14 Best Acting Performances In Video Game History

As the medium continues to rival cinema more directly, what are the most standout performances?

One of the best things about watching the gaming medium flourish and evolve is seeing its cinematic flare expand alongside. As video games have matured, so have the ways in which they tell their stories, with the cinematic techniques on display now rivalling those used in film and television. Motion capture, script-writing and voice acting in particular have all contributed to the rise of gaming as a serious narrative force in recent years, but that hasn't always led to the greatest performances being recognised. Instead, roles are often rated on the iconic status of the character being portrayed, and though those performances are great in their own right, they're not as emotionally provocative or indeed as complex as others that have been overlooked in the past. This means you won't be seeing the Duke Nukems or the Master Chiefs of the medium on this list, because whilst those performances are certainly more recognisable and commendable in many respects, they don't quite illustrate the wide-ranging talents that have been displayed since. Still, many of these roles are only made possible by an impressive script, so irrespective of just how good an actor is, they're only as good as the material they're given. It can go both ways, but that only highlights why we should reflect on the best video games have offered so far. Spoilers ahead.

14. Melissa Hutchison - Clementine (The Walking Dead)

Clementine from The Walking Dead is a prime example of a well-rounded, authentic character, benefitting from both fantastic dialogue and a remarkable voice actor in Melissa Hutchison. She's the heart and soul of the series, and despite the fact that the second season degraded in quality somewhat, Clem still remains a fantastic character worth staying invested in. Though her age would indicate a sense of vulnerability, Clementine is anything but passive. In fact, she's an incredibly proactive character who is able to persevere in extremely dire circumstances. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KyUC7nE-f2M She may be unsettled by the events that transpire around her, but Hutchison makes it clear that though everything feels bleak on the horizon, Clem's youthful optimism enables her to pull through. It's an admirable trait to have in the zombie apocalypse, but it never feels dismissive of its severity.

13. Robert Costanzo - Joe Barbaro (Mafia II)

One of the most drastically improved franchise's of the past decade, Mafia II improved on many things, in particular the voice talent behind its characters. Introduce Robert Costanzo, who bar a role in BTAS as Harvey Bullock and some other animated adventures, had really yet to cement himself as a big voice acting talent. His role as Joe Barbaro however is simply fantastic, and begs the question - why hasn't he done more? Mafia II's mob plot line was lauded by critics when it first released, with the game managing to compile and pay homage to a plethora of mafia films from The Godfather to Goodfellas and more. Barbaro occupies the role of the player's main introduction to the criminal world, and in that task he succeeds indubitably. Better still, Joe is easily the best character in the story, outshining Vito and the game's primary antagonists with ease. Since Costanzo's performance is so overlooked, there aren't actually any videos of him online showing off his talents, you're just going to have to check out the game yourself. It's quite the underrated performance, but one worth seeking out if you have the time.

12. Aaron Staton - Cole Phelps (L.A. Noire)

Team Bondi's swan song for all things pulp, L.A. Noire possessed numerous traits that made it that summer's dramatic centrepiece - not least of which its tremendous utilisation of motion-capture, amplified eloquently by actors like Keith Szarabajka and in particular Aaron Staton. Staton took on the role of the game's main protagonist, Cole Phelps, as he navigates his way through the Los Angeles Police Department in a manner extremely reminiscent to 1997's L.A. Confidential. Phelps, a former marine officer ravaged with guilt, took on multiple cases ranging from traffic violations to arson attacks as the title's story progressed, all very severe in nature. Staton's performance as the detective is rooted in the context of the 1940s and his stalwart no-nonsense attitude - though not his defining feature - is paralleled with other officers in the department to great effect. Said role is also benefited by the aforementioned facial-capture technology used in recordings, which translates every dimple and expression into the title remarkably. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8a97dtTQmhY Cole may be a man of contradictions at certain points, but that just makes him evermore compelling.

