5 Best & 5 Worst Video Game Sequels Of This Generation

Sometimes originality is a bad thing, and sometimes it definitely isn't...

Sequels in the games industry get a harsh rap, with players calling for new IP's like a hoard of insatiable children, who's attention span is comparable to that of a Ninja Gaiden quick-time event. It's a shame too, because often developers need that second game to truly hone and fulfill their original vision, although this is not always the case. It's not unheard of for big name sequels to fall short of expectations, even if when held up on their own they offer a decent experience. That got us thinking, what are the best and worse sequels of this current generation? For this list, three is definitely not the magic number, as all titles must be the second entry in their respective series.

10. The Bad... Crysis 2

Ask a hardcore PC gamer what they think of Crysis 2. I could leave it there but for those of you without a hardcore PC gamer to hand, I should explain. Graphical prowess is intrinsic to the very heart of PC gaming, no matter what a shiny new, or in the case of 2012 a rickety old console can produce, if you want cutting edge visuals there's only one place to go. Developers gain tremendous satisfaction when pushing the graphical envelope, and PC players get a similar buzz from building machines to run their games. The first Crysis was just that, a benchmark, a game to truly show what your PC was capable of, so imagine the excitement when Crytek announced a sequel. Now imagine the disappointment when Crysis 2 launched with a severe lack of graphical options and a linear slog through the concrete jungle of New York.

9. The Good... Mass Effect 2

The first Mass Effect is a great game, no question, which is why it's so impressive that Bioware managed to top it in almost every conceivable way. Gone were the dry repetitive side-missions, replaced with more story driven and consequential affairs, that were just as compelling as the main plot. Combat also received a massive overhaul, in the first game combat was merely tolerated in order to continue to story, not so in Mass Effect 2. Shooting felt fast and fluid, something to be enjoyed on its own merit, while offering more replay value to a game that was already bursting with reasons to visit it again and again.

8. The Bad... BioShock 2

In BioShock, Irrational Games created one of the defining games of this generation, a triumph in storytelling where the atmosphere was just as scary as the splicers themselves. Despite this there was never really any call for a sequel, but money talks and a successful IP is rarely allowed to bow-out after its opening act. In February 2010 BioShock 2 released, not the product of Irrational Games but a raft of different studios, all thrown in to try and raise another classic form the deep. Despite being a fairly decent game on its own, this sequel simply couldn't live up to its predecessor's standards. The tacked on multiplayer did little to appease disappointed fans, and BioShock 2's hopes of recreating the same magic of the first game, were left dead in the water.

7. The Good... Borderlands 2

Borderlands 2, how very relevant... yes OK you'd have to be master of self-control not to be in some way effected by the advertising blitz surrounding this game, but it really does deserve to be on this list. Borderlands managed to gain a good amount of fans with its first outing back in 2009, but it failed to break through into the realm of Triple A status due to a lack of variety and bland characters. Luckily Gearbox Software knew exactly this and set about addressing these issues in a major way with the follow up. Fantastic writing brought the world of Panadora to life and the huge selection of enemies to blast through, ensured the substantial 20-30 hours needed to complete the game felt far less of a drag. It didn't quite live up to its promise of a bazillion guns but we'll let them off, this time.

6. The Bad... Test Drive Unlimited 2

Test Drive as a series has been around for a long time, but it never managed to produce a real top of the line success, until Test Drive Unlimited. The first ever MMORG or massively multiplayer online racing game, car fans embraced TDU ensuring the island of Oahu was alive with the sound of engines years after the game released. Test Drive Unlimited 2 looked poised to become one of the best games in the entire genre. Featuring a brand new island in the form of Ibiza, a day/night cycle, weather effects, off-road cars, and not to mention the entire island from the first game, how could it go possibly fail? With massive day one server issues, that's how. The MMO was missing from Unlimited 2 for nearly a week, leaving players outraged and no doubt costing Eden Games thousands of sales.

5. The Good... Red Dead Redemption

Although I€™m fully aware everyone reading this is a well informed, seasoned gamer, it may surprise some of you to learn that Red Dead Redemption is in fact a sequel. Back in 2004 Rockstar San Diego released Red Dead Revolver, a mission based game set in the old west that received a rather lute warm reception from both the press and players alike. Red Dead Redemption didn't break cover until 2009, when it did the influence of certain other Rockstar franchise was clear to see. Far more than just Grand Theft Auto IV on horses though, Rockstar described Red Dead as "more ambitious than GTA IV" and "the ultimate open world game". Whether it lived up to those bold statements is up for debate, but what isn't questionable, is the gigantic leap made in this sequel.

4. The Bad...Fable 2

The Fable series has done a lot of things right in the past, sadly though it's more renowned for broken promises than anything else. Although the first Fable game failed to live up to all of its promises, it still stood out as being the top RPG experience on the original Xbox. Then along came Fable 2, this time on the Xbox 360, fans salivated about the prospect of a next-gen Fable fulfilling the first game's undoubted potential. What fans got was basically an HD version of the original game, different in story but all to similar in design and gameplay. Sure having mans best friend along for the ride added something to the experience but like a lot of ideas in the Fable series, it felt underdeveloped and poorly executed.

3. The Good... Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

Naughty Dog's first foray onto the PS3 raised the bar for presentation in videogames, but was criticized for lacking any new ideas of its own. Now you could argue Drake's second outing in Uncharted 2: Among Thieves was guilty of the same thing, but that's rather missing the point. While it's true Uncharted 2 borrowed numerous elements from other games, it managed to stitch them altogether seamlessly, creating an experience that felt unlike anything gamers had experience before. Naughty Dog had proved it is possible to be a master of all trades, producing what many people regard as the best game of the current generation.

2. The Bad... Dragon Age 2

Bioware are the only developer to appear on this list twice, sadly though Dragon Age 2 is not here because it's a stellar example of a sequel done right. With Mass Effect 2 Bioware managed to increase the game's mass appeal without sacrificing what made the game great in the first place, they tried the same trick with Dragon Age 2 but failed in quite spectacular fashion. A more linear experience, with simplified controls and bland repetitive environments, Dragon Age 2 has been accused of dumbing down for consoles but that theory never really sat well with me because last time I checked, console gamers had just the same aversion to crap games as those on PC. Either way Dragon Age 2 is certainly a rare low in Bioware's normally impeccable record, a reminder even the best developers can produce a dud every now and then.

1. The Good... Assassin's Creed 2

The first Assassin€™s Creed game was an interesting, ambitious but ultimately a flawed experience, the concept was fantastic but the unlike Altair, Ubisoft didn€™t quite nail the execution. In truth the improvements necessary to take Assassin's Creed 2 into blockbuster territory were obvious. Mission variety was top of the list when it came to improvements in Assassin's Creed 2, the format of get contract, scout target, stab target, got old pretty quickly in the first game. This time around the story felt cohesive and developed overtime, add to that a much more interesting character in the form of Ezio, AC2 had found the spark the first game was missing. Arguably the real star of the second game wasn't the improved gameplay, story, or protagonist, but the time period of Renaissance Italy. Vibrant and colourful it may not have been able to sustain three outings but first time around, it was the final piece of the brilliant Assassin's Creed 2 puzzle. What do you think, what games deserved to make this list, good or bad? Share your thoughts below.

Contributor
Contributor

I like videogames. Feel free to contact me @TarakFord