5 Reasons Why GTA V Will Never Be As Good As Red Dead Redemption

Red-Dead-Redemption Now that GTA V has been out for over a month, everybody in the world who bought it (roughly six billion of you) has had time to try it, love it, and take it to completion. It is a far bigger game than anyone probably expected. It's prettier, plays better, and is just far more brilliant than it had any right to be. More impressive than all that put together, though? The fact that it not only managed to live up to the ridiculous hype that surrounded its release, it pretty much surpassed it all. Yes, the game's setting of San Andreas feels like a fully-rendered world and it performs on every level. The characters are well drawn, whilst their motivations are both hilarious and believable. The streets are teeming with life, the cops are just as cunning and ruthless as they need to be to keep up with the game's three brilliant protagonists, the graphics are beautiful and the gameplay is tight and varied. The radio stations and internet... well, they're so amazingly produced that you're often fooled into thinking you're listening to and using the real thing. But I must say... No matter how good it is, or how perfect its review scores appear to be, there's just something about GTA V that - for me - feels lacking. No, not lacking exactly, but... it hasn't connected with me in the same way as another one of Rockstar's flagship franchise titles did over three years ago. And that's why - even though in doing so I fully expect to be hunted down and tortured until I take it all back - I decided to write this article. Ladies and gentlemen, here are 5 reasons why (the brilliant) GTA V will never be as good as Red Dead Redemption...

5. The Setting

Red Dead Redemption1 Okay, like many points in this list I'm going to begin by talking about GTA V. Don't let the title of this piece fool you - this isn't an article on how Grand Theft Auto sucks and we should all throw our copies into a landfill. It's rather an exploration of why I don't believe it's quite as good as the spectacular Red Dead Redemption. Let us begin. As I said in the introduction, the world of GTA V is beautifully-realised. San Andreas is a place crawling with people from all different walks of life, cultures and origins, and it does an obscenely realistic job of creating a Southern Californian state that would believably house them all. From the ghetto to the suburbs, to the Vinewood Hills and all the way out to the sticks of Blaine County, each place is as varied, detailed, and bitingly satirical as the next. Still, Red Dead Redemption is set over two United States counties, and a Mexican state that is separated from its northern brothers by the San Luis river. Brace yourselves, chaps, because this is the frontier, and be it in cinema, literature, or anything else for that matter, I don't believe I've ever seen it better represented than it is in New Austin, West Elizabeth, and Nuevo Paraiso. See, the thing that sets these places apart from San Andreas is that in GTA V, Rockstar have done a stellar job at designing a world that has been built by humans for humans. This is no mean feat, but in Red Dead they've built a world that is still wild. It's not been bricked by man, but carved by the elements over thousands of years. It's natural and untamed and - though there are a few places where people have managed to stake out a place for themselves - Marston and the other characters in the game aren't just at the mercy of each other, but of Mother Nature herself. It's hard to draw a building. It's hard to make the bricks look real or the windows shine or the doors open just right. But these are things we know we can do, because they've been done a thousand times before. Show me a skyscraper and if it's even half good I'll be all: "Right on, a skyscraper." But show me a mountain prowled by wildcats, or a desert flecked with nought but cacti and death, or a forest so dense that it's almost impenetrable, and I'm harder to convince. If there's something slightly off about it, the illusion is ruined. If the animals are stilted or the tracks too convenient or the shrubs feel like copy-and-paste jobs, then the whole thing just falls to bits. In Red Dead Redemption, this never happens. Not once.

4. The Music

Radio stations. Who knew they could fit so much onto so many different in-game radio stations? Back in the days of Vice City on the PS2, I was hugely bowled over, not just by the quality of the soundtrack (I have to say that I'm a sucker for an 80s beat) but by the sheer size of it. As the years have gone on and the PS2 grew into the PS3, of course the track lists got longer, and the fake chatter and adverts and call-ins got more varied. Now, in GTA V, we're at a point where you can drive around for hours on end and never fear that you're going to hear the same thing on the radio twice. It's an amazing thing, when you think about it, and a perfect example of how Rockstar is able to simulate real-life and all its variances on a single game disc. Waiting to see who's on the soundtrack is always a big thing for me come the release of any new GTA, and this time around, I wasn't disappointed. Hell, you don't even just have one set of radio stations. Get too far from the mast in Los Santos and it switches you over to Blaine County programming. Insane! But then there's Red Dead Redemption. Of course, there were no radios on the horses back in 1911 (not that I'm saying horses come equipped with radios these days, but you get the idea), so Rockstar had to come up with something different to keep us occupied on our long treks over the prairie. And boy, did they. Enlisting the help of Bill Elm and Woody Jackson, Rockstar created a soundtrack so deep, so emotional, so fraught with adventure and danger and peace and loneliness that it still features heavily on my iPod today. Of course, they took their inspiration from classic westerns, mainly those by Sergio Leone. Not only did they manage to ape some of Ennio Morricone's most beloved work in the process, they managed to - in some cases - better it. And that's not to mention the songs that were drafted in from other artists. Each one, marking a particular beat in the story, was written, scored and performed so perfectly, their utilisation puts everything else to shame. Try not gasping in wonder as "Far Away" trickles from your speakers, Compass accompanies you home on horseback, and William Elliot Whitmore growls over the closing credits. Can't do it, can you?

3. You're A Cowboy With A Horse

Red Dead Redemption

Yeah, it's fun to be a gangster. It's fun to steal cars and drive fast and rob banks (I'm talking in-game here and not in real life - neither myself nor WhatCulture! condones robbing, stealing, or speeding through the streets knocking pedestrians down in real life), and GTA V does allows you to do all of these things in an awesomely fun way. But...

Listen, when we were kids, everybody liked to play Cops and Robbers. It was one of the first games we played, running around the streets with plastic guns, or tooling down hills in our go-carts screaming nee-ne-nee-na at the tops of our voices. But before we played Cops and Robbers, we played Cowboys and Indians. There's something about the life of a man who lives in the wilderness, surviving on nothing more than his hands and his wits, that spoke to our most base desires as children, and it's something that still lies in us today. Maybe it's because the world is our own, but ever so slightly removed. It's similar, but without the traffic lights and the rules and the responsibilities. It's a world where you can get your clothes dirty and adventure has the potential to sneak up on you from around every corner. Our idea of the Wild West these days is how we used to see our world when we were knee high to grasshoppers; full of excitement, intrigue, places to explore where nobody had ever been before, where treasure just might be buried under your dusty boots. And that's not even counting the horses. Who doesn't love horses? Nobody, that's who. Riding towards the setting sun on the back of your trusty steed, that's written with muscle and personality, is a far more intimate experience than putting your life in the hands of some faceless, seen-it-a-hundred-times-before machine. Yes, cars and bikes are fun, but horses are better...

2. The Characters

Red Dead Redemption

GTA V took a brave decision when it decided to have three protagonists in its new game. But it was one that paid off in spades. We got to experience the world of San Andreas through the fresh eyes of the up and coming kid (Franklin), got to suffer family life and the trials and tribulations of middle-age with a GTA character who "won" (Michael), and - and this is a stroke of genius on Rockstar's controversy-courting part - we got to live out all our sickest fantasies through the psychopathic eyes of someone who was probably insane (Trevor). But no matter how great each of these characters are, the fact remains that in the paragraph above I was able to describe them all to a tee in less then a hundred words. In Red Dead Redemption, you play as one guy: John Marston. He has a dark past, has committed terrible acts of theft and murder, but he's trying to be good. He's walking the straight and narrow for a wife he loves and a child who he wants to grow up to be everything he isn't. Now, when the game takes place, his family are taken from him and he's forced back into the life. It's a grudging thing at first - he swore to leave it all behind, to make good with his remaining years, but does he not laugh as he kills? Does he not cry for his love? Is he not as quick to hurt as he is to heal, as fast to shoot as he is to offer his time and help? I suppose I can describe John Marston perfectly in a few words: he is a man. A fully formed, completely three-dimensional man, and through him we see both the blinding acts of love and sacrifice, and the darkest blacks of selfishness and violence, that we're all inherently capable of committing.

1. That Ending...

The narrative as a whole in Red Dead Redemption is superb. We journey with Marston across miles and miles of terrain that ranges from barely-liveable to completely hostile, treacherous to murderous - and along the way we meet a cast of characters that are believable, hateful, endearing, and hilarious, without ever feeling like cartoons or clichés. But even if the fifteen-odd hours of story that proceed the last ten minutes of Red Dead Redemption were complete and utter crap, it would still be a dump worth wading through just to see THAT ending. There are probably a handful - if that - of people reading this that don't know the end of Red Dead Redemption, but I'm going to do it spoiler-free regardless. Instead, I'm going to tell you how I experienced it, and then, if you don't know what happens, you're free to go and find it out. I had played it solidly for a week. I had fought with Marston, sweated with him, hurt and swore and bled with him, and I finally got told that it was time to ride home to my family. I did so, picking my way down through the mountains and guiding my horse through the wood, all the while listening to Liddell's Compass with tears standing out boldly in my eyes. And eventually, I got back to them, and I smiled. Cut to an hour later. My pad is lying forgotten by my PlayStation, and I'm out in the garden. I'm shivering as I smoke, my cigarette trembling on my lips as I stare off into the distance, all too aware that my face is a pallid shade of grey and my guts are churning as though I've been kicked repeatedly in them. As the tears slid down my face, and my heart juddered in a kind of mourning-state, I sat there for around fifteen minutes. When it was over, and I felt good to move again, I dragged myself back into the house, and packed the game away. To make someone feel so strongly about a story is something that's common in books and in the movies, but it only happens in video games every so often. Even then, though, that's not what's so impressive. What blew my mind was just how brave Rockstar were in ending their game this way. Was it pleasant? No. Was it fun? No. Was it right? Absolutely. So there it is, pa'dners: 5 reasons why the admittedly awesome GTA V will never be as good as the so much more awesome Red Dead Redemption. Controversial? Maybe. Right? I'm not sure. I guess that's up to you to decide. Hit me up with your cheers of agreement or hisses of hate in the comments below, or keep it short and sweet at @CGibsonWrites on Twitter.


Contributor
Contributor

A bald, broken boy who’s trying to build a life one step at a time. A SunBro until his final hollowing, he loves a good story, and has been recently seen teaching his class the important lesson of how to refresh an Amazon link until the PS5 pre-orders go live.