13 Classic Video Games With Ridiculously Stupid Stories

Ac Black Flag It€™s often been said that video games are a bit lacking in the narrative department. While countless number of contemporary FPS series have been harshly criticised for their bumbling, borderline offensive plotlines, the fact is video game stories have sucked since the dawn of the medium. Back in the day, you didn€™t need much more motivation than, €œHey, there€™s an evil mushroom, go stomp on it,€ or, €œSee that nasty centipede thing? Go shoot it; cheers.€ It€™s time for us, as gamers, to finally slaughter our sacred cows by singling out beloved videogame classics with utterly stupid stories. So hold onto your Dickens as we Chekhov the 13 worst classic videogame storylines.

13. Castlevania

Castlevania Kicking us off (appropriately enough) at the number 13 slot, we have the macabre NES classic €˜Castlevania.€™ In this seminal action-platformer your play as whip-toting vampire hunter Simon Belmont as you lash your way through Dracula€™s castle in pursuit of the Count, taking down such iconic foes as Frankenstein€™s monster and the Grim Reaper along the way. After much hardship, you track down the Lord Vampire himself. Then you slay him. Roll credits. Wuh? Where Simon€™s Quest€™s narrative is legendarily nonsensical (incomprehensible villages and inexplicable tornadoes anyone?), Castlevania€™s story is near-absent. You€™re a vampire hunter. You hunt vampires. Go hunt some vampires. Snore.

12. Super Mario Bros.

Mario Bros Yeah, yeah, we€™ve all seen the meme; €œThank you Mario! But our princess is in another ca-€€ yadda, yadda, heard it all before. Still, it bears repeating that Super Mario Bros. basically recounts the most poorly planned hostage retrieval operation imaginable. Mario jumps, stomps and fire-flowers his way through seven worlds, inflicting untold suffering on innocent denizens of the Mushroom Kingdom before happening on the actual location of his missing monarch. By which time, the emotional and physical suffering endured by Princess Toadstool at the hands of her captors will no doubt have left nothing but a ravaged, bitter shell to rescue. Death would have been kinder.

11. Command & Conquer: Red Alert

Red Alert A series with a premise so ludicrous it€™d be laughed out of the room by the writing team for Lost. If you€™re not familiar with the franchise, just attempt to read the following while keeping a straight face: In 1946, Einstein builds a time machine in New Mexico. Travelling back to his homeland in 1924, he runs into a young Adolf Hitler and €“ in the act of shaking his hand €“ causes a temporal rift that erases the future Fuhrer from history. This prevents the onset of World War II, allowing Stalin€™s regime to wage war against the whole of Eurasia and (eventually) the world! Did you manage it? Thought not. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=26xImZV7VmY

10. Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare 2

Cod While the Call of Duty franchise has been held responsible for the intellectual murder of the videogame market, I€™ll come right out and say the first Modern Warfare carried off its narrative with real elegance and even managed some moments of profundity. Not so with this towering pillar of thick. The plot of Modern Warfare 2 sounds like the product of a McCarthy-era Republican scribbling the contents of their diseased brain on the back of a George Bush campaign flyer. Russian Ultranationalist figurehead Imran Zakhaev is made a martyr in his homeland following his death in the previous game, leading the psychopathic terrorist Makarov to take advantage of public hysteria by shooting up a Russian airport and framing an undercover American agent, resulting in international conflict. BUT it turns out the real baddie is an American General named Shepherd who€™s determined to plunge Russia and the U.S. into World War III because€he€™s€the baddie? Sorry, you lost me.

9. Resident Evil

Resident Evil It€™s not so much the material as the delivery with this one. The original Resident Evil€™s story of a team of special military operatives struggling against legions of mutated, undead horrors in a creepy mansion/research facility is a perfectly decent vehicle for some gory gaming escapades. Where the story falls apart is in the woeful, abysmal and utterly reprehensible script and voice acting, both of which are showcased to their worst in the notoriously hammy live action intro sequence. The horror€

8. Tetris

Tetris Blocks. Just€falling blocks. Nothing but endlessly€eternally€falling blocks. Shudder.

7. Assassin€™s Creed Franchise

Assassins Creed I€™ll be honest €“ I never really got the hype surrounding the Assassin€™s Creed games. To me they all came across as tarted-up tech demos, showcasing some (admittedly impressive) parkour physics, while never putting them to much use. There€™s no accounting for taste, but what can€™t be denied is the consistently repellent narrative that ties these titles together. Honestly, I couldn€™t pick the worst Assassin€™s Creed story, every game is so littered with plot-holes, contrivances and needlessly convoluted technobabble that I€™m just going to take the franchise as a whole and run through some of its dumber moments. Aside from the lumpen Sci-Fi €˜twist€™ (that was ruined in promotional material for the first game) we have a super-powered Pope, time-bending alien deities, a Native American assassin who manages to stroll past every major historical figure from the war of Independence and now€pirates? Just take your pick, it€™s all pretty stupid.

