9 Terrible Openings That Almost Killed Great Video Games

Even Naughty Dog doesn't get it right all the time.

Video Games bad openings
Naughty Dog/Bethesda/Konami

Video game openings are notoriously difficult to get right. Not only do they have to set up characters and plot in a uniquely memorable way, but they also have to act as intuitive tutorials for new players, teaching them the skills they need to actually have fun and proceed with the game itself.

But unlike a good movie or book, games are such giant, complex beasts, they can fully recover from a botched opening if the rest of the experience is solid. Because they're so large and juggle so many different moving parts, it means that a good introduction won't always make or break the experience.

In fact, some of the industry's best titles completely fudged their opening acts entirely.

Even for the most talented developers in the business it isn't easy to tow the precarious line between easing the player into the game while still giving them a bombastic opening that perfectly ties into the rest of the experience. It might all still work out in the long run, but these opening lulls have resulted in some of the best titles in the medium having opening sections so bad, they put players off replaying them at all.


9. The Witcher 2

the witcher 2
CD Projekt RED

Unlike its sequel, The Witcher 2 was an unforgivingly difficult game. Featuring combat that required a precise understanding of enemy types and a battle system where traps, potions and magic all needed to be used on the fly between regular sword swings, the title aimed to punish players until they eventually mastered its mechanics.

Which would be fine, but the game itself did an incredibly poor job of communicating how to do anything other than running straight towards your untimely death in the first few hours.

Without any real tutorial or explanation of how to actually use the array of offensive and defensive capabilities at your disposal, the opening of The Witcher 2 became a frustrating game of trial and error just to get past the first couple of missions.

Later in the title's Enhanced Edition, some of these issues were fixed (and they finally introduced an actual tutorial rather than throwing you straight to the wolves), but by then it was too little, too late.


8. Wolfenstein: The New Order

wolfenstein the new order
Machine Games

Rebooting franchises is never easy, but Wolfenstein: The New Order's need to not only reintroduce players to the narrative of this first-person shooter series but move its characters from World War 2 to an alternate history 1960s setting must have been a particularly overwhelming task for the development team.

And while the studio was able to pull off this feat in the long run, the opening of The New Order definitely suffers from not only trying to cram all of this story information down players' throats, but by focusing on set-pieces that don't reflect the title's core gameplay.

Taking its time to even give you a weapon, once the game actually lets you loose to storm a Nazi headquarters you're funnelled down trenches and forced to stealth your way through corridors in highly scripted sequences that are a far cry away from the game's otherwise player-driven approach to action.

The New Order does slowly get better after this opening, but even the levels that come directly after it suffer from holding the player's hand just a bit too much.


7. Spec Ops: The Line

spec ops the line
2K Games

Spec Ops: The Line is a classic of the last generation, but the title gained its reputation entirely in spite of its actual gameplay.

Purposefully playing like any other third-person shooter from the era, the game's cover-based gunplay was no threat to the likes of Gears of War, and although the sand-storm setting provided some visual flair and dynamic moments, there's nothing in the title's opening hours that distinguishes it from anything else released around the same time.

However as the plot progresses you realise that this mundane approach to violence is entirely the point, with the narrative becoming a twisted critique of video game violence in general as Spec Ops pulls the rug out from under players in its final chapters.

Unfortunately it takes a while to get to these twists, and until then there's no reason to think that this title is anything other than another forgettable shooter.


6. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V The Phantom Pain Hospital.jpg
Konami

Metal Gear Solid V's opening level plays nothing like the rest of the game. Entirely linear in its design, you're forced to crawl around a besieged hospital as you evade guards and attempt to mount an escape, all the while suffering debilitating injuries from a helicopter crash.

The opening is supposed to make you feel powerless, and in all honesty that would be fine if it didn't go on for so long. This introductory mission can last up to an hour, and while it's thematically rich and an evocative start to the game, it's marred by how frustrating it can be - especially on a second or third playthrough.

Things improve from there as MGS V slowly unveils its open world, but even then the drip-feed introduction of gameplay elements and the Mother Base hub world makes this lengthy introductory sequence drag on even longer as you're shuffled into tutorial after tutorial.


