9 Ways The Last Of Us 2 Was Almost Completely Different

This was nearly a COMPLETELY different game.

The last of us abby
Naughty Dog

No video game is ever perfect from the off. The very nature of development is iterative and collaborative, with stories and gameplay changing as the years go on and everyone from the top level to the bottom pitch in their own ideas.

The Last of Us is no exception.

The first game famously had a rocky production process, with every idea thrown at the wall and then chopped and changed to get the masterpiece that eventually released. Now, you couldn't imagine a reality where Tess was the main villain of the game, or Joel was an ageing cop with a heart condition, but those were just two of the many original ideas that were changed.

As you can imagine, coming up with a sequel that both challenged and complemented the story of the first game was even more difficult for co-writers Neil Druckmann and Halley Gross. Thanks to some excellent interviews - in particular those with Washington Post, Kinda Funny and Indiewire - we now know just how different The Last of Us 2 could have been.

Were the changes for better or worse? I'll leave that up to you...


9. The Dance Was Originally Playable

The Last Of Us Part 2 Dina
Square Enix

One of the final scenes in TLOU 2 is actually one of the very first that Naughty Dog showed off (albeit, not in its entirety). The sequel picks up the night after a community dance in Jackson, where Ellie drunkenly kisses Dina and Joel threatens a man for being a homophobic ass.

While this night is conveyed beautifully in a cutscene towards the end of the game, Halley Gross revealed that it was originally a fully-playable section. Here, you could freely explore the church the dance was held in, have an optional conversation with Ellie's ex Cat, and take in the Jackson atmosphere.

There were even specific mini-games, with Gross elaborating to The Washington Post:

“Our designers built out these amazing games, and you could mix drinks, and you could pretend to be a Clicker and chase little kids using Listen Mode.”

What's even more interesting is this scene wasn't always saved for the end of the game (which could explain why it was shown off in the marketing). Gross explains that originally it was the opener, but kept being moved around until it was placed at the end to underscore Ellie and Joel's final reconciliation.


8. Joel Had A Girlfriend (Who Would Die)

The Last of Us Part 2
Naughty Dog

TLOU 2's opening is actually a sequence directly lifted from The Last of Us: One Night Live, an event held in 2014 which featured live music from composer Gustavo Santaolalla and Ashley Johnson and Troy Baker reenacting scenes from the original game. However, director Neil Druckmann slipped in something special for audience members only: a newly-written epilogue between Ellie and Joel.

Funnily enough, this turned out to be, almost beat for beat, the intro of TLOU 2 with Joel visiting Ellie and gifting her the guitar. The set up, the use of Pearl Jam's Future Days, even Joel's crappy joke were all there, with one slight alteration: in that live performance, Baker's character mentions his girlfriend, Esther.

For a long time, Esther was actually going to be featured in the sequel's story, but was one of the many characters cut to keep the focus on Ellie's arc. Gross explained that the new character would be the focal point of a scrapped flashback, that would have occurred six hours into the game.

This sequence would have seen Ellie and Joel visiting Esther, who lived on the outskirts of Jackson, near the dam from the original game. However, when they arrived, her house would be overrun with infected, and the two would find her dying inside. You'd then play as Ellie going to get water to comfort the dying woman, only to hear the gunshot, with it being ambiguous who pulled the trigger.

It already sounds like an emotional scene, but it would have incited a confrontation between Ellie and Joel, with the former lamenting that this wouldn't have happened had the Fireflies developed a cure.

Gross explained that it was ultimately cut because of the limited screen time Esther had, which effected how much you connected to the scene.

Apparently Esther still lived on in the form of a note penned by her you could read in Joel's house, but this too was cut shortly before release.


7. Ellie And Abby Each Had 5 Playable Days

The Last Of Us 2
Naughty Dog

The bulk of TLOU 2 takes place over three days in Seattle, told twice through the differing perspectives of Ellie and Abby. In the Indiewire interview however, Neil Druckmann and Halley Gross confirmed that originally each character had five playable days in the city.

