9 Video Games That Almost Took GTA's Crown

Behold the great pretenders.

Few games have changed the industry the way Grand Theft Auto III have. When it exploded onto consoles in 2001, it introduced a bold new vision of gaming. Sure, the €œopen world€ concept had been played with before but never on this scale as suddenly, gamers were thrown into a near-limitless (at least comparatively so) world of adventure. It was a true game-changer for developers and Rockstar built their mammoth brand on the back of sequels that got bigger and pushed the boundaries even further. Naturally, as always when there€™s a successful game, there are imitators. Those trying to ride GTA€™s coattails and tune in to the new excitement gamers were feeling after taking a trip to Vice City or San Andreas. Inevitably, some of the copycats are rather weak next to what inspired them, but others were able to use the sandbox format in unique ways, and actually improving on what Rockstar had achieved in some areas. Though GTA remains the undisputed king of sandbox games, there are legitimately a number of competitors that can lay claim to challenging for the crown. And in some cases, they came pretty damn close to being even better...

9. Mercenaries: Playground Of Destruction

Rather underrated, this 2005 game took the logical idea of an open-world motif and applied it to a war setting. You could play as one of three mercenaries, each with their own unique skills, in a North Korea threatening war on the South. The game play was a good mix of driving and shooting with a variety of weapons but what made it stand out was how you could work for the various factions about the country, from North Korean troops to Allied Nations and Russian Mafia. That leads to the fun of playing sides against each other, taking on multiple missions for more cash and enhancing your reputation€ which can sometimes be a bad thing as your actions define your standing with each faction. The combat was great as you could go from stealth play to openly blowing up entire towns in tanks, calling for air strikes and private assassination missions. The game truly did up the ante over GTA with the idea of a nation literally at war and the ability to play factions against each other better than the more streamlined storylines GTA would give you. And perhaps the franchise would have expanded on that potential if the sequel wasn't marred by production issues and the death of its studio. Were it not for that, there could well have been more Merc games and a more legitimate threat to GTA's crown.

8. Just Cause 2

The first Just Cause game had massive potential but could never quite get there and despite picking up some fans, could never compete with the polish GTA offered. The sequel, however, went all out with a fantastic adventure that came a lot closer. Sure, the story was rough but it had more than enough to win you over. The first game gained attention for the nice ability to para-sail around so that was of course kept and in came the grappling hook that could attach players to speeding cars or planes, allowing you to leap across chasms and combine with the parachute for some pretty bad-ass moves that could make GTA stunts look downright tame. The idea of a €œchaos meter€ than can build up as you go just encourages you to go all out blowing the crap out of stuff and not even bother as much with the storyline if you don€™t want to. That's a great turn over GTA as you could spend even more time doing side quests without the need to bother with the storylines and in fact, the story barely even mattering. The franchise hasn't quite reached the quality or the popularity of GTA, but with a third addition out soon, that could well change.

7. The Simpsons Hit & Run

Arguably the best game to capture the flavor of the classic animated series, this 2003 entry takes the obvious idea of "GTA Springfield" and runs wild with it. All the actors from the show provide voice work and the script is as sharp as any Simpsons episode with inevitably funny lines and nicely done 3-D cut scenes. Running around this replication of Springfield is like a fan's dream as it allows exploration of landmarks like Moe€™s Tavern and the Escalator To Nowhere and as with the series, you can enjoy slews of background gags and Easter Eggs. The €œplot€ involves bee cameras and aliens but frankly it doesn€™t matter really. What matters is how you can buy outfits from the show (Bartman, Policewoman Marge, 800 pound Homer), drive around Springfield looking for coins, side quests involving Krusty, Millhouse and others and enjoy a brand experience that even GTA cannot compete with. The Simpsons motif elevates this over GTA in a big way, but it's just a shame that the story-lines and gameplay couldn't quite match up to the fan experience or what Rockstar offered even with GTA III.

6. Mafia: The City Of Lost Heaven

Some may argue that Mafia doesn€™t have a lot of €œopen world€ elements in comparison to others on this list, which is thus a major reason it's never been a serious threat to GTA's crown. But it still remains a game that stands out brilliantly among other releases of its time. The story is the key to it all, winning you over with its cut scenes (truly fantastic for 2002) and excellent animation but more importantly, well-written characters as we see Tommy still trying to be a nice guy in a dirty world and holding to honor others don€™t. Let's face it, the story was the weakest part of GTA III but Mafia more than makes up for it with a crime tale right out of a Coppola or Scorsese movie that truly wins you over. The car driving was top notch, you truly feel how hard it was to get going with vehicles of the time and the way they handle differently was something unique. The gun battles also dropped in Tommy guns and pistols and felt far more authentic than the armory mechanics of the GTA series. From small missions to full-scale blowouts, the game won you over and truly stood high among the initial wave of GTA clones. Its sequel may not have been of the same quality but still good playing with a 1950€™s vibe, showing the mob in a time of change and how (unlike other games such as GTA) you see the car you€™re driving in a cutscene, damage and all. It was overlooked thanks to GTA IV's release and seen as a second-rate copy, which is a shame given that it has its own strengths and deserves recognition.