11. Ashley Johnson - Ellie (The Last Of Us)

The Last of Us heralded the end of the seventh-generation of consoles in an incredible way, with Naughty Dog delivering a tale interwoven with incredible performances from Ashley Johnson and Troy Baker, among others, as well as a nuanced narrative made great by its analysis of human morality. It is Johnson's role as Ellie that's the standout performance, however. Not only does the actress ground the suitably post-apocalyptic setting of the title, she bears the emotional core of it as well. Baker's turn as Joel is equally as enthralling, but Ellie as a character is just outstanding, with Left Behind only furthering the emotional gravitas evoked by the game's main narrative. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tv4losIoaPw Whilst I may not be looking forward to the prospect of a sequel to Naughty Dog's magnum-opus in the slightest, it really is difficult to find yourself not looking forward to seeing more of Johnson and Baker's talents.

10. Jennifer Lee Taylor - Cortana (Halo 4)

Though a large quantity of Halo fans may harbour a distinct disliking for Halo 4 as a whole, the story's focus on the Chief's relationship with Cortana was absolutely stellar, and built upon all the past games in the series in a constructive and innovative manner. The fourth main instalment in the franchise saw Chief's AI companion mentally deteriorating at an unprecedented level, which in turn led to some of the most emotive scenes in a Halo title ever. Cortana had been a mainstay of the Chief's escapades since 2001, so to see her in such a dilapidated state - wrought with grief at the prospect of no longer being able to accompany her friend anymore - was palpably sorrowful. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ACvIxGpzGs8 The level of emotion displayed wouldn't have been made possible without Jennifer Lee Taylor's acting talent though, who managed to make the slow winding descent of an AI into madness feel believable and above all empathetic. It's a sombre end for such an iconic character, but at least she went out with a bang.

9. Sam Witwer - Starkiller/Galen Marek (Star Wars: The Force Unleashed)

Sam Witwer is no stranger to the Star Wars franchise, but it may surprise some that before he was the new voice of Darth Maul in The Clone Wars, the actor took on the likeness and voice of Galen Marek in The Force Unleashed series. Providing the mo-cap and voice for the would-be protagonist, Witwer channelled the frustration and confusion that became the hallmarks of the character with great sincerity, and was a huge contributing factor in the widespread praise that was had for the franchise's narrative debut. https://youtu.be/Ic7bR9IXWRQ?t=3401 Though this series may no longer be canon, it's still a worthwhile interpretation of the Star Wars mythos that was made evermore enjoyable by the acting talent on display - Witwer being the key highlight.

8. Michael Mando - Vaas Montenegro (Far Cry 3)

Who could forget this particular gem? Or indeed, the iconic monologue that accompanied it? Michael Mando's purpose-built psycho-pirate wowed gaming audiences when he appeared in the Far Cry series' third entry, explaining Einstein's definition of insanity to a whole new generation of gamers and in turn propelling the character to newfound heights of popularity. Vaas was the clear highlight of Far Cry 3's drug-addled story mode, so it was a shame he was killed off so early on in the tale and replaced with an antagonist that was well...just not as interesting. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xw_KMj2ZCig Any one scene involving the character could shift from calm tranquility to unfettered anger in a moment, which displayed just how much of a threat he could be. On top of this, Mando displays some truly remarkable range in the role, which just completely eclipses the other talents involved in the game's production. To make things even better the actor portrayed the role in a live-action web series, showing that behind and in front of the camera, Vaas is still a terrifying personality to witness. Mando's talent in the role has definitely been a contributing factor to Far Cry's rise as a triple-A franchise, and has spawned countless poor imitations of the character desperate to emulate the same sort of effect. There's nothing quite as good as the original role however, and that's why Vaas will remain as such an absorbing antagonist.

