9 Video Games That Got Away With Being Total Rip-Offs

What if we told you Angry Birds' gameplay was older than you think?

What is it about popular culture and plagiarism that go hand-in-hand? It€™s become all too common to find out that your favourite book, game or song is in fact a complete rip-off that shamelessly stole someone else€™s idea and somehow turned it into a success along the way. Are there even any original thinkers out there anymore? Probably not if you want to use the world of gaming to lose what little faith in humanity you have left. Ever since the medium€™s humble beginnings in the 1970s, the industry has been all about riffing on established ideas and concepts. Every few years a new game will come along with an amazing new design concept and money-hungry publishers will churn out poorly designed clones in an attempt to capitalise on its success. Sometimes it turns out that even a game that€™s perceived as the originator of the concept actually stole it from another title. As you can tell, plagiarism and game design are a match made in heaven. The following nine games somehow managed to get away with ripping off an existing idea, while their creators presumably twirled their evil moustaches and cackled maniacally all the way to the bank.

9. Columns

What It Ripped Off: Tetris. Tetris enjoyed massive success in the late 1980s when it came bundled with Nintendo's bulky brick of handheld goodness called the Game Boy. Its catchy music never grated on you even during marathon sessions and its block sorting, line forming gameplay satisfied the OCD person that's inside all of us. It was the first killer app for handheld games and created a whole new market for addictive puzzlers. And so of course Sega jumped on the bandwagon and did exactly what Nintendo did (contrary to their famous 'we do what Nintendon't' marketing phrase) by releasing a puzzler of their own called Columns. Columns may very well be the most unimaginative title ever, second only to "Block Sorting" or "Puzzlepocalypse" (actually that one sounds quite good). Columns plays very similarly to Tetris, except that you had to line up three of the same jewels instead of creating lines across the whole screen. What innovation! The similarities don't end there. The game speeds up as the player's score rises and ends when the columns reach the top of the screen. Sounds familiar, right? Sega also released Columns on their battery-sapping Game Gear handheld in the hopes of catching the same success Nintendo had with the Game Boy (spoiler: they didn't).

8. Vigilante 8

What It Ripped Off: Twisted Metal. Twisted Metal brought the car-combat genre kicking and screaming into the third dimension when it released on the PlayStation back in 1995. Its cheesy tone, tight controls, killer rock soundtrack and awesome vehicles and characters that brimmed with twisted personality spawned a franchise that helped Sony's first console find an audience in teens and adults. Inevitably its fine example and subsequent success made it irresistible to copycats. The most shameless of all is Vigilante 8, which released on the PlayStation in 1998 and the Nintendo 64 a year later. It featured similar weapons (machines guns mounted on cars, homing missiles, mines) to Twisted Metal, but didn't feel anywhere near as good to play. The weapons lacked punch, the AI cars tended to just stand there and let you shoot them and crashing into people didn't have the same satisfying, damaging effect in Vigilante 8. Oh, and getting your car to do a u-turn exactly when you need to was next to impossible. You may as well try to teach your cat ballet. It did have destructible environments and visible car damage that was quite impressive for its time, but it just lacked personality. It had different characters with their own intertwining stories but none of them were particularly interesting. Playing a car combat game for its story is as pointless as reading erotic fan fiction for the social commentary, but our point is that the whole game just felt soulless. Congratulations, Luxoflux. You somehow managed to make speeding around environments and blowing everything up a mind-numbing chore.

7. PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale

What It Ripped Off: Super Smash Bros. There's something magical about bringing every single Nintendo character into a game and having them try to murder each other. The Smash Bros. games are a love letter to Nintendo fans, paying homage to the company's rich history with little nods and easter eggs at every turn. By 2012 Sony had been around long enough to develop a diverse range of iconic characters of their own, from Parappa The Rapper all the way to Nathan Drake. They decided to make their own answer to Smash Bros. and the result was... Smash Bros. with Sony characters - only with more boredom and a lot less charm. The ridiculously named PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale felt like Smash Bros. after it had the life sucked out of it. Nintendo somehow manages to pull off mixing all of its art styles together in their Smash games, but seeing Sweet Tooth beating the hell out of Parappa The Rapper just didn't look right at all. It's like Yoshi suddenly appearing as Marcus' long lost friend in Gears Of War. It's weird, jarring and unsettling. It didn't completely copy Smash, though and Sony at least came up with a unique idea for the combat system. Knocking your foes out of the stage could only be done by performing a special move. To do that, you had to fill up your AP meter by dealing damage to your enemies. It was a bit of a marmite mechanic, with some some players thinking that it made the action less unpredictable, while others thought it gave the game a unique focus. Alas, PASBAR (that seriously has to be the worst abbreviation ever) wasn't the success Sony hoped it would be and didn't sell that well. Maybe having a less silly name and more unique ideas would have helped.

6. Crash Team Racing

What It Ripped Off: Mario Kart. There have been many games that have attempted to duplicate Mario Kart's success over the years. A recent example being the Sonic And Sega All-Stars series, but at least they differentiated themselves a bit with awesome mid-race vehicular transformations that turned your kart into a boat or a plane. Crash Team Racing, however is pretty much a straight-up Mario Kart rip-off. With that said, it's a pretty damn good rip-off. The controls are just as responsive as Mario Kart and the game can be almost as fun at times. Just like in Mario Kart, you race around courses, powersliding around corners and using wacky weapons on your fellow racers whenever you get the chance. Weapons did work a little differently in Crash Team Racing, however. You could collect fruit to make your weapons arsenal more powerful, which is a pretty nice touch. It also had boss races similar to those found in Diddy Kong Racing, so it effectively ripped off two games at once. Impressive! Crash Team Racing is a great game and could very well be the finest rip-off that ever existed (even its final lap jingle was eerily similar to Mario Kart's). But to Naughty Dog's credit, they knew exactly what they were doing when developing this game and were successful in making a decent Mario Kart clone for PlayStation owners to enjoy.

