9 Most Controversial Video Game Moments Of 2017

Did someone say microtransactions?

Star Wars Battlefront 2
EA

Loot boxes. Overpriced DLC. Season passes. Microtransactions.

An endless sea of detestable buzzwords has been grabbing the gaming headlines for all the wrong reasons this year, stuffing your lunchtime news feed with bulletin after bulletin bringing to light yet another story about money-hungry publishers doing their best to milk consumers dry.

Destiny 2, Middle-Earth: Shadow of War and Assassin's Creed: Origins, among others, have continued to walk the cash-laden path, but it's EA that has the biggest target over its head, thanks to Star Wars Battlefront 2. The internet continues to direct its collective outrage over the growing level of monetization in triple-A titles at the publisher's door, to the extent that it has been forced to renege on the original model envisioned for DICE's shooter set in a galaxy far, far away.

Fascinating to watch unfold, the scandal has been - and the plot will no doubt only get thicker - but at the same time, we shouldn't let it distract us from some of 2017's other colossal missteps. There's been plenty of them, after all.

From Microsoft's foot-shooting decision to cancel one of its only first-party exclusives, to hardware faults and PR disasters, upsets of all different flavors populate 2017's gaming calendar like a stubborn stain in the toilet bowl. Get the bleach ready, we're going in.

9. Nintendo Switch Launch Stock Hit With Hardware Faults

Nintendo Switch joy con controllers
Nintendo

As far as disastrous hardware launches go, the record for Nintendo's reputation-saving hybrid console is squeaky clean, certainly in comparison to some of the worst offenders (red rings of a certain deathly quality come to mind) that consumers have been saddled with over the years, but it hasn't escaped unscathed.

Not long after launch, early adopters of the new tech discovered that one-half - always the left - of the Switch's Joy-Con controllers struggled to record player input when disconnected from the console.

Following a series of complaints from customers with voided warranties, no doubt, Ninty responded to the worrisome hiccup, describing the issue as a "manufacturing variation," but offering no repair or returns scheme to rectify the problem.

The Big N eventually did a U-turn on that policy, offering those affected the chance to send their faulty product back for repairs, but there was no need - the 'fix' involved placing a neatly-cut square of conductive foam inside the left pad to boost its weak wireless signal.

It goes without saying, of course, that the so-called 'variation' - i.e. 'we forgot to put the foam in a batch of launch stock' - hasn't reoccured since.

Funny, that.


8. Activision Slaps A Premium Price Tag On Nine-Year-Old DLC

Call Of Duty Modern Warfare Remastered
Activision

Sure thing, Activision: reselling a nine-year-old map pack for a similarly aged video game is fair, because, you know, it wasn't already a big enough slap in the face that you refused nostalgia hunters entry to the remastered classic without first opening up their wallets for Infinite Warfare.

The consumer-friendly publisher that it is, of course, Activision made Modern Warfare Remastered available as a standalone purchase during the summer just gone - seven months later, when anyone who cared enough to relive the experience had already coughed up the cash - but that's a minor offense, compared to the piss-poor handling of its Variety Map Pack.

In 2008, when the original DLC launched, Activision priced it at $10 - a fair, affordable price tag for a bundle that included several maps. In 2017, for the exact same content (remastered - not remade - visuals aside), it decided to bump that figure up to $15.

By all means, publishers, charge whatever you want for your add-on content, but don't expect your own community to gobble it up and ask for a refill. We're not idiots.


7. Microsoft Cans One Of Its Only First-Party Exclusives

Scalebound 2015
Platinum Games

Is the Xbox One X an impressive bit of kit? Objectively yes. Is it the premiere console for all your multi-platform needs? Unquestionably. Is it backed up by a healthy library of first-party exclusives? Not on your nelly.

Crackdown 3 and Sea of Thieves, two games that feel as if they've been haunting the release schedule since the eighth console generation began, have survived several delays and mediocre receptions to remain on track for launch sometime during 2018, but not Scalebound, it wasn't so lucky.

Platinum Games' action RPG was canned outright at the dawn of 2017, leading many to question their decision to drop the three-figure sum on a console starved of exclusive software, one that wasn't answered all too well by Xbox's passionate chief, Phil Spencer.

In fairness to Phil, Halo Wars 2 and Cuphead have been strong additions to the platform within the last 12 months, but compared to PS4's Nioh, NieR: Automata, Horizon Zero Dawn and Persona 5? Well, let's just say that Microsoft will need to up its game (output) if it hopes to regain lost ground in 2018.


6. EA Says Farewell To Visceral Games

Visceral Games
Visceral Games

Like Bullfrog, Westwood and Mythic before it, Visceral Games has met its end at the hands of EA, scuppering any chances of Isaac Clarke ever getting another crack at the Necromorphs. Indeed, the Dead Space series now resides in a vacuum devoid of life not dissimilar to its namesake, but it's not the only collateral damage caused by Visceral's demise.

The studio had been working on its own addition to the Star Wars universe - codenamed Ragtag - which, according to EA's Patrick Söderlund, was envisioned to be a "story-based, linear adventure game." Sounds great, right? A story-heavy Star Wars adventure would be the perfect alternative to DICE's multiplayer-centric Battlefront 2. The best of both worlds.

Or...not.

Our Visceral studio has been developing an action-adventure title set in the Star Wars universe. In its current form, it was shaping up to be a story-based, linear adventure game. Throughout the development process, we have been testing the game concept with players, listening to the feedback about what and how they want to play, and closely tracking fundamental shifts in the marketplace. It has become clear that to deliver an experience that players will want to come back to and enjoy for a long time to come, we needed to pivot the design.

