8 Bad Video Games With Great Combat
It turns out that violence does solve some problems, if you do It right.
Whether it’s the art style, the characterisation, the movement or just the technical side of things even the worst games can get something right. A nice graphical sheen, or a well told story can do wonders for even the least interesting titles, just as a sufficiently bad element can ruin an otherwise fantastic experience.
In fact as the technology and software used to make games becomes more and more standardised, getting something wrong is only getting harder. Although this can come at the cost of those standard elements becoming samey and boring no matter how well they work (we’re looking at you, Assassin’s Creed, Arkham Asylum, Mad Max and Shadow of Mordor).
But with combat being such a big part of modern video games just nailing that one thing can save a game from being completely terrible.
In this list we’ll be looking at some stinkers, some disappointments and some severely lopsided experiences that at least partially saved themselves through well implemented violence.
Whether the following games can be considered the worst in their series or just the worst, they did at least get the combat right.
8. Red Steel
It’s no wonder that people were excited for Red Steel when it was announced: a first person shooter using the Wiimote to aim realistically at the screen, occasionally slowing down to have sword fights by swinging your arms around.
Sadly the reality didn’t live up to the dream and when Red Steel launched it was met with mixed reviews, owing to inconsistent visuals, poor controls and technical issues. In the end it did sell well, but the general consensus among the gaming population is that Red Steel 1 is a bad game.
Bit of a surprise then when you boot this game up, sit through the intro sequence and then immediately start having a blast with the game’s combat - accurately blowing Yakuza away like you’re Kazama Kiryu with an air zooka.
Every gun feels powerful and kicks like a mule, the bad guys run and duck for cover and even chase you down when you try to take cover yourself. The sound effects give every gunshot and explosion a sense of weight, and the shotgun might be the most satisfying in any video game after Doom 2’s super shotty, sending gangsters flying with every pull of the trigger and even tearing up the scenery around them.
It more than makes up for the lacklustre katana fights which can be won just by wildly swinging the controller until you give yourself repetitive strain injury.
7. Dark Souls 2
Even now I hear a million voices cry out in terror as someone dares to question Dark Souls 2. Calm down boys and girls, Dark Souls 2 is not a BAD, game, but it is almost universally agreed that it’s the worst in the Souls series.
Leaping from the jumping off point of Dark Souls 1, Dark Souls 2 muddied the quality waters with enemy spamming, cheap tricks and nightmarish AI invaders that are so ridiculously overpowered they could make you rage quit the entire series (thinking of you, Armorer Dennis). Dark Souls 2 is more of the frustrating, hair pulling, screaming out loud difficulty than the glorious struggle of the previous game.
But the combat, just as good as it was in Dark Souls 1 and 3 almost makes up for it. All the same flourishes, careful planning and giant reward await. It even brings in some new tricks to enhance the experience what with Dark Souls 2’s improved dual wielding and the addition of power stances giving you more options in combat, there are definite improvements over the previous game.
But the less said about 8 directional movement the better.
6. Resident Evil 6
Resident Evil 6 is the nadir of the Resident Evil series. A series known for its ridiculous campiness reaching its most ridiculous point whilst also taking itself more seriously than ever before; all the melodrama of the previous 5 games put together and none of the payoff.
But the combat? Omnidirectional dodge rolling, dual wielding pistols, punching zombies’ heads clean off, drop-kicks, suplexes and DDTs?! It’s like Capcom took the combat system from a kick-ass action movie video game and slotted it into the wrong series.
And it does a lot to make up for the ridiculousness of the rest of the game, turning a game so stupid you’d struggle to make fun of it, into a rip-roaring comedy action flick.
To see a series that started off with players having to control their characters as if they were a literal tank to avoid slow moving zombies, become a slick action game full of backflips and one liners is quite the transformation. But after the meandering slog of Resident Evil 5 I suppose they had to try and recapture the excitement of the 4th entry somehow, and if backflip kicking a zombie's head off is the only way then I'm all for it.
5. Evolve
Fresh off the blistering success of the Left 4 Dead games, developer Turtle Rock studios tried to catch lightning in a bottle by inverting their formula and having four people vs. one instead of four people vs. hundreds. The result of this experiment was Evolve, a monster hunting asynchronous multiplayer title that saw one overpowered hulking beast facing off against four diverse and specialised hunters.
The result of THAT, however, was abject failure. Selling poorly on launch, player numbers dwindled quickly. Eventually the game went Free to Play, but it was too late, and a combination of lack of content and balance issues officially brought an end to Evolve 2 years later.
Let's face it: the hunter combat is 90% walking around looking for footprints to follow and 10% either vaporising an unevolved monster or being stomped into the ground by an evolved one. The skill level of the monster normally sets the tempo for matches, with the true draw of the game being playing the part of these gigantic monstrosities.
And getting into a one on four fight against a group of capable hunters has got to be among the most intense experiences in gaming. One minute you're breaking snares and dodging artillery, the next throwing the hunters around trying to kill them before they kill you.
