8 Greatest Video Game Second Chances

Apology accepted.

Dead island 2
Dambuster

We all make mistakes. Trust me on that one.

To err is to be human and I've sure heard the phrase "err sir please put your trousers back on and stop rubbing deli meats over your chest" enough times to know that I need to stop drinking that imported cough syrup. In these moments, where you've been caught out by life or a gamble didn't pay off it's important to take stock of the situation, as it's here in these moments that we learn the type of person we are, and more importantly who we should strive to become.

If you've hurt people, apologise (and bloody mean it), if you've damaged something attempt to repair it, and if you've unfortunately pushed things too far, learn from the mistake and do all you can to never repeat it. These are the ways to build trust back up, to give your words meaning, and to sometimes find out where you need to do some personal improvement. It's as valid for the individual as it is for video game developers around the world, as with oily microtransaction practices and other shady workplace scenarios, often they have a lot to apologize for.

Thankfully, these teams worked hard to right wrongs, repair bridges, and prove they were worth a second chance.

8. Sonic Mania

Sonic Mania Jules TYOA
Sega

Ahh Sonic, the franchise that truly encapsulates the phrase "Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. Fool me the number of times the Sonic games have.....shame. Just endless shame"

Seriously I can't think of another game series with this many misses that have been this passionately defended by the fanbase (outside of Dynasty Warriors but more on that later). From the utter disaster-piece that was Sonic '06 to the Sonic title whose name mirrors the noise you make playing it (Sonic ARRRRRRRGH), the blue blur has indeed unsharpened the lines of what constitutes decent output time and time again.

Yet it's also the series that has the most "phoenix rising from the ashes" moments, and of these Sonic Mania really does stand out ahead of the pack.

If nothing else I'll lavish praise on this game just for the fact that Sonic Team didn't make it and I enjoy the idea that they get annoyed each and every time this is mentioned, but aside from pettiness this game truly is what Sonic should always be about. Well-designed levels, outstanding art direction, and blistering speed.

This game was a veritable love letter to the source material and made by a true and blue fan of the series, and the fact that SEGA actually picked this game up to be released officially is mindblowing. As is the decision not to make a sequel.

Maybe they're saving that for their next Sonic saviour arc.


7. No Man's Sky/Battlefront II

No Mans Sky sean
Hello Games

Let's face it, you knew that these two games were going to feature in this list, and there's very little chance I'll be saying anything you haven't already heard a thousand times over when it come to detailing the spectacular failings of both No Man's Sky and Star Wars Battlefront II.

In fact, both games have such a similar villain origin story to redemption arc that it's possible to discuss both at the same time without having to change much of my verbiage! So let's go!

Out of the gate, both titles promised to be so much more than they could ever hope to deliver on, with pre-release hype building around features found to be either hugely inferior in the final product or straight up missing entirely. Then on launch, both titles sold extremely well before the public quickly got wise to the fact that there was something altogether shady about the experience and a PR Nightmare ensued, leading to the devs to respond in a manner that only invoked more frustration and ire.

Yet instead of slinking back into the shadows laughing like Tom from that one scene in Tom and Jerry that still haunts my dreams, both dev teams decided to double down and actually fix their !*$% games. Over a long period and a sustained release of exciting (and free) content, both titles were patched back into shape. Better still, the support continued, actually elevating the titles beyond the scope of even their original promises to the extent that at this current time each stands aloft as a genuinely great gaming experience.

It's been a rough road, but the outcome is the same. No Man's Sky/Star Wars Battlefront II is a fantastic game. Delete where appropriate.


6. Legacy Of Goku 2

Legacy Of Goku 2
Webfoot Technologies

When is an RPG not an RPG?

When it's Legacy Of Goku, a video game released for the Game Boy Advance in 2002 that pertained to carry the RPG title yet delivered an experience so aneamic that fans were left questioning why they were being hamstrung so viciously.

If you wanted as close to a one-to-one delivery of the manga franchise's most famous moments without any of the suspense, excitement, or challenge this is the very strange game for your very strange request, as LOG really was a bit of a floater in the punchbowl. Hilariously most reviews of the game stop their praise at the graphics because there really isn't even that much to comment on after this point, yet I don't think the fanbase found this quite so funny.

Yet fret not friends, as a Senzu bean was chucked towards the series in the form of Legacy Of Goku 2 which improved on every single criticism and then some, delivering a brand new art style, a more action-oriented focus and a monstrous amount of content that gave fans plenty to fight through. Ideally, this is what LOG 1 should have been, and it's a shame that the series had to skirt utter obliteration to realize that it needed to deliver fans legitimately good content, yet I'll take any chance to punch Cell in any of his smug faces so thank you very much Webfoot for making this.


5. Dead Island 2

Dead island 2
Dambuster

Ok so hands up, I really bounced off of Dead Island.

Outside of the admittedly entertaining opening area, the game became an utter slog of both terrible resource management and confusing tones, whiplashing between B-movie schlock and trying (and failing) to be a tearjerking examination of the human condition. The graphics were rough enough to cut beef on and the bloom effects were blinding in places, making the game an experience that you might want to love but was impossible to overlook the faults.

The series was kicked further in the throat with Riptide releasing with all the same issues, and then seemingly capped in the head by Escape Dead Island which I can confirm, was indeed a video game and I'll end my praise there.

Add in the huge gestation of Dead Island 2 and things seemed done and dusted for the series. Or so I thought.

