7 Most Overrated Video Games Of 2021

Deathloop is a perfect game??!

deathloop game
Arkane Studios

Yup, it's that time again.

Even in a year where we were lucky to get any games that turned more than a few heads at once, there are always those titles gamers agree over time were recommended a bit too much.

The games that as the following months trickled out and that launch hype died off altogether, were left being analysed and considered in a way that actually highlights more flaws than confirmations.

It truly is hard to make something that stands the test of time when so many ancillary factors are forcing developers to cash in on trends or attempt to make as much money as possible in a shorter launch window, but that's entirely the point:

How much are the following games deserving of their high scores, and which falter when put under the microscope?

Obviously, none of the following games are bad - far from it - only that they're worth another look when we're talking about the absolute best 2021 has to offer.


7. Hitman 3

Hitman 3
IO Interactive

For as painful as it is to say, Hitman 3 just wasn't that good.

It was totally more of the same of Hitman 1 and 2's incredibly solid stealth gameplay, but for a title that should've gone the extra mile to round out the trilogy with confidence, what we got was just that bit too lacking.

Besides the paltry amount of missions and fact the final one isn't really a Hitman level at all, this was also supposed to be paying off five years' worth of an unexpectedly engaging narrative.

Yes, no one goes to Hitman for the story, but that was entirely the point - Hitman 2016 had begun sewing the seeds of 47's childhood brother, Lucas Grey. Hitman 2 revealed 47 was behind the death of Diana's parents, and Hitman 3 would see all parts of the character's formerly blank psyche collide. 47 had more agency in between levels than ever, regaining a lifetime's worth of memories and adding weight to who you were tracking down on-mission.

Instead of ANY of that elevating the final instalment, Grey was killed almost immediately, Diana hand-waves away 47's forgiveness as the pair work together again, and 47 just takes a phial of memory-erasure juice so he can go on killing forever. Even that scene itself - centred on finally meeting the head of the illuminati-like Providence, sees him taken out in an incredibly boring way, considering your options everywhere else in the trilogy.

Hitman 3, for as stunning as it is, feels more like a glorified DLC map pack than a whole new game.


6. Resident Evil Village

Varcolac Alfa Resident Evil Village
Capcom

For a game marketed entirely on one Lady Demitrescu being 2021's version of Jack Baker i.e. a persistent enemy you'd build a set of encounters around, becoming a definable part of Resident Evil Village overall?

Well, she dies in the first fifth of the game.

Annoyingly, all Lady D's best encounters were used in marketing, as Capcom completely doubled down on the character to sell the game. That's immaculately effective PR, but you then need the rest of the game's villains and pace to match the early-going, which RE8 arguably does not.

When it comes to persistent enemies overall too, Village does next to nothing with their mechanics or even the way you think about dealing with them in-game. It's Mr. X from RE 2; RE3's Nemesis all over again, and that's a bit lacking.

Worst of all, the game's mystery storyline - centred entirely on why longtime hero Chris Redfield just shot RE7's Mia Winters - made absolutely no sense as to why he didn't immediately explain what was happening to Ethan himself.

Resident Evil is obviously known for overblown campy tones and "Just go with it" plots that often become meme-worthy, but to hang the entire thrust of the narrative on a mystery that completely under-delivers does make Village hard to recommend.


5. Forza Horizon 5

Forza Horizon 5
Playground Games

As gorgeous and must-play as Forza Horizon 5 is... it was also the first time one of these games dropped, and was EXACTLY what you thought going in.

From the car-switching intro with various slow-motion stunts to the races against things like planes, trains and in this case a jet-ski - all scripted to let you win at the last second - Horizon 5 is an all-out visual feast and a perfect execution of a formula, but that's also its biggest problem.

This is now a recognisable execution on a bankable formula that yes, came into its own across Horizon 3 and especially 4, but *I'd* say, needs to be wary of just cranking these out.

The issue that slowly killed the mainline Forza games - other than microtransactions in Forza 7, anyway - is a feeling of stagnancy and repetition. Perfectly serviceable games tick boxes and rake in the dough - just look at Far Cry 6 and Forza Horizon 5 - but on the other hand we can get Call of Duty: Vanguard.

Forza Horizon 5 is absolutely a showcase of what powerful Xbox hardware can do - the problem is that Horizon 4 did every last trick back in 2018.


