7 Video Games That Survived Development Hell (And How)
Get the true story behind some of gaming's most complex projects.
Though not always the most patient lot, gamers have learned to appreciate that amongst all the major entertainment mediums, video games take a long time to make. Developing a video game, especially when building a new franchise from the ground up, is a massive, arduous undertaking, and therefore it can be many years before the finished article winds up on store shelves.
Throughout the relatively short history of gaming, however, there are a number of infamous cases where a project fell into what's known as 'development hell’, taking an inordinate amount of time to come out, with many becoming running jokes amongst the industry and its fans. Some even took so long between announcement and release that many assumed the games would never come out.
This can happen for a wide variety of reasons; the title being passed around from developer to developer, progress slowing to a halt due to new, unfamiliar technologies, or simple over-ambition getting the better of development staff. And whether these games were any good upon their eventual release is almost inconsequential, when compared the fascinating stories of how they finally surfaced…
7. The Last Guardian
Following the cult status achieved by Fumito Ueda’s Ico and Shadow of the Colossus, gamers eagerly anticipated news of what the beloved Japanese game developer was going to come up with next.
In 2009, The Last Guardian was officially unveiled as a PlayStation 3 exclusive. The following year at the Tokyo Game Show, a release window was announced, telling gamers to expect the game in time for the holidays in 2011.
Early in 2011, though, the game was delayed.
Development was slow and Sony weren’t happy the game’s serious performance issues on PlayStation 3. They brought in outside teams (from the likes of God of War devs Santa Monica Studios) to try and help out but, in 2012, the decision was made to move the game onto PlayStation 4 in order to fully realise Ueda’s vision. On PS4, performance greatly improved, and it was now up to the remaining developers to finish the project.
Slowing things down further was the fact that in December 2011, Ueda left Sony due to feeling “a sense of crisis within myself about a lot of things” and a number of his team followed suit. Together they formed a new studio, GenDESIGN, and were contracted to work in partnership with Japan Studio to finish The Last Guardian.
After a re-reveal in 2015 and one more delay (of course), The Last Guardian finally launched in December 2016 to a mixed, though mostly warm, critical reception.
6. Final Fantasy XV
Beginning life as Final Fantasy Versus XIII, a long and troubled development cycle started in 2006 with talks of the game being rebranded as the next mainline entry in the series, coming as early as 2007 due to its scope and ambition. However, it continued as Versus XIII all the way until 2012, before that decision was finally made with the game supposedly only 20-25% complete after six years.
With the project clearly not progressing at more than a snail’s pace, Square Enix were forced to step in and a reshuffle in the development team saw Hajime Tabata take over for Tetsuya Nomura as the game’s director, with development essentially starting over again.
At E3 the following year, the game was publicly re-revealed and rebranded as Final Fantasy XV – seven years after beginning development. Regular updates followed, including two playable demos released to the public in 2015 and 2016, before a release date was finally announced. After a decade in development, Final Fantasy XV would release on September 30 2017.
Only, it didn’t. Unbelievably, it was delayed yet again.
Finally, after further polishing, the game released to a largely positive critical reception on November 29th 2016. At this rate, expect to get your hands on Final Fantasy XVI sometime around the mid-2020s.
5. Aliens: Colonial Marines
Developed by Check Six Games for a 2001 release on the PlayStation 2, Aliens: Colonial Marines was cancelled before it ever saw the light of day.
In late 2006, though, Sega revived hopes that fans would get their hands on a new Alien game when they acquired the rights to the franchise and announced, just days later, that Gearbox would be working on a brand new title in the universe. The name of that game? Aliens: Colonial Marines.
In 2009, Gearbox released the massively successful Borderlands and immediately went to work on its sequel, deciding to outsource the bulk of Colonial Marines’ development to a company called TimeGate. Problem was, TimeGate were already working on the sequel to their first-person shooter Section 8, so didn’t actually get around to working on Aliens until late 2010.
When they received the game materials, Timegate were shocked at how little progress had been made on the game in the four years prior. On top of that, the game’s script hadn’t been finalised and they were being fed different directions from both Sega and Gearbox.
Then sometime in mid-2012, once they were winding down development on Borderlands 2, Gearbox took development back. With such a fractured development, it would have been a miracle if Colonial Marines was good – and it wasn’t.
It finally released in February 2013, Gearbox and Sega were then (successfully) sued for false advertising when the game was of notably lower quality than demos shown in the lead up to its release.
