15 Worst Gaming Heroes Of The Last Generation

These characters are flat, one-dimensional, boring, annoying, pathetic or make us want them to die, just to escape the monotony.

A good protagonist should embody everything a gamer wants to be, or alternatively have interesting flaws that make us involved with their personality and characters. The protagonist, at no point, should be flat, one-dimensional, boring, annoying, pathetic or make us want them to die, just to escape the monotony. This past generation, we've seen many great heroes rise up to the challenge. Sack Boy, despite being just, well...a sack, made us fall in love with his crazy expression and array of outfits. Some, like Raiden from Metal Gear Solid, managed to redeem themselves after being a floppy haired moron in his previous gaming attempts. If you've sucked in the past, coming back as a blade-wielding killing machine in a cyborg suit is a sure-fire way to redeem yourself. The list goes on and on. Nathan Drake, Joel from the Last of Us, Solid Snake, Chell from Portal and countless others have all stepped up to the plate to bring us marvellous experiences over the past few years, but it is not these people that we need concern ourselves with. Instead we're going to look at those heroes that were so terribly pants, so annoying, so boring and so naff that they probably didn't have a place being in our games at all. Step forward, entry number fifteen.

15. Norman Jayden - Heavy Rain

Wading through the turbulent waters of Heavy Rain's narrative took a lot of time, effort and ability to skip over random plotholes, but the character that stood out the most as a strange entry in the narrative is agent Norman Jayden, a weird dude with fancy spectacles and a penchant for shaking and hallucinating stuff. While main protagonist Ethan Mars is wandering around shouting Jason at everyone and their mother, Jayden is entering crime scenes, using his fancy glasses to make everything highlighted and descending gradually into madness. Old Norman is responsible for finding the Origami Killer you see as part of the FBI, but what they don't know is the fancy technology with the glasses he uses causes him to completely trip out and he's reliant on a mysterious drug that makes everything nice again. The main problem I had with Norman was he just kinda felt like he was thrown in to the character list just for the hell of it. We already had an investigative cop in the form of Scott Shelby as a playable character, so Norman had to differ from him so they gave him a set of specs and a drug habit that made no sense whatsoever and set him off to save the day. Heavy Rain's plot was, for the most part, pretty good. I really felt it was let down by these sections overall and the game would have benefited from removing them altogether.

14. Marcus Fenix - Gears Of War

Let's face it everyone, Marcus Fenix was a bit of a crap character. Despite being voiced by the man behind Bender of Futurama fame, Marcus had no particular redeeming qualities other than you used him to chop things into little bits. He showed emotion rarely and was eclipsed constantly by his chum Dom who had much better storylines going on. Marcus was just...there. He was a character we inhabited, but never really got to know. Sure we met his daddy and stuff and killed countless Locust along the way, but Marcus' story all ended with a whimper rather than a bang. Yeah, Gears of War may never have really been about storyline, but Marcus' character really didn't help that along any. The supporting cast, particularly Cole, Baird and Dom, were much more interesting, less growly and had actual dynamics about them. Marcus, on the other hand, was just a big burly gentleman with a chainsaw gun and penchant for lingering behind chest-high walls that conveniently spawned wherever he did go.

13. Hawke - Dragon Age 2

How do you make a successful sequel? Of course it's simple - you strip out absolutely everything that made the first game awesome, limit the ability to explore, change the combat system, change the storyline, throw in some repeated dungeon design and make your character a generic dullard who ends up caught in a silly political conspiracy. If you couldn't interpret the disdain for Dragon Age 2 dripping off that previous paragraph, let's make one thing clear. I didn't like Dragon Age 2. It was such a slap in the face for those of us that loved the first game, all stripped back in favour of trying to nab the attention of more people through a dumbed down experience. Yep, it's great that more people should be playing a game, but surely the best way to nab the attention of gamers is to actually make a good game, rather than a truly painful experience filled with more loading screens than is suitable for maintaining sanity. As such, it's hard to like Hawke, the burly man with the beardy thingy or the generic woman without the beardy thingy who rapidly becomes far too difficult to mould into the character you want, like you could on the original game. The fact that multiple race options, such as dwarves and elves, were also removed from the equation, meant even less choice. Hawke was basically an attempt by game developers Bioware to replicate the success of Commander Shepard from Mass Effect. Unfortunately Hawke very much isn't our favourite character on the Citadel, and should not return for the (hopefully) better sequel Dragon Age: Inquisition.