Call me jaded, but reading between the lines of Söderlund's statement, it gives off the impression that Visceral's project simply didn't provide enough opportunity for EA to work in microtransactions and avenues for optional payment to keep players hooked.

Sound familiar?


5. Destiny 2 Fails To Meet Expectations

Destiny 2 Bright Engram
Bungie

Oh Bungie, where did it all go wrong? Destiny 2 was supposed to be a blank slate for the series - a chance to cut away the problem parts birthed from the original's troubled development and the perfect platform to show Guardians just how much you've learned over the last three years.

Except, that's not what Destiny 2 turned out to be. Not really. It's as if, midway through the extensive renovations of the original, one half of Bungie splintered off to begin, in earnest, work on a sequel, ignorant of the innumerable number of improvements made to the vanilla game with The Taken King and Rise of Iron.

Whether there's any truth in that suspicion, nobody but Bungie can provide an honest answer, but it's an understandable one to have, considering that Destiny 2 - besides the obvious visual and narrative improvements - feels like the sequel to a game that no longer exists.

The sad irony is, Destiny Year Three, bolstered by endless patches and game-changing expansions, is more deserving of sequel status than the numbered follow-up that landed this year.

Whatever the problem, Bungie needs to get on top of it fast, or else this will be the only legacy Destiny 2 leaves behind.


4. Middle Earth: Shadow Of War Jumps On The Loot Box Bandwagon

Shadow of war microtransactions
Monolith

There's an important distinction to make between microtransactions that offer randomly-generated content and those that provide exactly what you pay for. The line is thin, but it's there.

For instance, Assassin's Creed Origins offers 'time-saving' boosters that allow the player to circumvent certain activities - like discovering hidden items on the map - by revealing them all for a small price. Ridiculous? Absolutely, but hey, there's at least no lack of transparency.

Shadow of War, on the other hand, opts to go down the Loot Box route. Like its predecessor, the selling point of Monolith's Tolkein-skinned sequel is the Nemesis System, only now, Talion can recruit those he's subjugated to fight for him in the war against Sauron.

It's a wonderful system deserving of praise, but also a time sink that requires investment to get the best of the best recruits. So, do you spend countless hours hunting for legendary Orcs and Uruks, or cut corners and spend a few bob for better odds?

Bear in mind that, if any of your box-born commanders die in battle, they're gone for good, meaning you've just spent cash on absolutely nothing. Nada. Zilch.

For any game, this sort of practice is frowned upon, for one that demands full retail price? It's a bad joke.


3. Pokémon GO Festival Devolves Into A PR Nightmare

Pokemon Go
Niantic

Who's to blame for Pokémon GO Fest's catastrophic failure? Is it Niantic, for not taking the precautionary measures necessary to ensure its game was still playable in the worst case scenario, or the network providers, who the developer criticized for not doing its part to support the bombardment of its infrastructure by Trainers in their thousands?

The jury's still out on that one, but there's one truth that's not up for debate: Niantic's live reaction to the disaster was pure comedy gold; cringe comedy of such quality that it'd put a script penned by Ricky Gervais and Stephen Merchant to shame.

Give this footage, captured on the ground, some eye-balling and tell us that you didn't look away - even for a second - for fear of perishing from the crushing embarrassment.

Niantic issued an apology not long after the debacle unfolded, of course, but not before issuing full ticket refunds and a free legendary Pokémon to all attendees.

Now there's a lesson it won't soon forget.


2. Mass Effect: Andromeda's Janky Animations And Laughable Dialogue

Mass Effect Andromeda
Bioware

What's to be said that hasn't already been parroted ad nauseam over the last nine months? In its launch state, Mass Effect: Andromeda's animations were bad. Not, 'Oh, these are a slight downgrade on Mass Effect 3's five-year-old efforts' bad, but honestly, truly, bewilderingly awful.

That BioWare's space epic caught so much flak for its putty-faced, googly-eyed NPCs - and the apparent Periodic Limb Movement Disorder plaguing inhabitants of the Milky Way's neighbor - where others perhaps wouldn't, is indicative of the level of quality that's come to be expected of a triple-A developer, not least one befitting the reputation of BioWare.

Had the troubles ended there, maybe, just maybe, BioWare could have escaped scrutiny, but nobody was going to forgive or forget Andromeda's laughable grade-school dialogue, voice acted with the charisma of a B-Movie actor.

In the words of Kallo: Kill. Me. Now.


1. Star Wars Battlefront 2: Attack Of The Microtransactions

Star Wars Battlefront 2
EA
"The intent is to provide players with a sense of pride and accomplishment for unlocking different heroes."

Oh yes, who doesn't take pride in spending 40 hours of their free time to unlock a single, solitary hero for one video game?

Take no notice of those 673,000 downvotes, you get us EA, this is exactly the type of banal grind that consumers looking for entertainment want. Not unlockables achievable in a reasonable time frame or fluid, meaningful progression, but a boring, monotonous grind that exists solely to incentivize additional spending on microtransactions. That's game design 101.

Sarcasm aside, in the week's since Battlefront 2's launch, EA's gone into full damage control mode, temporarily - or permanently, it hasn't decided which yet - suspending the sale of its premium, loot box-buying currency, at the same time boosting the quantity of what little in-game rewards there were for actually engaging with content.

Those are no doubt the first in a long line of changes to come, but the damage has already been done. The last thing we should do is criticize EA for attempting to make amends for its mistakes, but it doesn't deserve praise, either.

The situation should never have reached such a critical point in the first place, but maybe now publishers will think twice, before treating their customers like mindless cattle.


Contributor
Contributor

Joe is a freelance games journalist who, while not spending every waking minute selling himself to websites around the world, spends his free time writing. Most of it makes no sense, but when it does, he treats each article as if it were his Magnum Opus - with varying results.