9 Reasons Why The Witcher 3 Is Better Than Skyrim
The Witcher wins simply because its characters actually have emotions.
Ever since the release of The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt in 2015, debates have raged as to whether it's the superior game to Bethesda's iconic fantasy RPG, Skyrim.
With the rose-tinted glasses being applied to CD Projekt Red's new release and Bethesda's RPG well and truly in the dust, back in 2015 many fans claimed that it was a bit unfair to dethrone Skyrim just because everyone was caught up in a hot new property.
But now that they've been out for more considerable amounts of time and the dust has settled, it's finally time to admit that yes, The Witcher 3 is the new king of open world fantasy RPGs.
Where the developers at CD Projekt Red were striving to improve on everything their previous games did wrong, Bethesda have become complacent in recent years, still putting out good releases but increasingly resting on their laurels.
Wild Hunt trumps Skyrim in almost every category, and going forward, Bethesda needs to study the competition to see how they might claw back what was once a surefire position at the top of the open world fantasy genre.
9. The Missions Actually Let You Role-Play
While Skyrim is technically a role-playing game, you wouldn't know it just by completing a few missions. Sure, the same structure of taking quests and tackling them at your leisure is a classic staple of the genre, but the actual missions often rely on players just killing a bunch of guys or collecting a few items.
The Witcher 3 on the other hand constantly shakes up the focus of its quests, making sure there are actual role-playing options for players to tackle in every quest. Some might not include any conventional gameplay at all, with one particularly memorable extended sequence focusing on Geralt partaking in a theatre production while staking out a person of interest.
It was this imagination when it came to mission design rather than the cut-and-paste objectives of Skyrim that made CD Projekt Red's game stand out, keeping it enjoyable even after countless playthroughs.
8. Different Ways To Travel Keep Exploration Interesting
Exploring the worlds of Bethesda's RPGs is an amazing experience, but the actual act of travelling around the developer's maps often feels like a chore.
And with only the ability to sprint for a short period of time and a clunky horse-riding system making up your traversal options, there's a good chance that you spent the majority of Skyrim fast travelling around rather than adventuring on foot.
CD Projekt Red however attempted to make the sheer act of travelling in The Witcher 3 enjoyable on its own, increasing the options at your disposal to get around the game's large maps.
Whether that meant taking to the main roads by horseback, exploring uncharted territory on foot or travelling downstream in a boat, there was always an interesting way to get to your destination, ensuring exploration as gameplay element was always fun and varied across the hundred-hour campaign.
7. The DLC Is More Expansive
While Skyrim enjoyed some decent post-release content, it was few and far between. The two main expansions were solid efforts by Bethesda to build upon threads that were overlooked in the main game, but they released so long after the title hit shelves, and didn't add anything that revolutionary from a gameplay perspective, that they didn't feel like essential purchases.
The Witcher on the other hand released a constant stream of free DLC in the weeks following its release to keep players engaged. While not too substantial (extra kill animations, quests, weapons and armour), it was a nice gesture from the developers and enough to keep players talking about the title until the true expansions dropped.
Likewise, the two major pieces of DLC that were released arguably improved on the quality of the missions and storytelling found in the base game.
Hearts of Stone was a brilliant nine-hour romp inspired by classic fairtyales over the same open worlds seen in the original release, while Blood and Wine was an epic 40-hour adventure set in a brand new sandbox that could have been an entirely new game in its own right.
6. The Characters Can Actually Convey Emotion
It might be kicking a dead horse at this point, but Bethesda's engine isn't great at conveying any kind of emotion in their characters. Often resorting to comic scowls and smiles or just out-right explaining how they feel, George Lucas style, Skyrim's narrative suffers because the characters who populate its world don't feel like real people.
And while it might be unfair to compare an Xbox 360 game to an Xbox One game in terms of graphics, it's not just a case of the visuals of the The Witcher being better. The game just does a better job at making its characters feel real, focusing on small nuances and gestures rather than broad strokes to convey character emotions and motivations.
