Assassin’s Creed 4: 10 Major Problems It Has To Fix
Now GTA V and FIFA 14 have been unleashed on the world, the next big game you should be anticipating is Assassins Creed IV: Black Flag. The sixth game in the series (the numbering system got dropped for a couple of years), this time around we get another fresh historical setting; after the crusades, renaissance Italy and revolutionary America we now get to hit the high seas as an eighteenth century privateer. Aside from the obvious awesome factor of pirates, Black Flag has an interesting hook; its a prequel to Assassins Creed III. Well be playing as previous hero Connors Grandfather, Edward Kenway, and hopefully experience some of the events only hinted at in the epic revolution story; maybe well see just what pushed Haytham into the Templar Order. Black Flag arrives with a tricky job to do; it has to win the doubters back. Despite giving us a very interesting tale in the Creed universe, Assassins Creed III didn't quite hit the heights of the previous entries in the series, which can be seen with the polarizing views of fans. Although the overall game was enjoyable, there were vast stretches that came out as monotonous and many wider concepts felt a little half baked. Here are the ten biggest problems from the previous instalment that Assassins Creed IV has to fix if its to survive in a year full of mammoth releases.
10. An Engaging Present Day Side
Given how Assassins Creed III ended its unlikely well be taking control of Desmond Miles again. Instead the present day protagonist of Black Flag will be an Abstergo analyst using either Desmond or his fathers stored memories (that throwaway line about Abstergo downloading your pasts has ended up being quite important). While its really just a plot device to make up for killing the hero, it gives the opportunity to do something no other game in the series has done successfully; have an interesting modern set story. The first few outings merely used the animus as a way to deliver key plot moments through cinematics and even when things got more adventurous, they were still an afterthought; I liked the brief first person levels in Revelations, but IIIs real world missions felt a little too scripted. Even when it was at its best, Desmond was a bland character which made extended time with him a chore. Giving us a proper taste of Assassins (or Templars) in the present would be a real ace in Black Flags hand. Ubisoft made the decision to not just have this be a historical tale, so why not relish in that a little?
9. Worthwhile Money System
I'll be the first to admit the Assassin's Creed monetary system has always been flawed. Nonexistent in the first, once introduced it was always a little too easy to amass huge funds over a relatively short period of time. The obsessive gamer in me would be so driven by completionism that I'd end up with all the best weapons and all the money I'd ever need before venturing into Sequence 4. From that angle I can't fault Ubisoft for trying something different from not only the previous games, but the industry as a whole. On an execution level, however, trading was horrible. Having to craft one item to craft another item to send that off to wait ten minutes for £1000 was not only time consuming, but boring. The crafting menu was so unwieldy after a couple of attempts to use it I gave up; playing through the missions ended up giving me just enough to buy the maps, weapons and ship upgrades I wanted. This is unlikely to be an issue in Black Flag. The whole notion of being a pirate promises a pillaging based money system that makes earning even small amounts fun; Id happily make half what I would from trading if I was doing something that didn't have me sighing every two minutes.
8. Additional Objectives That Make Sense
One of the best additions to the core gameplay in 2010's Brotherhood was the optional primary mission objectives. Suddenly the ways of being an Assassin could be highlighted. Sure, someone doing a quick playthrough could complete the missions however they felt like, but those wanting the proper Ezio experience could hunt down targets exactly as he did. In an attempt to make the game harder (one thing people never praised Assassins Creed games for was their difficulty) the optional objectives were made a little trickier and a lot more specific in AC3. And in most parts it worked to challenge you to find the best killing method. But in a fair few missions you could easily spend an hour plus trying to find the one sequence of events that got you 100% completion. Things like not knocking into any citizens and timed naval missions were pretty much down to luck thanks to the unpredictability of NPCs, while many of them (particularly ones that required you to remain undetected or timed chases) required you to know exactly what would happen in the mission before it started. Now this is less testing your ability to be a good assassin, but willingness to sit through the levels until you know every scripted event by heart, betraying the whole notion why these were introduced in the first place.
7. Axe The Leading Camera
The naval missions we got last year were a great introduction to seafaring ways with a lot of variety for a side mission. From the preview videos it looks like everythings been kicked up a notch; ships are fast, inter-ship gun play has more complexities and, hopefully, one of the most annoying (although I have to say trivial) examples of a computer controlled camera in gaming has been removed. Theres nothing worse than to be sailing the Aquila full throttle in a wide turn, only for the camera to force you to look to the side at a group of pirates youd have noticed anyway. From making you smash into friendlies to adding unnecessary pressure to timed missions, these are simple moments that riled me up every single time. It sounds so petty, but when youre on your tenth naval mission, only to have to be shown something that could easily be made out on the mini map feels a little patronising. I understand that there was a lot riding on how fans took these missions, given how essential they are in getting us ready for extended sailing in the prequel, so am happy to ignore this one as a legitimate criticism of Assassins Creed III in general, but will be rather annoyed if it survives through to Black Flag.
6. Please Give Us An Emotional Story (And Someone Relatable)
The original Assassins Creed now comes across as little more than a tech demo for the franchise; many of the key elements are here, but the depth we now expect was yet to be introduced. Altair still stands as one of the most important assassins - his outfit is always a much coveted unlockable - but his lone outing succeeded solely on gameplay. It was Ezio Auditore who really who really made the franchise one with relatable characters. Seeing him develop over the course of three games from cocky playboy to tired Grand Master, all among a vibrant setting previously unseen in gaming had us completely involved in the plot full of minor, otherwise forgettable historical players. Even Desmond, in the original almost called Stock Hero, was attempted to be filled with some character beyond being plot essential (success or not isn't important). Connor (and Haytham) were interesting characters, but it was hard to get an emotional connection to them. Noah Watts did a good job giving Connor dialect-free speech, but that inadvertently made him feel aloof and ruined any chance of creating an emotional conflict between him and his father (menacingly voiced by Adrian Hough). For Black Flag to sit alongside both the series best (and for Edward to take on definitive pirate characters like Jack Sparrow) there needs to be a little more relatability this time around.