4. Returnal

Returnal PS5
Sony

Easily the cruelest and most demanding title maybe in PlayStation exclusive history, Housemarque adapting a bullet hell aesthetic to a punishing roguelike with random rewards resulted in a notably divisive game.

Where gunplay, atmosphere and an eventual sense of reward can be stellar if you make it through, only a paltry 23% of people have reached and beaten the final boss, with everyone else giving up on Returnal's setup over time.

Sadly, despite the game reviewing very well, its core feel is just too abusive of your time. Weapons and upgrades are entirely random, with only weapon skill carrying over between runs. An average attempt at a run stretches at least 45 minutes, meaning you've got nothing to show other than maybe some different ammo types, damage increases or a new weapon, if it happened to drop that time around.

Couple with being killed from off-screen, enemy shockwaves coming through walls to kill you behind cover, and you have a supremely awkward game that occasionally asks too much.

For their first 3D release, Housemarque clearly had a lot on their plate and the project was overhauled across development. Still, the systems here - and fact it took them almost the entire year to implement a save system - reveal the design as fundamentally flawed.


3. Microsoft Flight Simulator (Xbox)

microsoft flight simulator
Microsoft

Not criticising the reality of being able to hop in a Boeing 747 and fly in real time to photo-realistic Mt. Fuji, admiring satellite-accurate weather patterns along the way. That... is genuine science-magic made playable.

No, what kinda sucks about Microsoft Flight Sim on console... is that VERY little work was done to actually make it feel remotely satisfying as a console experience.

We're talking obtuse as hell, mouse cursor-driven menus, online guide-requiring steps to modify your controls and add basic features. Getting anything more out of this other than picking destinations and hoping for the best sees you diving into tons of FAQs online, alongside breakdowns of what different alarm sounds or parts of your plane's dashboard even mean.

Microsoft Flight Sim is a staggering achievement in code, but if you're bringing it to a system without mouse, keyboard or a wider set of shortcut bindings i.e. a whole new audience who need to be onboarded significantly - it needed a UI, controls and presentation overhaul.


2. Pokémon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl

pokemon brilliant diamond shining pearl
Nintendo

With Diamond & Pearl, Nintendo have officially overused a specific "game feel" that's been creaking and showing its age for over a decade now.

Hell, even back in the late 90s we were sick of buttoning through individual lines of text when in combat, teaching our pokemon moves in that "1... 2... poof!"-type way or just slugging through menus.

Ultimately though, Pokémon was a formula that sold, and sold ludicrously well, so where's the impetus to change?

Well, come Sword & Shield - the eighth generation of twin-games, no less, not counting additional re-releases over the years - and people had had enough. Having the franchise debut on Switch - yet still have largely the same pace as something from the original Game Boy - felt like the last straw.

Couple this with the fact Pokémon Let's Go Pikachu and Eevee adapted Pokémon GO's catching system and ability to see creatures in the wild before acquiring, and the Diamond and Pearl re-releases feel practically prehistoric.

Yes, you can argue they're "faithful" to the originals, but when Pokémon Yellow's remake did make advancements - and Nintendo acknowledged these outdated ways by greenlighting the gameplay-upended Pokémon Arceus - 2021's re-releases were traditional to a fault.


1. Deathloop

Deathloop PS5
Bethesda

Even now, months after launch when Deathloop dropped to a host of perfect and near-perfect scores, I don't see it.

And man, have I tried.

Arkane's wannabe sandbox murder sim gives you four main areas - split across a single day's timeframe - where you need to take down 8 different targets across as many timeloops as you need, until they're all slaughter-able in one go. Its advertised and championed as something where you'll slowly move the pieces into place, Hitman-style, for that one final, glorious kill-chain.

However, playing Deathloop feels clunky as hell in almost every way. Once you're out a ludicrously elongated tutorial, it's practically "Bells & Whistles: The Game", distracting you from the fact you're simply loading into an area, going to a place and holding a button or killing one person, with an abundance of menu systems, crafting options and supposed customisation that ultimately barely factors in.

Worst of all, this supposedly open-ended structure boils down to the same final mission and the same ending, regardless of whatever you do beforehand. And that's without mentioning the game's invasion-based multiplayer means you and other players are encouraged to mess up whatever potential mission structure there is, before you get there.

Deathloop arrived like some gilded, angelic creation all those in its presence must bow and be thankful for, and while I treasure Arkane as a studio, they completely missed the mark here.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Deathloop
 
Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.