While most of the content was left on the cutting room floor, Gross did confirm that Ellie's Day 4 would have embedded her more in the story of the Scars. The deleted segment would see her shipwrecked on the faction's home island during a storm (perhaps on her way to the Aquarium seen during the final version of Day 3), offering a look at the settlement before it's burned down later.

The concept driving it was similar to showing Jackson or the inside of the WLF stadium: Naughty Dog were attempting to give you an insight into the inner workings of the community, and show that there were innocent families and good people living similar lives to the other characters.

Apparently the sequence was quite lengthy, but received the chop because it felt like a diversion for Ellie's story. Gross explained to the Washington Post:

“It was really cool. The designers had a lot of great elements to it, but we ended up scrapping it because it didn’t move [Ellie's] story along narratively. It was like cool gameplay, cool setup [and] did something really nice in terms of expounding on the enemy.”

6. Laura Bailey Originally Auditioned For Dina

The Last Of Us 2
Naughty Dog

It's difficult to think of a game series better cast than The Last of Us. These actors have become synonymous with their characters, and that relationship has given us some of gaming's best ever performances.

Ashley Johnson and Troy Baker as Ellie and Joel are of course the first that come to mind, but it's arguably Laura Bailey as Abby who had the most difficult job ahead of her. Not only does Abby demand an incredible amount of versatility and nuance to do the writing justice, but her transformation from monster who killed a beloved character to someone who could be redeemed in the eyes of the audience needed to be convincing in order for players to not immediately revolt.

Bailey, of course, nails every aspect of this and then some, bringing both tender ferocity and an understated vulnerability to the controversial figure. However, the actor was not the first choice.

In fact, Neil Druckmann didn't want her in the game at all.

In an anecdote told on the Kinda Funny spoilercast, the director explained that Laura Bailey - quite rightly - is one of the most popular video game actors working, and he was looking for someone new to tackle the character. Initially, she was thought of for Dina instead, but after after auditioning a bunch of different candidates for Abby, only Bailey brought what he needed.

Apparently, most were playing Abby with straight-laced anger, going as large as possible whereas Bailey kept the vulnerability at the heart of the performance. She understood this isn't someone who is an uncompromising monster, but someone acting like one.


5. Ellie's Final Scene Was Less Ambiguous

The last of us 2
Naughty Dog

Like The Last of Us, TLOU 2 ends on an ambiguous note. After returning to the farm to find it empty following sparing Abby, Ellie attempts to play the guitar one final time, before leaving it behind and venturing off to an unknown future.

It leaves plenty up to player interpretation (Will she return to Jackson? Would Dina take her back? Is she cutting ties with communities entirely?), but the original version of that scene had more clues hinting at the outcome.

Neil Druckmann recalled that co-writer Halley Gross included a small beat before Ellie leaves the farm, showing her picking up one of JJ's toys. The implication being she's going to return to Dina and their child in Jackson.

While that would still leave ambiguities, Druckmann felt the action implied too much about where she was headed, and opted to omit it for a more open-ended climax.


4. Joel's Death Was Totally Different

the last of us 2 ellie
Naughty Dog

Joel's death is by far the most important - and controversial - scene in the entire game, so it's probably no surprise that it was tinkered with over and over during the seven years the project took to make.

While there was never a version where Joel didn't die (though some team members allegedly wondered whether they'd made a mistake seeing the overwhelming response to the reveal trailer), both the macro and the micro elements of the scene were constantly in flux.

For instance, during the same anecdote where Druckmann reveal Bailey's audition tape for Abby, he also revealed that it was this key scene the producers used as a screen test. However, in this version, the character would actually torture Joel with a knife, rather than a golf club. It also would have been obvious that she was partly disgusted and left empty by her actions.

