4 Video Games That Prove The Review System Is Broken

Godhand01

Review systems are just baffling. Think about it for a while, and they just are. How is the quality of a game quantifiable on a hundred point scale? Who says what five stars means? What is a B+, and then how does Metacritic turn that into a number? Video game websites play a large role in a game's success. How many of us are guilty of judging a game on it's review score? I have been guilty in the past of totally writing off games that I have come to love when I finally pick it up. It is only human to assume that a journalist is in a position of authority so should be listened to. And you know what, sometimes that's true. Sometimes reviews get it totally right. There are, after all, a lot of terrible terrible games out there. But in the end, review is opinion. What one person thinks is utter tripe could be your golden cup of tea. Reviews are strange because there was so much weight given to them in the first place, both on the side of players and developers, but now a good review is essential to a game's survival. Of course, general consensus is hard to deny, and that's why the website Metacritic has become so important. Grouping together the opinions of hundreds of reviews and averaging the score is definitely a better way of assessing whether a game is really worth playing, but it still misses one vital opinion; yours. Sometimes critics get it wrong. And these examples serve to argue that the review system, with all it's decimal points and percentages and stars, is utterly broken. Click 'Next' to begin...

4. The Wonderful 101

Metascore: 78 The WiiU isn't having the best time. With a lack of new software and the impending release of a new wave of rival consoles, things are only set to get worse. Nintendo has released some killer stuff over the last few months like Wind Waker HD and the release of EarthBound (finally) but a third party game developed by Platinum Games is the most brilliant of them all. The Wonderful 101 is an action game where you control 101 superheroes. All at once. The heroes appear in a little pack on your screen and you swarm enemies taking them out with your collective strength. Using the Gamepad (or my personal preference, the Pro Controller) you can activate special abilities by Unite Morphing. The Wonderful 101 is colourful, exciting and includes an epic story that is equal parts stupid and really stupid. But if you sit back and enjoy the ride, The Wonderful 101 is the most fun you'll have had in a long time, and is the perfect antidote to all the seriousness of games like GTA V and The Last Of Us. The Wonderful 101 getting an average of 78 doesn't do the game the justice it deserves, and although it's by no means a bad score, no doubt many players will miss the game because of it. Which is a damn shame.

3. Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3

Modern Warfare 3 Cover Art Revealed 600x300 Metascore: 88 I am not at all a fan of Call of Duty, but I can appreciate it's place in gaming. One of the best selling video game franchises of all time, Call of Duty's yearly iterations are the main reason for a rather bulky amount of 'shooter fatigue' among many gamers. Regardless of anyone's stance on Call of Duty though, it is clear that Modern Warfare 3 is a rather dull instalment. A 6 hour campaign that focuses on non-interactive visual spectacle ('look the Eiffel Tower is falling down... over there!') and a multiplayer that is merely fine add up to a game that was hoping so much to be exciting that it forgot to add any actual excitement. Yes, Modern Warfare 3 does have some interesting plot points but the fact that it came after Black Ops (everyone's new favourite COD series) made it feel like a back-step. But it was a Call of Duty game. So it got rated highly. And everyone bought it.

2. Killer Is Dead

Metascore: 64 Suda51s latest game has a criminally low Metacritic score of 64, a pretty sure fire way to put the nail in the coffin of a new IP. Killer is Dead is a character action, hack and slash game, in the vein of No More Heroes, Lollipop Chainsaw and well, basically anything by Suda51. It's ridiculous, epic, brash and even more ridiculously epic. Killer is Dead revolved around a hitman named Mondo who received contracts from a shadowy agency. Each level saw a new client and a new hit. Of course, the plot quickly escalated and before you knew it, you were fighting a bug monster on the moon. It was a load of fun with a killer art style to boot. Yes, the 'Gigolo' missions (which saw you perving on girls with x-ray specs) were a little weird and uncomfortable but the main game was fun for anyone, at least anyone who likes the genre and knows what they're getting into. Killer is Dead is by no means a masterpiece, but it's not as bad as critics would have you believe.

1. God Hand

Godhand01 IGN review: 3.0 And to round it off, let's look at one review in particular. Probably the most famous bad review of all time, God Hand received an abominable 3.0 from IGN. The review, still available for reading on the website, makes for some chilling reading, especially if you've played the game. Because God Hand is great. A third person brawler with an exaggerated plot of nonsense is just plain fun. The fighting system is awkward to start with because there is a learning curve, much like Killer is Dead and The Wonderful 101 on this list, and that is maybe a reason (but no excuse) for the review. Reviewers' harsh deadlines don't really allow for someone to spend tens of hours working on learning a fighting system. That being said, IGN's review is just an abysmal piece that seems dead set on moaning about gripes that simply aren't a big deal. God Hand is not the greatest game of all time but IGNs review might be the worst review I've ever read. What poorly reviewed games do you love? Are you guilty of judging a game on one review score? Make some noise in the comments below...

Contributor
Contributor

Chris McGeorge is a 22-year-old author, who has passion for video games, films and television. Whenever he is not knee deep in a manuscript, he can usually be found strolling the streets of Los Santos or trying to wrap his head about a new JRPG battle system.