12. Joanna Dark - Perfect Dark Zero

Way back in ye olde times of yore - also known as 2005 - a console known as the Xbox 360 was unleashed upon the populace via the local town crier. 'HERE YE, HERE YE!' he would shout, 'YE XBOX 360 BE RELEASING THIS YEAR!' and there was much rejoicing. Particularly in my household. Back then, when I was but the tender age 15, I was amazed by the super shiny new console that I found that Santa had left me that Christmas day. He also happened to give me Perfect Dark Zero, a launch title for the console. At the time, I thought it was absolutely the bestest thing ever. The shiny new graphics and wonderment at the new controller kept me enthralled for ages, but I was very naive. Perfect Dark Zero was a very bad game and - after going back and replaying the superior originally on N64 - was an extremely poor attempt at revitalising a franchise. Protagonist Joanna Dark, with her flaming red hair and general witticisms, has such faded into obscurity and can be found right at the back of the cupboard of forgotten gaming characters, coated thoroughly in dust. She's currently hanging out there with Crash Bandicoot, who is currently actually buried under said pile of dust and won't be resurfacing anytime soon. Of course the same is nearly always true of launch titles. The best games always come out after years of a platform being released and Perfect Dark Zero was never going to be amazing. It could have been a new franchise for the Xbox 360, but alas, such things were not to be.

11. Lymle Lemuri Phi - Star Ocean: The Last Hope

Just eat her. Please. Seriously, every single time this character spoke, I wanted to just end it all. The very spawn of the devil in videogame character form, Lymle was a pathetic little girl with magical powers, with a pathetic little girl voice that grated on my nerves like the world's biggest cheesegrater. If you look into the lore of under-appreciated game Star Ocean: the Last Hope, Lymle is actually fifteen years old. Due to some mumbo jumbo and things about planets she just appears as an annoying imp destined to bring about the apocalypse due to annoyance. Can you tell I really didn't like Lymle yet? It's a shame really, because the other characters of TLH weren't actually that bad. I invested many an hour into it, and thought it was actually one of the better RPGs of the last few years. It's just that every, single, cutscene, this bloody character had to speak. She should be erased from history immediately and my memory should be erased. It's making me angry just remembering it.

10. Starkiller - Star Wars: The Force Unleashed

Is he a clone? Is he not a clone? Is he dead? Is a hero, or a villain? Is he secretly shacked up with Darth Vader on a night time? Why does he hold his lightsaber behind his back like a silly person does? Surely that's asking for trouble? All of these are mysteries of Darth Vader's secret apprentice Starkiller, who starred in the Force Unleashed 1 and 2. Considered Star Wars canon, these games bridge the gap between the events of the newer trilogy, Episode I, II and III, with the older trilogy, episode IV, V and VI. It was a pretty exciting premise for a Star Wars fan and although being Starkiller, the super-beefed up Jedi/Sith of doom with basically unlimited power, the storyline really wasn't that good. This is especially true of the second entry in the series which fell totally flat about halfway through an incredibly short narrative and got bogged down in nonsense. He's certainly no Han Solo, that's for sure. Star Wars has struggled to gain characters as memorable as those in the original series for years now and Starkiller was certainly not the right person for the job. He may not be the worst hero ever, but Starkiller is certainly deserving of a place on this list.

9. Jake Conway - Ride To Hell: Retribution

If you're a star in what is pretty much universally accepted as one of, if not the worst game of gaming's seventh generation, you're going to get on a list such as this. Jake Conway, biker, idiot and sexist-extraordinaire is completely unrelatable, poorly voice acted, stars in a game that's so bad its laughable and - most hilariously - stars repeatedly in awkward sex scenes constantly where everybody involved leaves their clothes on. Better still, Jake is surrounded by his equally irritating biker chums, likes to spend his days taking part in motorcycle drives that feel like you're driving a truck made of glue through a pile of glue, and just generally looks like a bit of a tit. Of course as is the case with all things terrible - see the Mortal Kombat movies or Batman, circa 1960 - it's important to actually experience these things first hand for yourself to see how bad things really can get. Then you can laugh about it and feel better about all the churned out AAA sequels you were just getting sick of. Huzzah for Ride to Hell and well done Jake, you're officially a turd.

