8 Dead EA Video Game Franchises That Deserve A Comeback
EA's sitting on a GOLDMINE of untapped potential.
It's one of the many wonders of the world how EA continues to be the successful mega-publisher it is today. Ranging from distasteful (putting it mildly) monetisation methods to its infamous track record for putting the shutters on beloved studios like Visceral and Pandemic, hardly a month passes by without its PR department having to do damage control and explain why X game series failed to be successful and why we won't see it again for Y (read: a very long) amount of time.
Mistakes will be made, of course, and success is never guaranteed, but EA continues to sit on an ever-growing mountain of back catalogue titles that, despite their past successes, continue to be neglected like a public urinal due to one or a series of failures. Often, those have been a result of EA's own poor decisions - Dungeon Keeper Mobile's insulting freemium model and total ignorance of Command & Conquer's fan base, to name but two - but even success stories like Burnout and DICE's spin-off Battlefield series, Bad Company, go without sequels years after their last iteration dropped.
Management of a megacorporation goes beyond the expertise of this writer, but it's tough to see how if done with the proper love and respect, bringing back any of these wouldn't work in EA's favour, earning it some serious brownie points in the process.
We've waited long enough.
8. Medal Of Honor
Deposed as the shmup king by Call of Duty's phenomenal rise to prominence in the late noughties, Medal of Honor proved incapable of keeping pace with its new competitor and has faded further into memory ever since. Eager to abandon its own IP at the first sign of trouble, EA discarded the franchise in favour of DICE's Battlefield to serve as its flagship shooter, and would only revisit the former years later.
2010's gritty quasi-reboot set during the Afghan War laid the groundwork for what could have been an excellent alternative to the increasingly outlandish warfare propagated by Modern Warfare and its successors, but then 2012's Warfighter came along and ruined any prospect of the two coexisting. Filled with bugs, a bad script and bland multiplayer, what should have been a more successful follow-up felt largely phoned in by comparison.
EA at least took the blame for Warfighter's poor quality, citing an "execution problem" as the major contributor to its failure and now, instead of attempting to right those wrongs, the entire franchise has been tragically left in stasis until God knows when. Probably until Battlefield's popularity inevitably runs dry and EA brings the cycle full circle by replacing DICE's shooter with yours truly.
7. Skate
There's a reason why Skate 4's potential announcement is a topic that crops up every year like clockwork. It's a series loved and adored by many, not just by real-life practitioners of kickflips and ollies. Skate 3's suite of online modes and open world concrete playgrounds are what awarded it a positive reception in 2010, but it's the unintentionally entertaining, let's say, "quirks", that continue to perpetuate its popularity almost a decade later.
Glitches (of the humorous kind), as well as endless entertainment provided by its ragdoll physics, have helped Skate 3's popularity persist as a title that's just as fun to watch as it is to play. Maybe it's the partially accidental nature of Skate 3's success that continues to turn EA off from attempting a sequel - or the poor performance of Activision's Pro Skater series in recent years - but surely the risk is one worth taking?
One need only look back to last year's E3 where, shortly before EA's presentation in L.A., it emerged that the publisher had reactivated Skate 3's online servers. To know that the series holds a special place in the hearts and minds of many, EA need only provide the tools for the same sort of emergent gameplay while restraining itself from shoehorning unnecessary microtransactions.
6. Dungeon Keeper
You might think that the controversy generated by Dungeon Keeper Mobile was entirely attributable to its offensive monetization practices and dumbed down gameplay, but you'd be dead wrong. At least, in EA's eyes, you would be. Post-catastrophe, EA's head of mobile Frank Gibeau did what EA does best by utterly failing to recognise why its bastardization of Bullfrog's beloved strategy series garnered universal derision, stating that:
"I think we might have innovated too much or tried some different things that people just weren't ready for..."
Publishers shifting the blame of a game's failure onto the fan base is always a smart move, and it definitely had nothing to do with Dungeon Keeper's detestable first foray into the mobile market. A platform which, by the way, could have been the perfect home for Horny and his imp army, had EA not forced Mythic to make a Clash of Clans clone that insisted on nickel and diming its customers.
The secret to making a good Dungeon Keeper game is to ditch all of those forced elements and return to the remarkable (for its time) creature ecology and strategic dungeon building of the originals, not this cookie-cutter abomination. Bullfrog's classic deserves more than that.
5. SimCity
After a decade of hard work, Maxis finally delivered the fully three-dimensional city-building sim it had always aspired to make in 2013, and for the lucky few that made it past an unquantifiable number of disconnections that plagued its woeful launch, the wait had been worth it.
For everyone else, EA's strict always-online policy for the soft reboot resulted in servers threatening to implode under the strain of thousands of login requests, turning what should have been a victory for Maxis into a total nightmare.