4. Duke Nukem Forever
Probably THE most notorious offender on this list, the aptly-titled Duke Nukem Forever released in 2011 after a whopping 15 years in development.
Early promotional information indicated that the game would be released sometime between ’97 and ’98 but that came and went, as did the millennium, and the game was nowhere to be seen. After years of silence, 3D Realms finally piped up in 2001 stating that the game would be released “when it’s done.”
What was going on?
Creator George Broussard’s unwavering perfectionism and obsession with the latest technology meant the game’s development was stop-start at best. After beginning development on the Quake II engine, Broussard’s need for Forever to release with the latest and greatest technology saw the team essentially reboot the project by switching over to the Unreal Engine. And so things continued, with Broussard’s constant need for upgrades consistently halting development from progressing at any real pace.
In May 2009, 3D Realms was in serious financial trouble. Major downsizing led to the loss of the game’s development team, development shut down and many saw this as hasta la vista for Duke. Adding insult to injury, publisher Take-Two Interactive filed a lawsuit against the developer over their “failure to finish development.”
In 2009, Borderlands developer Gearbox were handed the reigns and managed to put the finishing touches on the game. Duke Nukem Forever released on June 10 2011 to a largely negative critical reception. Ouch.
3. Team Fortress 2
After the franchise began life as a mod for 1996’s Quake, its creators were employed by Valve to make it a fully-fledged, stand-alone Team Fortress title. Team Fortress 2 was announced at E3 1999 as an online military shooter with a realistic, modern war aesthetic.
Shortly after the announcement that the game would be switching over to the Source engine in mid-2000, though, everything went eerily silent. And silent things remained for six years until, in 2006, Team Fortress 2 reared its head.
Reintroduced during EA’s Summer Showcase event, Team Fortress 2 was revealed as a drastically different game to the one shown seven years previous. Gone were the realistic, modern war visuals and in their place was a gorgeous, cartoon-inspired aesthetic. According to Team Fortress creator Robin Walker, the development team built “three to four different games” before settling on the final design.
No wonder it took so long!
Team Fortress 2 finally released in October 2007 as part of the video game bundle The Orange Box alongside Half-Life 2: Episode 2 and Portal. And though indecisiveness saw the game take ages to release, it didn’t take critics long to fall in love with the game – it was received with near-unanimous praise.
2. Too Human
Announced by developer Silicon Knights in 1999 as a game for the original PlayStation, Too Human released as an Xbox 360 exclusive in 2008 after a partnership with Nintendo in the early 2000s.
Wait... what?
After its announcement in 1999, development halted when Nintendo announced an exclusive partnership with Silicon Knights. The game was shifted over to the big N’s GameCube in 2000 where news of the title went silent as the developers were moved onto two other releases – Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem and Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes.
It was 2005 before the name Too Human was heard again. Shortly after announcing a partnership with Microsoft (Silicon Knights sure get around), Too Human was unveiled once again, this time as a trilogy of Xbox 360 exclusives. The first of which was to be released in time for the holidays in 2006.
It didn’t.
Engine issues (Silicon Knights president Denis Dyack publicly lambasted Epic’s Unreal Engine 3 and sued the creators for it supposedly not functioning as promised) and being passed around from publisher to publisher saw Too Human take nine years from announcement to release. And a resoundingly mediocre critical response ensured its sequels never saw the light of day.
1. L.A. Noire
Team Bondi’s neo-noir detective thriller L.A. Noire was a technical marvel when it released in 2011, never before had gamers seen facial animations with anywhere close to the level of detail on show. But it was just that attention to detail that saw the game miss its original release window by three years.
L.A. Noire, famously, was the first game to use MotionScan – a state-of-the-art motion capture technology that utilised 32 cameras to capture facial expressions from the game’s actors in excruciating detail. This level of detail was vital to one of the game’s core mechanics – interrogation. Players were charged with interrogating perps and judging whether they were telling the truth by studying their face. It was incredible and unique.
The only problems with this level of detail: it took ages and cost a fortune. The game slipped from its internally slated “fiscal 2008” release window. And this was only the first delay.
According to a series of email leaks, Rockstar were ultimately forced to step in and ensure the game was actually completed. It eventually released in May 2011, after seven years in development, as a commercial and critical success. But the damage had already been done; Team Bondi was liquidated just six months later.