8. The Cast Of Final Fantasy XIII

They'd all be deserving of a place on this list individually I'm sure (except the Chocobo chick, who was brill) but the cast of the 13th entry in the Final Fantasy series are all about as interesting as listening to a lecture on the history of outboard motors presented by a dull man with a suspicious moustache. Despite this fact they've gone on to now be in three whole games, with series creators Square Enix blatantly ignoring fans' disdain for the characters and plowing ahead regardless. Let's talk about why everyone's annoying in greater detail, shall we? Lightning - Even moodier than Squall (and that's saying something), unrelatable and dull. Has pink hair and a sword thingy. That's about it. Snow -Far too nice for his own good. Also wears a silly coat and silly hat and has a girlfriend who looks like a tiny tiny person when stood next to him. Hope - The whiny kid of doom who constantly whines about everything that happens and doesn't get any better over time. Vanille - The bundle of energy with an Australian accent. Nerve-grating Fang - The stoic warrior, with an Australian accent. Basic carbon copy of Lightning, with less pink hair. Sazh - Has a fro and a child. Has a bird that lives in his fro, which is more interesting. So yeah, there's the characters. Good job the world was full of things to explore and see and do and all that right? Oh...yeah...it wasn't was it? Give me Cloud, Squall, Zidane, Tidus and all their supporting cast over these guys any day.

7. The Cast Of Dead Island

Remember when we all saw the really emotional, zombie-filled, slow-motion rewind trailer for Dead Island and it looked like it was going to be a moving experience that really made us all fall in love with a new franchise? Yeah, me too. In reality, Dead Island was nothing like its trailer. It was cleverly done marketing that generated a lot of the buzz and shifted a lot of copies of the game (which isn't terrible, but not spectacular) but its generic cast of random people do nothing to engage our involvement. In fact, halfway through the first Dead Island, for no reason whatsoever, all four of these characters suddenly magically appear together as a group even though you're never seen them together before. I understand that co-op is an option in this game, but this one really made the whole thing just look stupid. With pretty damn bad voice acting thrown in, no memorable lines to speak of and basically no reason to actually get involved with your character, the Dead Island series ended up being much worse than it really could have been. Ah well, there's always the Walking Dead for tears in the zombie apocalypse eh?

6. The Dudes And Dudettes From Ninety Nine Nights

Despite sort of becoming a series due to the fact that its had two games, even though practically no one liked the first game, the Ninety Nine Nights franchise, which has absolutely hardly anything to do with nights, ninety nine of them or anything whatsoever, produced some equally baffling characters to play around with. If you've never heard of Ninety Nine Nights, there's probably a reason for that. N3, as 'tis affectionately dubbed, is a hack n slash super beat-em-up where you are cast as one of seven heroes battling legions of countless enemies repeatedly using uber-powered moves of doom. Admittedly this one did come out way back in 2006 - and as such we can't expect too much of it - but even for its time, the Ninety Nine Nights experience was hard to stomach thanks to bad level design, impossible objectives and moves that left you completely exposed to attacks that would drain most of your health bar. More annoying still, the cast of heroes were irritating, pointless and were meant to have storylines that all branched together to make one glorious whole, culminating in an event that tied everything together. Instead we got a generic list of dudes, including the busty teenage temptress in tight-fitting armour, the lovely blonde floppy haired heroic knight with the posh accent, a goblin dude to represent the other races, the big burly gentleman with the big burly weapon that's almost entirely useless thanks to being far too slow, the annoying 12 year old with magical powers and....a troll. Throw in some poor voice acting, a dash of plot points that made no sense and - voila! - you've got the recipe for a perfectly steamed pile of festering manure with a side order of characters that make you want to beat yourself to death with your controller. Magnifique.

5. Naughty Bear

I'm pretty convinced that the people behind Naughty Bear were two things. Firstly they were big fans of Conker's Bad Fur Day, the excellently adult-themed platformer that graced us with its presence on the Nintendo 64 all those moons ago. They were also clearly not very good as Naughty Bear, despite trying to be as naughty as possible, was quite clearly just a poor attempt at emulating Conker's success. A third-person shooter at its core, Naughty Bear is about a cute little teddy bear who gets laughed at by his friends and - rather than resolving it nicely as is the wont of most other cuddly bears - decides to go on a killing spree. He's a very naughty bear you see. Widely panned by critics and gamers alike, Naughty Bear should have immediately withdrew whence he came, back into the twisted minds of the game developers. But wait, what is this? Is that the Lack of Logic Alarm ringing proudly out across the rooftops? It certainly is my friends! Despite Naughty Bear being named among the worst games of the year in 2010, it managed to spawn forth an equally bad sequel not too long ago. So to sum up what Naughty Bear was, it's basically like a really bad, bad rip-off of kids TV. Naughty doesn't speak, but does facial expressions while a silly narrator talks over the carnage. Now if Naughty Bear is to ever come back - which he shouldn't, ever - he should really go and study Conker again to see how to do it right. Y'know, "...I am the great and mighty poo...." See what I'm saying?

