15 New Video Game Heroes - Ranked From Worst To Best

Mario, Sonic, Master Chief, Nathan Drake... who next?

Video Game Heroes
CD Projekt RED/Square Enix/Bethesda/Yacht Club

Have you noticed how the general 'image' of gaming has changed over the years?

Where in the 80s and 90s it was very much all about having a 'mascot'; a cutesy or otherwise attention-grabbing figurehead you could plaster on the front of any marketing campaign, as the generations advanced and matured, so did that approach.

Gone were the likes of Sonic, Crash and Mario - the latter is obviously still a big draw, but Nintendo are the only company so overtly trading on a 'traditional' image - and in was the advent of bulkier, more humanoid, embody-able figures like Nathan Drake and Master Chief. That mindset continued, we saw the rise and fall of the 'bulky space marine' after Gears of War dominated the latter 2000s, and as of right now, mascots and system-selling 'celebrity' characters have all but disappeared.

Now you buy a game for its mechanics, its world or its developer pedigree - or at least you do for the most part, as the majority of the following managed to be just as notable and worthwhile as the games themselves.

Have a think - which modern video game characters are worthy of hanging with the ones we all grew up with?

Spoilers: It's harder than you think...


15. JD Fenix (Gears Of War 4)

gears of war 4 JD fenix
Microsoft

Literally just a Nolan North/Nathan Drake impression stuff inside a spacesuit, JD is a man upstaged by his own surname. Case in point: Meeting up with his father, Marcus Fenix, star of the original Gears trilogy, who immediately becomes far more likeable and damn-near loveable, simply because he's not trying so damn hard.

If the original Gears helped spawn the aforementioned 'space marine' look, Uncharted has set in motion this manufactured attempt at a nonchalant persona we're now seeing multiple studios fall back on when they're aiming for 'mass appeal'.

Mass Effect Andromeda's male Ryder is the exact same (the exact same); a personality-by-design spreadsheet of C-grade grips come to life, masquerading as a worthwhile character thanks to otherwise solid game mechanics. There's nothing offensively bad about JD Fenix, but he reeks of everything wrong with each continued attempt to will consumer love onto a 'happy-go-lucky' hero.


14. Adam Jensen (Deus Ex: Human Revolution)

deus ex human revolution
Eidos

The other side of the coin to all this forced humour is the 'I've seen some things/I-talk-in-a-gruff-voice-because-I'm-just-that-damn-serious" archetype - one that voice actor Elias Toufexis was clearly told to emulate in the last two Deus Ex games. 2016's Mankind Divided saw Toufexis tone down the throat-gargling to a slightly less laughable degree, but Jensen as a character is barely anything more than a walking excuse to bust out as many augmented abilities as possible.

That's kinda the point, being he essentially lost his humanity when he was killed and brought back following a terrorist attack, but we rarely get insight into his mindset other than the occasional forlorn look out a window whilst smoking a cigarette.

Instead, the majority of your time controlling Jensen will be hearing Toufexis chew his way through lines of dialogue in a way that makes for many a hilarious impression, but ultimately never lands how they're supposed to.


13. Corvo Attano (Dishonored)

dishonored game
Arkane Studios

Speaking of randomly gruff protagonists, Corvo was initially mute in the first Dishonored as it felt like Arkane were going for the whole "silent badass" thing.

Then Dishonored 2 happened, and despite Stephen Russell's casting being a surefire way to immortalise the character as another true great (Russell previously voiced Garrett in the Thief series), he was written and played in the flattest way possible. Nothing quite so overly hilari-gruff as Adam Jensen, but nothing that leant any weight to proceedings, either.

Like Jensen, Corvo is saved as a video game character thanks to his abilities, which range from being able to teleport across cities to freezing time mid-firefight, and the party trick of possessing an enemy, only to walk them into the path of their own bullet.

Now that is cool, but imagine if they wrote a character around those mechanics that really made you love playing as them. It's such a missed opportunity.


12. The Dragonborn (Skyrim)

skyrim dragonborn
Bethesda

Aesthetically, Mr. Born is a 10; just a mound of muscle, intent and traditional fantasy rolled into one. The second we saw this fella adorning the various materials leading up to the new Elder Scrolls, we knew Bethesda were onto a winner.

Sadly, qualifying him as a character opens up a glorious can o' worms I'll let you fight out in the comments: Are mute protagonists with zero agency of their own, still characters?

Many Gordon Freeman fans seem to think so, and though I'll fall back on the Dragonborn's many Shouts, fighting styles and abilities to say he's an outstanding hero to play as, when it comes to personality or any descriptions beyond appearance, you're on your own.


11. Marcus Holloway (Watch Dogs 2)

watch dogs 2
Ubisoft

Watch Dogs 2 is one of the finest examples of a developer cracking after being constantly berated by the public.

"Okay, okay, alright, we're sorry. We'll get it right this time!"

As such, everything in WD2 is a fix from the original: The combat is FAR more in-depth, the tone is way less dire and actually embraces the sheer fun inherent in a city where literally everything is remote control, and new hero Marcus is the centre cog that turns all these things on a dime.

