8 Video Game Side Characters We Should've Played As Instead

Commander Shepard has NOTHING on Garrus.

mass effect garrus
Bioware

What is any video game without a compelling protagonist you'll want to spend tens or even hundreds of hours with?

No matter how well-written and addictive a game might otherwise be, without an interesting and entertaining lead, they're always going to be missing that one essential piece.

And sometimes it just becomes screamingly obvious that one of the side characters has categorically stolen the show, enough that you wish you were just playing as them instead.

That's absolutely the case with these 8 supporting video game characters, whose charm, loyalty, combat readiness, and overall badassery made them a more appealing proposition than the meat sack we were stuck playing with.

This isn't to say that the protagonists were totally awful in each case, but simply that they were outclassed in every way that a hero can be by one of their NPC pals.

If there were any justice in the world - and there sadly isn't - we would've been sitting pretty with these side characters instead of Generic McHeroFace. And so, on with the list...

8. Barry Burton - Resident Evil

Resident Evil Barry Burton
Capcom

The original Resident Evil gave players the choice of stepping into the shoes of either Jill Valentine or the inventorily-challenged man-mountain that is Chris Redfield.

But much as we might like Jill and Chris, they ultimately play a distant second fiddle to the true beating heart of the entire Resident Evil franchise - Barry Bloody Burton.

Barry may be a goofball support character for Jill in the first game, but his penchant for howlingly ridiculous one-liners, healthy appetite for tasty Jill Sandwiches, and all-round Good Guy vibes make him by far its most charming and generally likeable character.

Even with his rep for being quasi-unintentional comic relief, Barry is extremely helpful throughout the game, often showing up at just the right time with his trusty .357 Magnum Colt Python to provide a handy assist against a tough enemy, enough to make you wonder why we're not just playing as this guy all along.

Though Barry did eventually become a canon playable character in Resident Evil: Revelations 2, the fact that he remains an out-of-reach NPC in the original game is just a damn crying shame.

As resourceful and tough as Jill and Chris might be respectively, they're just not Barry, who steals every damn scene he's in.

Seriously, Capcom - a Barry campaign which covered the original Resident Evil from his perspective would sell like the hottest of hotcakes. Get on it.


7. Jordi Chin - Watch Dogs

Watch Dogs Jordi
Ubisoft

It's in no way controversial to suggest that Watch Dogs' protagonist Aiden Pearce is a walking plank of wood in desperate search of a personality. Sorry, but it's just true.

As close to a po-faced parody of a Video Game Protagonist as Ubisoft will ever willingly give us, from his name to his face to his voice to his charisma void of a personality, he feels like a player character generated by ChatGPT on a bad day.

It's all the more maddening given that the right guy for the job was right. freakin'. there. Jordi Chin is Aiden's partner and "fixer" throughout the game - an impossibly slick, charismatic fella who is basically everything Aiden isn't - that is, everything you'd actually WANT in a Watch Dogs protagonist.

Aiden is by comparison a dull, blunt object, something Jordi himself even not-so-jokingly points out throughout the game, perhaps ill-advisedly. In a game as fundamentally ridiculous as this, Jordi's playful sociopathy and endearing loquaciousness make him such a better fit for the larger than life material.

Aidan, conversely, is gruff and dour to the point that he's ironically impossible to take seriously.

Instead, Jordi is regrettably relegated to supporting player status while we're forced to slog through the campaign as one of the most charmless video game heroes of the last decade - if not beyond.

In the event that a fourth Watch Dogs ever does happen, Ubisoft has a perfect protagonist waiting in the wings, but you probably shouldn't bet on it, sadly.


6. Nick Valentine - Fallout 4

fallout 4 nick valentine
Bethesda

As great as Fallout 4 might be, that's rather in spite of the fact that its protagonist, the Sole Survivor, is an absolute nothingburger of a hero.

Even with this being the first game in the series to feature a fully voiced protagonist, the Sole Survivor's cringey sarcastic quips and lessened impact on the overall world make them one of the series' least compelling main characters to date.

But Fallout 4 did introduce fans to one of the greatest sidekicks in video game history in Nick Valentine, so we'll forgive them.

A trenchcoat and fedora-wearing detective synth heavily inspired by classic hardboiled fiction by way of Blade Runner, Nick is by far the game's most entertaining companion and, honestly, one of the Bethesda's best-written characters EVER.

And so, banishing him to supporting NPC duty can't help but feel like a waste - like hiring Humphrey Bogart to be a mere day-player in a film noir. It just doesn't make any damn sense.

From his fascinating backstory to his amusing personality, Nick basically feels like a perfect Bethesda lead on paper - a gruff gumshoe with a heart of gold whose wild case history could keep players entertained in perpetuity.

Simply, Bethesda is leaving a small fortune on the table by not giving the world a Nick Valentine game.


5. Vivi - Final Fantasy IX

Final Fantasy IX Vivi
Square Enix

A possibly contentious pick now, with Final Fantasy IX's Vivi.

Look - Zidane's a good protagonist and all, but he's just not Vivi, OK?

While it's fair to say that some supporting characters would lose their charm and appeal were they thrust into the main character role, it's tough to believe that would happen here, given that Vivi is already the beating heart and soaring soul of the entire game.

