20 Most Critically Adored Games Of 2014

The critics have spoken.

Super Smas Bros Rating
Nintendo
It's pretty safe to say that the first full year for the PS4 and Xbox One left a bit of a sour taste in many gamers' mouths - even if the struggling Wii U had its best year to date. The year that was supposed to be a watershed time for consoles saw numerous delays, seemingly unfinished games, and flat-out disappointments and while there were some great games, there were plainly way too many poor ones too. In a market missing the usual number of tent-poles, Watch Dogs and Destiny disappointed; Assassin's Creed: Unity and Drive Club were very broken upon release; Batman: Arkham Knight and The Order: 1886 were delayed, leaving precious little in big name terms to get too excited about. And yet, amidst all the turbulence, there were still games that exceeded expectations or seemingly exploded out of the blue. From high-octane AAA blockbusters to quiet, emotional indie games, 2014 may not have been as awe-inspiring as fans had probably hoped, but it still provided many memorable games and moments. And there were more than a few games that delighted the critics - the 20 highest rated of which (excluding iOS and remastered versions - because that's just cheating, even when it's GTA V on XBox One and PS4) - according to MetaCritic - follow here in celebration of their achievements.

20. Super Smash Bros. - Wii U

Super Smash Bros 600x400
Nintendo

Rating: 92/100

The ultimate party game is STILL the ultimate party game! Super Smash Bros. on Wii U was - inevitably - a smash hit.

Similarly to Mario Kart, Nintendo have a winning formula with Smash Bros. and simply iterate where need be; more characters, better level design/detail, 8-players, and more modes. Super Smash Bros. Wii U is the best in the series and the game of the year.


19. Dark Souls II - Xbox 360

Dark Souls 2
From Software

Rating: 91/100

YOU DIED! And apparently so did millions of others in 2014 because Dark Souls II was pretty damn popular.

Taking the soul-crushing difficulty that made its predecessor so popular, the devilish sequel maintained the difficulty while ramping up the visuals, gameplay and adding some huge monsters.


18. Bayonetta 2 - Wii U

Bayonetta 2
Platinum Games

Rating: 91/100

5 years after the original, Bayonetta 2 proved to be well worth the wait.

A Wii U exclusive, the sequel was enthralling, beautiful, epic, and a new standard-bearer for the hack 'n' slash genre.


17. Velocity 2X - PS Vita

Velocity
FuturLab

Rating: 90/100

Released on both PS Vita and PS4, Velocity 2X proved to be at its best on the Vita.

Velocity Ultra was a great game but 2X improved upon it in every way; stunning visuals, near-perfect gameplay, and an awesome soundtrack.


16. Shovel Knight - 3DS

903530

Rating: 90/100

Shovels and knights... what's not to love? Okay, so maybe that's not the easiest sell in the world, but it worked.

Shovel Knight blasted onto 3DS and became somewhat of a phenomenon, thanks to its charming visuals and old-school mechanics. Look out for it in 2015 on PS3, PS4 and PS Vita.


15. Out Of The Park Baseball 2015 - PC

Out Of The Park Baseball 15
OOTP Productions

Rating: 89/100

Out of the Park 15 achieved far higher ratings than Playstation behemoth MLB: The Show '14. The baseball simulator hit a home run on PC's.

Out of the Park 15 gives players unprecedented freedom for creation and personalization, as well as being the best pure baseball sim out there.


14. Child Of Light - PS3

Child Of Light
Ubisoft

Rating: 89/100

Ubisoft's Child of Light was the highest rated game of 2014 for the studio, proving that, sometimes, heart and charm are more important than millions of dollars and hundreds of studios.

Simple and effective mechanics, endearing characters and beautiful art, all wrapped up in a wonderful bite-sized RPG.


13. Dragon Age: Inquisition - PS4

Dragon Age: Inquisition
BioWare

Rating: 89/100

"I'm here to set things right. Also? To look dashing." Dorian pretty much described the whole game.

Taking every lesson they learned from Mass Effect, Bioware turned Dragon Age into an unmissable RPG that may have set the bar for the genre.


