13 Infamous Mis-Steps That Ruined Iconic Gaming Characters

Or how to lose fans and alienate players.

Like Hollywood, the video game world has its stars who have sometimes had falls from grace. Sometimes, just like in Hollywood, they recover and have fantastic career comebacks - after all, the mid to late nineties weren't great for Sylvester Stallone, but he made a huge comeback with Rocky Balboa. And now he's gone back to making the same films as he was making before his career nearly ended. You could say the same thing happened for Lara Croft. After her PS One glory she had Tomb Raider The Angel Of Darkness on PS2, which almost killed the franchise. Luckily it came back and has had two reinventions including the fantastic reboot last year. Of course for every Rocky style comeback, there's a Christian Slater or a Mel Gibson who either lose their star quality or get a bad public image from which they just can't come back. Here we'll examine some of the missteps which have seen our favourite characters and franchises stumble and fall, thanks to idiotic, misplaced creative decisions. Some of them have fortunately made a comeback, whilst others are still living in hope of getting up before the ten count...

13. Leaving Naughty Dog - Crash Bandicoot

Crash Bandicoot was for a long time the mascot for the Playstation, and he was up there with Sonic and Mario. The developers who created him are also the guys who make the excellent Uncharted series so it's annoying to know that his downfall is simply because of who owns his copyright. If Crash was still with Naughty Dog who created him, he'd surely still be giving the plumber a run for his money. Unfortunately Crash was created by Naughty Dog, but they didn't fund the game and although Sony paid for him to be an exclusive for his first five games, they couldn't keep him forever. The crash for Crash came as soon as he left Naughty Dog Productions loving arms, although his demise was a slow and drawn out process. Each of his first three platforming games on the PS One was a good game, and they got better with every sequel, and both Crash Team Racing and Crash Bash even gave Mario Kart and Mario Party a run for their money. But then his return to the platforming world saw him head over to the GameCube and Xbox as well as the PS2, but the game wasn't as good as any of his PS One games and the load times are legendarily long. Things stayed okay for a while with both Crash Nitro Kart and Crash Tag Team Racing being acceptable kart racers, though neither was as good as the original Crash Team Racing. On the platforming front his games were likewise reasonable efforts but the series just lost its momentum with Crash Of The Titans and 2008's Crash Mind Over Mutant, which felt oddly soulless. As a mark of his fall, Crash didn't even make an appearance in the Playstation All Stars Battle Royale franchise mash up despite being the face of Playstation for so many years.

12. Star Fox Adventures Stopped The Fox Flying

First there was Star Fox, and then there was Star Fox 64 and both were great games. Everything else that has come since can be seen as one extended misstep which has ruined Fox from standing proudly alongside Mario as a Nintendo mascot. Star Fox Adventures game was developed by Rare, but despite being an alright game is a massive black spot on both Fox's and Rare's records. Rare's final game for a Nintendo home console started life as the Nintendo 64 Dinosaur Planet, before being moved over to the GameCube and given Fox as its lead character. Unfortunately, Dinosaur Planet was always intended to be a Zelda like game and that took Fox out of his comfort zone, which as we all know is in an Arwing. Star Fox Adventures only received a lukewarm reception and many speculated that it was rushed to completion before Rare moved over to Microsoft. Nintendo then turned to Namco to develop the next instalment. Star Fox Assault was a greater return to the skies for Fox, but retained some ground elements with fox on foot. It wasn't amazing and did little to bring back to his glory days of the N64. Star Fox Command on the Nintendo DS mixed up the style of play once again in the series, and whilst it was better received, it was the third Star Fox game in a row which gained most of its attention because of its name value rather than its individual merits. Star Fox 64 3D on the 3DS is his best game in years, but it's a remake and not an original title. Hopefully he'll come back to full strength on the Wii U.

11. Bomberman: Act Zero

Bomber Man is a funny little character. With a block head and weird bomb like spheres for hands and feet, he's a weird man whose body is composed of bombs. His design is typical of the cartoon characters that come out of Japan, and his the way he looked very much channelled the spirit of the games he appeared in. His games are simplistic in their concepts; run around a maze and blow things up to solve puzzles whilst avoiding getting caught in the fire of your own explosions. You don't really need any more story or logic than that, but then that was the pleasure of the games. But then, unthinkably, the developers stripped away all Bomberman's cuteness and made Bomber Man Act Zero a gritty realistic game on Xbox 360. It didn't really change up the gameplay of the franchise too much, but it completely took away its soul, and you have to wonder exactly who they thought the game would appeal to? They basically pulled away everything that attracted the core demographic, as if that has ever been a smart idea.