Zidane was certainly a refreshing riposte to the moodier, sulkier heroes of the two previous Final Fantasy title, even if he's ultimately not THAT interesting and his, er, overpowering horniness has aged him like milk left out in the scorching sun.

Vivi, however, is a more compelling character in every way, from his unique look to his fascinatingly tragic backstory as a Black Mage and outstandingly layered emotional development throughout the game.

Zidane is fine but basically unremarkable by comparison, with Vivi stealing the show at every errant opportunity, enough that the pair clearly should've swapped storytelling priority.

Vivi's journey of self-discovery, of learning what to do with the short time allotted to him in life, is arguably the best of the entire Final Fantasy series, and it's tough to imagine that magic diminishing if he switched places with Zidane.

If Square Enix ever gets around to remaking Final Fantasy IX, it'd be a bold change well worth making.


4. Lamar Davis - Grand Theft Auto V

GTA V Lamar
Rockstar

Grand Theft Auto V largely pulled off its three-protagonist gimmick with flying colours, but let's face it - Franklin is definitely the lesser of the three lead characters.

Though relatively "virtuous" compared to Michael and especially Trevor, Franklin's normality is also what makes him one of the series' least-interesting "heroes" to date - a straight guy buffer for those who find the others characters a bit too "extra" and "psychopathic."

Ultimately Franklin isn't nearly as fun as his pal Lamar, who is basically an endlessly stocked vending machine of hilarious and unforgettable one-liners.

Effectively a polarity-reversed version of Franklin - he's outgoing and ridiculous in all the way that Franklin is ordinary and, honestly, a bit boring.

Above all else, throwing Lamar into the mix with Michael and Trevor and robbing the game of its card-carrying straight man would've made for one hell of a combustible, chaotic triumvirate.

Fun fact: it's been rumoured for years that Franklin was originally able to die in GTA V's final mission, after which he would've been replaced by Lamar, yet for whatever reason this sadly never came to pass. Boo.


3. Goro Majima - Yakuza: Like A Dragon

Yakuza: Like A Dragon Majima
Sega

Though Kazuma Kiryu is objectively the Yakuza series' protagonist, his exhaustingly stoic personality ultimately can't hold a candle to the franchise's uncrowned king - Goro Majima.

Majima has been one of Yakuza's mainstay supporting characters since its inception, and only finally became playable in prequel Yakuza 0, where he shared protagonist duties with Kiryu.

But Yakuza 0 really only typefied that Majima is the series' most entertaining character - a glorious walking cartoon compared to Kiryu in particular, enough that he basically feels like a pointed parody of self-serious video game heroes.

The Mad Dog of Shimano may be a maniac, but he's a good-hearted maniac who, most importantly, rocks a magnetic presence that's difficult to ever look away from.

As such it's a damn shame that Majima wasn't given full solo protagonist honors in the most recent mainline Yakuza game, Like a Dragon.

While Like a Dragon's protagonist, Ichiban Kasuga, was himself a chilled out breath of fresh air compared to Kiryu, he was no substitute for Majima.

Though we've at least had a taste of him in the main character role, Like a Dragon seemingly offered up a ripe opportunity for Majima to snatch protagonist duties away from a semi-retired Kiryu, but Sega refused to pull the trigger.


2. Elizabeth - BioShock Infinite

Bioshock Infinite Elizabeth
2K Games

BioShock Infinite's Elizabeth is generally accepted to be one of the greatest AI companions in video game history.

And considering that the game is really her story, there's a fair argument to be made that she should've been the player character instead of Booker DeWitt.

Now to be clear, Booker isn't bad by any means, but Elizabeth's characterisation is so much richer and deeper.

Plus, considering the game is effectively a reverse-escort mission where Elizabeth spends it protecting Booker, it'd certainly be fitting if we played as her instead.

She's got a fantastic character arc, her voice acting is excellent, and she has a dynamic personality which differentiates her from the overwhelming majority of stiff AI companions. As such, she forges a far greater bond with most players than Booker could ever hope to.

Though Elizabeth did become playable for a short while in Episode 2 of the Burial at Sea DLC, it just wasn't enough.

Again, Booker's an absolutely fine lead, but Elizabeth would've been an all-timer player character. Instead, she'll have to settle for being GOAT support.


1. Garrus Vakarian - Mass Effect

ME3 Garrus Normandy
Bioware

Your mileage will surely vary with Mass Effect's protagonist Commander Shepard depending on whether you chose Femshep or her sawdust-dry male counterpart, but all the same, neither Shepard can truly hold a candle to Garrus Vakarian.

Garrus is the consensus favourite companion character throughout the original trilogy for damn good reason - he's a velvet-voiced badass with a firm moral core and basically undying loyalty to Shepard, yet he's also unafraid to call out bullhooey when he sees it.

Whether you stay strictly pals or become lovers, what more could you possibly want?

And unlike most companions Garrus actually has a substantial role across all three games, while being meaningfully developed as he seeks to find his place in the galaxy.

Everyone wants a space bro who's got their back just like Garrus, but you know what'd be better than that? Actually playing as the damn space bro.

Between his charming personality, combat effectiveness and willingness to stick things out to the bitter end, Garrus is a companion we desperately wanted to inhabit - in a totally not creepy way, of course.


In this post: 
Mass Effect
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.