7 Video Game Character Deaths That Carried Real Weight

"Had to be me. Someone else might have gotten it wrong."

mass effect mordin solus
Bioware

Being a medium that is has so many nameless and faceless monsters dying and respawning without consequence, gamers tend to take life and death for granted.

It's those rare cases when a character dies - and stays dead - that really stick with you. The cases are rare for a number of reasons: Killing off a major character in a game is a very daunting task, and most developers don't want to pull that proverbial trigger without good reason.

Death has to be permanent in order to carry the proper weight, and the prospect of suddenly and permanently removing an aspect of the story or a particular game mechanic can be extremely daunting.

How does the player replace the functionality of a lost character, and how does the loss of said character impact the story? These questions and more go into the removal of a key character, and with the inevitable and merciful death of 2016 being imminent, here are seven times a character death was done right.

This is your blanket spoiler warning. Enter at your own risk...

7. Andrew Ryan - Bioshock

bioshock andrew ryan
Irrational Games

Ryan may not be the final boss of Bioshock, however make no mistake, he is most definitely meant to be an antagonist. In his own words, "It is only when we struggle in our own interest does the chain pull society in the right direction."

In a sense, Ryan makes the argument that greed is not only good, but necessary for the benefit of all. Of course, the decaying and splicer-infested corpse of Rapture shows just how well that worked out for him.

Once confronted, Ryan lays bare the motivation the player has - namely that the player was told to do things and did them without thinking for themselves because that was how they were programmed. A sleeper agent sent to Rapture by Atlas to take down Ryan. All using a simple question that doubles as a trigger phrase to strip the protagonist of will:

Would you kindly?

Ryan then proceeds to demonstrate his power over the character in a chilling sequence as Rapture bursts at the seams around him. With one last order he commands the player to kill him, and the player character obeys without input.

In essence, Ryan won. He chose his own death and forced you to do it.

After all, a man chooses. A slave obeys.


6. Shinjiro Aragaki - Persona 3

shin megami tensei 3
Atlus

Persona 3 is your typical JRPG in many ways, whilst it's the contemporary setting and themes that set the series itself apart.

Instead of a medieval world of swords and sorcery, you step into Japan circa 2004 with magic powers. The emphasis on forming relationships and learning about the world around you provide a focus on the characters and the bonds between them, making the Persona games feel so personal to so many, and no character embodies that theme better than Shinjiro Aragaki.

Aragaki has history with the two senior members of the group, and will even provide favors for them when needed. After rejoining the group and becoming a playable character, Shinjiro's past starts to unfold in conversation.

In battle, he quickly establishes himself as a very defensive oriented character that can take hits better than anyone else, making him an mainstay in the party. Of course, if that were all, he wouldn't be on this list... unfortunately.

On October 4th, Shinji meets with Ken to confront his guilt over the death of Ken's mom. However, he ends up not only talking Ken down, but takes a bullet meant for Ken as well. As Shinjiro dies, he sparks the growth of the rest of the team in how they deal with tragedy, ultimately bringing them closer together and challenging the player to move on without him, both as a character and in battle.

All in all, it grounds the narrative and makes things personal for the player, giving them even more reason to fight.


5. Everyone - Undertale

Undertale game
Toby Fox

When it was getting funding on Kickstarter, Toby Fox called Undertale "a fun RPG where nobody has to die", and while Undertale does indeed have systems in place to make the pacifist route not only enjoyable and engaging, it also gives the option to kill everyone you come across.

However, when you engage with the monsters in Undertale, you begin to learn about them on a very personal level. The random encounters in RPG's have really never been more than grinding fodder in 90% of games in the genre. The inclusion of allowing a player to kill any character they please - or all of them - speaks to the simple genius of the game.

When playing a pacifist route through the game, the player is allowed to learn and interact with the monsters - particularly the bosses. They hang out at bars, work jobs, and have more personality than a player would expect. In fact, the game sort of tricks the player into killing the first 'boss', and then rubs their nose in it.