Removed from its grievous technical issues, that's exactly what SimCity was. Even the fair criticism it garnered for having a smaller build space than its predecessors was a score deduction that would have been rectified with post-launch updates if only Maxis had been given the chance. In light of the fallout, EA has left the series to settle so that the stigma can wash away and here we are, six years later, wondering if the publisher will ever revisit another dead IP bursting with potential.
You've waited long enough, EA, don't let 2013's tragedy be how SimCity is remembered.
4. Command & Conquer
In none other than Command & Conquer is EA's incessant need to try and fix what isn't broken more apparent. From 2010 onwards, the series, once synonymous with the RTS genre, has been on a downward spiral into obscurity due to its publisher's unsolicited attempts to reinvent the wheel.
Command & Conquer 4's disposal of traditional base-building in favour of a pseudo-MOBA framework, Generals 2's ill-received intention of asking players for money to unlock content and, of course, last year's Rivals mobile game have proven, time and time again, that EA hasn't the faintest idea how to do Westwood's iconic creation justice. Dumbfounding, given the ever-so-simple solution: just make a Command & Conquer game.
Don't insult the series' grassroots PC fans with a watered-down mobile spin-off. Don't try and monetize the living daylights out of content already in the game and don't try to straddle multiple genres to widen appeal. Bring back base building, strategic resource management and in-game progression that rewards the better player with the satisfaction of wiping an opponents base off the face of the Earth with an army of unparalleled militaristic might.
Do that, EA, and you might find yourself the proud owner of a well-received C&C title.
3. Battlefield: Bad Company
Physical sales of last year's Battlefield 5 were less than half than that of its 2016 predecessor, but why? Was it the ridiculous minority movement that tried (and failed) to boycott DICE's latest shooter that led to the drop-off, or is the simple answer - that franchise fatigue is beginning to set in - more likely? In truth, there's no definitive reason, but Battlefield 5's heavily iterative nature only lends support to the latter being responsible. If EA wishes to sidestep a repeat performance this year, there's an easy remedy staring it right in the face.
2010's Bad Company 2, a purposefully scaled-down affair in order to accommodate consoles, remains one of the most fondly remembered entries in the series to date, both for its tighter focus and for being the first instance of a Battlefield title to feature environmental destruction. Levelling entire outposts and buildings to flush out enemy squads holed up within offered a level of emergent tactical play that has since become a lesser focus of DICE's design process, in favour of hyper-realistic warfare.
EA might not think it so, but there's room in the market for the best of both worlds. If mainline Battlefield titles are yielding diminishing returns, give it a well-deserved rest and bring back the more arcade-focused sister franchise for a change.
2. Burnout
You're a games publisher in control of a studio responsible for the greatest open world sandbox racer of a generation. Off the back of its success, do you offer congratulations and greenlight a sequel, or reduce the developer to little more than a jobber? For reasons that still elude everyone to this day, EA opted to shoot for scenario B, disallowing Criterion from going anywhere near supercars and vehicular destruction post-Burnout Paradise, tasking it, instead, with putting together the multiplayer components for DICE's various shooters.
Since 2008, the closest it's come to spearheading its own racer is as co-developer of 2013's Need For Speed Rivals and, given the glowing reception that game received, it is truly beggars belief why EA continues to deny Criterion the opportunity to work with its first love. If it's for fear of trying to appeal to an audience that no longer exists, last year's Paradise Remaster rocketing straight to the top of retail charts couldn't make it more obvious to the publisher that the appetite for more Burnout is bigger than ever.
The reluctance to commit is astounding and leaves little room to wonder why Criterion's co-founders opted to depart in 2014.
1. Dead Space
Dead Space 3 is responsible for cutting short Isaac Clarke's crusade against the Necromorphs and, to that, there's no counterargument. But was its failure a result of Visceral losing its way, or just another example of EA sticking its nose in where it wasn't needed? The answer is as obvious as you'd expect, and while Visceral wasn't innocent in causing Dead Space's downfall, it was the publisher's meddling - specifically forcing the adoption of more action-oriented gameplay and the inclusion of microtransactions - that made it sink faster.
In fact, had Visceral simply been left to its own devices, Dead Space 3 would have continued to respect its predecessor's survival horror roots and potentially would have secured funding for a sequel. One which had already been planned ahead for.
As part of an interview with Eurogamer, series director Ben Wanat outlined Visceral's plans for Dead Space 4, including an increased focus on non-linear progression and emphasis on forcing players to scrounge around abandoned ships to collect the basic necessities for survival against the uncomfortably gruesome Necromorphs. As for Isaac, he'd continue his role as the unsung hero, responsible for defending mankind from the looming apocalypse headed its way while also battling his own psychological demons.
Sounds like the sequel Dead Space 3 should have been.