. While Capcom was play-testing Onimusha: Warlords, they noticed a glitch that allowed the player to "juggle" enemies into the air with their sword. The developers found this bug so entertaining, they made it a key component in Devil May Cry's fighting mechanics.

It may have been heartbreaking when Capcom had to start from scratch with RE4, but it was worth it, since that decision indirectly led to the creation of one of the coolest franchises ever.


2. BioShock

BioShock Big Daddy
2K Games

Early on in BioShock's development, the team devised three pivotal concepts - drones, protectors, and harvesters. This trio eventually evolved into the Little Sisters, Big Daddies, and the Splicers.

Apart from those three elements, BioShock was totally different to begin with. Instead of exploring the aquatic terrain of Rapture, the story took place on a monster-filled spaceship. Originally, the story followed Carlos Cuello, who's tasked with finding and deprogramming a senator's daughter, after she's been brainwashed by a cult.

When Take-Two Interactive realised the setting and story wasn't working, they changed everything. This time, the developers envisioned BioShock taking place in an abandoned Nazi lab, which had been unearthed in modern times.

Although this plotline was abandoned, many factors were incorporated into the finished product, including plasmids, EVE, automated security systems, stealth, expositional audio recordings, and a consistent relationship with a character through a radio.

Director, Ken Levine, felt BioShock looked too cyberpunk, (which he regarded as cliched), so he changed the setting once more, this time to an underwater city. After that, it only required some more adjusting to get the BioShock we know today.


1. Diddy Kong Racing

Diddy Kong Racing
Rare

When a game goes through drastic changers in graphics or genre, you can usually see a sliver of what the prototype was going for. However, the original version of Diddy Kong Racing has virtually nothing in common with its retail form.

Although Rare's beloved title was a vibrant and cartoony racer, it was pitched as a real-time strategy title, centred around a time-travelling caveman!! According to Rare developer, Lee Musgrave, the initial pitch "was in the style of Command & Conquer and not related" to what we got.

Over time, it evolved into a Disneyworld-inspired adventure called Wild Cartoon Kingdom. By 1997, the project was reshaped into a driving game called Adventure Racers. Shortly after, it was changed AGAIN to Pro-Am 64, serving as a sequel to the NES racer, RC Pro-Am (which nobody remembers).

When Banjo-Kazooie missed its December 1997 deadline, Rare felt obligated to release a AAA title that Christmas. But since Pro-Am 64 wasn't a well-known brand, Rare knew it wouldn't grab consumers unless it incorporated an iconic character.

This inspired the team to not only implement Donkey Kong's sidekick, Diddy Kong, but to make him the titular star. This decision altered the game's design to fit the DK aesthetic, and incorporate other staples from the franchise, including Bananas and Kremlings.

When you compare how it started to how it ended - and how many people cite Diddy Kong Racing as the REAL best kart game on N64 - the two properties couldn't have had less in common.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Bioshock
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows