7 Difficult RPG Choices That Completely Broke You

From Assassin's Creed to Witcher 3, these are the decisions which stopped you dead.

Until Dawn Chris Ashley
Sony

Most gamers know that analysis paralysis can strike on something as seemingly insignificant as what colour eyebrows to give your custom protagonist. This in mind, it’s a wonder we make any progress at all, especially with 80 hour RPGs that frequently compel you to make difficult choices.

Choosing whether or not to nuke a village of lazy orphans who have never lifted a finger to help you is one thing. Those freeloading orphans can look out for themselves. But when it’s a choice between the deaths of two of your favourite characters, things can quickly get traumatising.

Here’s seven choices that RPGs forced you to make that completely broke you in ways you haven’t still fully recovered from.


7. Parting Is Such Sweet Sorrow - Dragon Age: Inquisition

Hawke Dragon Age death
BioWare

Like many of the RPGs on this list, Dragon Age: Inquisition has a mind-boggling amount of story permutations. These game states depend not only on your choices during Inquisition, but in the two massive games that preceded it. As such, by the time you’re forced to leave a companion behind in the other-worldly fade, there are a few different choices you might need to make.

Still, there’s a good chance you’ll be forced to pick between some stalwart companions. Alistair is a personal favourite from Dragon Age: Origins, and Hawke is the character we all spent the entire second game with. Loghain is possibly a bit less beloved - he did betray you in Origins, after all - but it's hard not to love anyone brought to life by voice actor Simon Templeman. There’s tactical consideration too, as Loghain is in charge of the Grey Wardens at this point in the story.

However your world state ended up, it’s no easy choice to sacrifice a companion to a giant mutant spider and cut their story short. Naturally, the only way to set this right is to play the whole series over and over again, forever.


6. Anti-Reverend Run - Fire Emblem: Three Houses

Fire Emblem Three Houses Edelgard Church
Nintendo

Fire Emblem: Three Houses doesn’t like to make it easy for you, considering even the choice of which house to play as first is excruciating. Should you then make the obviously correct choice of siding with Edelgard’s “It’s fine, they’re just into genocide in a fun anime way’” Black Eagle House, you’ll then be faced with another doozy at the halfway point, where everyone’s favourite edgelord asks you to rebel against the church you’ve been fighting alongside for the past several hours.

Even if you’ve already had some doubts about Rhea and the church’s motives up to that point, it’s still not easy to turn against an institution that the narrative has positioned as a force for good. This is one of Three Houses' themes, of course, and while it doesn’t always succeed in fleshing out its factions, the ambition to present its conflicts as morally grey and a case of perspective is admirable.

In retrospect, the correct choice is obviously to run away with Edelgard and destroy the church. Still, at the time, the decision feels monumental.


5. Murder The Children Or Nah? - Witcher 3

Witcher 3 Whispering Hillock
CDProjekt Red

The Witcher 3, for all its sweeping, fantasy storytelling, had a bit of sadistic streak. Namely, it seemed to really enjoy torturing the player with horrific consequences for already difficult decisions. The Whispering Hillock mission - where Geralt has to decide whether to kill or release a potentially evil tree spirit - is one such choice.

This quest plays off an ingrained instinct we all have as RPG players. It always feels more natural, if you’re trying to follow a morally good path, to try and save, help, and otherwise aid those you meet. The game further subverts this by making the quest steps to release the tree spirit far more convoluted than just battering it with your swords. Having to go the extra mile makes it feel like the naturally correct path.

Geralt’s reward for this act of mercy? Some orphans get saved, sure. But you’ll also have to deal with the murder of an entire village, plus the suicide of the Bloody Baron. Or, you could take the other option, and let the orphans get eaten by the woods hags. Either way, you’re in for some grimdark.


4. Mordin, Mo’problems - Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3 genophage dispute
BioWare

The genophage - a horrific biological weapon used on the Krogan species to combat overpopulation - hung over the lore of Mass Effect like a black cloud through the entire series. In Mass Effect 2, we meet Mordin, the salarian scientist responsible for working on the project. Then, in Mass Effect 3, we can end up having to make one of the most difficult choices imaginable. We can cure the Genophage, but Mordin will die in the process.

There’s a good chance that by this point, you’ve got a couple of close Krogan companions whose lives will be seriously affected by this choice. Then, there’s Mordin himself, a morally complex character who is nonetheless charming, hilarious, and absolutely steals any scene he’s in. Any way you slice it, you’re going to end up losing a friend. Cheers, Mass Effect.

It’s a testament to the quality of Mass Effect’s writing that it manages to make a galactic level decision that affects millions of lives feel so personal by framing it through the perspective of individuals. Doesn’t make it hurt any less, though.


3. The Wolf Of Sparta - Assassin’s Creed: Odyssey

Assassin's Creed Odyssey Wolf of Sparta
Ubisoft

By the time our chosen protagonist meets their father figure Nikolaos in Assassin’s Creed: Odyssey, they’ve got an entire wax tablet’s worth of reasons to Spartan kick him in the chest, straight off the hill he’s standing on. Primarily, there’s the fact he tried to murder you and your sibling at the start of the game. Nice one, dad.

There’s also the promise of a big chunk of change for the wolf’s head, which is doubly tempting for a broke Misthios like your character. So, it’s up to you. Stab your dear old daddy and collect on twenty five years of unpaid child support, or show the aging warrior some compassion?

It’s a seriously fraught character moment whichever route you choose, as vengeance has been a huge part of the protagonist’s motivation up to this point. Still, with so many mysteries surrounding the game’s story already, it might be best to at least get some answers first. Plus, maybe leaving Nikolaos to his guilt is an adequate revenge in itself.


2. Spin The Bottle - Until Dawn

Until Dawn Chris Ashley
Sony

No good night out features a choice between whether to kill yourself or your girlfriend. It’s just not on anybody's wishlist, really. What to wear, where to eat, start slow on beer or get the shots in first thing? All valid choices. Put a bullet through your own head or live the rest of your miserable life in the knowledge that you only saved your own cowardly skin by blasting the brains of your loved one all over the wall? Not ideal.

Until Dawn, being the feel-good funfest it is, decides to make this choice mandatory. Chris and Ashley are incapacitated, tied up, and Chris is given limited time to decide who lives and dies. Some plot spoilers have been unavoidable on this list, but I won’t spoil how exactly this one plays out. I wouldn’t want to ruin the opportunity for you to get extremely depressed over a video game, after all.

In a game full of hard choices that generally revolve around avoiding death at all costs, this one asks you to stare death right in the face. Or, just be a coward, that’s cool too.


1. Farewell, Sweet Ti’zo - Pyre

Pyre choices
Supergiant Games

Supergiant’s third game (and third masterpiece out of four in a row, tbh) Pyre was part visual novel, part sports sim. If that doesn’t sound like your thing, don’t worry. It absolutely works, and features such great characters and writing you’ll soon be hooked on the journey.

Pyre has a big cast, but you’ll still get opportunities to know them all personally. Then, when you reach the game’s ending, you’ll have to make a series of choices which could well involve leaving a whole bunch of them behind in a permanent state of purgatory.

So much of the emotion of Supergiant's games come from Darren Korb’s beautiful soundtracks, and Pyre is no different. The ending theme wraps up your journey with lyrics about the characters that change based on which choices you make here. This can either be great, or just rub it in, depending on how things went.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Until Dawn
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Nic Reuben hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.