Anthem: 8 Reasons Why It Failed

What could've been.

Anthem game
Bioware

Anthem positively oozed potential and promise. That initial reveal during E3 2017 (which ended up being much closer to reality than most E3 reveals) promised something game-changing: A brand new IP that combines Iron Man-style flight mechanics with a Dragon Age fantasy world. But it didn't stop there, as we'd be getting co-op quests, loot-grinds, and a story worthy of a developer known best for immersive narratives and memorable characters.

Sadly, beyond the game-breaking/PS4-bricking problems, the story felt like it stuck in familiar territory, never striving for true originality. Character interactions had their moments but were firmly shoved to the background thanks to the game's seemingly-endless load screens and all-in-all rote missions. Even after a month's worth of patches and attempted fixes, Anthem's internal systems and structure guarantee a permanently flawed experience. It may reach a passable status in a year's time, but presently, Anthem has ultimately failed.

Instead of making timeless experiences that will live on in the hearts of players forever, you get a somewhat fun time-sink that will be (if it hasn't already) dropped for whatever entertaining loot-shooter comes next (oh hello, The Division 2, that was quick!).

Just where did it all go so wrong?

8. Released As A Foundation To Build On Rather Than A Full Experience

Anthem Game Colossus Shield
Bioware

If gaming companies aren't careful, the 'Games as a Service' model may kill the AAA gaming market, just like it killed much of the goodwill Anthem had.

Gamers don't like getting ripped off, and when a publisher openly acknowledges that what you're buying is essentially unfinished? There's bound to be some protest. After all, unless a game is free-to-play, entertaining gameplay can only get you so far. Without anything else to warrant further time investment and the price tag, players will forget to log in one day and then never come back.

Anthem is far from the only game to make this mistake, but it's easy to recognize how it has already suffered due to this financially-focused decision. Rather than allowing the devs to include more notable content (at the cost of delaying the game another half-year perhaps), EA let a half-baked product be sold as a fully-prepared course.

While this practice may not prevent you from initial financial success, it starts your game's relationship with players on the wrong foot. Instead of hooking a fanbase right away, you make them question whether they made the right choice in believing you, leading to an extremely questionable future for all involved.


7. Lore-Building Done Through Pause Menus

anthem game
Bioware

Show, don't tell. A core component of good storytelling that... Anthem doesn't follow.

There's a massive open world to rocket through, yet if you want to really learn anything about it, you've got to hit pause and scroll through the database. It may be in-game (looking at you, Destiny's Grimoire), but forcing players to not play if they want to scrape lore out of your title is an undeniable failure.

Think of the fictional worlds in this medium that you're invested in. The Elder Scrolls, Witcher, Bioware's own Mass Effect. All keep you invested thanks to the lore and world being developed through interactions with both it and the characters within.

Knowledge of different races, regions and more comes through dialogue and quests that you take part in, allowing the world-building to feel natural and cohesive across the game's structure.

Anthem too often sticks to the shortcuts of establishing a universe by way of exposition dumps, and that pause menu codex is really the only source to appreciate what's hidden under the surface. Bioware should've remembered the hard lesson Bungie had to learn with Destiny:

Codexes should be complementary, not mandatory for understanding a given universe.


6. Learning Nothing From Destiny

Anthem BioWare
EA

Speaking of 'lessons that should've been learned from Destiny,' Bungie's divisive shooter came out over 4 years ago and illustrated the rights and wrongs of shared world multiplayer games.

Even with all of the clear lessons established by that game's failings and over 6 years of development, Anthem makes so many of the same mistakes. Lack of content, compelling plotlines and a grind-fuelled gameplay loop are simply not acceptable, especially after all this.

Think about how long it took before The Taken King came out and the Destiny brand was legitimized a year after its initial release. Unlike Bungie's shooter, Anthem did not get off to a red-hot start and it's already casting serious doubt on the IP's future. Will the player base be patient enough to hold out until there are substantial content additions that flesh out the open (relatively-vacant feeling) world, similarly to The Taken King?

Leaving out any needed season passes was a nice touch, but with the best advice a current Anthem player can give to a potential one being 'Eh... wait for it to get better,' it's tough to convince gamers to buy in.


5. Load Screen Cop Outs

Anthem Menu
EA

When massive open world games like Red Dead 2 have a single loading screen during gameplay and you have endless (lengthy) ones splitting up every given moment, you know something's not right.

Handling multiplayer servers may have a fair share of processing demand, but the several-minutes-long loading screens placed between minuscule tasks (matchmaking, going to a mission, leaving one, etc.) feel more like the development team took an easy way out instead of pushing the tech further. Beyond the simple annoyance of it, any momentum the game has going for it at any time is continually ruined.