Playing as Holloway encourages you to bust out his laptop and fly an explosive-dropping drone into an enemy base. It makes you want to hang out with your in-game friends, do side missions, save the city and chill atop the San Francisco Observatory to watch the sunset.

Like Vice City and San Andreas, Watch Dogs 2 is an immaculate open-world game with a character that actively makes you want to see everything on offer - something even GTA V couldn't get right.


10. Agent Francis York Morgan (Deadly Premonition)

deadly premonition
Access Games

Onto a far more self-aware video game that doubles as a Twin Peaks tribute and then as its own beast entirely. Deadly Premonition is the sort of characterful, Japanese humour-infused delight you need to check out if Metal Gear Solid's more off-kilter moments ever did anything for you.

Playing as one 'Agent Francis York Morgan' (please just call him York), you unravel this truly bizarre murder mystery plot filled with more memorable individuals than a Pixar marathon. Morgan himself is a walking smorgasbord of western influence, part X-Files detectives, part Twin Peaks' Dale Cooper, part Hollywood film critic and all-parts memorable. Even the way he flicks his lighter open to randomly smoke during conversations is brilliant, and that's before I've mentioned how he thinks the way his coffee 'moves' in the morning can predict the future.

Developer SWERY (as he likes to be known) is as batsh*t-passionate about video games as they come, and Agent Francis York Morgan is like a tiny window in his completely loveable soul.


9. Meat Boy (Super Meat Boy)

Super Meat Boy
Team Meat

The nearest thing we've got to a back-to-basics retro-made-new 2D character in the vein of Mario, Meat Boy is just a simple cube of meat armed with a jump and a sprint, determined to right the wrongs of his world.

Also like Mario, his beloved princess (in a thematic sense) Bandage Girl, has been taken by the evil Dr. Fetus, resulting in some of the most brutally hard platforming you've ever played.

Thankfully, developers Team Meat continually refined the game over a very taxing development cycle (which I'd recommend checking out as part of Indie Game: The Movie), though when the end result was so authentic and still accessible as this, it was worth the meat-sweats and tears.

Mario's charms were routed in this 'everyman' (a plumber) doing the necessaries and saving the day. By proxy, Meat Boy is but a sliced-off embodiment of purely positive fatty intentions. What's not to love?


8. Garcia Hotspur (Shadows Of The Damned)

Shadows Of The Damned
Grasshopper Manufacture

If you thought Francis York Morgan and SWERY were a suitably ludicrous pop culture-referencing pair, enter Garcia 'F*cking' Hotspur, developed by the barmy army over at Grasshopper Manufactured, and directed with explicitly ridiculous purpose by none other than Suda51 (who's a person, not a group).

Garcia himself is a purple leather-wearing Mexican demon hunter. One with a friend named Johnson, who happens to be a floating flaming skull, though the latter does double as a whopping great pistol and a motorcycle when necessary.

Naturally, the whole game is as freewheeling as this - Suda51 also created No More Heroes and the recent PS4 Souls-like Let it Die, to name but two - including endlessly self-referential humour about how games are designed, alongside fighting the most inventive enemies you've ever seen.

Watch any trailer, any cutscene, and single SECOND of Hotspur in action, and you'll 'get' director Suda51's irreverent humour. It really is something else.


7. Lincoln Clay (Mafia III)

Mafia 3 III
2K

Take The Punisher, Luke Cage and Rambo, give them more of a darker initial edge in terms of how they get by (Lincoln is a member of the Black Mob who also happens to have served in 'Nam) and you've got one hell of a protagonist for the otherwise divisive Mafia III.

Though Clay is only 'hero' in the same vein as those aforementioned "Whatever it takes" types, his set up is a nicely clean-cut revenge tale - one that comes with stellar voice work and acting. There's a real anger in his voice and demeanour that you can tell is bubbling away below the surface.

You want to embody Clay as this instrument of pure retribution, you want to tear apart everything your newly-appointed enemy has built, and you want to do it in the most brutal way possible. It's rare that by boiling a character down to such a simple arc, it can succeed where more complex narratives fail, but everything about Mafia III's pure narrative drive is a welcome breath of fresh air.


6. Clementine (The Walking Dead)

walking dead clementine
Telltale

The WD games remain some of the most nerve-wracking and genuinely harrowing experiences you'll ever, with Clem - following all the training she received from Lee in season one - evolving into a young girl who will do whatever's necessary to survive the zombie-infested post-apocalypse.

Although you do have some control over how she's perceived by the other characters in terms of dialogue options and actions in the first game, many secondary characters come to rely and depend on her as both she and their collective groups mature in time.

Clem used to be the youngest female protagonist ever seen in a mainstream game, but as the writers keep throwing increasingly macabre events her way, it helps highlight just what stellar foundations were put in place back in that 2012 original.


5. Wei Shen (Sleeping Dogs)

Sleeping Dogs
Square Enix

The world is yet to see a brilliant Fast & the Furious or Point Break game, but the whole 'cop goes undercover and slowly loses their allegiance' setup is a tale as old as time. For Sleeping Dogs it's applied to Hong Kong, seeing you play as the phenomenally well-voiced and all-round likeable hero, Wei Shen.