4. Fi - The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword

Although she's admittedly not the star of the show, Fi deserves a place on this list. She is, after all, the only way Link knows how to do anything ever. Fi, if you're not familiar with the character, is Link's helper in The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword. A manifestation of the power within Link's sword, Fi's only function within the game is to literally pop out just after you've watched a cutscene showing you what to do and then explain exactly what you have to do in lengthy, robotic fashion. Such examples include popping out to tell you your heart count is low despite the game constantly beeping to alert you of this fashion, telling you she has deduced a 95% probability that the structure you just opened contains whatever you're looking for and just generally wanting to make me cut her to pieces with my Master Sword. It's a real shame actually, as Skyward Sword is probably the very finest game that's ever been released on the Wii. But Fi...man, she was hard work. I literally felt my rage growing every single time she popped out of the sword and started talking nonsense to me. She may not have been the hero of the piece altogether, but I simply couldn't get through this list without including one of the most irritating characters not only from this generation, but gaming altogether. Bring back Navi. All is forgiven.

3. Ratonhnhaké:ton - Assassin's Creed III

If you can pronounce that, I award you with one cookie. Well done. Better known by his adopted name of Connor, old Ratonhnhaké:ton was the protagonist of AC III, aka the one in the series that was a bit rubbish. To be fair to him he had some big boots and hood to fill when Ezio Auditore de Firenze bowed out in Assassin's Creed Revelations, but his character was just so, so bad that he had no hope in hell of ever being another Ezio. I mostly blame the voice acting for not caring about Connor. He sounded at all times like a completely disinterested bystander who was simply along for the ride. Emotion wasn't part of Connor's repertoire, and I honestly think dressing a part of the wall in Assassin's robes would have made a much more gripping protagonist. It's a shame really because the setting of ACIII actually had potential to be great. When you're playing as someone you don't like though, you're simply not going to enjoy it. Connor's plight was not helped in the slightest for not letting us actually play as him at the start of the game. Instead we were Haytham Kenway, a witty, interesting character with an interesting tale to tell. Seriously, read the accompanying book for AC III - it tells the story of Haytham and it's much more interesting than Connor's ever was. The reception to Connor is clear from his removal from the series after one game. Instead he was replaced by swash-buckling pirate/assassin Edward Kenway, grandfather of Haytham. Requiescat in Pace Connor, you shan't be missed.

2. Duke Nukem - Duke Nukem Forever

Who'd have thought we'd ever outgrown the Duke? Always a complete douche, sexist and exceptionally amusing back in the day, Duke finally returned to our gaming systems in the last generation with the game that had constantly been in development hell, Duke Nukem Forever. Perhaps it should have stayed dead. Years out of touch with both gaming and the humour of its audience, Duke Nukem Forever truly made most people realise that the Duke's time had come and gone. The once amazing hero had spent too long in the cupboard of forgotten game protagonists to ever reclaim his crown and was destined only to be remembered as the person who wrote with an actual piece of excrement. The future of the Duke franchise remains hazy but unless something really drastic is done, there's no way to recover from Duke Nukem Forever. A game that long in development should have been amazing and revitalised Duke's fortunes. Instead the Duke can now be found drinking from a brown paper bag in an alleyway down the town centre, drawing on walls with his own bowel movements. A not-so-valiant effort Mr Duke.

1. Sonic The Hedgehog - Sonic 06, Unleashed & Others

Yes, technically Sonic is actually the by-product of many generations before the last one, but he's stuck around last-gen as well and he's really had a tough run. The Sonic series really hasn't survived the transition into modern gaming. What was once awesome is now mediocre, with crap characters, pointless mechanics and frustrating level design all thrown in to create some truly terrible games. There were some glimmers of hope for the franchise in Sonic Unleashed and Sonic Generations, but terrible games such as Sonic 06 really tarnished the speedy hedgehog's legacy. Seriously, did you play Sonic 06? It was absolutely appalling. With the longest loading times ever after moving for about two seconds, deaths that occurred for no apparent reason due to shoddy level design and an actual human female falling in love with a massive blue hedgehog, this game was just ghastly from start to finish. The 'werehog' sections of Sonic Unleashed were also guilty of ruining Sonic. A pseudo beat-em-up with Sonic in faux-werewolf form, the hedgehog lost his trademark speed and replaced it instead with stretchy arms for reasons that are still yet to become apparent. So well done Sonic, you've managed to top this list with some truly appalling efforts. Here's hoping that the next generation is kinder to you or you alternatively just give up and die already. So, who was your worst character from the last generation of gaming? Tell us your woes down below in the comments and we shall remember them extremely unfondly.

Contributor
Contributor

Dan Curtis is approximately one-half videogame knowledge, and the other half inexplicable Geordie accent. He's also one quarter of the Factory Sealed Retro Gaming podcast.