8 Most Underrated Video Games Of 2021 (So Far)
Which games deserve more love this year?
2021 has been a weird year for video games so far. With the industry still adapting to the challenges faced due to the ongoing pandemic, a whole bunch of releases have been delayed, with the next generation getting off to a pretty slow start.
Just because a lot of the big hitters have been pushed out to 2022 and beyond doesn't mean there hasn't been anything good to play though. In fact, we've already published our best games of the year list and it's absolutely stacked, with plenty of great titles across PC and consoles for fans to get stuck into.
In fact, it's been so good that's it's made all the other mid-year lists difficult. There have been few outright stinkers, even less disappointments, and it feels that in the vacuum of the big hitters all of the titles that would usually occupy underrated lists have been awarded more time to shine.
Still, there have been a few bona fide underrated gems in the first half the year, and these are the ones you absolutely need to check out.
8. Little Nightmares II
Coming four years after the surprise smash original, Little Nightmares II didn't really make the same impact. Despite being home to a whole range of improvements and enjoying solid reviews, it quickly slipped out of the conversation.
That's a shame too, because the horror sequel builds upon the haunting atmosphere of the original in some pretty gnarly ways. The differing environments of game's Pale City are always a joy to explore, whether you're in demented classrooms patrolled by snake-necked demon teachers or booby-trapped shacks.
While the general structure of the follow up remains the same as the first - you control a young child with their face hidden as you explore this twisted storybook reality and avoid its myriad of deadly beasties - the fluidity of the gameplay is really what makes the title excel.
It's often just simple platforming and puzzle solving, but there's a great sense of weight and purpose to the movement that makes you feel part of this world and, consequently, part of the horror.
With the studio saying they're done with the franchise from now on, there's never been a better chance to savour the experience.
7. The Medium
Bloober Team are proving to be a pretty divisive studio as of late. Excelling primarily in first-person horror games, genre fans have either religiously played every new release, or written off their efforts as cheesy tall tales that constantly fall short of the mark.
It's undeniable that the team has become more confident with each project though, and The Medium is easily their most creative work yet.
This time around the developer has swapped out its regular first-person perspective for a third-person 90s survival horror throwback. In The Medium you take control of Marianne, a medium gifted with the ability to travel between the human world and the world of the supernatural. This power of hopping between planes of existence factors into the gameplay too, as you solve puzzles simultaneously across different versions of the same levels.
It's definitely experimental, but for the most part it results in pretty tight and imaginative puzzles. Even better, controlling two characters at the same time via split-screen is surprisingly intuitive. Like A Way Out a few years ago, it's cool to see a developer take something as simple as a split screen framing and forefront it, using the conventions of video games in brand new ways.
Is it perfect? Of course not. The stealth sequences kind of suck, the ending is certainly something and it doesn't quite sustain its momentum for the long haul, but as an early next-gen Xbox showcase, it's more than worth trying.
6. Scott Pilgrim Vs The World: Complete Edition
I've tried to keep remasters and re-releases limited this year, but Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World: Complete Edition is a special case. That's because, rather than just a handy little re-release for people who no longer own an Xbox 360 or PS3, this launch actually saved the brawler from obscurity entirely.
Due to licensing issues, the title was pulled from storefronts previously, remaining unaccessible for years as players and fans badgered publisher Ubisoft to bring it back. Fortunately, their prayers were eventually answered and now this excellent and underrated side scroller can finally be picked up with ease.
In what's fitting of a game that became an obscure cult classic based on a beloved movie that sadly was a box-office bob-omb, Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World: Complete Edition similarly dropped to only the joy of the hardcore fans, with everyone else probably not even realising it came out at all.
That's such a shame though, because this is easily the best version of the beat-em-up you can get. A loving ode to the 8-bit days of yore, Ubisoft's title has a whole host of personality, from the colourful sprites to the brilliantly translated music.
Any Scott Pilgrim fan owes it to themselves to try it out - and hey, why not get it just in time for the movie's delayed 10-year anniversary celebrations?
5. Oddworld: Soulstorm
One of the strangest PlayStation properties to receive a hardcore fanbase, a return to Oddworld has been anticipated since the release of the absolutely stellar remake, New 'N' Tasty, in 2014.
Follow up Soulstorm was set to be a much more ambitious project though. Rather than a straight up remake of next game in the series, Abe's Exoddus, this was going to reinvent it, re-imagining and changing the whole original rather than simply re-creating what was there previously in high fidelity.
Still, once again you're taking control of Mudokon Abe, moving through 2.5D stages in the pursuit of liberating others of your kind while avoiding getting drilled with bullets.
