9 Video Games With Reviews No One Can Agree Upon
Literally everyone is wrong literally all of the time about literally everything.
Online reviews are some of the best ways to figure out whether or not you should play a video game. We've all scoured threads and posts on various social media platforms reading each person's opinion, in order to justify buying a game. Some people turn to review websites for their decisions, others just browse forums where everyday people can post their opinions.
Either way, reviews and recommendations are everything in the gaming world.
Most of us are able to think of at least five games that have been universally agreed upon as either good or bad. Some fine examples include the original Halo trilogy and The Last of Us, while universally bad games include the likes of Mass Effect: Andromeda and the 2006 instalment of Sonic the Hedgehog.
However, there are some games out there with extremely mixed reviews. And using the word "mixed" is an understatement. Even professional review sites are up in the air on certain titles, and the debate is on-going to this day.
Sure, every game has its pros and cons, but let's talk about which games have the gaming world in constant debate over whether or not they're actually worth the time.
9. Grand Theft Auto IV
Rockstar took a plunge into the unknown when they released GTA IV. The GTA franchise is known for its comedic commentary on dark subjects like crime and corruption and one could even go so far as to say that despite all of the games being filled with violence, GTA is a silly franchise. However, that excludes GTA IV.
Instead of the usual satirical approach, Rockstar went a different direction when they introduced protagonist Niko Bellic. Niko's story is of a man who attempts to chase the American dream, but despite him wanting to leave his criminal past behind, he seems unable to shake it. It's a tale of redemption and it gave Niko depth. Instead of the caricatures of old GTA, we were introduced to a realistic character. The game was a success and Niko's gloomy story and the bleak backdrop of Liberty City seemed to be what fans wanted.
However, that's not entirely true as many fans thought that the serious approach was unnecessary and poorly done. Many referenced the fact that despite Niko wanting to change, he doesn't grow as a character. He's perfectly fine murdering people post emotional cutscene and that fact didn't sit right with many.
8. Gone Home
Gone Home is an extremely interesting title to discuss when it comes to mixed opinions on video games. The reviews of this game are polarizing, to say the least.
There are some that say that The Fullbright Company's walking simulator is a true masterpiece.
They'll tell you that the ambiance and the mystery of the Greenbriar mansion are like no other game you've ever seen. They'll say that the story is one of the best and that all the time you spend walking around trying to piece together what happened is absolutely worth the hassle. They'll also point out that the solution to the mystery is what makes the entire game worthwhile.
And then there are some opposing opinions.
Many players will say that the game is a cheap gimmick. There are those who believe that the walking simulator genre can't really be called a part of the gaming industry as it doesn't offer the player enough interactivity to constitute being an actual game.
And then there's a discussion on the story of Gone Home. Was the narrative poorly delivered? Was the twist at the end worth all the effort? The debate continues.
7. PlayerUnknown's Battle Grounds
One of the first games to popularize battle royale, PUBG was developed by Bluehole and came onto the gaming scene in 2017. Known for its realistic graphics and more subtle approach to battle royale than other titles like Fortnite, PUBG became the go-to for people who were fans of the Call of Duty franchise.
The known pros of the game include the realistic approach to player vs. player survival, a huge map with large amounts of players, and the high risk high reward matches. It's a fun challenge and a rewarding experience for anyone looking to change up the usual team death match we're all used to.
However, PUBG has lost some fans and there are a lot of people who have very different opinions on the subject. With the introduction of loot boxes and microtransactions within the last year, the popularity of the game has decreased. More recently however, players have had to contend with connection issues due to servers being shut down. As of now, only one server exists in North America - in the state of Ohio. With more than 24% of the player base in the U.S., that's not exactly an ideal situation.
6. No Man's Sky
There are many people who will always call Sean Murray a criminal. A liar who hyped his game up and took everyone's money. It's entirely possible that they'll never forgive him or Hello Games' No Man's Sky.
Upon launch, the game was barely playable, much less enjoyable. Despite being told that there would be much for players to do, there was barely anything. Players could land on a planet, collect resources, and interact with exactly one alien before returning to their ship and doing it all over again. The gaming world has since been up in arms and people will still say that No Man's Sky is beyond saving.
However, there are others who are ready to forgive. Because despite a disastrous launch and anger all over the internet, the developers took it all in and tried again. They tried to fix the mistakes and the results have been wonderful. People swear that it's an entirely different game and it's absolutely everything that was promised. Reviews are far better now. Even so though, is it fair to forgive them for what they did? Or should we teach them a lesson about fraud to the sound of our wallets shutting?
