8 Video Game Endings That Cost You EVERYTHING

Were these endings really worth it?

Undertale Genocide
Toby Fox

Video games are generally expected to end in a way that rewards the player for their efforts, whether serving up a gorgeously glossy two-hour cinematic coda - looking at you, Hideo Kojima - or simply wrapping up the story in a way that’s emotionally gratifying.

And then there are those video game endings that go the total opposite way, forcing you to make a major sacrifice of some sort, ensuring you’ll end up losing basically everything by the time the credits roll.

Perhaps your attempt to have it all was met with an unexpected punishment, or pursuing the so-called “Golden Ending” required you to make an agonising choice. None of these endings could be reached without a major penalty, for better or worse.

Indeed, in some cases the ending made total sense from a dramatic perspective, while in others, it left players straight-up ready to bend the game disc over their knee and show it who’s boss - or in our digital era, turn their controller into a damn frisbee.

No matter how they made you feel, though, none of these endings came without a considerable price…

8. Mafia III

Mafia 3 Lincoln
2K Games

Mafia III's ending offers players three distinct paths for protagonist Lincoln Clay - leave his life of crime behind, rule the city of New Bordeaux alongside his underbosses, or double-cross the other underbosses and take everything for yourself.

And clearly, one of these endings is just way more fun and badass than the others, right?

Going full dirty and killing your lieutenants after taking the city's crown, however, offers up only the most momentary of victories for Lincoln, as upon leaving and getting in his car, he'll be suddenly blown to ribbons by a car bomb.

It's subsequently revealed that the bomb was planted by his friend Father James, who desperately attempted to talk Lincoln out of staying and ruling. 

James states that he made the agonising decision to kill Lincoln after realising he was no different than the game's primary villain, mob boss Sal Marcano, and so doesn't regret doing it.

Mafia III clearly has a message for those who try to have it all - grab everything and you'll lose the lot, at the hands of a slippery clergyman no less.


7. Oddworld: Abe's Oddysee

Abe's Oddysee
Oddworld Inhabitants

By default, Oddworld: Abe's Oddysee only offers players a measly three grenades on Normal difficulty, but by beating the game with certain conditions, you'll be able to unlock unlimited grenades for your next playthrough. Sounds grand, right?

But the price requires some serious douchebaggery on your part - you'll need to go through the entire game without lifting a finger to help rescue any of your fellow imprisoned Mudokons.

Worse still, you need to make sure all the Mudokons are dead before you reach the end of the game. 

This will trigger the bad ending which is typically unlocked by rescuing less than 50 Mudokons, but will be followed up by a personal message from the game's villain, Molluck the Glukkon.

Molluck congratulates you for "whacking all those Mudokons," calls you a "twisted creep," and then offers you infinite grenades for your next playthrough. Infinite grenades? Awesome. Murdering all your fellow prisoner slaves to get them? A heavy burden for the soul.


6. Heavy Rain

Heavy Rain
Quantic Dream

If you want to platinum Heavy Rain, you're going to have to get your hands really dirty.

The interactive drama allows players to dictate the fates of its four central characters, including the Origami Killer himself. And while you're obviously encouraged to try and keep the non-murderous characters alive, if you want that sweet, sweet plat, you'll have to willingly hand a W to the game's antagonist.

The "Perfect Crime" trophy can only be popped by letting the Origami Killer, eventually revealed to be PI Scott Shelby, get away with it. 

This involves cleaning up any evidence throughout the game that might tie Scott to his various crime scenes, while also working hard to ensure that most if not all of the game's other central characters end up dead.

You'll then get to witness a soul-crushingly bleak ending in which Scott gets off, well, scot-free, ensuring the subsequent trophy pop comes with a hefty side-order of guilt.


5. MediEvil 2

Medievil 2
SCE Cambridge Studio

It's generally a given that if you commit yourself to hoovering up a ton of in-game collectibles in pursuit of the Golden Ending, said ending is going to be a special, happy one, right?

Well, in a grand act of trolling on the part of its developers, MediEvil 2 goes the total opposite way, by ensuring that those who collect all 20 chalices will be rewarded with a grand bummer of a cliffhanger ending.