7. Dave Fennoy - Lee Everett (The Walking Dead)

Another Walking Dead character this time, but one equally as revered as Clementine. Season 1 of the TellTale series placed players in the role of a recently incarcerated Lee Everett, right at the start of the Zombie apocalypse. It occupies a space somewhere between the comic book source material and the massively popular AMC TV series, but manages to take the best and brightest aspects of both (at least in the first season) and place them in a point and click environment. Lee as a character is massively flawed, but that's just the right thing for a relatable character to retain. He's sincere, humble, and massively protective over Clem and his surly band of survivors. Indeed, by the time the credits start rolling all the player can really do is admire the acting talent on display - especially when the ending is so utterly heartbreaking.

6. Matt Ryan - Edward Kenway (Black Flag)

Over-saturation and repetitiveness may now be the hallmarks of the Assassin's Creed saga, but it never used to be this way. Indeed, even when the franchise what at the peak of its yearly release schedule, the developers at Ubisoft managed to produce a gem of a title in Black Flag - by far the most innovative of AC titles yet. In the role of the game's morally ambiguous Assassin, Edward Kenway, was Matt Ryan. A relative newcomer to the acting scene, Ryan has since attained much praise for his role on the unfortunately cancelled Constantine, where he played the eponymous occult protagonist - himself also an anti-hero. It is his role as Edward Kenway however that marked geek culture's first introduction to Ryan's talent, and with such a brilliant performance being conveyed, it'd be hard to find a better one. Protagonists of the AC series have always been anti-heroes consumed by a questionable doctrine, but the Welsh Assassin in question brought that front and centre to the narrative's progression. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cru5cms4_1Q Edward was a pirate more concerned with finding wealth and pleasure than assuming responsibility as an Assassin, but this made his character arc in the title all the more intriguing as a consequence, which is pretty remarkable considering the slew of emotionally bankrupt caricatures the series has conjured up since.

5. Steven Ogg - Trevor Phillips (Grand Theft Auto V)

Could there be a better GTA character than the Trevor Phillips? He's a perfect embodiment of the sociopathic tendencies gamers tend to commit whilst roaming around the franchise's open arenas, yet is also a hugely charismatic anti-hero with multiple motivations and traits that make him evermore endearing to the fanbase - this all after he murdered one of GTA IV's best loved characters. It takes a lot to garner that much praise from the community and critics alike, but as soon as you're introduced to Trevor's antics it becomes instantly understandable as to why he's earned such an iconic status. He's written superbly, given the best material to work with, and has the perfect voice and likeliness in Steven Ogg, and that's before you're treated to his hilarious character-switch scenes. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9xXmndx1mgY Ogg, himself a much-loved online personality, was simply born to play this character. The role is absolutely unchangeable and franchise-defining in its own right - it's just that good.

4. Mark Hamill - The Joker (Arkham Asylum)

First making waves as the character in the iconic Batman: The Animated Series, Mark Hamill marked his return to the Clown Prince of Crime in the 2009 breakout hit for Rocksteady studios, Batman: Arkham Asylum. Taking a premise first made famous by Die Hard and positioning The Joker in the role of puppeteer was absolutely fantastic, and it's fair to say that Hamill brought his A-game to the project. (not that he never does, of course) As Batman, players get to delight in the Joker's taunting voice blaring overhead via loudspeaker, leading to some absolutely stellar dialogue scripted by the great Paul Dini. The game's third act may falter under all its previous build-up, but Hamill is perfect in every single scene. https://youtu.be/FUNspPpwU9I?t=998 With such a standout performance being given every time the actor gets in the recording booth it's easy to see why the character went on to have a domineering presence in all the franchise's follow-ups, even if it did come at the detriment to variety. With Hamill now preoccupied with the Star Wars saga indefinitely, it would appear as though Arkham was his last hurrah as the character - a fitting end to his tenure in the role for sure.