You're also ruining the immersion factor on top of everything else. Games like Anthem thrive when they can engage you and make everything feel believable. Not only do they add up to better playing experiences, but it also makes gamers more agreeable and far more likely to overlook any noticeable flaws.

Destiny suffered from this too (take a shot for every time that phrase is said), and Anthem decided to outdo Bungie, only to make the problem worse.


4. Cashing In On Latest Trends Over Creating Something Timeless

Anthem Game 3
Bioware

Games like Mass Effect and Dragon Age Origins will continue to be replayed because they are simply great games that will never feel outdated. Instead of continuing this, Bioware hopped on the shared-world loot-grinder trend, putting out a game with mindless flying and shooting, leading to nothing memorable.

Beyond the obvious reasons behind this genre taking off, what positives are there?

Who remembers the stories and characters (besides Cayde-6) in Destiny or The Division? What moments shocked or stimulated any kind of emotional response? None. None of them did. Probably because everything was largely serviceable or surface-level fun that fades away the moment it's over. There's nothing timeless; no replay value to speak of - just something you can pick up every so often or never think about again when you're done.

What does Anthem do that warrants repeat playthroughs? You can shoot, you can fly, but once those two components become ordinary, what's left? Chances are, most players' journey through Fort Tarsis and its surroundings is a one-time trip.


3. EA Didn't Let Bioware Be Bioware

Anthem Game
EA

EA did not allow Bioware to make a Bioware game with Anthem. No memorable stories or characters (the developer's bread and butter) to be found, only generic personalities that largely distribute quests at you like you're a beggar that just wants substantial content.

The dialogue wheel has been removed in favor of a more binary system that's mostly just two contrasting options. With no relationship system to really speak of, you need to squint to see Bioware's identifying markers within Anthem.

It's frustrating too, as every so often you'll see the true Bioware, desperately trying to fight out of EA's constraints. You'll get into the occasional enjoyable character interaction that brings momentary bliss, only for it to end and you're kicked back into place.

The reality of Anthem? It's a game that feels too familiar in too many areas and never does enough with its story and characters to help raise the experience above that mountain of issues. There's no developer identity to give it any soul. Whereas many of Bioware's previous creations felt like heartfelt realizations of years' worth of work, Anthem feels like a corporate entity, through and through.


2. Largely Amateur Mission Design

anthem game
Bioware

Bioware has been responsible for a number of wonderfully creative, endlessly entertaining missions through the years. Anthem does not continue this.

Beyond a couple of notable missions, you're largely just going to be shooting bad guys and protecting safe points. The game relies on players getting creative on their own to take the place of actual variety, while the game itself remains painfully close-minded and simple.

How did this happen? You've got an impossibly-pretty world and undeniably-cool Javelin suits, but absolutely nothing imaginative set up for them. It's like investing in a world-class sports car, only to drive it to and from your job. Where are the thrills? Couldn't you have mixed it up a little, break up the ho-hum nature of (seriously, again) the same missions that ruined Destiny.

Mission variety is essential in these shooters (while also being incredibly rare), serving as a key factor when players are deciding which looter-shooter they're going to invest their free time into. Alas, Anthem elects to stick with the ordinary, making its slew of campaign missions increasingly-repetitive and ultimately, a slog to complete.


1. Broken Loot System

Anthem Loot
Electronic Arts

Even if you were willing to forego everything that has already been mentioned, Bioware still seem utterly incapable of making a workable, satisfying loot system, for a game who has its loot system as its very foundation.

Collecting rare and, eventually, Legendary weapons serves as a key to progressing through Anthem's endgame content. While you may attempt to continue with Epic or Masterwork-tiers, Legendaries are the key to success.

Big problem though: Legendaries are exceedingly rare.

Now, you may say 'But that's the point, they should be tough to get!', and while you're right in some sense, this is a system that goes beyond 'just being tough.' As detailed by Forbes' Paul Tassi, the drop rate for these items is atrociously low. Like getting 8 Legendaries after 100+ hours low. And even when you get these items, they could be hopelessly outclassed by another if the inscriptions are lacking.

While Destiny had a low drop rate for peak-performance items, you only really needed one of them. Once you had that Legendary gun, you wouldn't really need anymore. In Anthem, you'll never have enough to progress, just an endless loop of grinding for little reward. It makes sense why Bioware would purposely inflate playtime like this, but they sure didn't have to be so transparent about it.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Anthem
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gamer, movie lover, life-long supporter of Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man and Ben Affleck's Batman, you know the rest.