While it received a lot of pre-release hype, the reviews weren't overwhelmingly positive at launch. You can see why as well, as Soulstorm is very much a game indebted to 90s and early 2000s design, for better or worse.
That means you're going to come up against a lot of headaches that you haven't seen for a long time, including some pretty infuriating checkpointing that can suck the life out of certain sections as you try, try and try them again.
It's rougher than it should be, but Soulstorm is still charming, full of personality, and a fun platformer at heart. The stages themselves can be grand and visually impressive, and commanding the hapless Abe in the pursuit of revolution is always a worthy goal.
4. Outriders
As the old saying goes: you only get one chance to make a good first impression. Unfortunately for Outriders, its launch was essentially the equivalent of meeting your girlfriend's parents for the first time after a pretty heavy day session where you've forgotten your clothes and haven't quite washed the alcohol off your breath.
Put simply: it was not good.
Bugs and extensive server issues kept fans who'd ponied up full price for the looter shooter from even playing the game on launch weekend, and it was so bad that the developers actually had to apologise multiple times - and for good reason.
Outside of those issues though, Outriders is a surprisingly solid shooter. Now, just like most people I've had my fill of these Division-by-way-of-Destiny grindfests, but this release at least has a bit of creativity on show. The weapons and powers are varied, the combat is as stellar as you'd expect from the devs behind Bulletstorm and it does boast some pretty decent visuals on next gen machines.
It's probably not going to change your mind on this specific sub-genre of shooter, but if you're after a fun power trip to play through with friends, you could do much worse.
3. Nier Replicant Ver.1.22...
Nier: Automata was a surprise hit when it dropped in 2017, so much so that some players didn't even realise it was a sequel. That's because the original title, Nier, didn't make anywhere near as much of a splash back in 2010.
While most agreed that conceptually and thematically it had a lot going for it, Nier was criticised for its uninspired combat and padded missions that resulted in long stretches between the flourishes of genius in there.
Put simply, it was a game that would have benefitted from more tinkering, which is exactly what it received when a remake, Nier Replicant ver.1.22, released earlier this year.
The title casts you as the brother of a dying girl called Yonah (in the original you're actually her father), as you search high and low for a cure to the 'Black Scrawl' epidemic. Along the way you'll experience the kind of dark humour and pathos you'd expect if you played Nier: Automata, alongside the intense creativity and originality that made the sequel such a resonant piece of work.
The improved combat doesn't quite match the variety and impact of Automata, but it's still enjoyable and stylish, and sustains your interest as the story extends into the tens of hours.
The improvements made here over the original make it much more accessible to a mainstream audience, while the wit and charm at the heart of the title remains as quirky as ever.
2. Returnal
Originally, I wasn't going to put Returnal on this list, but then I saw it didn't quite hit with fans as much as it did critics. Now, Metacritic is certainly not a barometer to assess an entire population by, but it was surprising that it only just crept over a 7/10 for player reviews.
And 7/10, for a game like this, is totally damning.
Dropping you on a mysterious alien planet that resets every time you die, the rogue-like features six distinct biomes and a whole bunch of creatures along the way that want your blood.
Developers Housemarque have always been adept in creating gripping, stylish combat loops, and this is no different. With a variety of weapons to master and level up, you're forced to engage in dense, bullet hell combat encounters that never let up in terms of tension.
It's difficult, yes, but so rewarding to overcome the challenges lurking within. Throw on top some sweet, sweet cosmic horror, and you've got one of the most purely engaging games of the year.
1. Mundaun
Coming out of nowhere earlier this year, hand-drawn horror game Mundaun is one of the most original titles released so far in 2021.
It tells the spooky tale of a man returning to his village in the Swiss Alps after receiving a note informing him that his grandfather has died in a barn fire. Like all notes in a horror game, it tells him that everything is fine, and totally normal, and the he shouldn't bother making the trip for the funeral arrangements.
Of course, the man does, and you pick up as him as you explore the countryside, investigate your grandfather's house and try to figure out why a mysterious man with a cane keeps appearing in waking dreams.
European horror like this is rarely authentically captured in the gaming space, but everything in Mundaun, from its Swiss-German speaking cast to the haunting (and sometimes hilarious) hand-drawn visuals is steeped engrossing folkloric horror.
It's a truly unique aesthetic that's bolstered by surprisingly engaging gameplay, as you explore the village and shield yourself from figures that patrol the area once night falls.
Sadly, it's not the most polished game you'll play all year. Combat can be extremely frustrating, with inputs not registering that result in your death, while some of the puzzles can take a while to get your head around. Likewise, there are a few performance issues that stop it being a smooth experience.
Still, you have to remember: most of this was created by only one developer, and those issues certainly don't take away from the charm, appeal and genuine excitement to be found.