12. Mario Kart 8 - Wii U

Mario Kart 8
Nintendo

Rating: 88/100

Another year and the Italian plumber does it again, and in serious style by all accounts.

The ever-improving Mario Kart takes the fantastic formula and builds upon it every year, with better track design, character models and even more anarchy.


11. Hearthstone: Heroes Of Warcraft - PC

Hearthstone ccg
Blizzard

Rating: 88/100

Hearthstone is a collectible-card game set in the Warcraft universe, and a damn addictive one at that.

Free-to-play done right - this was one of the biggest compliments thrown at Hearthstone, along with its charming visuals and friendly design.


10. Middle Earth: Shadow Of Mordor - Xbox One

903525

Rating: 87/100

Aaaannnd there goes another Orc head. Somehow killing them relentlessly never got boring, and obviously critics agreed.

Shadow of Mordor took the best elements of Batman and Assassins Creed, and melded them with the Lord Of The Rings lore, to create the surprise hit of the year.


9. The Walking Dead Season 2 - PS3

The Walking Dead S02
Telltale Games

Rating: 87/100

The second season of Telltale's episodic Walking Dead series was every bit as exciting, dark, emotional and twisted as the first. And fans loved it.

Taking Clementine on another cross-country journey, Telltale's second season of the interactive adventure game left everyone desperate for a third season.


8. The Talos Principle - PC

Talos Principle
Croteam

Rating: 87/100

Assuming the role of a sentient AI, players must navigate diverse locales and solve complex puzzles in order to figure out what happened to the humans.

The Talos Principle is that rare example of a game that is every bit as smart and intriguing as it tries to be.


7. Divinity: Original Sin - PC

Divinity Original Sin
Larian Studios

Rating: 87/100

From humble beginnings, Divinity: Original Sin was a Kickstarter project that sold over half a million copies and received critical acclaim.

The best of old RPG's meets a modern package in a challenging game recommendable to any RPG fan.


6. NBA 2K15 - PC

Nba 2k15
2K

Rating: 87/100

Most sports games are a safe bet for high sales and critical praise but NBA 2K15 was the cream of the crop in 2014.

Standing above the competition, NBA 2K15 was acclaimed for its amazing graphics, smart A.I and phenomenal MyCareer mode.


5. Astebreed - PC

Astebreed
Edelweiss

Rating: 86/100

Resogun meets Gundam Wing in this high-octane shoot 'em up by Japanese indie dev, Edelweiss.

Critics praised the arcade-style shooter for its slick visuals and exemplary controls, touting it as one of the best shooters of 2014.


4. Legend Of Grimrock II - PC

903520

Rating: 86/100

Dungeon-crawling PC sequel, Legend of Grimrock II was a very pretty game with a particular emphasis on old-school puzzle solving.

For anyone who had played the first game, the follow-up was a joy, taking everything that worked so well first time out and refining, improving and expanding.


3. Titanfall - Xbox One

903519

Rating: 86/100

Touted as the successor to Call of Duty, Titanfall turned out to be more of a whisper in the wind.

It says something about the state of the genre at the minute that it's also the only FPS game to break into the top 20.


2. Shantae And The Pirate's Curse - Wii U

Shantae Pirates Curse
Capcom

Rating: 86/100

Uber-Japanese platformer, Shantae And The Pirate's Curse on Wii U turned out to be one of the best platformers of the year.

Boasting challenging, varied and most of all entertaining gameplay, it's one that rewarded commitment and skill in even the hardiest of players.


1. The Swapper - PS Vita

903517

Rating: 86/100

A MetroidVania-style puzzle platformer set in space... what's not to love?

Though initially released on PC, the decorated game came to PS Vita and consoles, including the Wii U late in 2014, picking up the same kind of attention as when it first landed.


Contributor
Contributor

Journalism student from Ireland. Interested in video games, books, rock music, films, comics, TV and wrestling - the basics! Check out my Twitter for PS4 screenshots and random comments!