9 Amazing Video Game Developers Killed Off By Their Publishers

Gone too soon.

Dead Space 3
EA

For developers, the fear-inducing visage tucked away under Death's shroud of darkness isn't that of a bleached skeleton, but an ordinary human; balance sheet clutched in one hand, big red marker in the other. If a product flops or the sales numbers don't add up, candidate numero uno for the chopping block is the front line, often through no fault of its own.

Lionhead's collective dream in 2012 was to make Fable 4, a surefire winner with a strong fan base, and yet, Microsoft, seeking to capitalize on the growing popularity of free-to-play, opted to sink $75 million into a risky project (Fable Legends) that its crew had no experience with making. Where's the logic in that?

The very same gross mismanagement and lack of foresight that sunk Lionhead's ship tends to repeat for many of the industry's most tragic casualties, but the explanation need not always be so convoluted. Oftentimes, the answer is as simple as money, or, more precisely, the lack thereof.

Some publishers (hint: the name begins with E and ends with A) are more concerned with generating dollar bills than others, even if it comes at the cost of a world-renowned studio and expert in its field, there are no second chances.

Stay classy, video games.

9. Maxis Emeryville

SimCity 2013
EA

Founded: 1987

Defunct: 2015

What happened: You remember SimCity, right? Maxis Emeryville's God game simulator was considered to be best-in-class for almost two decades, all the way up to its fourth instalment in 2003. Then, all went dark.

Not until 2013, did Maxis finally let loose a long-awaited sequel, but rather than arrive to rapturous applause, the soft reboot was derided for its smaller scope and the requirement to always be online to enjoy any part of it, including single-player.

As you'd expect, it wasn't long after that EA, dissatisfied, put an end to the offshoot studio, relocating various IPs elsewhere within the company.

On paper, that means EA could, at any point, announce a new SimCity game. Has it? Of course, not, and it probably won't be anytime soon, either. According to a former Maxis employee, the reason why a sequel to SimCity 4 took so long was that the series didn't make as much money as The Sims:

"Money. It all comes down to money."

8. Bizarre Creations

Project gotham
Bizarre Creations

Founded: 1988

Defunct: 2011

What happened: Metropolis Street Racer, Project Gotham Racing, Geometry Wars: Bizarre Creations delivered some of the most consistently excellent entertainment throughout the noughties, a future that would surely only shine brighter under Activision's welcoming embrace, right?

That's a big fat no; Bizarre shuts its doors in 2010, following two hard-hitting disappointments: Blur and James Bond 007: Blood Stone.

Neither was an outright failure, but in Activision's eyes, Bizarre had lost its mojo. Former members of the defunct company, however, had a different opinion on the matter.

Former managing director Martyn Chudley let slip to Edge in 2011 that Activision couldn't help but thrust its nose in to oversee Blur's development, stifling morale and creativity.

We weren't an independent studio making 'our' games anymore - we were making games to fill slots. The culture we'd worked on for so long gradually eroded just enough that it wasn't 'ours' anymore."

Take note, publishers, if you're going to take ownership of a respected developer, respect them. Don't squander its talent on no-name projects cooked up only to fill a date on the calendar. What a shame.


7. Runic Games

Torchlight 2
Runic Games

Founded: 2008

Defunct: 2017

What happened: One of many studios that set up shop after the mass staff exodus from Blizzard North took place, Runic Games, on the merit of its founders' pedigree alone, became a one-to-watch, following its formation in 2008.

Among its staff were the Schaefer brothers, the two men responsible for Diablo, so when 2009 rolled around, bringing with it Torchlight, a dungeon crawler not dissimilar to its creator's past work, action-RPG fans naturally went wild.

Torchlight II continued the successful streak in 2012, but it wasn't until last year that Runic produced anything further: the overlooked and unassuming Hob.

Three months later, parent company Perfect World announced that Runic had breathed its last. The publisher decided it wanted to focus on the 'games as a service' (sounds familiar) model, a new vision that Runic, apparently, wouldn't fit well with.

Gone, just like that.


6. Black Isle Studios

Fallout 2
Black Isle Studios

Founded: 1996

Defunct: 2003

What happened: The lingering fear of any publisher-owned studio is what happens if their parent company goes under.

Black Isle Studios, which we have to thank for the phenomenal Fallout and Baldur's Gate series', had those fears become reality at the conclusion of 2003, just in time for Christmas. Lovely.

After several years of increasing financial difficulties, Black Isles' owner, Interplay Entertainment, found itself with little choice but to cancel a slew of the former's planned projects, but even that wasn't enough to make ends meet. Scrutinizing its balance sheet one final time, Interplay opted to lay off the entirety of Black Isles' staff, in turn killing off the original Fallout 3 (Van Buren).

A terrible crime of wasted potential? Absolutely, but the talent did survive. Obsidian Entertainment rose from the ashes of Black Isle and continues to thrive under the banner of Bethesda.

Consider Fallout: New Vegas to be the closest you'll ever get to the original Van Buren.


5. Lionhead Studios

Fable 2
Lionhead Studios

Founded: 1996

Defunct: 2016

What happened: A lacklustre $75 million project that never came to be is what sunk Lionhead's ship.

