7 Inherent Flaws In The Awesome BioShock Infinite
The original BioShock game is considered to be one of the finest achievements within the realms of video game design. If you were going to mount a serious case for "video games as art," you might use BioShock as your prime example. In terms of aesthetic design, it's up there with Shadow of the Colossus and Half-Life 2. Last week, the latest game in the series, BioShock Infinite, was released to overwhelmingly good reviews. It is, without a doubt, the best game I've played in a long, long time. So why, exactly, has Infinite been bestowed with over 80 gaming awards and heaps of 5 star reviews? What makes it so good? Simply put, the game is an astounding artistic achievement: visionary and beautiful, it's a wonder to behold. From an aesthetic perspective, it is damn near flawless. The world that the player travels over the course of the game, Columbia, is one of the most vivid and detailed gaming environments ever constructed. Infinite also clings to a brilliantly dense and complex narrative that isn't afraid to push the boundaries of what a "video game story" is: it tackles real issues - like religion, racism, politics, and morality - with superior, relevant intelligence. The characters are rich and vibrant and programmed to be like real people (seriously: this is the first game to ever feature an A.I. "companion" that won't drive you crazy for a single second). That's not all: the game is unafraid to take its time, to give you moments to reflect and think on the consequences of your actions. Moments that allow for things like this to happen. When BioShock Infinite comes to an end, your personal journey with the game won't: it stays with you. That said, the game is not perfect, nor is it lacking some inherent design flaws. Whereas the visuals, the characters, and the bold storyline can be praised almost extensively, there are certain aspects of BioShock Infinite that don't quite gel. Let me put this into perspective: I love this game. I think it's something close to a masterpiece. It had a severe emotional affect on me, which - especially where video games are concerned - is something to be praised€ well, infinitely. I completed it almost a week ago, and it's still on my mind. But I want to take a look at what I believe to be some of the game's lesser aspects - some that I feel could've been better realised. Please note that there are some spoilers spread throughout the following article (I've tried to keep them to a minimum). If you're haven't played the game in full yet, I'd advise that you don't read on.
7. It's Awfully Similar To BioShock
All right, so this a game in the BioShock series, so it's obvious that there were going to be some similarities - lots of them, in fact, and that's fine. But when you consider that the original Bioshock came out out six years ago, you begin to think: "Six years on, and this is what we get?" I don't necessarily mean that in the snarky tone you probably read it in, though. What I mean to say is, BioShock Infinite doesn't do that much to separate itself from its predecessor - not in the "six years have passed" sense, anyway. Aside from the plot itself (and even that draws extremely close similarities, right?), there isn't much difference between this game and the original. If you've played the game, you'll know that in a way, that's exactly the point: that "infinite" subtitle isn't there for nothing. But as I ventured around Columbia, awing at its beauty and detail, I soon began to feel like I was just re-living the original game, albeit under a different skin. Sure, there's a new sky-rail feature and the overall mood is somewhat different, but the game itself feels like a twisted copy. Once again, those who have completed Infinite will probably insist that the point of the game is that it bears a huge resemblance to the original - and on purpose. But that's more to do with the storyline and not the gameplay itself. Despite the six year gap, BioShock doesn't really feel like a "new" game in the way that, say, Half-Life 2 felt for those who had played the original entry (also separated by a six year gap, by the way). In gameplay terms, at least, Infinite feels like something of a BioShock 2.5.
6. The Combat Isn't Anything Special
My first experience with the combat system in BioShock Infinite wasn't a particularly good one. It felt frantic, and confusing, as if I wasn't doing it right but didn't know why. This was made especially difficult as a hail of enemies fired relentlessly upon me as I tried to get into the swing of things. Thing is, after a while, you get the hang of it. From then on, it's fine. Is it ever really that fun to fight your enemies in Bioshock Infinite, though? I'm not sure. I mean, in a lot of ways, combat in Infinite isn't that much different from the combat in a lot of first-person shooters. You run around, looking for cover, using a variety of weapons, like shotguns, RPGs and sniper rifles. For better aim, you look down the sight. There's a good haul of guns to be had, though the game restricts you from having more than two guns on your person at any time (why?). You also get to use something called a Skyhook, a kind of rotating claw-arm of death, which is undoubtably the highlight of your arsenal. But combat here is almost note for note similar to the combat in the original Bioshock, to be honest, and I don't think anybody could make the claim that the combat is the best thing about either game. Delving into a lot of making of videos regarding Infinite's production, though, it seemed to me like creator Ken Levine really wanted to make sure the combat was something special. It doesn't feel that way to me, really. Sure, there are sky-lines now, which are certainly fun to glide around on, but can you really use them for combat purposes in the defining ways that Levine wanted? Not entirely: they're too fast, and you'd be seriously lucky to aim correctly whilst you're whizzing around at 80mph, trying to figure out where or what an enemy looks like. Levine insists that he feels like that got it right, but it still doesn't feel fully-fledged to me. Then there's the game's Vigors, which are pretty much the Plasmids from the first game. If you're unfamiliar with both, these are basically serve as "magic," which you are supposed to use in combat in a dual fashion (with whatever weapon you're boasting). Although Vigors are a lot of fun to customise and experiment with, I only really found a few of them to be of real use. Not only that, but the game kept having to remind me to use them, almost as if it knew I might forget. It was right: I did, though I'm still not completely sure why. Maybe because, ultimately, it was just easier to blast an enemy with a shotgun instead of trying to figure out which Vigor would be best for the situation. All in all, though, the combat here is fine - it just isn't anything to write home about.
