8 Horror Video Games That Took Things Too Far

Pushing the boundaries of taste and conventions...

Manhunt Too Far
Rockstar

When it comes to horror games, more is quite often... more. It's a genre that thrives on pushing the limits of taste and bathing its audiences in blood, body horror, and sometimes a bit of boob as well (assuming the nudity then leads to murder as is shown in so many horror films).

However, as you can imagine there has to be a point, even within an industry of extreme, when enough is enough. When you simply can't show the horrible things you've planned out for fear of alienating an audience, causing controversy, or quite simply alerting those around you that you might require medical help.

And it was these attempts at showcasing graphic content that saw the ESRB being formed, as a response to violence and other non PG material in games, and horror titles still have to abide by their classifications.

Yet has this stopped horror video games from trying to go beyond? Hell no! Hence why across the years we've seen many titles court controversy that has resulted in a positive or negative spin for the game itself. These eight entries pushed all the buttons possible leading to court cases, outright bans, and of course, a ton of complaints.

8. Graphic Executions - Manhunt

Manhunt game
Rockstar

It must be a dubious honor for Rockstar to hold the "most violent video game ever" tag for Manhunt 2, as not only is this a rightly deserved plaudit, but it's one that has marred the developer as a workforce that chased controversy over everything else.

Luckily, we've seen the studio tone down somewhat since these edgelord days, but for a while, the Manhunt franchise was the go-to place for gamers to explore a bit of the old uber-violence. However even returning to the more "tame" (and I use that word lightly) original title, Manhunt is still full of content that would make even the hardiest of us wince.

The concept of unwillingly starring in a snuff film is horrible to begin with, but the level of detail that went into the execution animations really pushed the blood-soaked boat out. From smashing people's faces in while they gasp for breath trapped within a plastic bag to being garrotted so hard their neck is sliced into, players could "unlock" even more brutal finishers by stalking their prey for longer.

Manhunt soon became known as a title that used "violence as gratification" and while Rockstar were keen to hold a mirror up and say "this is how society fetishizes violence in the media", the presentation here was stomach turning to say the least.


7. Doki Doki Literature Club

Monika doki doki literature club 4th wall
Team Salvato

Fourth wall breaking moments in video games can elicit all sorts of different effects within the player base. Some can be humorous nods and winks, others can call into question the very nature of gaming, but when it came to Doki Doki Literature Club few of us realized just how far this title was going to push the envelope.

When you begin your time with this title, you might rightly assume that it's just another romance novel-esque dating sim and for a while, it appears to hit these specs. However, things take a HARD left turn when the tone of the game plunges into the horrific, with characters killing themselves and becoming aware that they are in a video game directly talking to the player.

There's even an action where one of the main characters asks you to enter the game's directory files and delete information from the title itself. It becomes this horrifyingly meta experience that blurs the lines of reality and fantasy and does it convincingly enough that it will leave you frozen to your core for hours if not weeks after.


6. Silent Hill: Homecoming

Silent Hill Homecoming Scarlet
Konami

The Silent Hill games have always had their finger on the pulse when it came to knowing just how to make their audiences squirm. With a clever blend of brooding atmosphere and enemies that aren't just horrifying to look at but showcase all manner of repressed fears, the series has (or had) gone from strength to strength, and while the later entries might not have captured the hearts of fans and critics in the same manner as the originals, Silent Hill: Homecoming really wanted to make a name for itself.

And boy howdy did it do just that.

In an attempt to recapture the glory and gory days of old, Homecoming's development team Double Helix sought to bring more body horror and violence to the table in an attempt to make gore and psychological horror exist within the same title equally. What this meant was a lot of broken bones, horrible body mutilation, and even a complete bisection.

This, as you might expect raised eyebrows across the board, as while Silent Hill had in no way been shy about violence, it had up until this point lacked the graphical processing to make these actions look as disgusting as they were.

For some countries, this depiction was enough for them to issue bans and in the case of Germany, the game was banned from being imported as well thereby removing its trace from the area.


5. Hatred

Hatred Game
Destructive Creations

I genuinely despise having to talk about Hatred any more than I need to, just because the game itself is a desperate attempt to generate sales through its edgelord outlook of "I'm so dark and brooding that I'm going to murder people for no good reason". However, it's also a perfect example of a horror game that took things too far for just that reason.

And yes I do classify this as a horror title because a) look at the presentation, tone and content, and b) the game is HORRIFIC to play. Trust me, that pun is genuinely better than this cack is to control.

