8 Popular Video Game Mechanics That Suddenly Disappeared

Where the hell did these awesome mechanics go?

Shadow Of Mordor Nemesis
Bethesda

It's not unfair to say that true innovation is tough to come by in the video game sphere, and considering how difficult it is to make even a basically competent game, that shouldn't be terribly surprising.

So it's always fun to see a game deliver a totally unique, outside-the-box mechanic that gives players something they never even knew they wanted. 

And typically, whenever a developer comes up with a creative feature for their game, it'll be listlessly borrowed - or, less charitably, ripped off - in a bevy of other titles.

What's more surprising, then, is when a popular mechanic enjoys its brief moment in the sun and then basically just... disappears. 

It's absolutely expected that a neato gameplay flourish will be imitated endlessly, and so when it doesn't, players can't help but wonder - why not?

That's absolutely the case with these mechanics, which while widely praised by critics and even warmly recalled by players years, potentially decades later, quickly evaporated into the digital ether.

Given that many of these mechanics could've made an epic impact across a large swath of genres, it's truly odd that they disappeared almost as suddenly as they arrived...

8. Active Reload

Gears of War 4
The Coalition

Active reload is one of those elegantly simple but deliciously satisfying mechanics that probably should've taken the shooter realm by storm. And yet, it didn't.

Active reload was first popularised by the Gears of War franchise, effectively serving as a quick time event (QTE) mini-game in which you need to hit the reload button during a small window of time.

If you succeed, you'll reload faster than usual, often with a small combat buff, but if you mistime your button press, the gun will jam for a couple of seconds, leaving you vulnerable to enemy attacks.

It was a brilliant risk-reward mechanic and one that was seemingly relatively easy to implement, and so, why didn't it ever catch on? Hell, Gears of War creator Cliff Bleszinski even straight-up encouraged other games to copy it.

Despite a small scattering of subsequent shooters implementing active reload, the last major games to feature it were Returnal and Marvel's Guardians of the Galaxy back in 2021.

Since then it's been bafflingly absent from the gaming space, perhaps suggesting the developers don't much like the feature for one reason or another.


7. Scalable Multiplayer Maps

Perfect Dark Zero
Rare

Perfect Dark Zero is far from a perfect game, but it did briefly popularise a multiplayer mechanic which should clearly be a standard among shooters - scalable, adaptive map sizes.

The game's multiplayer suite allowed up to 32 players to compete in a bevy of match types, but ingeniously, the map size would change to accommodate the number of players in the lobby.

If, say, only 16 players were battling it out, the map would block portions off, in turn shrinking it down to be more manageable for a lower player count. 

This ensured you didn't spend half the game time running around looking for enemies, as proves immensely frustrating for anyone caught in a low-populous multiplayer shooter match.

Despite this being one of Perfect Dark Zero's more fondly remembered mechanics, scalable maps simply never caught on and have been a disappointing rarity among shooters for the past near-two decades.

That even cream-of-the-crop FPS Call of Duty hasn't rolled out adaptive maps yet feels like a huge missed opportunity.


6. Vehicular Shifting

Driver: San Francisco
Ubisoft

The most recent entry into the Driver franchise, 2011's Driver: San Francisco, introduced an innovative new mechanic for the racing genre - shifting.

The game's amazingly coked-out premise - in which a comatose Tanner finds himself able to inhabit the bodies of any other driver on the road - is really just a gonzo excuse for players to teleport into any other vehicle on the map they so please.

Being able to shift into a car and quickly drive it directly into the path of an enemy - or other racers in multiplayer - is stupendously entertaining, and while this mechanic was by far the best-reviewed aspect of the game, it's gone barely anywhere since.

Sure, The Crew franchise dabbled in shifting between certain vehicles, but where open-world racing games are concerned, a full-fat version of this mechanic should be a no-brainer. Why doesn't, say, Forza Horizon let us instantly scour the map and leap into any car on the highway?

Though there are probably technical challenges involved with implementing such a mechanic, Driver did it brilliantly almost 15 years ago.


5. Blade Mode

Metal Gear Rising Revengeance
Konami

Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance touts the freakin' awesome Blade Mode, in which players can slow down time and brutally dismember enemies - is there any other way? - to their heart's content.

More than that, Blade Mode could be used to damage vehicles, destroy enemy cover, and even deflect bullets. 

In fact, the slicing system was so wild that it actually had to be scaled back during development, due to an early version of Blade Mode "completely [destroying]" the level design.

Now, it's fair to say that such a complex dismemberment system likely creates some serious logistical issues for any video game that implements it.

