7 Video Games That Broke Their Own Rules
Hey Jedi: Fallen Order, that's not how lightsabers work!
A lot of work goes into video game world-building. Some studios (usually the larger ones) have dedicated groups of people whose sole purpose is to ensure that the lore makes sense, and that it's free of contradictions and inconsistencies.
Most studios will also have mantras and rules that they want their gameplay to stick to, whether that's to ensure a fair and competitive environment in online titles, or to make a singleplayer experience as fun as it can possibly be.
But whether it's on the gameplay side of things or the story side of things, rules are made to be broken, and that's exactly what certain developers did.
Whether it's for an understandable reason (like wanting to increase a game's challenge), or a more nefarious reason (like conning players out of their money, which has become annoyingly common over the last few years), some games blatantly break the rules they've set up for themselves, often without even acknowledging that they've done so.
To be clear, we're not saying these games are bad - most of them are actually pretty great - but they did bend certain rules, often with frustrating consequences.
7. Portals Can't Move (Portal 2)
The vast majority of puzzles in the Portal series are wound to perfection, making it abundantly clear what the player can and can't do in each given situation.
For instance, throughout both of the core games, it's firmly established that your portals will disappear if you place them on a moving surface. This rule was obeyed all the way through 2007's Portal, and for most of 2011's Portal 2 - before it was ultimately broken in one infamous puzzle.
In the sequel's fifth chapter, there's a neurotoxin room that requires players to destroy a generator by using a laser to cut through some tubes.
This is accomplished by firing a portal onto a moving white platform, causing the laser to slice through each tube like a hot knife through butter.
As pointed out by fans of the series, this is the only time in both games where portals are capable of moving, and though some people go to ridiculous lengths to defend this rule-break ("well, the Earth is moving, so technically portals are always on a moving surface"), it quite obviously goes against the established limitations of portal movement, for no good reason.
6. Lara Absolutely HATES Killing (Tomb Raider)
Early on in Crystal Dynamics' 2013 reboot of the Tomb Raider series, this young and inexperienced Lara Croft is captured, bound, and beaten by a Russian man. Shortly after, the same man tries to sexually assault her, forcing her to kill him in retaliation.
Despite the fact that this guy clearly deserved it, the act of taking someone's life is utterly traumatic for Lara, who falls to her knees weeping, covered in his blood.
The game is telling us that this version of Lara isn't some happy-go-lucky, Nathan Drake-esque mass-murderer. She isn't okay with killing and she only did it out of necessity, and at the end of the day, she's just an archaeology student who's never had a proper fight.
Almost immediately after this scene though, this rule is broken: Lara suddenly becomes an unstoppable killing machine, shooting guys with arrows, stabbing them with pointy weapons, and even beating them with her bare fists. She doesn't show a lick of remorse, and she acts like she's been doing this for years.
Now sure, it wouldn't be a very fun game without combat, and Lara clearly has to fight in order to survive. But the whole rule of her being emotionally affected by killing is completely dropped after that initial scene. It's jarring, to say the least.
5. Healing Should Be Difficult (Apex Legends)
From the beginning, one of Respawn's core mantras for Apex Legends was that healing should slow you down, that it should make you an easy target, and that players should think carefully about when they choose to do it.
To that end, they removed a movement technique called "bunny-hopping" - which allowed players to bounce around like a rabbit while popping a shield or a health med - just a few months after the game launched.
But then, when Season 7 rolled around at the end of 2020, the studio seemed to forget about that mantra by launching an insanely powerful Legend called Horizon.
Horizon's tactical ability allowed her to throw down a Gravity Lift that launched her into the air at a high speed, which was useful for dodging enemy fire. Crucially though, the lift gave her enough time to fully heal while using it, meaning that she could max out her HP while being a fast-moving, difficult-to-hit target.
The immediate response to Horizon was that she's broken, and that she desperately needs a nerf, with players rightfully pointing out that other Legends with movement abilities - such as Wraith and Pathfinder - can't heal while using them.
Fortunately, the effectiveness of the Gravity Lift has since been reduced, but Horizon is still a massive contradiction to the way that Respawn intended healing to work.