And if you do survive long enough to dodge out of the force field you can run away and lick your wounds, ready to fight, and win, another day.
4. Infinite Undiscovery
You’d be forgiven for having never heard of Infinite Undiscovery. While developer tri-Ace have some impressive titles under their belts, Infinite Undiscovery isn’t one of them, and that’s on top of it having released 13 years ago, to mediocre reviews.
The plot is boring and full of cliches, and while the visuals are fine for the time, the writing is just as bizarre as any other JRPG of that era. But the one element that raised those reviews from “bad” to “okay” was the combat.
Now, Infinite Undiscovery may look very much like any other real-time combat JRPG, but the devil is in the detail. Battles are flashy and fantastical with special effects flying everywhere as your team members batter lumps out of unfortunate enemies in an incredibly satisfying manner. And with the ability to have up to 12 friendly brawlers spread across 3 parties in a single battle, fights can get real hectic real quick.
While the combat is primarily about keeping combos going, our protagonist Capell can connect with his team mates in order to direct their movements. On top of that there are moves that can only be used by Capell connecting with that specific team member. Perform well enough and you can earn XP bonuses or post-fight healing.
With the possibility of up to 18 different potential party members that makes for a whole lot of different in-combat possibilities.
3. Hybrid Heaven
Has there ever been a game that promised more and delivered less?
Hybrid Heaven is an adventure game for the Nintendo 64 that promised an action packed tale of betrayal, political intrigue and high-stakes action, which was a big deal in the years after Metal Gear Solid came out.
Unfortunately what was delivered was a slow paced 3D adventure title where you look for keys to open doors and use what amounts to a high tech taser to shoot drones and panels.
And while the platforming isn't terrible, the game’s saving grace is its unique menu based melee fighting system that lets you throw out everything from right hooks to combo attacks to WWE style wrestling moves.
Your move set gets more expansive as you play through the game and while it may not sound like much on paper, actually nailing down a string of punches and kicks into a suplex is as immensely rewarding as seeing the list of new moves you just learned from your fallen enemy.
You can also aim for specific parts of the body to attack, potentially disabling them if you do enough damage and thereby disabling certain moves.
And if you don’t want to be constantly going through menus you can save your own custom combos for your character to follow through with, alongside preset ones that are there by default.
It turns what is usually a pretty slow march through a dull narrative about the US government being overthrown by aliens into an actually pretty awesome fighting game.
2. F.E.A.R. 3
After the uh, climactic, ending to F.E.A.R. 2, F.E.A.R. 3 takes you back into the shoes of Point Man, now being helped along by his brother Paxton Fettel. Now, you might have some questions since Fettel died in the first game, but we already know that death is more of an inconvenience for psychic people in the F.E.A.R. universe.
The campaign is a mess. The tone is inconsistent, and the scares are nowhere near as fresh as in either of its predecessors. New developers, Day One, have fallen for that modern horror pitfall and decided to show us all the dark background details of the original story instead of allowing us to fill in the gaps ourselves. And what we don’t see is always scarier than what we do see.
Despite the issues with the story and the direction of the campaign, the gameplay is as tight as ever. Both Point Man and Fettel play drastically differently, given Fettel doesn’t have a physical form which you'd expect to lower his combat efficiency somewhat.
Point Man sticks to his tried-and-true formula of turning on bullet time and eviscerating rooms full of enemies with gunfire and flying kicks, but Fettel’s combat is much more interesting.
With his ability to possess enemies and fire psychic blasts from his hands, Fettel puts enough of a spin on the gameplay that you can absolutely forget how big of a step-down F.E.A.R. 3 is in terms of narrative and characterisation.
1. Berserk: Millennium Falcon Hen Seima Senki No Shō
Berserk: Millennium Falcon Hen Seima Senki no Shō, or, ‘Millennium Falcon arc Chapter of the Holy Demon War’ is as faithful as you could possibly get to the source material, to its own detriment.
In Berserk, protagonist Guts is branded with a mark that constantly draws all sorts of evil to him. Wherever Guts goes, hordes of monsters follow. Sounds like the perfect setup for a video game right?
It follows that this game constantly has hordes of infinitely respawning enemies slowly draining your health through pure attrition. Every part of the game is the same: trying to go somewhere while hundreds of enemies block you in every direction.
On the other hand this Berserk game is also extremely close to the source material on how lethal the primary protagonist is, and a hell of a lot of work has gone into animating all the different ways he viciously dismembers the demons that get in his way.
Guts twirls, pivots, slashes, shoulder barges and when that’s not enough you can break out his prosthetic arm to sling some crossbow bolts and take out entire crowds with the cannon hidden under its fist.
The combat is more than satisfying enough to justify the snail’s pace that the game moves at and ends up being probably the best video game example of how to handle Guts’ fighting style. Unfortunately it also nails how much of a nuisance it would be to be swarmed by demons everywhere you go.
Watch Next
How Well Do You Remember Dark Souls?