8 MORE Video Games Where The True Ending Is The Bad Ending

The world goes on even if you fail.

legacy of kain
Crystal Dynamics/Patrick Johnson

In most media, your true long-term good guy vs bad guy story only ever works if the pair are evenly matched or can't do lasting damage to each other. The villain needs to come back next week with a new plan so they can never be outright defeated and the heroes may fall but they'll always get back up.

But what if that's not the case? What if, the hero's failure is all a part of the grand scheme and the bigger picture?

Some video games give players choices and very few of these use the more depressing events that follow to inform their sequels. Others reveal their true pathways depending on what you do or don't do, including even dying having major plotline ramifications.

It might make sense to you that the canon ending to a game is the one where the hero prevails and everyone goes home happy... but that's not always the case. Sometimes, evil wins. And sometimes, writers find far more fun building upon the darkest of scenarios.

This list looks at a few more examples where the worst endings possible just so happen to be what actually happens.

8. Blood Omen: Legacy Of Kain

legacy of kain
Crystal Dynamics/Patrick Johnson

Whilst the Soul Reaver games are arguably the jewel in the Legacy of Kain crown, they only happen depending on certain events in the first title.

Blood Omen introduces the dark fantasy world of Nosgoth and stars Kain, a recently awakened vampire who intends to enact revenge for his murder and winds up part of a bigger plot over the balance of the land. At the end of the game, players are given a simple choice: either choose the side of heroics and sacrifice themselves to save the world or raze it and rule over the ashes.

If the player chooses to be a goody two shoes then vampires are vanquished from the realm. However, if they choose the canonical ending then they turn Nosgoth into a wasteland and become a megalomaniac.

Even aside from the tradition of saving the world in video games you’d naturally assume that sending Kain off into the afterlife after fulfilling his unfinished business might be the right thing to do but that’s not the case. In choosing selfishness, Kain becomes the antagonist for the next game in the series Soul Reaver and the ravaged Nosgoth becomes the setting for the whole franchise.

The future of Legacy of Kain literally only exists if you not only let evil win but become it.


7. Dragon Quest

dragon quest 1
Square Enix

Over the years, the interconnected nature of the Dragon Quest series has become rather tenuous but the first trilogy of titles are all clearly linked. Dragon Quest II takes place 100 years after the original, which sees the player going on a quest and slaying a dragon (hence the name, really).

There’s a moment before the closing fight where the Dragonlord will actually do the stereotypical villain thing and invite the player to join them, promising to let them rule over half of the world. It’s intended to make players steel their nerves before they launch into battle and DQ2 pretty much assumes you selected that choice. After all, if you don’t then the screen fades to black and the game freezes.

However, thirty years later, a little more was added to this previously thought plotline cul-de-sac in Dragon Quest Builders.

In this charming little spin-off you play the role not of a warrior but of a builder (these titles really are straight forward) who is charged with reconstructing the world after the defeat of the hero. In this timeline of events, the player accepted the Dragonlord’s offer, which turned out to be a trap and the dragon destroyed the kingdom.

The hero from Dragon Quest can even be found hiding out in a small fortress he’s nicknamed “half of the world” and cackling like a maniac to really drive home his failure.


6. Silent Hill 2

Silent Hill 2 James Maria
Konami

All-time horror classic Silent Hill 2 puts the player in the role of James Sunderland who, by the game’s end, remembers that he killed his own wife out of desperation. The game finishes with one of many endings, none of which ever given the outright stamp of canon approval. However there are certain implications that can be examined.

James' father Frank appears in Silent Hill 4. At one point, the player can inspect a photo which remarks that Frank’s son and daughter-in-law disappeared after going to the town of Silent Hill.

Now, it’s reasonable that James merely broke contact with his family after he cracked and killed Mary. After all, Silent Hill 2 doesn’t give a timescale between the murder and the events onscreen. However, according to the novelisation, it happened “just a few days ago”, meaning he hadn’t been gone long at all.

In that case, James doesn’t leave the town after Silent Hill 2 which counts the (relatively) more upbeat endings out. Ergo, Silent Hill 2 either ends with him attempting to perform a ritual to revive his dead wife or driving into the lake to pay his penance. The latter of these, called In Water, happens to be the ending in the novel and one preferred by several of the game’s staff.

But if that is too depressing for you, then you can just imagine the game ended with a Shiba Inu in a headset if you like.


5. Max Payne

Max payne 2
Remedy/Rockstar

Mr Payne has led a pretty awful life through his trilogy of games but, at the end of Max Payne 3, he at least gets to quite literally walk off into the sunset. However, his final fate may well be much darker and, bizarrely, tucked away in another game.

Control, Quantum Break, Alan Wake… Each one of Remedy Entertainment’s games features not just Easter Eggs but pure justification that all of their titles take place in the same universe.

Alan Wake, star of his own 2010 horror title, is a novelist known for his crime thriller series. The hero of these shares some surprising similarities with Max Payne. That being said, the man in these books is called Alex Casey… even though he is quite literally voiced by Max Payne actor James MacCaffrey.

Casey has a gruff noir detective way of looking at things and an addiction to painkillers. His penultimate book is called “The Fall of Alex Casey”, a reference to the title of The Fall of Max Payne. And, in the final volume The Sudden Stop, Casey describes his death as the result of chasing revenge 13 years ago - the number of years between Max Payne 1 and 3.