The cinematic nature of CD Projekt Red's RPG lends itself more to believable moments of drama, while Skyrim's static camera and stiff characters constantly remind you that you're playing a video game.
5. Deeper Combat
While on the surface Skyrim and The Witcher 3 both have similar combat systems, the latter is so much deeper than Bethesda's game could ever be.
Despite boiling down to similar hack-and-slash combat encounters, to really excel in CD Projekt Red's release you have to properly plan and think up different tactics depending on who you're fighting.
Not only are your two different swords designed for different groups of enemies, but certain monsters have specific strengths and weaknesses that need to be exploited if you want to make it out to the other side of a battle with them unscathed.
Throw in traps, potions, magic and levelling-up abilities, and The Witcher 3 has a depth to its combat that makes playing the game enjoyable long after you've slain your 300th Drowner.
4. Moral Choices That Actually Mean Something
There were plenty of choices and decisions to make during Skyrim, but rarely did they ever have lasting consequences in the game world.
And even when they did, for instance following the decision of who to back in the civil war, the plotlines and characters rarely ever came up again, so players didn't actually get the feeling that they were impacting the world they were inhabiting.
Contrarily, every single thing you did in The Witcher 3 seemed to haunt you, whether you wanted it to or not. Even tiny decisions could have huge ramifications later on - such as political allegiance granting victory to sides that directly impact the look of the world itself - making you constantly think about every move you made.
Likewise, the big moral choices weren't signposted anywhere near as much as they were in Bethesda's game. You had to go on your gut feeling as to whether what you were doing was right or wrong, and more often than not the game never explicitly graced you with a conventionally 'good' or 'bad' outcome.
3. The Main Quest Is Just As Good As The Side Missions
Despite being home to some of the most memorable side missions Bethesda has ever created, the main questline of Skyrim was a complete mess.
Even though it had a strong foundation and an interesting initial premise surrounding the Dragonborn's return, the title's open world structure couldn't capture the immediacy or the scale that the narrative required.
Strangely enough though, despite having a similar do-what-you-want-when-you-want approach to its missions, The Witcher was still able to craft a grand fantasy story that remained intense and satisfying over its 100-hour runtime.
Building upon two other games worth of story, the third release was able to conclude long-standing plotlines while also introducing contained new ones of its own. Even though you could go off and explore until your heart was content, you rarely ever felt the need to because you wanted to see where the story was going next.
2. A Wider & More Inventive Range Of Enemies To Battle
Although Skyrim featured a wide array of enemies to fight, it sort of felt as though Bethesda just reeled off a series of fantasy-sounding names and made character models based on them.
And while The Witcher probably stole its cast of enemies from the same list, it at least added its own spin to them and made its monsters actually have a place in the world.
After a few hours you can start to gauge which enemies you can expect to find in which locations based on their features and habitat, adding a coherence to the world that was sometimes lost in Bethesda's hodgepodge approach to world design.
Also, the visual design of these enemies is just downright jaw-dropping. Watching a Griffin flying overhead for the first time is breathtaking, while walking into the wrong cave and being attacked by an elder vampire can be enough to warrant a change of trousers.
1. A Playable Character That Not Everybody Sucks Up To
One of the major issues with the worlds Bethesda create is that they always fall apart as a result of the way they frame the player character.
In every single RPG they've released so far, the main character is readily accepted as the saviour of everyone they meet, automatically rising the ranks to lead major guilds and factions after doing a few fetch quests.
But because The Witcher is based on Geralt rather than a pure creation of the player, the developers are able to create a more dynamic and three-dimensional protagonist.
Geralt isn't automatically accepted by everyone as the hero we know/want him to be, and in fact, it often takes a lot of persuasion for people to believe that he's even a nice human being.
It makes the world the player inhabits more believable when they can't get what they want all of the time, and it makes the protagonist's progression through the world feel more natural and organic than the video-gamey systems present in Bethesda's releases.