Gameplay is enjoyably arcady, a potent mix of Batman Arkham-like combat, The Wheelman-esque driving and run n' gun segments all blending into one. It thunders along at a brilliant pace precisely because of Shen though, who thanks to Will Yun Lee's confident line reads and Shen's ability to not crack under pressure, makes for one of the most gripping crime thriller narratives in all of gaming.

Oh, and this is still an open-world game, so tomfoolery like the above is still on the table (providing you don't want to get marked down for un-cop like behaviour).

Never ask Wei Shen who he is...


4. Ciri (The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt)

Witcher 3 Ciri
CD Projekt RED

Geralt misses the cut thanks to originally appearing playable in 2007's first Witcher game. Instead I'm highlighting Ciri, a long fan-favourite from Andrzej Sapkowski's books, who in Wild Hunt, is attempting to flee the menacing Wild Hunt.

The Hunt themselves are a band of demonic Sauron lookalikes hellbent on assumedly killing Ciri to both understand and acquire her power, but Cirilla Fiona Elen Riannon (her full name) manages to outwit them at every turn.

A very strong and feisty individual, Ciri is blessed with a great number of abilities, using them to warp between groups of enemies at ease, or take down hulking griffins otherwise baying for blood. Atop her natural talents, she's a Witcher, schooled in the various ways to hunt the worst creatures around, looks out for her fellow human, isn't afraid to weaponise that latent power to devastating effect, and even willingly sacrifices herself to save the realm at the climax of the story.

Part of Witcher 3's magnificent scope is subtly tracking how you treat her over the course of the game, but if you let those most inherently individual components come through naturally, the happiest ending sees Ciri continue to protect the Continent, journeying off as an accomplished Witcher all her own.


3. Ellie (The Last Of Us)

Ellie The Last Of Us
Naughty Dog

What? Where's Joel?!

Well... even if you can totally empathise with his whole 'dooming the world to save his new surrogate daughter' thing (which I can), the main takeaway is ultimately that he's a bad egg. We know Joel had some shady background as a trader, was involved in keeping himself and brother Tommy alive in a way that "gave [Tommy] nightmares", and executed Marlene at the last second for the sake of making a clean getaway. Oh, and he lies about the latter, resulting in his 'daughter' going on the warpath, as seen in The Last of Us 2.

On the other hand is Ellie, and though living in this cordycep-infected world has forced her to be very cut and dry with personal relations, at the core she's courageous, willing to believe the good in those around her, and even wants to sacrifice herself to help synthesise a cure for humankind.

It's precisely because the world around her is so mired in desperation that Ellie being forthright and logical stands out - something that for as much as many of us all love Joel, ends up putting her here instead of him.


2. Aloy (Horizon Zero Dawn)

horizon zero dawn
Sony

Pegged to be Sony's 'next big PlayStation mascot', I... don't think that's become the case, though the fault lies with everything I described in the introduction - the industry's size doesn't work with marketing where your entire brand is behind one character anymore, even if they are extremely well crafted.

Speaking of which, we get to see Aloy grow from an infant all the way through to a young adult, challenging the various tribespeople and their values, as she's forever labelled an unwanted outcast due to not knowing her mother. Obviously, the world of Horizon is one filled with just as many comments on religion and individualism as it is the advancement of technology, fear-mongering and destiny, but we're with Aloy every step of the way.

She finds out precisely what happened to her mother, who Aloy is 'supposed' to be, those former tribespeople attempt to shift their view on her due to unforeseen circumstances, and Aloy's reaction/rant about their fickle nature is one of the best scenes in recent memory.

Hopefully Sony will do a better job of pushing Aloy going forward, but right now, the quality of her game and the writing within more than does so already.


1. Shovel Knight (Shovel Knight)

Shovel Knight
Yacht Club

The gallant, the dirt-cleansing, the one-and-only grace-giving world-saving hero himself, Shovel Knight is by far the most loveable, iconic and downright brilliant new-age character by a landslide.

Enough of the shovel-based puns though, as developers Yacht Club really did knock it out the park with the design of his game, too. Now part of the Treasure Trove, a series of multiple campaigns focusing on other characters from the 2014 original, Shovel Knight sees the titular hero embark on a noble quest to save his beloved Shield Knight from the evil Enchantress.

Atop this fantastical backdrop, everything about Shovel Knight's approach to life makes you love controlling him. He forward-flips onto each stage, feverishly searches treasure chests for jewels, hops aboard his shovel for a downward, Ducktales-style attack - or he unlocks a range of abilities like mid-air dashes and fireballs to dispatch foes in style. All that, when he's not stopping to fish or wow the townsfolk with sheer heroic head-turning stature.

Since launch, Shovel Knight has been more than embraced by gamers and the public, being immortalised in a TON of places, appearing as an official Nintendo Amiibo, and even most recently as quest-giver in Yooka-Laylee.

The soundtrack, the look of the game itself, playing it and watching Shovel Knight's courageous charge forth when you first set him in motion - it's why we game, personified. Steel thy shovel!

--

Who's the best new video game hero? Let us know in the comments!


Watch Next


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.