22 Biggest Disappointments Of E3 2016

Crash Bandicoot is back... kinda.

Crash Bandicoot Kingdom Hearts 3 God Of War 4 Scalebound
Sony & Microsoft

E3 2016 is over for another year, and the roadmap for the next 12 months of gaming seems firmly laid out.

As exciting a time as it truly is to be a gamer, this was overall one of the milder, more mixed E3s: only Sony really delivered anything remotely approaching a home-run, while the other conferences were a combination of good, bad and cringe-worthy.

The disappointments range squarely from gameplay reveals that didn't live up to the hype, to release date announcements that never came, and some decisions both creatively and business-wise that have rightly been met with a ton of skepticism.

Some of these letdowns will pan out for the best in the end, whereas others are already doomed to mediocrity. Either way, these reveals and non-reveals left us craving so much more coming out of the expo.

Here are the 22 biggest disappointments from E3 2016...

22. No Proper Mass Effect: Andromeda Gameplay

Mass Effect Andromeda
EA

Though EA dropped a two-and-a-half minute Mass Effect: Andromeda trailer at E3, it's a shame that a) that was all we got and b) actual gameplay footage was only scattered throughout.

Most of the trailer was rendered in a cinematic style totally not indicative of the actual gameplay, and much of it was more a behind-the-scenes featurette than anything else.

Sure, the graphics look absolutely amazing from the little we did see, and the new Mako is all sorts of awesome, but given that we're a year out from the game's official announcement and probably less than 9 months from it actually hitting stores, many were reasonably expecting an extended gameplay demo.

Sadly, it didn't materialise.


21. Microsoft's "Play Anywhere" Only Supports Digital Games

Microsoft E3 2016
Microsoft

E3 saw Microsoft introduce their Play Anywhere service, where gamers can buy select games on either Xbox One or Windows 10 and be able to play it on the other platform without needing to buy a second copy.

It's a great idea, though sadly will only work for digital games, which kills a lot of the appeal for those who still buy physical either for collecting, for selling in the future, or because digital storefronts can be more expensive than retail.

While it makes sense from Microsoft's perspective to operate in this way, as policing physical copies would be much more difficult, couldn't they give every physical copy of each game a serial number that ties it to an Xbox Live account or something like that?

On one hand it's a consumer-friendly move, but on the other, it also entices gamers to place more power and trust in the hands of Microsoft.


20. No Gender Options In The Legend Of Zelda

Zelda Breath Of The Wild
Nintendo

Persistent rumours spread in the weeks leading up to E3 that Nintendo would announce a gender option in the new Zelda game.

However, it turned out to be total bunk in the end, much to the dismay of those who were hoping for more inclusive ways to play the awesome-looking new adventure title.

It's not the end of the world, as fans have dealt with a male Link all these years just fine, but considering how Link's gender has so little bearing on the plot, this is a rare franchise where a gender option would work without potentially screwing things up.

Maybe it'll happen one day, but not this time. Sorry, folks.


19. The New Prey Has Nothing To Do With The Original

Prey e3
Bethesda

Yes, the new Prey game looks fascinating and beautiful, but it also seems a million miles away from both the unique Cherokee characters and quirky tone of the original, not to mention the direct sequel that was eventually cancelled in favour of this distinct reboot.

So different is this take on the same IP that most probably didn't realise what it was until the title appeared at the end. As such, one has to ask why they even bothered using the name of a fairly obscure 2006 shooter: it's not like the original has a ton of brand identity attached to it.

Perhaps Bethesda's thinking simply came down to "Prey is a cool word for a game, and the original's fanbase is small enough that we can get away with just recycling the name for a new FPS."


18. Sony's Crash Bandicoot PS4 Tease

Crash Bandicoot Skylanders
Activision

Gamers the world over went into fanboy meltdown mode when the distinctive Crash Bandicoot music hit during Sony's conference... before it was announced that the original Crash trilogy will be getting remastered from the ground-up for release on PS4.

It was exciting news, but fans couldn't help but feel a little trolled when Sony Interactive Entertainment Chairman Shawn Layden followed up with, "Crash Bandicoot will also appear first on the PlayStation 4 this October... in Skylanders Imaginators."

It sounded like a brand new Crash game for PS4 was about to be announced, and then the rug was pulled out for some Imaginators nonsense that most fans of the original Crash games couldn't give a damn about.

Yes, the remaster news is awesome, and should lead to a new Crash game down the line if it sells well, but damnit, they really had us going for a moment there...


17. Recore's Disappointing Gameplay Reveal

Recore 2016
Microsoft Studios

Though its teaser trailer turned a lot of heads at last year's E3, the more extensive gameplay footage from Recore this year sadly didn't strike the same note.

The jumping and shooting animations in particular looked incredibly rough, like something you'd see in an early alpha rather than a game just 3 months away from release.

The graphics also weren't particularly impressive, and considering that this felt like an exciting new IP 12 months ago, it's a shame that the anticipation pretty much slid away after this totally underwhelming unveiling.

It looks like a game you'd maybe buy at the "indie price" (for want of a better term), but not at a full, boxed retail price point.


16. Quake Champions Isn't Coming To Consoles

Quake Champions
Bethesda

Yes, there's a new Quake on the horizon! Hooray! Well, if you're a PC gamer, but if you stick strictly to consoles, you'll be depressed to learn that Quake Champions is a PC exclusive, due to the game's technical requirements in service of the competitive gaming circuit.

Given how few shooters are PC exclusives these days, it seemed like a given that the console crowd would get this one and lap it up, but instead they'll have to sit it out, which seems pretty harsh.

Quake may have first and foremost been a PC franchise, but like the new Doom, it would be an easy multi-platform hit in the right hands.


15. Scalebound Is Utterly Unimpressive

Scalebound 2016
Microsoft

After giving E3 a miss last year, Scalebound returned this time for an extended look at some co-op multiplayer gameplay.

Sadly, it just didn't inspire much excitement at all: the graphics, characters, writing and gameplay mechanics all seem either dull or cribbed from better prior games.

All in all, it just doesn't seem very unique or interesting despite the massive scale of the boss fight shown off. It was an absolute shoulder shrug of a demonstration, neither terrible nor memorable nor especially good.

This is one game that really needed to show up with something impressive after missing last year's show, and PlatinumGames categorically failed to do that.


14. Not Enough Information About Steep

Steep game
Ubisoft

The gameplay footage we saw of Ubisoft's new extreme sports IP Steep certainly looked impressive and promising, but there's one big problem: we still don't really know what it is.

Yes, you can explore the Alps and race against your pals, but what else is there to actually make the game worth a full-priced retail purchase?

What's been shown so far doesn't seem hugely populated in terms of content, especially as Ubisoft didn't do a terrific job of playing-up the scale or really explaining the bulk of the game.

It's still an intriguing title, but one that needs some elaboration in the near-future, especially with its release planned for December.


13. Gears Of War 4's Gameplay Is Just Business As Usual

Gears Of War 4
The Coalition

The lengthy gameplay footage for Gears of War showed off the brutal and visually lavish warfare we've come to expect from the series... but simply didn't do much to show the series evolving in any significant way.

Compare Gears to the other GoW, God of War, which took a bold step forward for its first PS4 outing. By contrast, Gears basically seems like the same old gameplay with little variation (beyond some snazzy new toys and sharper graphics), and while it'll probably be a fun outing, those going in expecting a jaw-dropping leap may end up disappointed.

It probably didn't help that the dialogue was absolutely atrocious, too, not that the series has ever been known for its wit and sophistication.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.