Even if the player resets the game in an attempt to change that outcome, Undertale doesn't let them get away with it. More than anything, Toby Fox has created a game about consequence, and he works that theme into every decision the player makes.

By having the route that is permeated by death, the game emphasizes life, and how everyone has a story to tell.


4. Mordin Solus - Mass Effect 

Mass effect mordin
Bioware

Mass Effect thrusts the player into a galaxy of consequence that feels real and living, seeing the Salarian scientist Mordin joining the Normandy crew after Shepherd and company help him cure a plague that was ravaging the streets of Omega.

His fast talking stream of consciousness dialogue lent him a unique personality that no other character comes close to. When it's revealed that he was involved with the creation and distribution of the Genophage that doomed the Krogans to a slow extinction, his willingness to do what must be done for what he believes is the correct solution comes to the forefront.

When Shepherd's crew takes the war with the Reapers to the Krogan homeworld, Solus not only develops a cure for the Genophage but wants to distribute the cure despite the will of his race's government fearing another uprising from the Krogans.

His willingness to lay down his life to save others serves as a galvanizing force. It allows the Krogans to finally reclaim their survival and for the player, it makes things even more personal as the Reapers take yet another comrade.


3. John Marston - Red Dead Redemption

Red Dead Redemption - John Marston
Rockstar Games

Very few games will kill a character that the player controls during the course of the game's story, and for good reason. It's tough to take out what is ostensibly the main focus of the story that empowers the player. Fewer still do it before the game truly ends and of those that do, Red Dead Redemption stands out among the rest.

Getting to that point in the story requires a lot of the player, and during that time, the player gets to know John very intimately. They see what makes him tick, what drives him, and most importantly how they can identify with his plight.

When John walks into that hail of gunfire it hits the player like a ton of bricks. And while Jack may not be the larger than life man that his father was, Jack taking revenge for his father would not have carried a fraction of the cathartic weight that it did without the build up of John's character.


2. Sarah - The Last Of Us

THE LAST of us
Naughty Dog

While the death of Joel's daughter Sarah was spoiled by the box art for The Last of Us, it was no less impactful. Most games featuring a zombie apocalypse usually thrust the player into the thick of the undead hordes with a small explanation of how the world began the fight with the rotting armies of the dead. It is very rare that we as players get to experience the fall of the world first hand.

When the game starts up, we take control of Sarah instead of Joel with amazing performances from all the actors involved, drawing the player into the relationship between father and daughter with fairly little dialogue. When things begin to happen, however, it's done with an expert sense of pacing. Things seem off at first before slowly ramping up to the family fleeing the infected for their lives.

Sarah may not have had a whole lot of screen time, but her tragic death only served to truly set the stage of the rest of the game. It established early on that Joel had some serious baggage going into the wasteland while also putting every NPC encountered on the chopping block.

Once Ellie is introduced into the story, Joel's reluctance to open up emotionally becomes more and more apparent even as Ellie slowly breaks down those walls.

This all culminates at the climax where Joel simply cannot lose another daughter, even if that means missing out on a potential vaccine for the fungal plague that brought the world to its knees.


1. Aerith - Final Fantasy 7

final fantasy 7 aerith
Square Enix

When Yoshinori Kitase set out to make Final Fantasy 7, he had just lost someone very close to him. That sense of loss and having to carry on with life permeated how he approached the creation of the game.

When players lost Aerith, an army of fans scoured the internet in its infancy in search of a way to bring her back. Players attempted to recreate impossible scenarios and indulged every unfounded rumor all in the hopes of bringing Aerith back and it's easy to see why.

She was for all intents and purposes, the girl next door. Couple that with her limit breaks being defensive and healing oriented, and she provided a very important service in battle that made her a mainstay in many player's formations.

When she dies, the world around her seems slightly darker for her absence, despite not being free of her influence.

There's a reason why Final Fantasy 7 resonates so strongly with a huge audience. Let's just hope Square Enix doesn't screw it up with the remake.

--

Which video game death totally gut-punched you? Let us know in the comments!


In this post: 
Mass Effect
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Freelance writer, magnificent beard having, narrative focused, gaming nerd.