6. Mega Man 6

Megaman 6 It€™s fair to say that Mega Man 6 is nobody€™s favourite entry in the series, but at the same time it€™s far from the little blue bot€™s worst outing (I€™m looking at you Mega Man Star Force). However, MM6 makes the cut on account of possessing one of the most predictable plot €˜twists€™ in the history of gaming. As Mega Man you compete in a robot tournament organised by the enigmatic Dr. X, who bears no resemblance to and is most definitely not in any way related Mega Man€™s long-time foe Dr. Wi-€ERMAHGERD! Yes, in a twist about as surprising as the critical reception of an M. Night Shyamalan flick, the tournament€™s shadowy benefactor turns out to be Dr. Wiley. Listen closely and you can hear the sound of absolutely no-one being in the least bit shocked.

5. Halo 2

Halo 2 While the original Halo was a justly-acclaimed shot in the arm for console shooters, it didn€™t offer much in the way of complex narrative. Then again, it didn€™t need to €“ the ring world setting was cool, the alien menace suitably menacing and your playable protagonist was the perfect silent hero; a mysterious super-solider decked out in kick-ass combat armour. At he end of the day, that€™s all you needed. Then the sequel came along and made the critical error of over-egging the pudding with a confusing civil war subplot, told from the perspective of the alien scourge you€™d been fighting in the first game. Honestly, I didn€™t much want the snarling monstrosities from the original Halo to be imbued with depth and motivation €“ I just wanted to stick them with plasma grenades some more. When Bungie went and introduced the omnipotent parasite that spoke exclusively in iambic pentameter, it was a start of a long road to story-telling hell, paved with bogus religious imagery, dull characters and trite dialogue. No thanks.

4. Metal Gear Solid

Metal Gear Solid While many gamers applaud Metal Gear Solid for its €˜ground-breaking€™ level of narrative complexity and thematic scope, to me it carried the distinct whiff of a frustrated auteur who would€™ve much rather just gone and shot a movie. Saying that, on the basis of this game, it probably would€™ve been a really bad movie. As super-spy Solid Snake (snigger), you are tasked with infiltrating a military base overrun by mutinous troops lead by an elite team of special operatives, all of whom are fond of giving really long speeches at the point of death. Throw in some cod-philosophical nonsense about genetic destiny and another extremely daft €˜villain-revealed€™ moment and you€™ve got yourself a big fat, pseudo-cinematic turkey.

3. Indigo Prophecy/Fahrenheit (EU)

Fahrenheit And here we have yet another game developer who€™d rather break bread with Spielberg than Shigeru Miyamoto. I personally regard David Cage as something of a toxic influence on the videogame industry, an argument outlined beautifully by this gentleman. Ironically, Cage is an outspoken critic of the €˜immaturity€™ of videogame storytelling. What he neglects to mention is that his own €˜opus€™ contains a storyline so patently ridiculous it reads like someone threw a bunch of pulp sci-fi novels in a blender, scattered the page fragments on the floor and built a plot around the random arrangement of words and phrases. From a promising introductory sequence, the game rapidly degenerates into every science-fiction cliché, incorporating Mayan mythology, Matrix-style superpowers and a €˜child saviour.€™ However, nothing quite tops bit where the internet goes sentient and tries to take over the world. Citizen Kane, it aint.

2. Skies Of Arcadia

Skies Of Arcadia I€™ve never understood why this 100+ hour snooze-fest enjoys such a rabid fanbase. Such is the popularity of this Dreamcast stinker it even got a GameCube port in 2002. I could harp on about my dreary voyage through the skies of Arcadia from a gameplay perspective, but this list is supposed to be focusing on crappy narratives. So, how does this game fare in the story stakes? What you€™ve got here is a painfully obvious pacifist/environmentalist yarn told through a pretty bland resistance story from the perspective of €˜air pirate€™ Vyse, a protagonist so maddeningly upbeat that he would€™ve been made to walk the plank on my ship long ago. There€™s some rubbish about biological WMDs and €˜Moon Crystals,€™ all communicated through some of the worst dialogue I€™ve ever been forced to endure, which seems largely to consist of inter-gender bickering roughly on par with an episode of The Big Bang Theory.

1. Final Fantasy VII

Final Fantasy Vii Yes, really. I€™m not usually one to jump on the revisionist bandwagon, but with this one the fan-boys need to be dragged kicking and screaming into the light. Isn€™t is odd that, (SPOILERS!) despite Aerith€™s death appearing on every €˜classic video game moments€™ list on the web, the rest of the game€™s narrative gets nary a mention? There€™s a good reason for that; the plot of Final Fantasy VII makes€no€sense. What€™s more, it€™s wilfully baffling. There€™s something about the planet€™s life-stream and an evil bloke who wants to unite with it to become a god, but he€™s actually a clone of an alien invader and the planet has created monsters to defend itself from him, but then it turns on its own human population for some reason and the monsters start killing everyone€and there€™s a sort of tiger-thing? In writing this list I went through a refresher course by playing the game to completion again, then I went on Wikipedia to try and decipher its plot but I€™m still none the wiser. This game commits all three of the cardinal sins of writing: over-complexity for the sake of it, a confusingly vast roster of characters and a conclusion that fails to provide any proper closure to its sprawling narrative. Add to that the fact that Aerith might not actually have died in that scene, and you€™ve got yourself the fattest sacred cow of classic videogame storylines.

Contributor
Contributor

Sam Miranda hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.