4. Shine Sprites Are Tricky To Get (Super Mario Sunshine)
Less of a single rule, and more the entire concept of the game being fundamentally broken (and no, we're not talking about its awful camera), Super Mario Sunshine finds our hero trying to save Isle Delfino from a plague of pollution.
To do this, he must collect over 100 Shine Sprites - the island's source of power - which are scattered throughout the world.
The game sets up that Mario is gonna have to work real hard to get those Shine Sprites back, engaging in some difficult platforming sections, puzzles, and contending with Bowser (and Bowser Jr.) along the way.
So, if we consider this story setup as our "rule", the break occurs when you discover that most of the Shine Sprites are held by ordinary townspeople who could easily give them back to you, but, for some bizarre reason, decide not to.
One particular NPC will even give you 24 sprites - but only in exchange for 240 blue coins. Mate, don't you want to fix your town?! Just give Mario the sprites goddamnit!
This has been a running joke among fans for years, and was highlighted once again when the Mario 3D All-Stars collection launched in 2020. A plot thread could've easily been added about the NPCs being possessed by an evil force or something, but instead, they're all just being dicks for no reason.
3. Lightsabers Should Be Ridiculously Strong (Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order)
Lightsabers might be one of the most powerful weapons in movie history, but they were nerfed pretty hard in Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order.
In Star Wars canon, it's known that these iconic blades can cut through almost anything in a single swipe, from human flesh to metal doors. Only materials like beskar - used to forge Mandalorian armour - are the rare exceptions to this rule.
However, in Fallen Order, your lightsaber acts more like a traditional sword, rather than a laser sword. Enemies in this game take tons of hits to defeat - even your bog-standard Stormtrooper grunts - despite the fact that, again, lightsabers should be able to slice through anything they touch with ease.
Outside of a few specific cases, the game also lacks dismemberment, another lightsaber staple used in the movies, as well as games like Jedi Knight II: Jedi Outcast.
On the subject of dismemberment, Respawn said they only wanted to use it for the occasional story beat, but as for those underpowered lightsabers as a whole? Well, the explanation is obviously "to make the game challenging", but it still flies in the face of everything we know about lightsabers in other Star Wars media.
2. Cosmetic-Only Microtransactions (Marvel's Avengers)
It says a lot about the current state of the gaming industry that studios now wear the phrase "cosmetic-only microtransactions" like some nonsensical badge of honour.
Guys. Skins have been a standard, free unlockable in games since... well, since forever. But gee, thanks for letting us pay for them now!
Anyway, before the launch of Marvel's Avengers, Square Enix also pulled that same stunt, saying they were "committed" to cosmetic-only microtransactions, almost as if they expected a round of applause for including purchasables in a full-price game.
But then, the game came out, was met with a mixed-to-negative reception, and didn't do as well as expected, prompting the publisher to pivot on that cosmetic-only rule.
In a recent update, paid XP boosts were added to the game, a move that was met with a huge backlash. Not only was it a little scummy that Square Enix had broken its promise, but these boosts were added after XP gains had been slowed - which made it seem like the game was trying to force players to spend real money.
Though these paid XP boosts were later removed, the damage had already been done by that point, and it was a very bad look for Square Enix.
1. New-U Stations Can Respawn Anyone (Borderlands Series)
Many games have disconnects between story cutscenes and actual gameplay, and the Borderlands series features an absolute whopper.
These games contain devices called New-U Stations scattered throughout Pandora, which are essentially fixed respawn points the player can use after death.
Considering that "guns blazing" is by far the best, most fun approach in Borderlands, these stations are a critical part of the experience - you're probably going to die a lot, and it's nice to know that respawning is a quick and easy process.
Despite all this though, the games' stories completely ignore that New-U Stations are a thing. It doesn't make sense that our heroes are concerned about dying when they can just respawn at any time, and what's more, nobody thinks to use a New-U Station when Roland is killed in Borderlands 2.
In other words, the New-U rule isn't consistent in the slightest, an issue that resulted in Borderlands 2 writer Anthony Burch declaring these stations non-canon.
New-U stations didn't really need to exist in the first place - just do it like every other game, and have the player respawn with no explanation. But as it stands, Burch's non-canon explanation is the only way to get around this one.
Watch Next
The ULTIMATE Star Wars Video Games Quiz