8 Worst Spin-Offs From HUGE Video Game Franchises

The worst gaming spin-offs that should've never been made.

resident evil survivor 2 nemesis
Capcom

When any video game franchise gets sufficiently huge, of course the possibility of spin-offs rears its head, as publishers plot to exploit their most lucrative IP for every possible drop.

And while there are countless spin-offs which have proven phenomenally successful in their own right - say, Mario Kart, Persona, Fallout: New Vegas, and Gwent, to name just a few - there are far more that end up falling flat.

After all, selling players on an extension of the core IP isn't easy if it's lacking some of the mainline series' key traits, but every so often, there's a gaming spin-off so thoroughly, hilariously miscalculated that it genuinely leaves fans reconsidering how much they love the franchise as a whole.

And that's certainly the case with these spin-offs, which while entries into some of the biggest video game series of all time, lacked the polish, finesse, creativity, production value and sheer reason to exist that their predecessors did.

Whether they were purely cynical cash-ins or simply poorly constructed attempts to widen the series' appeal, these spin-offs were all pure duds that largely fell upon deaf ears at launch...

8. Final Fantasy All the Bravest

Final Fantasy All the Bravest
BitGroove

You'll struggle to find a single living soul who will stick their neck out for Final Fantasy All the Bravest - a 2D mobile game sold on the promise of teaming up characters from many different Final Fantasy eras in a massive party of up to 40 heroes.

As cool as that sounds, All the Bravest is, for want of a better word, wack.

There's no story, the combat comes down to just basic tapping, and the aggressive microtransaction implementation was widely criticised when it launched in 2013.

It felt like a genuine embarrassment to see such a spectacular IP abused in such a crass way, all with Square Enix's obvious sign-off no less. 

Though All the Bravest swiftly faded into obscurity, it was only finally removed from all digital storefronts in 2023, effectively nuking it from existence. And nothing of value was lost.

No matter the many oddball, only dubiously worthwhile spin-offs Final Fantasy has had over the decades - looking at you, Dirge of Cerberus - it's weirdly comforting to know that things will surely never get this dire again.


7. Resident Evil Survivor 2 - Code: Veronica

Resident Evil Survivor 2 – Code: Veronica
Capcom

The Resident Evil series has had a surprising number of light gun spin-offs, several of which were actually quite good. But hoo boy, not Resident Evil Survivor 2 - Code: Veronica.

This sequel to the already-reviled Resident Evil Survivor adapts the story of fan favourite entry Code: Veronica into its own first-person light gun shooter, as players take control of either Claire Redfield or Steve Burnside.

But even for the most basic expectations of a light gun game, this is painfully rote stuff - find the key and kill the boss while navigating a host of dishwater-dull environments.

Even for its time this was an ugly game, from its graphics to its eyesore-inducingly hideous UI, while doing not one thing to flesh out the story or characters from its inspiration.

This is a generic light gun shooter that somehow slid across Capcom's desk and got approved for the no-effort cash-in treatment, yet proved so terrible it wasn't even given a North American release.


6. Mortal Kombat: Special Forces

Mortal kombat special forces
Midway

It takes a truly ungodly level of bad to out-do 1997's thoroughly naff Mortal Kombat Mythologies: Sub-Zero, but Special Forces went ahead and did it.

The game is a 3D spin-off in which players take control of Jax as he chases down Kano and his gang. 

Unsurprisingly, deviating from Mortal Kombat's fighting game formula for a more generic action game, complete with firearms, didn't go down well with fans.

Navigating each of the game's levels is a thunderously boring time due to the bland level design and atrocious AI, while there are no Fatalities to speak of.

Plus, the dire lack of most of the series' signature characters meant it barely felt like it existed in the MK universe at all.

Special Forces was ultimately enough of a commercial bust for Midway that they actually put the series on pause as a result, realising they needed to formulate a foolproof plan for the next mainline entry, leading to the series-rejuvenating Mortal Kombat: Deadly Alliance in 2002.


5. Hey! Pikmin

Hey! Pikmin
Arzest

In 2017, during the decade-long wait between the third and fourth main Pikmin games, Nintendo foisted the handheld spin-off Hey! Pikmin upon fans. 

And while in theory a handheld Pikmin for the Nintendo 3DS made complete sense, Hey! Pikmin ill-advisedly watered-down the series' much-loved core gameplay.

Swapping out the expected 3D real-time strategy mechanics for 2D side-scrolling platforming makes the resulting experience so simplistic as to be genuinely boring. 