5. It's Far Too Short
I know: a story should only be as long as it needs to be, right? In this case, BioShock Infinite is probably no shorter than your average first-person shooter nowadays (it's approximately 10-12 hours). Still, when my time was up, I just felt as though the game had been too short. How long it takes you to complete all depends on how fast you want to play it, of course: you're welcome to just race through to the finish, but that'd probably be one of the biggest mistakes you ever make (seriously). Not to mention that nothing would make an ounce of sense. Many of you are probably thinking: "Well, this guy didn't take the time out to play it properly if he thought it was too short." Fair enough, but trust me when I say that I did. I checked around every corner, peered through every shop window, completed all the optional missions, watched every one of those little silent movies, and even collected all the Voxophones. The entire game took me 15 hours. Was that worth the price of purchase? Obviously: this game would've been worth buying for just 5 hours spent in Columbia. But given how much work has gone into the world design, I just wanted to spent more time there, and I felt like - despite seeing so much of it - I didn't give me the chance to immerse myself for long enough. Maybe that's personal to me and other people thought the game was the perfect length, but I personally believe there was enough going on here to give us 5 more hours of story. Even with all the extra stuff that you can do to extend your playtime to around 20 plus hours, the main game itself - for me - just ended far too quickly.
4. The Save System Is Frustrating
A minor gripe, but a gripe nonetheless: Infinite's save system is just plain frustrating, though I'm not sure that the designers ever realised this when they were making the game. I think, in this case, it simply must have been overlooked or forgotten about. Infinite relies on an autosave feature, you see, which sets in every half hour or so as you progress. And an autosave feature is fine, but only if the game also gives you the option to save at your will. Not here, unfortunately, which means that there are times where the game might freeze, or fails to load between sections, when you're forced to replay entire sections. Sometimes - during longer sections - the autosave feature will wait close to hour before it kicks in, which means you're always playing in a state of fear, wondering if you're going to have complete entire parts again. Not a major problem, of course, but slightly misjudged. In a game like this one, where exploration is one of the best bits, it would've been nice to have an option to save at will.
3. Columbia Is Oddly Static
I'm not attacking Columbia's overall design here, because it's an amazing accomplishment, one crammed with an unbelievable and impressive amount of detail. But as I played the game (and I haven't heard this mentioned anywhere else thus far), something odd struck me about it: the city felt kind of... static. Despite the fact that it's this amazing place that exists wholly in the sky and there are airships flying about and hundreds sky-rails and hot dog vendors and barbershop quartets singing "God Only Knows," it just came off as cold. At first, I thought that this tone was one being pushed onto me purposely... and then I realised, it was something else completely: none of game's NPCs were moving. I mean, yes, they're "moving" in the sense that they've been animated, but nobody is walking or navigating the city in the same way that you are. Every character is stuck in a single position. This is a somewhat bizarre design flaw, I think, because it means that Columbia rarely feels like it's "working" in the way it should be working - this huge machine, a sum of all its tiny moving parts. Why isn't anybody walking about, breathing a bit of life into the place? The enemies are the only characters who ever move properly, and that's because they're obviously required to. But Columbia can't truly feel like an amazing city in the sky when it's people remain entirely fixed to the ground.2. The Middle Act Veers Dangerously Close To Filler
Infinite's pacing is mostly brilliant throughout, though there's a point that occurs towards the middle of the game where things begin to lose focus slightly, and you feel like proceedings are coming dangerously close to "generic first-person shooter" territory: You know... completing mindless errands for other characters (i.e. every other game ever made). Luckily this doesn't last long enough to drive you out of your mind, because the scenery is still magnificent. The game also seems to release what it's doing, before pulling the rug out beneath your feet. Phew. Still, this little blip takes up a few hours of precious gameplay time, and I think it's interesting for a couple of reasons. Despite the fact that so many developers are seriously trying to push the boundaries of what it is to "tell a story" with the video game medium, it's still tough for them to tell a story with the same amount of energy for a full on 10 hours. Understandable, of course, but it means that - even Infinite's story is excellent - segments like this still find their way in, despite the fact that genericness is what the best developers are actively trying to avoid.
1. Is The Ending Too Much?
I said in the introduction to this article that I believed BioShock Infinite's narrative aspects were near flawless. So why am I picking on the game's ending, right? First of all, I did say that I believed the game's narrative aspects were near flawless, and I do mean it (for the most part). When I praise the game's narrative, though, I'm praising the way that Infinite uses the medium to tell the story it's telling, and not necessarily each and every single one of its many, many plot threads. That's to say, Infinite is a game that puts story first. A lot of games don't. On that aspect alone, it's an incredible achievement. You're absorbed in the story the whole time - so much so, that Infinite's relatively basic combat system doesn't even come close to derailing the experience in any way, shape of form. The immersion is too damn good. But the ending of the story seems a little muddled to me, and is somewhat overreaching in its final moments. The ending of the game rushes to give you all the plot points you need to try and piece everything together, which is - in this case - enough to fry your brain for weeks on end. There are hundreds of theories doing the rounds on the internet as I write this, all of which are trying to figure out what exactly happened over the course of Infinite. Because of the extremely complicated, Primer-like nature of the story, nobody can really piece it together entirely. It was written that way on purpose, I think, and though I like the ending, I believe it's more deus ex machina than something that can be genuinely worked out and pieced together like a puzzle. The problem is, the game kind of gives you the impression that there's something incredibly complex at work, though I'm still not sure that the final "twist" makes a whole lot of sense. Maybe you could shoehorn it into something should you sit down and map it all out, but I think what you'd find, ultimately, would be something badly convoluted instead of brilliantly complex. Don't get me wrong: BioShock Infinite is incredible in the way it uses the gaming medium to actually tell a story. I mean, there aren't even any cut scenes - you play through the entire experience from beginning to end from a single perspective, and it's wonderfully captivating. I've just got this nagging feeling I can't quite escape: that the ending "twist" isn't particularly good for the story as a whole. Like this article? Agree or disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.