But all the same, it's surprising that we've seen it basically nowhere in the decade-plus since Revengeance hit stores, especially with the developer's extensive ongoing work in the action genre.

Sometimes people just want to slice a bad guy up into fifty itty-bitty pieces, and it's sad that more games don't allow this basic, admittedly somewhat unhinged, pleasure.


4. Pick Ten

Call of Duty
Activision

Back in 2012, Call of Duty: Black Ops II made a serious change to the hit FPS franchise's class system with its Pick Ten mechanic. 

When creating a custom build, characters were given 10 slots with which to fill guns, perks, and grenades as they saw fit.

The ability to balance and modulate your build, perhaps slotting in more perks than weapon attachments for instance, made it instantly popular with fans, and ensured it returned for three subsequent Call of Duty games - 2015's Black Ops III, 2016's Infinite Warfare, and 2018's Black Ops 4.

But in the six years since, Pick Ten has been entirely absent from the series, effectively being replaced with the Gunsmith customisation system. 

And while Gunsmith isn't bad by any means, it lacks the tight balancing and fun strategic element of Pick Ten, where players need to make tricky choices to bolster their loadout.

Frustratingly, last year's Modern Warfare 3 was reportedly planning to bring Pick Ten back, but developer Infinity Ward ended up scrapping it. 

Sadly with Gunsmith so firmly established now, it seems unlikely we'll see Pick Ten again, but what's stopping other shooters from implementing a similar system? Make it happen.


3. Body Part Damage

Deus Ex
Ion Storm

Deus Ex is one of the most beloved video games of all time for many reasons, and quite arguably the greatest immersive sim ever made.

One mechanic which it perhaps doesn't get enough credit for is its approach to body damage, whereby players have separate health values for each part of their body - the head, torso, left arm, right arm, left leg, and right leg.

While losing all the head or torso health will lead to death, players can have their limbs whittled down to 0 HP and suffer the consequences - hand damage reducing accuracy, while leg damage leaves players crawling around looking for a medkit.

It's a fascinating mechanic which forces the player to think outside the box compared to just about every other game out there. 

While the Fallout franchise has also featured body part damage throughout the years, that's about it. 

It adds such a fun and potentially hilarious element of strategy to play that it should definitely be more prevalent in games with a substantial survival element.


2. The Nemesis System

Shadow of Mordor
Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

Middle-earth: Shadow of Mordor was widely praised for its highly creative and ludicrously entertaining Nemesis System, which kept track of the player's interactions with Uruk foes throughout the game.

If an Uruk survived an encounter with you, for instance, they might show up later with memories of the prior fight and even retain injuries from it. 

Uruks who manage to kill the player will meanwhile be promoted to captain, while players could also try to instigate in-fighting among the ranks to unsettle Sauron's army.

It was a wonderfully clever way to make even the most pedestrian combat situations feel more meaningful, yet aside from reappearing in 2017's sequel Shadow of War, Nemesis has gone the way of the dodo.

Unlike every other mechanic on this list, though, we do have a reason why Nemesis fell off the face of the Earth. As it turns out, Warner Bros. pursued a patent for the system in the years following Shadow of Mordor's release, as was finally granted in 2021.

And so despite Nemesis clearly being a mechanic with ripe applications across so many game genres, developers were spooked out of even trying to imitate it, lest they feel the might of Warner Bros.' lawyers. 

Assassin's Creed Odyssey's mercenaries system dipped a toe in with its a very dumbed-down facsimile of Nemesis, but that's it. 

Though Warner's upcoming Wonder Woman game will reportedly be using the system again, it shouldn't have taken them roughly a decade to bring it back off the bench.


1. Multiplayer Bullet Time

Max Payne 3
Rockstar

When it was first announced that Max Payne 3 would feature an online multiplayer mode, most fans were simply left wondering, "How the hell will that work?"

Given that the ability to slow down time and gun down your enemies is integral to the very gameplay fabric of the franchise, it was tough to consider quite how Rockstar would implement such a feature in multiplayer.

But dammit, they pulled it off.

Cleverly, Max Payne 3's multiplayer bullet time operates on line-of-sight activation, meaning that if someone turns on bullet time, anyone they see and anyone who sees them will similarly enter slow-mo.

And beyond that, if anyone sees another slowed-down person, they too will slow down, ensuring that players away from the bullet time action aren't forced to encounter sudden slowdown out of nowhere.

Though the potential for clunkiness speaks for itself, it actually worked shockingly well, and yet received virtually no uptake in the wider action game sphere. 

Granted, bullet time's popularity began to fade in the years following Max Payne 3's release, but the game found a devilishly clever solution to a tricky technical head-scratcher and should've received more credit for it.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.