Clearly, Max Payne exists in Alan’s world. Perhaps Alan chose to protect his identity by changing his name when adapting his life into books. Moreover, somewhere along the trilogy, or perhaps afterwards, Max most certainly falls… for good.


4. Crash Bandicoot 2: Wrath Of Cortex

Crash Bandicoot 2
Naughty Dog

If the player simply gets through the story of Crash Bandicoot 2 then Dr Neo Cortex is last seen flying out into space and Crash and Coco retire to the beach. Coco remarks that Cortex’s satellite is still out there somewhere and the evil doctor can be heard laughing.

Want to take it down? Great! Just collect every gem in the game and then realise that you’ve accidentally awakened a great evil because of it.

By 100% completing Crash 2, players can fire up N.Brio’s laser cannon to blast the Cortex Vortex out of the sky, with one piece falling back to Earth. This might not mean much at first but, upon booting up Crash 3, this is exactly what sets the entire events of that game into action. A piece of the satellite collides with a temple, which awakes Uka Uka - a “great evil” that even the otherwise stoic Aku Aku fears.

This one is only the bad ending if you don’t want to play anymore Crash games I suppose. Then again, Crash would more likely prefer to hang out and nap all day rather than go on another adventure to get burnt, frozen, squashed, impaled and otherwise blown up.

This is all your fault! Why couldn’t you have just settled with “good enough”?


3. Warcraft: Orcs And Humans

Warcraft Orcs
Blizzard

The sheer size of the Warcraft franchise and universe is quite bountiful now but originally it started out as a single humble yet impressive RTS title. Warcraft: Orcs & Humans is recognised as a game that really pushed for multiplayer within the genre and even offered two campaigns to play through, playing as both sides of the war.

The game certainly set up some of the basic framework for Azeroth but this was far before Orcs were given the sympathetic backstory that they would be known for. They weren’t equals in this game - humans were clearly the good guys and orcs were clearly the evil monsters. This is evidenced by the fact that at the end of the Orc campaign the human kingdom is in ruins.

However, that’s what makes it important. This is actually a big pivotal moment in Azeroth’s history, where the humans are forced to flee their land and make allegiances with the likes of the elves and the dwarves. Despite expectation, it’s this ending that Warcraft II builds upon… and the next 25+ years of games.

If you beat the human campaign, the Horde is pushed back and presumably never heard from again. And, without that, we wouldn’t have grinding to level 60 in World of Warcraft… so make of that what you will.


2. Shadow Hearts Covenant

Shadow Hearts Koudelka
Sacnoth

One of the most underrated RPG series of all time, Shadow Hearts is an overlooked PS2 saga of dark fantasy and cosmic horror.

The original Shadow Hearts has two possible endings. The good ending sees protagonist Yuri and love interest Alice overcoming the big bad and presumably living out the rest of their days together. In the dramatically darker bad ending, Alice sacrifices her soul and is killed.

That’s gotta suck for poor old Yuri but it at least gives him something to work towards which is why it’s this ending that is carried forwards into Shadow Hearts Covenant. In the sequel, Yuri is driven by his desire to revive his deceased lover. Whilst Covenant also has multiple endings, either way players go back in time in an attempt to undo their original mistake.

Ergo, it has to have happened in the first game at all for them to change the mistakes they made in the second.

It’s pretty clever and really rewards players who have invested time into both the first and second game, not to mention the predecessor Koudelka which, importantly, also features a bad ending which is canon.

So lesson learned: if you want to know the true story of Shadow Hearts, always go with the more depressing option.


1. The Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time

Legend of Zelda Ocarina of Time
Nintendo

This Nintendo 64 adventure game classic might be the only game where, no matter what happens, it’s considered canonical.

For a long time, Zelda fans tried their best to make head and tail out of the spiralling number of games in the series. Detailed lore experts slaved away trying to understand which games took place when and how to justify how Hyrule looked one particular way and then another entirely in the next title.

And then Nintendo blew everyone’s minds with its three-way split timeline..

In Ocarina of Time, as his wont, Link faces down the villainous Ganon. With the beast slain, the time travelling hero is sent back to the time he came from to live out the rest of his childhood. From here, the timeline splits. The young Link goes onto Majora’s Mask and the world he leaves behind eventually floods to become the setting of the Wind Waker.

But what if you die during the boss fight? Well, that’s canon too.

If Link is defeated by Ganon in this showdown then the timeline splits in a third direction. The adventures that feature on this arm focus on the decline of Hyrule in the earliest games in the series like Link to the Past and the original Legend of Zelda.

So worry not if you die during Ocarina of Time. You’re making sure the timeline stays intact, right?


Watch Next


Contributor

Coming from a content creation background that now spans over two decades, Psy cut her teeth on personal video production and community radio. Originally joining the team as a writer and presenter, she added video editing duties to her responsibilities over time and became the longest-standing editor of the irreverent gaming show Tues Your Own Adventure. Psy has worked on many previews and reviews, long-form editorials (either her own, or supporting as an editor), as a frequent quizmaster and more. Praised for the two-pronged attack of her hard work ethic and light-hearted editing style, Psy is otherwise known as a font of retro video game knowledge which has caused her to rack up many gaming quiz wins. Outside of WhatCulture, Psy runs First Aid Spray Podcast - a long-running channel that focuses on Resident Evil in all of it's forms. You can follow her on BlueSky at http://psywhite.bsky.social and Instagram at http://instagram.com/therealpsywhite