5 Great (And 5 Not So Great) Stealth Video Games

"Huh? Whose footprints are these?"

Sc Cover
Ubisoft

Sneaking. Lurking. Traversing the shadows. Being one with the darkness.

However you want to phrase it, stealth has more of a fulfilling sense of reward than games that allow you to rack up the damage like a friggin' Terminator. Whether you want to completely ghost a level and have no one know you were there, or pick your enemies apart and put the fear into them, many games allow you to sneak your way through at your own pace.

It may not be for everyone, but when stealth is done right, it makes a game always more fun with the added challenge of not getting caught.

Not all games have grasped stealth as a means to play to the end though. Some stick it in as a mandatory thing in an otherwise un-stealthy game (looking at you, Marvel's Spider-man) that slows the pace down a tad, whilst others just don't get how to implement it properly.

With that in mind, here are ten alternating examples of when stealth does work, and doesn't quite hit the mark. Starting off with a not so great example, here's how not to do it:

10. Velvet Assassin

Velvet Assassin
SouthPeak Games

Starting this list on a bum note, we have a game that many were looking forward to: a third person stealth adventure set in World War 2.

The concept was great: much like Hitman: Contracts, the story and narrative is played out through a series of flashbacks. Loosely based on the life of Allied agent/saboteur Violette Szabo, the game sees you playing as Violette Summer as she lies comatose in a French hospital.

The execution, however, was a bit of a clunky mess, marred with too many stealth tropes that confused players and gave rise to incredibly sharp AI detection. Trying to utilise both Hitman and Splinter Cell mechanics, with uniforms and light/shadows respectively, it added too much complication in what should have been a straightforward stealth adventure.

It did have one unique mechanic, though. As long as you had a morphine syringe about your person, being spotted granted you a 'Last Stand'-style chance to eliminate that enemy. In theory, it was a get out of jail free card, but slightly redundant if there was more than one enemy.

The inclusion of a clunky experience/levelling system didn't improve much, which ultimately saw Velvet Assassin release to little critical acclaim.


9. Commandos: Behind Enemy Lines

Commandos BEL
Eidos Interactive

The oldest entry in this list, released way back in 1998 on PC, Commandos: Behind Enemy Lines serves as a beautifully harsh example of classic gaming.

Sticking with WW2, Commandos saw you take charge of a six man team of Allied agents, all with different abilities. Playing like a tactical Cannon Fodder, each top-down map saw you using your wits and patience to complete objectives. Your standard operative, the Green Beret, is capable of doing a lot of the heavy lifting, the Spy could change uniform and infiltrate enemy strongholds, whilst the Driver was the only man capable of using vehicles. You had to employ all given men in a level to succeed.

Stealth and tactics were strongly emphasised here, as your squad could only withstand a couple of shots before dying, and enemies were relentless. Being the '90s, there was no hand-holding, and very few checkpoints. Manual saving was a must, as it'd be frustrating to have to restart a level within reach of the mission end.

Commandos: Behind Enemy Lines hit initial success, spawning an expansion pack and two sequels. The last offering though, 2006's Strike Force, tried to imitate other first-person shooters of the time and didn't reach the same success as its forebears.

Since then, all has been quiet on the wartime front.


8. Thief (2014)

Thief 2014
SquareEnix

Also released in 1998, Thief, like Commandos, is considered another forefather of the genre.

Borne of an environment of "hard as nails" gaming, before checkpoint-led fodder became the norm, Thief: The Dark Project was all stealth. As master thief Garrett, you were there only to steal, not Errol Flynn your way through a swathe of enemies. There was a slight supernatural story to it, but it kept the main theme throughout: theft.

The last entry in the series, simply named Thief, tried to recreate that in the latest generation of gaming. Shame, then, that it couldn't pull it off.

It's not a terrible game. It just wasn't very good. Taking the open level approach and switching to linear(ish) levels hindered creativity, and locking level progression halfway through made previous areas inaccessible. But the biggest change was Garrett himself.

Gone was the, "I'm only here to steal" attitude, instead becoming a gruff, brooding pawn in a larger game. It caused a bit of a tonal shift, as the once-reserved and sardonic thief becomes an anti-hero in preventing dark forces emerging.