The most intriguing change happened quite late though, and concerned Joel's final words. Originally, as a result of being brutally beaten in the head, Joel was supposed to have been delirious when Ellie is pinned in front of him. Druckmann explained:

"Ellie’s being held down and Joel’s looking at her and we had this idea of like, “Oh man Joel’s brain is so fucked up at that moment that the only word that’s coming out of his mouth is his daughter’s name, ‘Sarah.'” It felt powerful, but then Troy [Baker] — to his credit — was like, “I don’t think he should say anything.”

3. Abby Murdered Joel Because Of His Hunter Days

The Last Of Us 2
Naughty Dog

While The Last of Us 2 was always going to feature Joel's death by the hands of Abby, the latter's reasoning was never set in stone. Though it's difficult to imagine a justification more thematically rich than Abby being the daughter of the Firefly surgeon Joel kills to save Ellie, the writers did have a cool idea that they initially ran with.

For a long time, Abby's actions weren't going to be tied to the Fireflies at all, and instead a flashback would introduce players to the character's family and caravan community. During these sections, it would be revealed that Tommy and Joel - in their peak Hunter days - killed Abby's family and destroyed her community, leaving her spending the rest of her life seeking revenge.

While the final version has a cleaner connection to the first title, it would have been fascinating to see how this altered story played out. The original game referenced the horrible things Tommy and Joel did to survive, and the sheer amount of people Joel crossed is something discussed often in the sequel.

This would have made it clear that, Fireflies or otherwise, there were plenty of people with justification to seek revenge on Joel, and he would always have to face the consequences of his past sins.

Ultimately the end result more neatly ties in with Ellie's story, but this is still a fascinating idea.


2. Ellie And Joel's Final Reconciliation

The last of us 2
Naughty Dog

One of the final scenes in the game is one of the most bittersweet, coming immediately after the dance hall segment and showing the final time Ellie and Joel interacted before his death. After two years of being on bad terms after admitting he killed the Fireflies and robbed the world of a cure, Ellie finally tells him that she's ready to start forgiving him.

Though the moment is tense and heated, the love between them is still there, and one thing is clear: this is going to a new beginning. They've wasted too much time, and they can finally start rebuilding.

Of course, this brief reconciliation is immediately robbed from them.

Partly why the scene works so well is because of how frosty their dynamic still is. This isn't closure for either of them, just a recognition that closure is in sight. Despite what it means for the future of their relationship, it's not the kind of conversation you'd want to be the final one with someone you love. There's no declaration of love spoken out loud in fact, and there are still some things left unsaid.

Again though, originally this was going to offer more closure for the pair. Initially the scene called for the two to hug, something which Ashley Johnson wasn't quite sure Ellie was emotionally ready for. She'd started to forgive Joel, but the two weren't quite there yet.

Druckmann agreed, as it's the kind of interpersonal missed opportunity that you would regret not taking if you knew you would never see this person again.


1. Ellie Kills Abby

Last of Us 2 Ellie
Naughty Dog

One major gripe The Last of Us 2's harshest critics have right now concerns Ellie and Abby's final fight. In the sequel, Ellie finally realises that revenge would be hollow, and that killing this person and threatening Lev would make her no better than some of the monsters she's scared of.

Some have called this a cop-out though, saying that the woman who killed Joel deserved to die and that by not taking her revenge, Ellie achieves nothing.

Though this isn't a criticism shared by the developers or myself, Ellie sparing Abby wasn't always how the game ended.

Druckmann has described a much bleaker finale, where the character actually does take her revenge and drown Abby on the beach. He explained:

"For more than 50 percent of the production, Ellie used to kill Abby at the end. Which gave a whole different kind of feel to the ending, and then another character would have to stop the cycle of violence. But at some point, through our conversations about Yara and Lev, we came to the realization that it wasn’t as honest to Ellie’s character that way. Deep down inside there’s goodness there. Hopefully she can go forward and build her life."

Watch Next


The Last Of Us Quiz: How Well Do You Remember The Original Game?

The Last of Us Prologue
Naughty Dog

1. What Is The Name Of Joel’s Daughter?

Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.