5. L.A. Noire

It had been tried before with the troubled True Crime games but Noire nailed what most folks thought an obvious idea: a GTA-style game where you play a cop instead of a crook. Rockstar went all out here with a stunning replica of 1948 Los Angeles, nailing the landscape, design and feel of the city at the time. Driving around, seeing famous landmarks, stopping small street crimes and finding classic automobiles, it was a great experience and you truly felt back in the past during it all. The gun battles were well done as were the chases, both car and foot and the fact this was a real city undoubtedly made it more attractive than Vice City or San Andreas in some ways. The real appeal was in the investigations into crimes, as well as the introduction of some of the best character models ever seen in video games. When you interrogated a suspect, you could see every facial tic and thus try to tell whether they€™re lying or not. You can check crime scenes carefully for clues to tie in and at times, have to make a tough choice on whether or not to charge the right person with the crime. That's something GTA has still never been able to match: the characters are more human than caricature. That realism, though, is also probably the reason it couldn't overtake GTA in sales and acclaim as the investigations could be repetitive and required far more concentration and patience than the typical GTA mission. And it's just more fun to be the bad guy.

4. Infamous

The concept of inFamous was long-overdue when it launched: an open-world crime game where your character just happens to have super-powers. From the opening moments as you get Cole to absorb electricity from nearby rails and street lights, it was impossible not to be hooked and the experience was almost unprecedented. The game also addressed how you would use your powers for real with the €œkarma meter€ deciding whether you€™re a hero or a monster and adding morality depth. GTA can play with morals now and then but for the most part, you're locked to one path; here, you see true consequences of your actions and decisions and that going wild with too much mayhem can be a bad thing for your character. It helps that the story itself is well done as you get into Cole€™s journey, his battles and all leading to that wild final plot twist that makes replaying a must to see how it unfolds.

3. Red Dead Redemption

While the underrated Gun was a fair attempt, it took Rockstar themselves to finally capture the idea of €œGTA in the Old West.€ You could spend hours roaming this magnificently realized setting, exploring forests, canyons, wonderfully detailed towns and forts. The side activities are perfect from bounty hunting to handling cattle and the side missions informing your standing added depth to the classic Western stuff of gun duels and chasing wagons. The story is the key to the game's appeal as John Martson stands as one of the greatest protagonists of any game of the last decade, easily blowing away any of GTA's often-clichéd leads. A classic Western hero (or anti-hero depending on how you play him), his quest is made clear as the game unfolds and he goes from small towns to Mexico on a personal hunt. You genuinely get to like him, and feel for him, which makes the game€™s stunning finale all the more emotional. Its Western motif does work against it as does the fact it's produced by Rockstar as many will see it as more a "companion piece" to GTA than a true successor. But it still stands well on its own as a game that shows that the GTA style can work well in most any period and place.

2. Sleeping Dogs

Originally conceived as a reboot of the rough True Crime series, Dog went through several developers, cancellations and redesigns that gave it some poor buzz. But when finally revealed in 2012, the game was a true delight for lovers of open-world games and Hong Kong action films in general. The plot is classic: Wei Shen is a cop going undercover in the Hong Kong Triads, trying to get closer to the big bosses. We get the classic stuff of him balancing his dual lives (you can do some €œpolice missions€) and the game smartly lets you earn points as either cop or crook, a good motif that GTA has never gotten into. Of course, it gets complicated with Wei realizing the irony that the Triad has more honor than his fellow officers. But what makes the game shine is how it approaches things. Yes, you do some driving and shooting but the bulk of action is in fantastic melee combat as you can upgrade with new martial arts moves and pull off some damn awesome €œenvironmental kills€ to take guys down. Melee fighting is something GTA has never been able to do well but Dogs makes it so natural that you end up loving the brawling more than any shooting levels. And of course, all of this unfolds in a brilliantly realized Hong Kong, one that many residents of the city hail as a near perfect recreation. The poor buzz may have held it back from huge success as does its shorter story length and overtly Asian motif. But "Dogs" did come closer than others to unseating GTA in terms of popularity. It was a great hit and showed that transplanting that formula to an international locale ups the ante and produced a game that not only stands equal to any GTA entry but even better and more in depth than what Rockstar has done.

1. Saint€™s Row

When it debuted for the launching Xbox 360 in 2006, Saints Row was instantly labeled as €œnothing but GTA-lite.€ Sure, the character creation section, where you could model your protagonist in any way, was different than the pre-selected characters of Rockstar but that was the only unique thing. It was much the same: playing a gang member in a dirty city, doing various missions, some wild stuff and the crazy cool of Johnny Gat but it still seemed nothing but filler until GTA IV was released. But then the second game was released in 2008 and instantly elevated the franchise nicely. This time, you could remake your character as male or female, even down to their voice, giving instant replay value. The city was larger and had more unique touches, the plot of taking on four different gangs at once was well done and the side-missions were truly fun. What other game basically makes you indestructible to get hit by cars in traffic in order to earn more money via €œInsurance fraud?€ Or using a septic tank to douse buildings to affect real estate? Indeed, while GTA IV was seen as rather serious at times, Saint's Row appeared to revive the wild, anything goes spirit of that franchise. It got wilder with the third game that inserted brilliant parody of product placement, fame, the entire video game genre and more. The missions were strictly insane from a fight on top of falling globe to being naked and coked up brawling in a brothel to using military jets in bombing raids. The story may have been short but the sheer amount of carnage you could enjoy made the game a blast. It climaxed with the fourth game, putting you inside a Matrix-like world where you could use actual super-powers to battle aliens and even watch Keith David and Roddy Piper reenact their brawl from They Live. That sheer wildness may be the reason Row has never totally supplanted GTA at the top despite its huge fanbase. The games can be too wild for some and far looser in character and play so gamers would prefer the more streamlined world GTA offers. But Row still offers a better challenge to GTA than the rest of this list by going so over the top you can't help but love it. Which sandbox and open world games do you think could have toppled GTA's crown as the greatest? Share your own picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor

A freelance writer with love of comic books, sci-fi/fantasy, action films, pro wrestling and more. An inventive mind and history major who hopes to bring some of that to readers.