Whilst not a massive deviation from series tradition and boasting some nice visuals for the early days of the latest console generation, it failed to win both new and old fans over. After its lacklustre release in 2014, the series has been dormant since.


7. Batman: Arkham Asylum

Batman Aa
Rocksteady

Much like the Christopher Nolan film counterparts, the Arkham trilogy was responsible for bringing Batman back to the gaming masses.

Whilst later games focused on exploration and action (and too many Batmobile jaunts), the first in the trilogy completely reinvented Batman to gamers and made him how he should be: feared.

Not the first game to try and properly incorporate stealth into Batman games (that was tie-in game, Batman Begins), Arkham Asylum was the first game to do it properly. Living up to the Dark Knight mantle, the game fully utilised and embraced that by making the Caped Crusader the apex predator throughout.

Adhering to Batman's "no killing" policy, AA had you perching on ledges and fixtures and picking enemies off one by one before progressing. As the game furthered, enemies were outfitted with new weapons or devices, to add tactical thinking and stop the gameplay becoming stale.

Save for a few navigational areas outside, the core environments were the pathways of the asylum, meaning you had to hide from gun-toting enemies, as a head on challenge saw Batman becoming riddled with enough bullets to see daylight through him.

As mentioned above, the sequels expanded on the world of Arkham and Gotham, that gave way to bigger environments and exploration. Whilst still great, the first one really encapsulates what being the Batman is.


6. Forbidden Siren

Forbidden Siren
SCE Japan

Stealth and horror often go hand in hand. Lately, we've had a revival with many first person efforts like Outlast, SOMA, Call of Cthulu and Alien: Isolation.

Back in the PlayStation 2's heady days of 2003, Sony Japan released Siren (or Forbidden Siren in PAL regions), a heavily stealth emphasised game taking influence from films like Ring, Dark Water and Grudge. Steeped in traditional Japanese horror, in that the scares were less jump and more lurking, Forbidden Siren should have tapped into a new vein of putting people on edge.

Whilst combat was there in drabs, the main draw was a unique mechanic: sightjacking. This feature allowed you to see through the eyes of nearby shibito (think living zombie), so you could gauge your position to try and plan a route through. There was nothing more terrifying than trying to see where the enemy was, only to see one looking at the back of your own head.

As pant-filling as it was, the game was a bit hampered by technical issues. Real face-mapping looked a bit ropey at points, and collision/climbing detection could unwittingly hinder an escape.

Kudos to SCE Japan for trying something new though, as it wasn't a complete flop. Spawning a sequel and "reimagining" for the PS3, there was an audience for it. But with nothing new since the latest offering in 2008, it's unlikely we'll get anything more from the series.


5. Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory

Splinter Cell Ct
Ubisoft

Much like Commandos and the Thief series, Splinter Cell is another master of the old school. Starting slightly later in 2002, the series has put out seven main games to date.

Some have deviated slightly and become more action-focused, whilst latest entry, Blacklist, tried mixing stealth and action, unfortunately to lacklustre sales.

But third entry, Chaos Theory, is the pinnacle of Sam Fisher's career. As opposed to Thief, SC: CT took its linear level approach and broadened each area, allowing multiple ways to reach your objective. Bolstering a new arsenal of both lethal and passive items, Chaos Theory left it to the player to choose their own path.

Non-lethal was ultimately more fun, though. Sure, you could shoot someone from across the room, but why do that when sneaking up and smacking them upside the head was more satisfying? This was the game that unconscious ragdoll physics were made for.

It also boasted a brilliant multiplayer with the Spies vs. Mercs mode. As the latter, you had lethal means of stopping the sneaky shadow sprinters from reaching their goals. As the former, you had to outwit the mercenaries by utilising the dark, the vents, and the walkways to succeed. It switched up the team deathmatch format to a more cat and mouse dynamic, and it's one that we've not seen since.

Whilst being dormant since Blacklist, Ubisoft's Serge Hascoet has said they are, "fighting for resources" for more potential Splinter Cell(s), so we can only hope.


4. Hitman Absolution

Hitman Abso
IO Interactive/SquareEnix

Ugh. Just look, look at that header picture. If you could sum up Absolution in one picture, that'd be it.

After the seminal 360 debut of Hitman: Blood Money, the next entry in the series should have been an improvement on the formula.