3. Ellen McLain - GLaDOS (Portal/Portal 2)

This one was a toss-up between Valve's maniacal testing robot, GLaDOS, and their friendly if not slightly insane AI, Wheatley (played incredibly by Stephen Merchant), but when it boils down to it there can only be one titan of the Portal series, and that's Ellen McLain. GLaDOS has a well-deserved spot on the podium of gaming's most iconic villains, with her instantly identifiable robotic voice providing both laughs and scares, in perhaps the most quotable gaming series of all time. The dialogue really is something to behold, but its delivery would be inappropriately muted coming from anyone but McLain, whose robotic cackling is a spectacle to behold once the game boots up. https://youtu.be/aXYuL4yo0tM?t=238 She's got an iconic voice for an equally iconic series, so its only natural that her performance was especially brilliant.

2. Nolan North - Nathan Drake (Uncharted Series)

Confession time: I'm not the world's biggest Uncharted fan. That doesn't mean I can't appreciate some stellar voice acting though, and Nolan North's portrayal of Nathan Drake is suitably charming to behold, even if it does border on the clichéd at times. Drake is the embodiment of all of cinema's classic adventurers, and that works just fine considering the IP's focus on big, globetrotting escapades that revolve around historical artefacts. Because of this the treasure hunter has embarked on a multitude of adventures since he first debuted in 2007, so he's been able to accumulate quite the following over the years. This hasn't come from the strength of the series' gameplay alone however, but the charismatic nature of its cast, most notably North's rendition of Nathan Drake. The character's exasperated running commentary on action set-pieces is both humorous and relatable, which again, seems to be the hero's best trait. He may not have the most complex personality, but the lack of nuance is completely negated by the sharpness of the scripts on offer - Drake's retorts are always hilarious. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IOmPDvVz3MA Drake's status as one of the main icons of the PlayStation brand is largely indebted to Uncharted's writers, but North's perfect interpretation of the script has gone a long way in gaining such accolades. He's a fantastic protagonist acted brilliantly by one of the industry's biggest talents, so it's little wonder why he continues to endure nine years on from his first adventure.

1. Troy Baker - Joel (The Last Of Us)

The seminal post-apocalyptic game of the generation, The Last of Us was always made famous by its moving narrative - one which was grounded by the remarkable performances of Troy Baker and Ashley Johnson. Baker's role as Joel cemented the tone, leading to themes of release and grief, and in doing so created one of the most memorable and gut-wrenching openings to a title in recent memory. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DidjobKweCs Baker's performance only gets better from there, but that opening scene contained some absolutely phenomenal acting that immediately informed its audience just how mature and emotionally challenging the title was going to be. The character certainly has some more weighty moments across the game's substantial runtime, but it's the introductory moments that you could show to anyone and watch their jaw hit the floor. Were there any performances that we missed? Post a comment below and let us know!

In this post: 
GTA GTA V
 
Posted On: 
Content Producer/Presenter

WhatCulture's very own resident movie guy, Ewan has been working in the content creation biz for over 10 years now, having started as a freelance contributor to WhatCulture Gaming all the way back in 2015. After graduating with a First-Class Honours in History from Northumbria University in 2017 (where he won a prize for a totally killer dissertation on the Watergate years), Ewan took on the role of Comics Editor at WhatCulture and quickly developed WhatCulture Comics into one of the biggest superhero-focused channels on YouTube. He followed this with a brief hiatus at Screen Rant in 2021, where he worked across the Gaming and Film sections as a writer and editor, before returning to WhatCulture as a Senior Content Producer / Presenter in 2023. He started his own podcast, We Love Dad Movies, in 2022, and has contributed several written pieces to the Eisner-nominated comics website Shelfdust as well. In his current role, Ewan incorporates his love of cinema, comic books, and history into written pieces and video essays for WhatCulture's Film & TV channel, as well as WhatCulture Gaming and WhatCulture Horror, with a particular focus on nineties-era Dad Movies, old school Westerns, and Golden Age Hollywood Noir. John Carpenter is his fave, and he thinks Batman Beyond should never have been cancelled. If that's your vibe, you'll probably like his stuff.