5. Assassin's Creed II

Assassin's Creed II 2
Ubisoft

Unlike the original game in the series which threw you straight into the action before stripping you of your weapons and abilities, Assassin's Creed 2 takes a decidedly more mellow approach in its initial hours.

Attempting to give players a deeper connection to the game's protagonist, the sequel lets you control Ezio as a young man before he takes up his role in the Assassin's Brotherhood.

While this section is admittedly a bit too long, it's not the fact that Assassin's Creed 2 doesn't give you a hidden blade in the first five minutes that's the problem, it's just that the opening story beats aren't as strong as they should be.

It's all well and good to focus on the early life of a protagonist in a game's opening, but to not put players off you have to at least make that early life interesting.


4. The Last Of Us

THE LAST of us
Naughty Dog

Before you begin your fury in the comments, let me clarify something: The opening of The Last of Us is amazing- the prologue, that is.

Set during the panic of the initial outbreak, it is one of gaming's best opening sequences, and remains truly outstanding how much developer Naughty Dog gets you involved in this heartbreaking story in the space of about fifteen minutes.

But what comes after is nowhere near as effective as that gut-punch of an intro.

Jumping forward 15 years, the game begins in earnest as you take control of Joel to hunt down a group of thugs who have back-stabbed him on a weapons deal. It's a decent set-up, but the problem is the gameplay that follows just isn't up to snuff.

The first few firefights especially don't reflect the flow of The Last of Us at all, as you're dropped into a bland environment with a few patrolling human enemies and some extremely conveniently placed cover.

As a tutorial it's fine, but the obvious "video gamey" presentation jars horribly with the more natural open areas that come after you finally meet up with Ellie.


3. Fallout 3

Fallout 3 Power of the Atom
Bethesda

The opening of Fallout 3 has been famously derided for being a poor introduction to Bethesda's otherwise excellent RPG. Chronicling your created character's life in the safety of Vault 101 from their literal birth, the opening hour has you going to birthday parties and sitting exams before you eventually break out and start the game proper.

But it's more than just the introductory sections in the vault that leave players with a horrible taste in their mouths, as the beginning of the main quest after your grand escape is similarly disappointing.

The quests starting in Megaton have you venturing out into the heart of the DC Wasteland, and only serve to show off all the game's worst aspects. As the first few hours funnel you into endless subway stations and firefights without substantially furthering the narrative, this post-apocalyptic tale doesn't make you feel like anything more than a glorified errand boy.

Obviously in a game like Fallout you could ignore these early missions entirely and try to jump into the good stuff immediately, but when you're thrown into a sandbox as big as this without any other directives, most players tend to gravitate towards these main quests.


2. Mass Effect

mass effect eden prime
Bioware

The original Mass Effect is considered as being something of a flawed classic in comparison to the games that followed it, and its meandering opening section is probably one of the main reasons why.

Introducing you to a fresh-faced Commander Shepard after a quick dose of exposition aboard the Normandy, the first tutorial section on Eden Prime is enjoyable enough, but it's a bit too straight-forward and features fewer RPG elements when compared to the rest of the main quests.

While Eden Prime is a wobbly introduction however, it's the following sequence exploring The Citadel that really brings the game's opening hours down. Letting you immerse yourself in side quests while you move from one end of the eerily sterile hub world to the next, the game should have spent less time piling on this busywork and instead put the focus on getting you in charge of your own ship, then letting you freely explore solar systems.

After all that sense of wonder at the vastness of space is what the original Mass Effect was all about, so to spend so much time delaying access to this exploration crippled an otherwise seminal title.


1. NieR: Automata

Nier automata
Square-Enix

Although it has a rather impressive on-rails introductory battle, once Nier: Automata finally unleashes its open world the game grinds to an immediate halt, introducing you to a myriad of mundane side quests and a main campaign that's initially comprised of doing favours for everyone you meet.

Fortunately though the decision to overwhelm the player with a large amount of seemingly innocuous quests in Nier's slow start has a purpose, used to introduce players to a sense of repetition and a gameplay loop that's later revealed to be more substantial and satisfying than it first appears.

This is a game that's supposed to be played through three times, and unfortunately the significance and impact of its opening hours don't come to fruition until you've at least finished the first part of this sprawling RPG.

--

Which games finally got good after naff opening acts? Let us know in the comments!


Watch Next


In this post: 
Fallout 3
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.