10. Lemmings Couldn't Evolve In A 3D Age

The charm, cleverness and steep difficulty of Lemmings combined to be one of the most addictive games of the early nineties. The game's premise was simple; guide a hoard of marching lemmings from A to B whilst giving instructions a few individual lemmings to do a few basic moves that will prevent them walking off a ledge to their demise. After Lemmings came Oh No More Lemmings and the brilliant and underrated Lemmings 2: The Tribes, but unfortunately thereafter came the missteps in the history of Lemmings: All New World Of Lemmings was a shambles. The lemmings received a new look, lost most of their moves and now had baddies to contend with such as the Lemme Fatale. Only three of the twelve tribes featured and the game didn't see any direct sequels. 3D Lemmings was an ugly, hard to control nightmare of a game that just about sums up everything that was wrong with the time period in which classic 2D games all decided that they had to go 3D. Two flops in a row and Lemmings as a series lost any amount of hype or most importantly evolution in gameplay. Lemmings became a Playstation exclusive, but despite a new game every few years, they have never been shown much love or care from Sony. Every Lemmings game they've put out has been a re-tread of the original Amiga game. It's a shame Sony shows the little guys no love, because if they were marketed right and unleashed on the mobile market they could be bigger than Angry Birds.

9. Turok Evolution And Turok (Reboot) Were Just Too Generic

The original Turok game on the Nintendo 64 was a moderate success: it was fun to roam around (in insane amounts of fog and pop up graphics) and kill dinosaurs, and was a highlight of the N64's launch period. A few months later Goldeneye happened and that really changed console FPS games. Turok 2 came out and had vastly improved graphics and controls and was over all a pretty good shooter and one of the highlight exclusives for the 64 bit Nintendo machine. When Turok made the leap to the next generation it went multiplatform and this may have proved a mistake for the series. Up to this point the games had all been Nintendo exclusives and there are a certain section of gamers who will buy games to be platform loyal. The Turok games had become stale so all they really had left to make them special was them being a Nintendo exclusive. When that stopped happening, Turok was just another generic multiplatform shooter. Acclaim, who developed Turok, soon went bust and that was the end of the series for several years. A reboot was released several years later, but was unrelated to the previous games in the series, and wasn't greatly received. It seems as if this hunter is just as extinct as his usual prey.

8. Alex Kidd Wasn't Up To Being A Mascot

Disney have Mickey, Warner Bros have Bugs and so it was only natural when video games came into existence that gaming companies would also come up with recognisable company mascots. Super Mario became the first video game character to rival Mickey and soon Sega wanted a piece of the action. Sonic The Hedgehog would become the biggest rival to Mario and helped Sega battle Nintendo throughout the 16-bit era in a closely fought battle, but he wasn't Sega's first mascot. Sonic's coolness, and incredibly popular game saw the hedgehog usurp Sega's previous flagship character Alex Kidd. Alex Kidd is now most famously known as the guy Sonic replaced, and it could be argued that his fall from grace wasn't because of any particular misstep. Instead it can be said that Alex Kidd never earned his spot as Sega's mascot in the first place - he was only there because Sega had yet to come up with anything good. His really misstep is that he was given the ball but didn't run with it.

7. Duke Nukem Forever Took Forever To Arrive

Duke Nukem is a pretty iconic character in the world of video games. He's a bad ass dude and was one of the early stars of the FPS genre, and made the leap from 2D to 3D better than most (to the point where many are unaware he started life in two dimensions). Duke Nukem Forever came out after a staggering fifteen years in development... and then it sucked. To be fair to the game, after all that wait it was impossible to live up to the hype, but it didn't even remotely live up to the even the lowest hopes for it. Duke is a character from a bygone era and the game played like a game from a bygone era to match. If the game had been released when it was first supposed to it would have been good, but not great, but by the time it arrived the mechanics and level design simply felt archaic. The funny hypocrisy of the situation is that if the game had originally came out when it was supposed to and then received an HD remake at the time it did eventually come out the reviewers would have been much kinder.