After recently playing Dead Island 2, I gotta say this is the game I always wanted. Vibrant, beautiful looking, and genuinely funny in places. Don't get me wrong there are still some wonky controls and iffy combat to deal with but overall this feels like a much better game, and a title that took it's time to produce something decent over just flopping onto the marketplace to be thoroughly gutted by critics.

There's still time to be proven wrong, but I really hope it doesn't.


4. Dynasty Warriors 7

Dynasty Warriors 7
Koei Tecmo

The Dynasty Warriors series must seem like such an odd franchise to anyone not already deeply invested into it.

"So you're telling me each game tells the same story, with the same levels, and only adds in like four new characters with each iteration? And it STILL LOOKS LIKE ASS?"

Hell yeah, it does, and I'll pre-order that sh*t the moment it goes live. Now trust me friends I have been burned by this series so, so many times, especially recently with Dynasty Warriors 9 and 9 Empires making me feel like I'm on life support and my oxygen has been replaced with a canister of farts, but never has my faith been shaken more than with the release of Dynasty Warriors 6 and that goddam Renbu system.

To better explain, Dynasty Warriors is basically a power fantasy for the ages and posits you as one of many warriors of legend, so the absolute worst thing you could do is take away everyone's unique moveset, tie them to weapons instead and then have half of your attacks locked behind a combo chain system. That's right, if you wanted to do something more than a swipe left and right you'd have to build up a combo to unlock those other combos.

If that sounds stupid, trust me it totally was.

So burned were the fanbase that all Dynasty Warriors 7 really needed to do was remove that to net a win, which it did, but also added in more special moves, greater aerial juggling, and a retooled upgrade system, making it not just a far superior game to DW6 but a highlight of the series overall!


3. Alien: Isolation

Alien Isolation
Sega

Despite what Ash Millman will routinely tell me, Alien: Colonial Marines is a bad game, a very, very bad game.

From the "totally real I swear guys" vertical slice pre-release content that was an utter falsification of the endgame experience, to the utter horror show that was its development cycle, all the way down to the code that was just one change away from delivering much better enemy AI, Colonial Marines was the "Game Over, Man" moment for many fans of the franchise and it was going to take a LOT of work for the series to recover.

And say helloooo to Alien Isolation.

I cannot express how much the franchise NEEDED this game, as finally after years of languishing in the action horror genre, the needle was shifted back to pure survival horror tension. With an incredible art direction that emulated the original films, and a double-brained Xenomorph that would learn your location and hunt you down with terrifying precision, Isolation became the benchmark for others to be measured by.

This was the sorbet experience to a buffet of lukewarm gruel and finally pushed Aliens back into relevancy and our nightmares once more. Cheers for that.


2. Ace Combat 7

Ace Combat 7
Bandai Namco

As a man with a perpetual fear of flying the Ace Combat games has never really stuck out as a series for me.

Something about being shot out of the air and then plummeting to the ground at speed just doesn't sit well for some insane reason.

That being said, I can most definitely appreciate the appeal of these games, as the Ace Combat games have carved out a niche within the industry for those that love smashing the sound barrier with a huge assortment of fighter jets and who love to flex their tactical mental muscles as they take on challenging AI enemies. It's a series known for its granular approach to jet customization and of biding your time just waiting for that one moment to strike.

This is why Ace Combat Assault Horizon really stood out like a sore thumb to many, and a raging middle finger to much of the fanbase, as this game was none of these things.

Assault Horizon is a game that Michael Bay likely has a picture of in his wallet that he looks at and sighs lovingly over before then exploding, as this was an over-the-top octane thrill ride that ditched the brains in favor of the bombs. Hell, they even turned what was once a balletic engagement between aircraft into a pseudo-on-the-rails shooter thanks to it's simplified Dogfight mechanic. This was a game designed with the many in mind but isolated the hardcore few that had sustained the series for so long.

Thankfully Ace Combat 7 arrived on the scene some years later and added in layers of nuance to the combat while keeping the things that worked from Assault Horizon aka the outstanding graphics and kickass soundtrack.


1. Devil May Cry 3

devil may cry 3
Capcom

While there has never been a truly awful Devil May Cry video game (c'mon even DMC had stellar action and you're kidding yourself if you think otherwise), Devil May Cry 2 is still a rather sore subject amongst the fanbase and it's not hard to see why.

Coming off the back of the literal game-changer that was Devil May Cry, Capcom strode out onto its balcony and looked over the piles of money and adoration being lavished upon them, turned to see the praise Hideki Kamiya and his team had garnered, nodded to themselves and said: "Thanks, now f**k off".

In other words, commissioning a sequel but not the team that made it was a rather boneheaded move, to say the least, and it was unfortunately just the start of things to come, as the sequel took all the charm, personality, and fun of its central cast and ground them face first into "pre-James Gunn DCEU grit". Defenders would say the tone is "darker", to the rest of us though we'd call it "more boring than listening to a presentation on wet cement hosted by an actual bag of cement"

Thankfully this impenetrable foundation was cracked open by the joyous return to form that was Devil May Cry 3, which did away with all the dour and doubled down on the demon-slaying, and reinstating a tongue in cheek swagger that you could feel it licking your ears. This was Capcom all but apologizing for wasting your time with DMC2's lukewarm action and high school drama club acting, as here it was all about the fun with no frills attached.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Dead Island 2
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jules Gill hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.