Indeed, reach the end of the game with all the chalices in tow and you'll unlock an ending where Sir Dan and his mummified love interest Kiya hitch a ride on a time machine, taking them back to Zarok's lair from the end of the first game.

At this moment, the pair are then attacked by a monstrous version of villain Palethorn, and we abruptly cut to black. 

Given that a third MediEvil game was never produced, we're left to assume that Dan and Kiya were killed by Palethorn - that's quite the bummer for a "true" ending you had to go well out of your way to see.

Considering that the "normal" ending sees Dan join Kiya for peaceful rest in the afterlife, you're evidently better off not faffing around trying to get all the chalices.


4. Nier

Nier Save
Square Enix

Nier takes the concept of sacrificing everything for an ending and elevates it to mind-bendingly meta levels, as in order to achieve the game's fourth ending, Ending D, you'll need to straight-up lose your save data.

This ending sees the player sacrifice themselves to save Kainé, resulting in their very existence being forgotten by every other character. This is literalised by forcing the player to delete their own game save, leaving the game as though it's never been played. 

Oh, and on a new playthrough you're unable to use the same name you entered for this one.

To hammer home the gravity of the situation, the game even asks if you're really, really sure about doing it. 

It makes for a uniquely affecting and impactful ending, though the recent Nier Replicant remaster added an extra fifth ending where the erased save file could actually be restored.

All the same, for those who played the original version of the game, it made for quite the agonising dilemma. Yoko Taro repeated the trick in sequel Nier: Automata, though it didn't hit quite as hard.


3. Hatred

Hatred Game
Destructive Creations

In the case of controversial shoot 'em up Hatred, it's entirely fitting that this nastily nihilistic actioner ends with everything in the immediate vicinity going up in smoke - including the player character themselves.

Hatred casts players as a humanity-despising mass murderer literally called The Antagonist - careful not to cut yourself on the edge there.

The game's primary goal is to kill as many people as possible, leading up to a climax in which the Antagonist decides he's going to blow up a nuclear power plant near New York City.

At the end of game, once you reach the power plant's control room, the Antagonist is gunned down by a group of soldiers, but before he dies, he triggers his planted explosives, destroying the power plant, reducing the city to smouldering rubble, and killing literally millions of people, including himself.

It's an ending that costs the player everything, and yet that's entirely the point of Hatred - your 12-year-old cringe-lord cousin's favourite game ever.


2. Undertale

Undertale Genocide
Toby Fox

The brilliantly bonkers Undertale has three main endings, depending largely on how players deal with the enemies they encounter throughout the game. 

The Pacifist ending is achieved by, shockingly enough, refusing to kill any of the game's enemies, while the Neutral ending is unlocked by killing some, but not all of them.

And then there's the Genocide ending, which also true to its name, can only unlocked by killing every single enemy in the game.  This requires players to not only kill every enemy they fight, but also hang around and trigger random encounters until all areas have been fully wiped out.

This will lead to an ending in which players battle Sans, arguably the best and most challenging boss in the entire game, before Chara shows up and straight-up erases the entire world.

And better yet, in order to replay the game, you'll need to then give your soul to Chara, in turn restoring the world.


1. Super Fire Pro Wrestling Special

Super Fire Pro Wrestling Special
Human Entertainment

Let's wrap this list up with a majorly deep cut now, by way of 1994's Super Fire Pro Wrestling Special, which for reasons that will soon become obvious, was only ever released in Japan. 

As with most wrestling games, the end-goal of the story mode is to win the world championship, which in this case involves defeating champion Dick Slender - an hilariously blatant Ric Flair rip-off.

But because the game's story was written by Suda51, the madman who later made Killer 7, No More Heroes, and Lollipop Chainsaw, of course it was going to have an unhinged twist.

Before the fight, Slender kills the trainer of protagonist Morio, and even if you achieve revenge by defeating Slender in the ring, the game ends with Morio realising his victory is empty as he has nobody to share it with - his trainer being dead and his romantic interest having rejected him.

And so, in the game's grim final scene, Morio goes home and shoots himself dead. That's... the reward players get after fighting their way to the big title match. 

On one hand it's ballsy as hell, on the other, there are many reasons why you'd never see something like this in a WWE 2K game.


In this post: 
Undertale
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.