Following four years of sleepless nights, delays, bug fixes and closed betas, Microsoft sent human resources through the doors of Lionhead's Guildford headquarters to break two big bulletins: that Fable Legends was being cancelled and that Lionhead was to be shut down for good.

The news came as a shock for everyone, employee and public bystander alike, but how did it reach that point of no return in the first place? Eurogamer's posthumous article featuring interviews with several former employees revealed that nobody within Lionhead ever really wanted to make Fable Legends, but Fable 4.

Microsoft had refused a pitch for the latter - which was to adopt a Victorian theme - in favour of having the crew pursue a project that would take advantage of the 'games as a service' model. Something Lionhead had no experience with.

In other words, had Microsoft simply allowed Lionhead to do what it did best, we could have been playing Fable 4 right now, rather than mourning its death. Sad.


4. Clover Studio

Okami HD
Clover/Capcom

Founded: 2004

Defunct: 2007

What happened: Faced with a mass exodus of talent from the semi-autonomous studio, Capcom's hand was forced into shutting Clover Studio down in 2006, less than three years after it was founded.

Hideki Kamiya, Shinji Mikami and Atsushi Inaba, all bonafide legends in the industry, managed to push out an impressive, critically acclaimed portfolio of games (Viewtiful Joe and its sequel, Ōkami) in that short space of time, but their quality wasn't enough. Poor sales, combined with an air of dissatisfaction with Capcom for its reluctance to take risks with new IPs, led to Clover's aforementioned staff loss, leaving Capcom with little incentive to keep the lights on.

Kamiya, Inaba and Mikami continued their partnership post-departure, going on to form the independent PlatinumGames which, if by some miracle you hadn't heard, continues to be rather successful. Mikami departed Platinum in 2010 to form the Bethesda-owned Tango Gameworks (of The Evil Within fame).

If only you'd been more open to new ideas, eh, Capcom?


3. Westwood Studios

Command and Conquer
Westwood Studios

Founded: 1985

Defunct: 2003

What happened: One strike and you're out. That's the EA way, ladies and gentleman.

Nevermind the fact that, during the 90s, Westwood Studios was considered to be a bastion of video game quality (or, for that matter, that it was the creator of famed RTS franchise Command & Conquer), just three years after EA had acquired Westwood, the studio had been liquidated and its staff near-universally laid off.

The reason? None was ever explicitly specified, but the closure came not long after the launch of Command & Conquer: Renegade, Westwood's first-person spin-off set in the base-building universe. Lukewarm reviews and an unsatisfactory financial return didn't swing well with EA and, well, you know the rest.

Petroglyph Games - which still survives to this day - was formed by former Westwood devs, but EA retained the rights to C&C.

Sequels made in-house never attracted the same level of adoration as the series creator's efforts, though, and now, the franchise is all but extinguished. Cheers for that, EA.


2. Pandemic Studios

Star Wars Battlefront 2 Original
Pandemic Studios

Founded: 1998

Defunct: 2009

What happened: One of the last greats of the Australian games industry, Pandemic Studios' closure in 2009 is yet another tragic upset to have occurred in the noughties, not least because it remains unclear as to why EA made the executive call to do so, beyond a wall of corporate jargon pertaining to asset consolidation and cost-cutting.

That a sizeable portion of Pandemic's workforce went on to find replacement careers at 343 Industries, Treyarch and Infinity Ward almost immediately. speaks volumes as to the quality of its former team and the respect its name demands.

Perhaps it was a blessing in disguise, though. Had EA kept Pandemic going, it may well have been handed the task of rebooting its own Star Wars Battlefront series. As any member of DICE can surely attest to, it dodged a bullet at just the right time...


1. Visceral Games

Dead space
EA

Founded: 1998

Defunct: 2017

What happened: A combination of mismanagement, corporate clashes and a dangerous lack of foresight all contributed to Visceral's heart-breaking demise last year.

The whole sorry story is too rich to tell here - Kotaku's Jason Schreier has done a terrific job on that front - but suffice it to say, the studio's degeneration began with the commercial failure of Dead Space 3.

The once-critically acclaimed survival horror was perceived to have betrayed its roots with the action-oriented co-op threequel. EA subsequently put the brakes on and assigned Visceral to Battlefield Hardline, a first-person shooter that the studio had no experience or interest in making.

That was the second red flag. The third came in the form of Visceral's unreleased follow-up single-player Star Wars game, made possible by EA's acquisition of the license.

Only, a haemorrhaging of staff, mandatory use of DICE's Frostbite engine (built specifically for FPS') and a lack of support on EA's end made the task an exhausting nightmare.

From day one, it expected Visceral to achieve the impossible.

"EA executives are like, 'FIFA Ultimate Team makes a billion dollars a year.' Where's your version of that?"

Speechless.


In this post: 
Dead Space
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a freelance games journalist who, while not spending every waking minute selling himself to websites around the world, spends his free time writing. Most of it makes no sense, but when it does, he treats each article as if it were his Magnum Opus - with varying results.