6. Perfect Dark Zero

Once upon a time Nintendo gave us the best home for shooters. Games like Turok, Quake and of course Goldeneye 007 made the N64 the place to gather around and blast your friends with a head shot. If Nintendo had known how successful Goldeneye would have been they would have probably done a deal to secure the rights to more than one James Bond film so they could have seen Tomorrow Never Dies developed by Rare as a N64 exclusive. Without Bond, Rare could only follow up Goldeneye with a spiritual successor to the game. In one sense this was a good thing, as even if they had Bond for longer, it would only be a matter of time before they no longer controlled the rights to their premier FPS franchise. Perfect Dark gave Nintendo and Rare the opportunity to create their own franchise, which with the same gameplay of Goldeneye would surely become the greatest FPS series ever. Perfect Dark required the Nintendo 64 expansion pack for most of its game modes, and just like any game that requires extra peripherals the sales weren't as high as they could have been. Perfect Dark was a much more polished and refined Goldeneye, but sold less. Then it all went really wrong for Joanna Dark. A tiny teaser for a Perfect Dark game was shown for the GameCube, but Rare was sold to Microsoft. The original Xbox didn't get the long rumoured Perfect Dark Zero and throughout this console's lifespan Halo and Master Chief became the rulers of the console FPS space. Still all hope was not lost. The original Perfect Dark and Goldeneye still held a lot of weight in the FPS world so it was an easy choice to launch the Xbox 360 with Perfect Dark Zero as its main launch title. The game wasn't developed by the same Rare who made either of their previous shooters and the game simply wasn't as good and certainly wasn't the Halo beater everyone expected it to be. And since it was no Halo beater, Microsoft simply decided to not beat Halo and have continued to continue with Halo as their flagship FPS and leave Joanna in the dark.

5. Resident Evil 6 Made Bad Choices

The Resident Evil games have seen a huge amount of evolution over the years, which some fans have at times been frustrated with. However if a series refuses to evolve it becomes stagnant and eventually gamers won't feel the need to pick up the latest instalments. For better or worse the Resident Evil series have rarely stayed the same, which ultimately is one of the main reasons it's still the premier brand of the survival horror genre approaching twenty years after its initial release. Each new entry in the series played around with new ideas, and gameplay mechanics. Resident Evil 4 put a huge emphasis on action, but retained the puzzles and atmosphere of the earlier games. Resident Evil 5, much to the annoyance of long term fans went into action overdrive and the addition of co-op play destroyed was little was left of the feeling of survival against the odds as you always had back up. The series continued to evolve with Resident Evil 6, but many would agree that many of the changes were for the worse. For years fans have wanted Capcom to ditch the tank controls, and whilst this was achieved, everything else was a mess. You still collected money and items from fallen enemies, but the inventive upgrade systems from Resident evil 4 and 5 were replaced with a weak version. This really didn't matter too much though they introduced hand to hand combat to the gameplay which meant you could button mash your way through much of the game. The biggest sin however was that there were many sections of the game where it didn't really feel like you were playing it. QTE's have been in games for years, but Resident Evil 6 took away choice of action to the extreme and had sections of the game which would play themselves if you held up on the control stick.

4. Banjo Kazooie Changed Genres

When the original Banjo-Kazooie game arrived on the Nintendo 64 is 1998 many called the platformer a Super Mario 64 killer. The game had far better graphics, the controls were easily as good and the story and characters felt like they ripped straight out of the offices of Pixar. Banjo-Tooie was hyped in the ending sequence of the first game, but took years to arrive. By the time it did arrive, it was one of the N64's swansong games meaning that gamers who had bought the first game during the early part of the N64's lifecycle had now moved onto Sega's Dreamcast or were saving their cash for the Playstation 2. The game therefore didn't get the sales or attention people would have expected which damaged the franchises status as a headlining act. The real misstep came after Rare was sold to Microsoft and had left the nurturing arms of Nintendo. Their Xbox 360 adventure could have played it safe as a fun platformer, but Banjo-Kazooie Nuts And Bolts was a strange hybrid platform racer. Whilst not a bad game it wasn't the game Banjo fans had been waiting for and the game wasn't a huge success.