Except, it wasn't. It was tonally different, it added a scoring element that penalised you for doing standard Hitman things such as knocking a guard out or creating a noisy distraction. Whilst a negative score could be balanced out, it was almost like the game telling you what to do, or suffer the consequences.

It took the freedom out of it, and became more a fussy mother, looking over your shoulder and almost directing you. Fans were not happy.

The story was also loud and bombastic. Hitman, as a series, has always been a bit fantastical, yet grounded in its plausibility. But Absolution threw in super soldier clones with power-activating necklaces, giganto Trejo-esque wrestlers and sexy killer nun squads. No, really. Killer nuns.

The grindhouse, pulpy style of story failed to hit the mark with series fans, and shoehorned linear levels took the creativity out a franchise whose very style was in the varied approach to levels.

It wasn't all bad, though. It gave IO Interactive four years to do their homework...


3. Hitman (2016)

Hitman 2016
IO Interactive/SquareEnix

As it turns out, four years is long enough for a franchise to really take back the title it once held, and Hitman (2016) did just that.

Suffering a slight misstep and banging their shin on the way up the podium, Hitman suffered initial criticism by announcing that levels would be episodic. Fans took to complaining immediately, complaining of cash grabbing and an unfinished product. But once the dust had settled, it worked in favour for the final game.

Gone was any trace of Absolution's garishness, and the welcome return of nuanced, massive levels made it the creative Hitman game fans loved. It also added new opportunities in levels to not hold your hand, but to say, "Hey, why not try this route?".

IO were on top form, releasing new targets and challenges for existing missions, ensuring players wouldn't get bored or lose interest before the next level release.

Once the full game was released, IO still supported and released new content periodically, and with a reimagined Contracts multiplayer (which is probably the only welcomed feature brought over from Absolution), faith was once again restored in the franchise.


2. Mission: Impossible

Mission Impossible
Infrogrames/Ocean Software

Despite 1998 being a great year for stealth games, this was not one of them.

Much like GoldenEye, released the year before, the M:I game served as a sort of retelling/reimagining of the film. Set as third person stealth adventure, we play as Ethan Hunt as he tries to stop the leaking of agency information and discover the mole in the IMF group.

Issues behind the scenes saw a production marred with problems from the start, as movie rights and Tom Cruise's ego saw changes in story and Hunt's look, respectively. Whilst still a commercial success, it didn't fair well critically.

It had some highlights, though. The suspension room scene was handled well, as was the train station encounter with the operative known as Max, but a few diamonds in an otherwise rough game couldn't hold it up, and it fell by the wayside.

Comparisons to GoldenEye, Syphon Filter and Metal Gear Solid were unfavourable, causing the series to sit back until the release of Operation Surma in 2003. Again, it couldn't hold a candle to similar games of the time, proving that it really was an impossible mission to make their own dent in the market.


1. Metal Gear Solid 3

Metal Gear Solid 3
Konami

This is it, then. The literal granddaddy of the stealth genre, the very pinnacle of the series largely credited with creating stealth. This, the magnum opus of the series.

Metal Gear Solid, also released in 1998 (what is it with this year?!) blew everyone's proverbial socks off when it came out, whilst MGS2 made everyone put them back on quite quickly. Seriously, Raiden... ?

So, when Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater came out in 2005, it was seen by many as a soft reboot for the series. Putting the modern/future timeline on hold, instead going back to a post-Cold War state of espionage, MGS3 took stealth fans back to metaphorical and literal franchise roots.

Rudimentary, stripped navigation and a superbly implemented camouflage mechanic saw gamers having to utilise the environments around them to be successful.

Retaining the ability to go all Rambo if players wanted to, the game was ultimately more rewarding when played properly: live up to your codename, be a snake. Slide through undetected, leave no trace.

Featuring a story with more double crosses than an illiterate wordsearch, with gorgeous visuals to push any Final Fantasy of its podium, MGS3 continued the legacy of large narrative and balanced gameplay. Whilst we may not see any new Metal Gear games for a while, Snake Eater will always be regarded as a masterpiece of stealth gaming.


Contributor
Contributor

Player of games, watcher of films. Has a bad habit of buying remastered titles. Reviews games and delivers sub-par content in his spare time. Found at @GregatonBomb on Twitter/Instagram.