5. Mass Effect 3
In 2012, we all knew that the tale of Shepard was coming to an end. It was gut-wrenching to say the least to think that our time on the Normandy was over. Players were hoping for the best send-off possible for the most loyal and badass crew in the galaxy.
However, after release, it was a toss up as to whether or not the end was the one we deserved.
Even barring discussion of the last fifteen minutes of the game, Mass Effect 3 was a game that was divisive in its delivery. People have disagreed upon whether or not it was a true ending to the epic space opera or if it was just a big let down. Some people felt as if their choices from the last two games were completely ignored, while others felt that it was a heartwarming and righteous way to end the series based on the decisions they made. On the topics of the closing to the Reaper War, the necessity and realism of the Citadel DLC, and the existence of Javik, the fan base is split.
Even seven years later, Mass Effect 3 and its ending are hot-button topics of discussion.
4. Bioshock Infinite
Was Bioshock Infinite a true entry into the Bioshock series?
The opinions are mixed. The bright and colorful setting of Columbia was certainly a departure from the dark and creepy Rapture. It was received well by some but very poorly by others. Some fans argue that by taking the story to such a different setting, Irrational Games completely tarnished the feeling Bioshock was meant to evoke. Initially meant to be an on-the-rails survival horror game with an amazing twist and a very interesting political and social lesson, the first Bioshock made us all fall in love with the story of Rapture.
However, some say that Columbia doesn't pack the same punch as Rapture and that there really isn't a lesson to be learned. Additionally, the fanbase is split on their opinion of the story of Booker and Elizabeth. The twist involving the two characters is one that's been hotly debated since the game's release. Was Infinite's twist really necessary to complete the overarching story of Bioshock? Was it even an interesting one? There are thousands of people who would rather swim back to Rapture than fly up to Columbia and deal with Comstock again.
3. Fallout 4
After what some people say is the best entry into the franchise, Bethesda had their work cut out for them to create something even better for the next generation of consoles and there are varying opinions on whether or not they succeeded in their endeavor.
Fallout 4 is entirely different compared to any of the other entries in the series. The voiced protagonist creates a separation between the motivations of the main character and the player.
The introduction of synths adds another layer to the story, but is it plausible in the post-apocalypse? The plot of the game proved to be quite a bit less in depth than what we experienced in New Vegas or Fallout 3. Because of these points, there is a rift between fans who consider it fantastic, and those who don't even consider it an RPG anymore.
For players whose first experience with Fallout was Fallout 4, it seems as if it's no contest when comparing it to the previous entries. The superior graphics and voiced protagonist bring a whole new experience to the game. However, if you ask a fan whose first experience was Fallout 3, you'll receive a different answer.
2. Assassin's Creed III
Pleasing the long time fans of Assassin's Creed after Ezio's story came to a conclusion was no easy task for Ubisoft. To suddenly have to replace lovable, relatable, and charismatic Ezio was a challenge. Some say that the soft spoken and introverted Connor was a great departure from bold and brash Ezio. Connor's story is also an even more tragic one than Ezio's but is he as likable? Many would say no.
In addition to the debate on the protagonist, (and completely ignoring the present day narrative of the game), some fans were a little bummed out to find that the new exciting time period they could experience was the American Revolution.
It's a lesson you learn for years as a student in the United States, and although it's kind of a cool experience, many players felt that the time period had already been depicted countless times. To go from the Italian Renaissance to an empty yet blossoming colonial America was not something everyone was happy about.
The introduction to playing as a Templar was called interesting and different and there are many things that ACIII got right. The fanbase is still in debate though.
1. Dead Rising 3
Some people say that the zombie parody genre is old hat it should just die (and not reanimate). They say that destroying the hordes in ridiculous ways is nothing fun anymore. Some fans say that they're searching for substance within their favorite parody genres. Dead Rising 3 tried to tackle this need. However, there are lots of mixed reviews as to whether or not it was a good idea.
Nick Ramos' story is one filled with ethical questions and a more relatable backstory than what was given to us in the previous installments of Dead Rising. But some people felt as if Nick didn't fit into the world as well as Frank West or Chuck Greene. Criticisms included the idea that he was taking his role far too seriously for the protagonist of a zombie parody.
In addition to these comments, there was a mix of opinion on whether or not the game flowed mechanically. Some commented on it saying that the gameplay was "sloppy" and "loose," while others said it was an okay ride.
Maybe we'll be able to agree on the next one?