5 Most Thought Provoking Video Games Of The Decade
Sometimes there are games that keep us up way after we put the controller down.
Hollywood films have often delved into thought provoking or downright existential themes, but the modern media of gaming has often shied away from such subjects. But with every mindless shooter of the generation, a few games that dare to do more are released that leave their audience with a collection of unsettling questions. With some of the more recent titles in gaming history focusing on narratives or character studies worthy of an Oscar nomination, its no surprise that as gaming has evolved, so has its themes.
Whether it's asking what it means to be human, or making us come to terms with the inevitability of our own demise, some of these titles delve into the darker aspects of our own psychosis. Some more than others. Although some of these titles may not be some of the most universally recognized, they deserve the spots on this list for their mature introspection into mental health, or how they challenge the way we perceive the world around us.
All of these titles will keep us engaged long after we have put down the controller.
5. Dark Souls
Dark Soul's is a nihilistic nightmare that attempts to break the player over and over again until they can overcome it, only to find it was all for nothing. The gameplay is the equivalent of throwing yourself at a brick wall again and again, slowly breaking the wall down until you finally succeed, only to find a bigger wall ahead. The game forces us to get better by constantly challenging the player with overwhelming bosses, elaborate areas and complex combat. But it rewards the player with the elation of success. No matter how unforgiving, through perseverance, any obstacle within Dark Souls can be conquered.
Once you have overcome the hurdles throughout the game, the final outcome remains the same. Humanity is doomed to the age of dark whether you sacrifice yourself to light the flame or not. The inevitability will always be the same. Your actions up to this point have not changed things and yet, you as the chosen undead and the player persevere.
In a similar vain to Camus' The Myth of Sisyphus, Dark Souls is like rolling a boulder up a hill only for it to roll back down. Instead of lamenting and fixating on the inevitability of death and our lack of purpose in life, Dark Souls teaches us to embrace life and celebrate success. Life is unforgiving and often cruel, but through perseverance you can achieve something. The elation and joy of accomplishing something achieves more than any meaning ever could.
Dark Souls is a masterpiece of atmospheric gameplay and the perfect allegory for life, forcing us to find happiness through perseverance and accomplishment even in the inevitability of failure and death.
4. BioShock Infinite
BioShock was a steam punk spiritual successor to the System Shock series and its atmospheric underwater Rapture was a testament to Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged. The game focused on the illusion of agency as a game mechanic until its final moments where you were presented with the horror that you're not actually in control at all, deconstructing the nature of gameplay itself. BioShock Infinite was the 3rd game in the series and it managed to elevate the existential dread to new heights. Literally.
Infinite is a deconstruction of idealistic utopias focusing on determinism and consequentualism. As Booker DeWitt arrives in a floating city called Columbia on a quest to find a girl, he is thrust in a reality bending adventure which forces him to confront himself literally and physically. It makes us question whether we are actually in control, or if we are nothing more than pawns in a great meta game of chess being played out dozens of times with the same results. It focuses on infinite universes and ideas such as predeterminism, while the game fixates on the idea of free will.
Booker is shown that there will always be a man, there will always be a girl and there will always be a lighthouse and that regardless of his actions the same thing will happen again and again across an infinite number of universes where he, Comstock and Elizabeth will play through the same inevitable loop again and again and the only way to stop it is to die before the cycle can begin again. While it may be one of the darkest endings in gaming history, it offers the slightest glimmer of hope to Booker and Elizabeth's future.
3. Hellblade: Senuas Sacrifice
Hellblade: Senuas Sacrifice is an introspective journey into mental health that really speaks to the voice inside your head. It focuses on its titular character's insanity as she attempts to focus her mind and fight against her inner demons in order to save her lover's soul from the underworld. Senua experiences constant hallucinations and delusions, often causing bridges to disappear leaving her trapped and isolated all while the voices in her head tell her to go back. The game portrays psychosis through her warped perception of the world due to the trauma of her losing her lover.
The way she perceives the world and the way you as the player see things are reflective of ludonarrative synchronisation as the gameplay, story and her perception of reality coincide. From the way that puzzles are nothing more than her confusion and inability to perceive what is really there, to the way that the enemies she fight's are all figments of her imagination Hellblade's gameplay itself is an incredible introspection into ones own sanity through storytelling, audio and visual design. The voices within Senua's own head are best experienced with headphones on as they change in intensity, offer conflicting advice or commentary. She experiences flashbacks as visual hallucinations which allows a medium of storytelling while maintaining the pacing and consistency.
Subtle changes in the environment such as trees moving or patterns appearing in shadows or reflections occur when moving causing a warped perception of reality for both Senua and the player. Senua isn't just a receptacle of madness for the player however, as the hero of her own story battling her inner demons, it attempts to destigmatize mental. Hellblade is a title that will change the way you see gaming as a medium as well as how you see the world around you.
2. Spec Ops - The Line
Adapting Conrad's The Heart of Darkness, Spec Ops' descent into trauma and the horrors of war will show a side of conflict that Call of Duty never could. From the outset, Spec Ops seems like your bog standard shooter. Spec Ops: The Line becomes a deconstruction of its own genre focusing on the glorification of the military while slowly sinking into the horrors of war leaving the player deeply disturbed by their own actions.
The game uses intense violence to comment on American nationalist foreign policy, while making us feel guilty for doing the things it told us to do. Meanwhile your character, Walker, tries to justify his actions based on orders in order to maintain his slowly dissipating sanity.
From PTSD fueled hallucinations to introspective monologues, The Line asks the player if they are the hero in this story as you continue your relentless massacre across Dubai in the name of salvation. The final scene shows your journey to find Conrad was based on a lie you told yourself to ignore the true horrors of your actions, confronting the true darkness within man and the lengths one will go to justify their guilt.
The spiral that Walker and his men drown in culminates in arguably one of the greatest and most introspective moments in all of gaming that leaves you truly horrified and it touches on culpability in such a way that leaves one scarred. The self awareness in Walkers destroyed mental state as he leads his men who slowly lose faith in him is a testament to the self awareness of the player as they slowly become aware of the atrocities they are committing, as we begin to disconnect from the character we once knew in the same way we begin to disconnect from reality.
1. NieR: Automata
2B or not to be, NieR: Automata is an incredible blend of existential dread, beautiful orchestral music, moving narrative and gorgeous visual design which is an existential introspection into meaning in an apparently meaningless world. From the robots quoting philosophy, to the lifeless androids strewn around the world, NieR makes you question what it means to have meaning. One machine in particular, named Jean-Paul, in reference to the French existentialist Sartre, states “existence precedes essence” as the characters attempt to explain the world around them and find their purpose in it.
As the machines begin to band together in communities it also starts to ask what the difference is between man and machine. When androids die however their consciousness is downloaded into another body in the same way that in religion the soul goes to heaven, death has so little meaning within the world of NieR, in almost Dark Soulsian fashion, once can remove their own oS and kill themselves by choice.
Throughout the game, your character is presented with the lies used to give meaning to the war and existence, justifying slaughter to give those left behind a raison d'etre. The title focuses on what it means to be human, artificial intelligence and the idea of meaning.
When NieR ends, its not truly finished, instead it allows a subsequent playthrough from another perspective which then leads to a post game on a 3rd playthrough that begins to truly unravel the horrors of existence within the beautiful whimsical world of NieR: Automata.
In a final act of defiance your are asked to break the cycle once and for all, in the most meta way possible, by deleting your save data in order to help other players end the cycle and create a better world and giving you something to die for.