5 Brilliant Ideas In Modern Games That Had Horrible Executions

sss It's a truism that a number of ideas sound great on paper but are revealed to be absolutely horrid when put into practice, especially when it comes to video games. For example, doesn€™t it seem like common sense that a Superman game would be an amazing experience? Yet we still keep figuring out ways to screw it up. Sometimes spectacularly so (see above image!) Granted, none of these games on this list come anywhere close to being as bad as Superman 64. In fact, they€™re all pretty good games, but they still have those underwhelming segments and infuriatingly inept mechanics that keep them from joining the pantheon of gaming. Here are 5 games with brilliant concepts that had awful executions.

5. Assassin€™s Creed II: The Entire Carnevale Segment

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YaPJCpUAbS4 I consider Assassin€™s Creed II to be the pinnacle of the series, an almost perfect game that brilliantly captures everything Assassin's Creed is about by letting players pull off stylish assassinations and leap from rooftop to rooftop in meticulously recreated cities like Venice and Florence during the Renaissance. Ubisoft had listened to the criticisms of the first game and in-turn provided gamers with a memorable open world filled with plenty of fun side quests and items to collect long after you finished the memorable revenge storyline. However, there is one nasty segment that sticks out like a gruesome pimple on an otherwise unblemished face: the Carnevale. The setup is that Ezio must participate in a number of events (minigames) to earn a Golden Mask that will grand him access to a party hosted by the man he needs to kill, Templar Marco Barbarigo. Sounds pretty like a pretty cool scenario, right? If only. The four subpar minigames are tedious, boring exercises . Worse, two of the events (capture the flag and racing) shine a light on what has always been the series€™ Achilles' heel: an awkward control scheme. The race event in particular requires an almost perfect response time, which is unfortunate since the game doesn€™t immediately tell you where you€™re supposed to go, and Ezio€™s habit of jumping in the wrong direction certainly doesn€™t help. You have to look for the white beacons of light, meaning that you must stumble through the stage several times before you even have the trajectory of the course laid out in your mind. Worst of all is that all of that hard work essentially is meaningless since the contest is rigged, forcing you to steal the mask from your target€™s bodyguard anyway. Boo.

4. Alpha Protocol: The Hacking Minigame

rsz_52520_orig

There are two types of difficulty when it comes to €œhard€ games. The first is of the €œharsh but fair€ variety; these are games that will challenge players but will never throw insurmountable odds at them and will often reward the players with a sense of accomplishment that far outweighs the value of any unlockable costume or concept art. Some recent games that fall under this umbrella are Super Hexagon, Dark Souls, and Max Payne 3. And then there€™s the other type: derp-hard, an intense level of difficulty that not only fails to fit the game's design, but it also doesn€™t leave the gamer with any sense of accomplishment or relief€”just annoyance. It pains me to say that Alpha Protocol is an example of derp-hard at its finest, not because of the primary cover & gun gameplay. No, we€™re talking about a certain hacking minigame that has driven even the most hardcore fans of the game bananas. To be fair, having a hacking game in a James Bond/Mass Effect inspired game makes sense and is a good idea. To make it excruciatingly difficult and hideous is not. Just look at this. Behold the Medusa of minigames, my friends http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=urhnx2XrySQ For many, this makes the game almost unplayable due to the frequency of these ineptly designed segments, which is a shame, really, since Alpha Protocol is, at its core, a great game featuring one of the best uses of branching storylines ever (seriously, anyone who feels like their choices didn€™t matter in Mass Effect should give this game a whirl). And to think that all Obsidian had to do was make this tiny game a little less hard€you know, like a certain relatively recent bypass minigame: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6aEwiovuEY

3. Far Cry 3: Tower Climbing

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GExFcK1Sdx0 Far Cry 3 borrowed a number of ideas from Ubisoft€™s other flagship franchise, Assassin€™s Creed, to great effect: disguises to blend in with the crowd, stalking prey and, most notably, the use of radio towers as viewpoints. Just like Assassin€™s Creed, you have to climb dilapidated towers in order to gain mini-map access to sections of the game world. Plus, you get free weapons, too. Admittedly, this starts out pretty cool, as€”from a first person point of view€”you climb each level of the tower. It€™s neat visually but gets old after a while, and considering the fact that there are 18 towers in all, the activity becomes more of a chore than anything else. It also doesn€™t help that the towers become progressively more difficult, sometimes unfairly so.

2. Playstation Vita: Extraneous Vita Functions in a Number of Games

rsz_puzzle

I recently received a Playstation Vita as a Christmas present and I love it. I could spend all day listing to you all the reasons I do, but there is an old lesson I wish developers creating games for the system would take to heart: just because you can, doesn€™t mean you should. The Vita has a number of neat functionalities, but that doesn€™t mean they automatically translate well into gameplay, yet developers keep trying to shoehorn these features into their games. For example, consider the ridiculous amount of touchscreen action in Uncharted: Golden Abyss. Some of those functions make sense, like when you€™re fighting hand-to-hand with a foe and have to swipe your finger upward on screen so that Drake can uppercut the dude into oblivion. But did we really, really need a charcoal rubbing game? http://youtu.be/xfxd0h_4SSA?t=4m42s This bit added nothing positive to my time with Uncharted:GA. In fact, it kind of detracted from the experience because sections like this are such blatant technology demos. I know what the machine does, guys, you don€™t have to constantly remind me. I€™ll leave you with another Vita functionality game in Assassin€™s Creed:Liberation that works oh so well: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3M6ENDBK4mE

1. Call of Duty: Black Ops II: the Strike Force Missions

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VHtNCTBNIK4 The surprisingly good sequel to Call of Duty: Black Ops brought two new features to the table€”at least new to the series. One of them, the branching storyline, worked unexpectedly well and has guaranteed that I and many players will go through the campaign again just to the see the different outcomes of the game. The other one, the Strike Force missions, could have been great way to shake up the formulaic gameplay of Call of Duty. Unfortunately, the missions, which have the player switching back and forth between RTS command and FPS action in order to successfully command a squad of human commandos and robotic assets against invading troops, just aren't optimized well enough. The enemy troops invade far too quickly for the player to switch back and forth between RTS/FPS (in a way reminiscent of the 1998 remake of Battlezone). And it wouldn€™t be such a big deal if the campaign didn€™t give the player a number of lives before permadeath on these missions, thus negating the chance of any real practice with the mode before entering the fray. This means that there€™s no incentive for the player to bother with the RTS mode; instead, it's often a better decision for you to just run and gun, and let your AI partners take care of themselves. Of course, all of this could be fixed with a patch or two, and I hope that update happens because this grasp for innovation is important for a series that€™s biggest criticism is still its genericness. What about you, readers? What are some concepts you€™ve seen in games that probably were a lot better before they were implemented?

Contributor
Contributor

Javy Gwaltney is an aspiring author, screenwriter, and essayist from South Carolina. He also likes to write about video games. You can find his articles on those at Bitmob and Whatculture! If you like, you can follow him on twitter: https://twitter.com/JavyIV