It's incredibly easy to see why this game courted controversy, starring a grease bag in a duster who wants to cause the world as much pain as possible before dying and offering some truly brutal depictions of murder on innocent people.

If the game had held a shred of self-awareness, maybe it could have been a visceral Black Mirror style commentary, but it takes itself way too seriously for this and as a result, simply becomes another piece of truly offensive gaming material.

This s**t sets the industry back people, do not support it.


4. Devotion

Devotion Video Game
Red Candle Games

If there's one thing that the video game industry has been made frighteningly aware of, it's that you should not mess with China.

I know it sounds a little strange to say, but over the course of the last few years we've seen instances of companies erring on the side of caution when it comes to pissing off the production giant of a country, and in the case of Devotion, a horror title made by Red Candle Games, a showcase of review bombings so bad that the game is now no longer on sale on Steam.

The issues stem from the fact that there is a text-based joke scrawled onto a wall within the house the game takes place in which compares the Chinese Paramount Leader to Disney character Winnie The Pooh. This has been a fairly recent meme which the internet obviously ran into the ground within a day and it's inclusion here is bizarre to say the least. However, one much less funny outcome was that the game received an obliteration of negative reviews proving that you can indeed take a joke too far.

It's a shame as well because the game itself is incredibly well-directed, calling on the previous success found in the likes of P.T.


3. Shadow Man: 2econd Coming

Shadow man
Nintendo

The Shadowman series is an oddly fascinating one. The original game landed with all the impact of a loose bowel movement when it came to sales and reviews because while being hyped up to the nines for months and having an aesthetic and narrative that was genuinely original, the actual gameplay truly missed the mark being janky and feeling extremely dated.

However this did little to stop this game from attaining cult-like status amongst those who saw beyond the technical limitations of the title, and there was enough groundswell for Acclaim to begin working on a sequel which again, unfortunately, ended up failing to set the world alight when it came to reviews.

Yet this didn't stop the sequel from garnering a tonne of heat for its insensitive approach to marketing. Acclaim decided that the best course of action in order to sell a game based on an undead bounty hunter of sorts was to propose pinning adverts for the game on real-life tombstones in cemeteries across America. The plan was to pay the families of the deceased for this headstone ad space, but needless to say, the plan failed in a catastrophic lambasting by the mainstream media.

So in this instance, it's not the game itself that took things too far, but the publisher that was too busy chasing that dollar in order to see how tasteless this move was.


2. Night Trap

Night Trap ReVamped
Night Trap LLC

It might be a strange thing to consider by anyone who's played Night Trap recently, but at one point in time, this was THE game that pushed the envelope too far.

Or at least according to the media... who apparently never played the game.

Night Trap, according to senator Joe Lieberman, was a game that promoted sexual violence against women and featured explicit sexual content, and he took these views to national hearings in order to try and get the game banned, comparing the title with another infamous controversy chaser, Mortal Kombat.

This negative press spin, started lest we not forget by a man who confirmed he had NOT PLAYED NIGHT TRAP, saw the developers in hot water across the board. Adding to the controversy was Nintendo who publicly announced that Night Trap would never be made available for their consoles, a rather underhanded swipe at the fact that Night Trap couldn't even run on their consoles as it required a CD-ROM (and a dig at Sega to make them appear more morally dubious by hosting the game on their console).

When playing the game yourself you'll see it to be nothing of the sort. Tame, boring even by today's standards, and with a message of SAVING people rather than instigating sexual violence against them. A rare example of the game itself being taken too far by everything other than its own content.


1. Agony

Agony Game
Madmind Studio

When you're basing a video game on Hell itself and all of the nastiness that it entails, then you're pretty much announcing to the world that your game isn't going to be for everyone, and Agony certainly delivered when it came to representing utterly bleak images of our worst nightmares.

The game found itself in an unusual situation, in that it was an immensely successful Kickstarter project and therefore not bound by the same worries and margins of a bigger developer/publisher. This also meant that its depictions of graphic violence, nudity, torture, and sex went unmonitored until it was time to release it. Rating boards only had to sniff the box art to know that the content was filthy and so gave it an AO or Adults Only rating, something which only a handful of video games have been branded with.

This put Madmind Studio into a bit of a pickle as this age rating meant that distribution in certain countries was now impossible. In short, they had gone way too far and now had to backpedal by toning down the violence considerably.

This in turn arguably affected the tone of the game for the worse as now we were experiencing a more PG version of hell, something that the game actively promised it would try and avoid.


In this post: 
Manhunt 2
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jules Gill hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.