5. Kinect Sports

What It Ripped Off: Wii Sports. Wii Sports had a lot to do with turning Wii into the success it became, making motion control a defining factor in its era. You could create a Mii that resembled you (or someone else - nothing beats seeing Hitler and Darth Vader casually playing tennis) and use it in the game. It was a small touch, but the motion controls combined with the Miis made people feel connected to games in a brand new way. It changed the gaming landscape and both Microsoft and Sony clamoured to jump on the bandwagon with the Kinect and PlayStation Move, respectively. It was Microsoft though that ripped off Nintendo's ideas the most. Kinect Sports was essentially Wii Sports for Kinect, featuring some of the same activities (boxing, bowling in the original and golf and tennis in Kinect Sports Season 2) and Microsoft even copied the Miis, giving them the much less charming name of Avatars. Microsoft didn't even bother trying to hide ripping Nintendo off, which was probably the best strategy as there's not really any way to disguise it when it's so blatant.

4. Angry Birds

What It Ripped Off: Crush The Castle. If you own a smartphone, chances are you've downloaded Angry Birds at some point. Flinging birds at buildings full of pigs and cackling like a James Bond villain as they come tumbling down has a universal appeal. It certainly sounds like a unique concept, but it isn't. Rovio stole a lot of Angry Birds' game mechanics from a flash game called Crush The Castle. So, what are the similarities? Well, in Crush The Castle you use a trebuchet to launch rocks in the air in an attempt to kill all of the enemies hiding in the castle to the right of you. As we all know, in Angry Birds you use a catapult to fling birds at pigs hiding in various structures loosely put together with wooden planks. Once you compare the kinds of projectiles in both games it's clear that Angry Birds wasn't just inspired by Crush The Castle - it full-on ripped it off. In Castle Crashers you start with a small boulder, then a slightly bigger boulder, followed by one that breaks up into three smaller boulders mid-air and finally an explosive boulder. Angry Birds uses the exact same projectiles, the only difference being that they're mildly cheesed off birds and not rocks. There's no doubt about it, Angry Birds is a shameless rip-off that Rovio cleverly tried to hide with cute aesthetics, which actually ended up being one of the biggest reasons why it became such a hit. After all, the birds and piggies are original and charming. It's just a shame that the games that they star in aren't.

3. Gears Of War

What It Ripped Off: Killswitch. Gears Of War is a rather influential title, with its cover-based shooting and blind firing being used by many games that came after it, including BioWare's Mass Effect and Naughty Dog's Uncharted. It's just a shame that its hilarious city sinking giant worm that makes an appearance in Gears 2 didn't catch on in a similar fashion. And of course it ripped off its core mechanic from another game: Killswitch - a fairly obscure game that released on the PS2 and Xbox back in 2004. While other games before it like Metal Gear Solid 2 had employed cover systems, Killswitch was the first to build itself entirely around the mechanic. Players would quickly duck behind cover and pop out and take quick shots in a very similar way to Gears Of War. Killswitch also pioneered blind firing from behind cover - another mechanic that Epic's shooter popularised. The reason why you may not have heard of Killswitch is that it admittedly was a fairly mediocre game overall, but there's no denying that Gears Of War stole a lot from this title.

2. Pong

What It Ripped Off: Tennis (the game). Yes, even the game that created the industry is a rip off, proving that developers have been stealing ideas for as long as there have been ideas to steal. Tennis was one of the games available for the Magnavox Odyssey - the world's first home console. Atari co-founder Nolan Bushnell had seen the tennis game in action for himself at a demonstration in 1972, and asked a new recruit named Alan Alcorn to duplicate it as an exercise. Bushnell suggested that a score was added to the top of the screen, but Alcorn went all out and made several other tweaks as well, adding in angled shots and making the ball speed up during rallys. After Alcon had created a prototype, Bushnell decided to see if there was a market for the game. And of course the rest is history. Pong was a massive hit for Atari and turned video games into a thriving industry. Its popularity came at a price, though as Magnavox later successfully sued Atari. There really wasn't much Bushnell could say in his defence, as Magnavox had his signature proving that he was at the Tennis demonstration that took place prior to Pong's release.

1. The Simpsons: Road Rage

What It Ripped Off: Crazy Taxi. One of the many good things about Sega's ill-fated and consequently much-loved Dreamcast console (consoles that die young are to gamers what trouble artists that kill themselves are to regular folk) was that it was powerful enough to handle the Japanese giant's arcade hits. Crazy Taxi was one of the many arcade games that got ported to the console in its short life, and it ended up being one of the greatest games to grace the system. A year later in 2001 The Simpsons: Road Rage came out and it was literally Crazy Taxi set in Springfield. Players controlled various famous faces from the show in a car, picking people up and driving them to their destination as quickly as possible. The only discernible difference from Crazy Taxi is that a yellow hand showed you the way instead of an arrow. That and The Offspring didn't feature heavily on its soundtrack. The similarities were so undeniable that Sega actually filed a lawsuit against the creators of the game, but it was settled outside of court for an undisclosed sum, leaving Road Rage to be produced on a mass scale. While Pong at least tried to improve the design of the game it ripped off, The Simpsons: Road Rage did no such thing, making it the most shameless rip-off in gaming history. What do you think are some of gaming's most blatant rip-offs? Have you played any that you've actually enjoyed over the years? Let us know in the comments.

In this post: 
Angry Birds
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

When I'm not playing games, I'm probably either writing about them somewhere or singing stupid songs inspired by them. Or eating pizza.