5. Stop With The Frigging Stylised Scenes
Games are becoming more cinematic at a meteoric rate. It used to be trailers would be made specifically on a more advanced engine, but as GTA V showed we're at a point graphically and creatively where entirely in-game content can be used to sell your game. But just because you can do things in a more creative way doesn't necessarily mean you should. Assassins Creed IV would be wise to not make the same mistakes as its predecessor and axe the stylised scenes that punctuated AC3's gameplay. The first time this becomes painfully obvious is the culmination of Sequence 8. After Connor waits a little too long to call his Assassins in to stop his execution the game suddenly moves into slow motion. At first I was convinced the game was glitching (again), but it sadly turns out to be a purposeful inclusion (although I still cant work out if it was for effect or a lazy way of showing Connor was affected by his hanging). Worse was the games climax, where youre forced to fight Haytham injured, then got to hunt Charles Lee down in the same state. Being forced to limp everywhere with a flashing red screen in an attempt from the game to show youre injured doesn't actually get me any more involved in the game. Thats ignoring that doing this highlights the characters otherwise invulnerability; you can survive falls from great heights and countless sword blows, but a couple of rocks have you limping for the next few hours.
4. A Point To Training Recruits
Another great feature added into the Ezio games that turned up in AC3 in a butchered form was Assassin recruitment. I really appreciated being able to jump into the Guild menu from any point (pigeon posts are so 16th Century), but oddly enough found myself visiting it a lot less than when you had to go to specific points to access it. In Brotherhood training your own team of Assassins to call for in battle was an exciting new concept and Revelations increased the customizability and turned sending your recruits out on missions into a proper mini game where leaving the greater map for too long lost your foothold across the Mediterranean. What we got in III felt like it should have been a version from a previous game, not a follow on. There was no chance of you losing the states you liberated and with only three levels of mission difficulty there was little challenge. Recruiting Assassins did bring with it new abilities, but once you had the citizens on side there was no motivation (i.e. no new missions once they became Master Assassins) to do anything but call them into battle. This is one of the few non fetch quest/fighting side missions that is actually interesting in Creed, so an unneutered version in Black Flag would be really welcomed.
3. Proper Explanation Of Key Game Elements
Jump onto Yahoo Answers and look at Assassins Creed III discussions for an odd sight; theres multitudes of people asking simple questions about the games core mechanics. This isn't because they've not been paying attention to the tutorial moments, but thanks to the game half-heartedly explaining it's central concepts. But wait, weren't the first six hours or so of the game one massive scripted tutorial? Correct, which makes this oversight particularly heinous. How you expose a frigates power kegs (ram it head on), the intricacies of liberating districts (complete all the seemingly optional and never ending side missions, including those that dont show up on the map, then do a proper liberation mission) and the purpose of forts (they add a couple more hours of gameplay) were all skirted over. These were some of the games better side elements and yet took too much time to really understand. Its fine for the game to leave exploration of all its concepts up to the player, but when other elements (naval missions) have more than enough time dedicated to them it feel imbalanced. Id be happier weathering the restrictive tutorial if it allowed me to best explore the good stuff.
2. Interesting Side Missions
Do you play an Assassins Creed game to scale the highest buildings and kill Templars or to play boules and walk back and forth across the map to deliver romantic messages? If your answer veers anywhere towards the latter go play Animal Crossing (and thats not a criticism; its awesome in a non-killing way). I'm not saying that more human side missions are a bad thing, but in Assassins Creed III things were pushed a little too far; you could spend hours doing missions you'd only ever think of attempting if you're trying for 100%. It could easily be a case of less is more. Remove some of the lacklustre Homestead missions and repetitive stuff like the Boston Brawlers and the game wouldn't feel any less expansive, but thered be fewer stretches that felt monotonous. Exploring the tunnels to find all the fast travel points was rewarding, but more in relief its over than actually having enjoyed the past couple of hours. That feeling is really emblematic of much of Assassins Creed III. This is the one thing Black Flag could so easily improve on; being a pirate is a lot more interesting than being a native American and with it comes a generally more exciting life and activities.
1. Deal With The Glitches Before Release
When Assassins Creed III first made its way into the hands of the fans the excitement was quickly dissipated by the high level of glitches present. I appreciate the animus was built into old rock this time, but you think Rebecca would have been able to get things running smoothly after ramshackle set ups twice before. There were the little things - your galloping horse passing a tree stump causes it to stop suddenly, boarding a ship loses all of your ammo and certain upgrades (such as dual wielding pistols) were removed whenever you fast travelled - that made a lengthy play session an experience punctuated with exasperated cries, but its the crashes and hidden mission icons that directly affected the overall enjoyment of the game. These were eventually fixed in a massive patch by Ubisoft, but it came two months after the games initial release, meaning most fans had already beaten and shelved Connor's adventure. Releasing an inferior product to make the pre-Christmas bucks with the intention of fixing it later on isn't fair to loyal fans. As GTA showed, people are happy to put up with not getting a new game every year if the polish in what we do get is so high. Are there any more problems from the previous games you want Assassin's Creed IV to fix? Tell us down in the comments.