It's linear, repetitive, and just too damn easy for its own good, ensuring that anyone who enjoyed the complexity and surprising challenge of the mainline titles was left with a game that felt like a desperate attempt to appease fans impatiently waiting for a new mainline Pikmin.

Despite this, Hey! Pikmin underperformed commercially, with the major gameplay shift likely being primary responsible for the lack of interest among all but the series' most die-hard fans.

Though the game's lackluster sales led many to believe that Nintendo might just give up on the cult IP entirely, thankfully they didn't, even if fans had to wait until 2023 for Pikmin 4 to finally release.


4. Metal Gear Survive

Metal Gear Survive
Konami

Even if Metal Gear Survive actually was a good game, it faced a tidal wave of pre-release negativity due to Konami producing it without the involvement of franchise creator Hideo Kojima, who acrimoniously split from the publisher following the release of Metal Gear Solid V.

But the real issue with Metal Gear Survive is that a wave-based zombie-fighting live service survival game just isn't what most fans wanted out of the franchise - it felt like a desperate, cynical attempt to cash-in on the trends of the era rather than deliver an experience worthy of Kojima's brand.

From the game's always-online nature to the presence of microtransactions, its excessively recycled assets from MGSV, and its wildly generic, tedious gameplay, this was a low-effort poking of the series' corpse that felt nothing like the titles that inspired it.

Tower defense, crafting, wormholes, and zombies just aren't what the Metal Gear franchise has ever been about, and so it's little surprise that Survive was a sales flop for Konami.

Within a year of the game's release, even those who did buy it had given up - it's been a total ghost town on Steam for the last six years.


3. Metroid Prime: Federation Force

Metroid Prime Federation Force
Nintendo

Ah, Metroid Prime: Federation Force, the game that made everyone take another look at Metroid: Other M and consider whether they perhaps treated it too harshly.

Federation Force's mere announcement in 2015 stoked the ire of the fanbase, who had been impatiently waiting for a new full-fat Metroid game and were instead presented with a title that felt like Metroid in name only.

A co-op-centric experience where Samus is barely seen, Federation Force felt like an original prototype which someone decided to slap the Metroid branding on.

Beyond this, the more cutesy art style felt wholly inappropriate for the franchise, and the football-based Blast Ball mode ended up sticking out like a sore thumb.

It's probably fair to say that Federation Force is as hated for what it wasn't as what it was, but it nevertheless marked a staggeringly tone-deaf, poorly timed attempt to open up the Metroid series' possibilities at a time when fans had waited far too long for another core title.


2. Silent Hill: Ascension

Silent Hill: Ascension
Konami

Though it seems like the Silent Hill franchise has finally gotten back on firm footing after so many years on the skids, it was barely 18 months ago that Konami curled out the abomination that was Silent Hill: Ascension.

Less a conventional video game than a shambling fusion of interactive browser experience and TV series, Ascension marked a bold attempt to expand the Silent Hill IP into an ongoing episodic adventure lasting several months.

However, Ascension was instantly pilloried by fans and critics alike for its borderline nonsensical narrative - even for Silent Hill - unintentionally comical dialogue and voice acting, and generally failed attempt to create an experience people would keep returning to on a weekly basis.

This is without even mentioning the embarrassingly intrusive microtransactions and bevy of technical issues which waylaid the launch, while the in-game chat was so stuffed to the brim with derisive remarks that it ended up being swiftly turned off.

Even barely a year after it finished "airing," Silent Hill: Ascension is already a distant memory to most Silent Hill fans, and thank god. 


1. Sonic Free Riders

Sonic Free Riders
Sonic Team

Shadow the Hedgehog has way too many vocal defenders to ever be included on this list, so we'll go with Sonic Free Riders instead.

This Sonic-themed hoverboard racing game was released for the Xbox 360 in 2010 and could only be used with Microsoft's motion-sensing Kinect peripheral.

That's all well and good except, as is so often the case with gimmicky motion control games, it played like pure booty.

That is to say, the motion controls, where you need to move your body to race through a course, were janky and unresponsive, ensuring most craved the warm embrace of a plastic controller in record time.

Even navigating the menus was a massive pain, compounding that this is a glorified tech demo that clearly wasn't ready for prime time, and yet got shoved out the door by Sega regardless.

There have been many low points for the Sonic IP, but as spin-offs go, this is the most ill-executed release to date.


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.