3. Prince Of Persia Lost Its Momentum

The original Prince Of Persia game was ground breaking at the time of its release for its rotoscoped graphics and realistic gameplay. Unlike other platformers the prince couldn't survive huge falls or leap several times his height. The realistic approach certainly made the game stand out from the pack, but it didn't have the same pick up and play quality of the more common cartoony games of the day. Prince Of Persia required skill, timing and if you wanted to complete the game you had to carefully learn what to do in each section to not fall victim to the many perils. The third game took a lot of cues from the style of Tomb Raider, which itself can be said to be a 3D version of a 2D Prince Of Persia game. Unfortunately Prince Of Persia 3D didn't play as well as Tomb Raider, nor did it star the video game sex symbol Lara Croft. The series would only really hit its stride with the release of The Prince Of Persia The Sand Of Time in 2003. A much more polished game than the previous 3D adventure, it bettered what Lara Croft had managed in her PS2 debut. This made people call for Tomb Raider to take cues from Prince Of Persia which it did when it came back for Tomb Raider Legend. After The Sands Of Time came The Warrior Within and The Two Thrones, both to critical acclaim, but the next game in the series which debuted on the Xbox 360 and PS3 didn't push the series further and whilst still a good game, didn't keep the momentum of the series going. There's only been one since which came out in 2010 to compliment the release of the Prince Of Persia movie starring Jake Gyllenhaal. Prince Of Persia The Forgotten Sands wasn't a bad game, but it hadn't improved upon the series since the PS2 days. It was almost as if the game only existed to fulfil the need to sell some games alongside the movie.

2. Knuckles Chaotix Lacked Sonic

Sonic is Sega's answer to Super Mario and just like the Super Mario franchise, the Sonic series of games have had its fair share of spin offs and breakout stars... well it's had its spin offs anyway. Yes, unfortunately for Sonic Team they've not had the same success that Nintendo has had with the likes of Yoshi, and Wario starring in their own games. They doesn't mean they haven't tried. Sonic and Knuckles was effectively Sonic 4. It's name came from the joint star billing of Sonic along with Knuckles, a character who had debuted in Sonic 3 as Sonic's rival. Knuckles came into gamer's lives as the red alternative to Sonic who had even more attitude and better moves, and for a brief moment you could almost believe that Knuckles could outshine the blue blur himself. But then it all went wrong. Knuckles Chaotix was Sega's one and only attempt to send Knuckles into the spotlight without Sonic, and they put it out on the Mega Drive 32X. The 32X was a 32-bit add on for the Mega Drive and one of Sega's strangest business moves which only proved to cause mistrust towards Sega from consumers. The add on was barely supported and quickly phased out, and Knuckles Chaotix was just about the only notable exclusive the system produced. Even then, the game isn't quite all it seems. Knuckles Chaotix began life as 'Sonic Crackers' for the Mega Drive. A game which would see Sonic and Tails tethered together. Somewhere throughout development Sega decided the game wasn't working as well as they would have liked and so elected not to put the Sonic name to it. So what it meant is that Knuckles sole solo effort was a game that wasn't deemed good enough to be a Sonic game, and released on a system deemed not good enough to be supported by Sega. The poor echidna didn't stand a chance.

1. Shadow The Hedgehog

Shadow the Hedgehog first appeared in Sonic Adventure 2 on the Sega Dreamcast. He is basically a palette swap of Sonic, which in itself is no bad thing - after all Mario and Luigi started out as a palette swap. Shadow isn't unique as a Sonic palette swap though as Knuckles is just a red Sonic, which his spikes slicked back and the later Silver the Hedgehog is just a white Sonic with extra spikes who was very poorly received by gamers. Like Knuckles, Shadow was popular enough to get his own game, but Sega decided to give him a more adult themed game with guns and motorcycle chases. Sadly, this meant the game was too adult for the usual child friendly Sonic audience, but still nowhere near an adult game. Also it came out in an era where all the 3D Sonic platformers were getting very mixed reviews so the game didn't help launch Shadow out of Sonic's shadow. Which other iconic gaming characters were ruined by stupid creative decisions? Share your thoughts in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

Hello! My name is David Pustansky. As well as writing for this site, I'm also an actor, presenter, writer, director and artist. So basically I love creative things where there's a story to be told. I run my own theatre company, The ImProDigies. Be sure to check our shows out. As I'm sure you'll see from my articles I often look into things with a unique and quirky perspective and have a strange attention to sometimes strange details. Enjoy!