Batman: Arkham Asylum vs Arkham City, Which Game Is Better?
Both are visually stunning and outstanding games to play and enjoy but just which one is the best? Let’s find out...
Theres just something about Batman. The DC character captivates, excites and moves us without comparison in this era where he dominates the box office, animation and more and more; gaming. Rocksteadys Batman game series is the most decorated comic book video game series of all time and, without compare, the best. However debate continues over which of the two games released is the strongest of the outfit; the surprise package, tightly honed, Poison Ivy in tiny clothes filled Arkham Asylum? Or the open world, expansive game noir and Talia Al Ghuls behind featuring in Arkham City? Both are visually stunning and outstanding games to play and enjoy but just which one is the best? Lets find out... Gameplay:
Arkham Asylum
Sees a focus on stealthy, ninja like action, hi-tech detective work and gadgets, Batman: Arkham Asylum opened up a new world of gameplay; making it intelligent, mysterious and interesting as well as action filled and kinetic. However the rather small playable world hinders the enjoyment taken from the game the further it progresses; as the completion of rooms of villains becomes quickly formulaic and easy to master. Where the introduction of a need for stealth whilst you scout the environment and guards is a captivating way of playing through the game to begin with; that quickly changes as the constant indoor settings meaning this can become dull and easy to achieve as it continues. The boss missions are always different and the slight addition of new technology, like timed bombs on the gargoyles, help keep it slightly more interesting but the core of the games action gameplay is very formulaic and it hinders Arkham Asylum. Gameplay Rating: 4/5
Arkham City Arkham City keeps the core principles of Arkham Asylum in terms of stealth, combos and the use of gadgets but surpasses its predecessor through its much larger and more varied open world. Balancing outdoor environments and indoor ones helps keep this game more stimulating than Asylum as its very rarely that you need to do identical tasks to progress. The varied and outstandingly detailed City environment gives both more difficult stealth exercises to get in to buildings you need to progress in as well as more expansive; out and out dust ups in the streets. The new option of wild, outdoor fighting allows you to swoop in to areas, attack, grapple, attack again, rush and escape with a quickly placed smoke pellet; rather than just twiddle around a few gargoyles. The more exciting gadgets featured on Batman and the villains help add to the excitement; motion mines, sniper rifles, grenades and more really push you and make this game a more stimulating game to play through the majority of its gameplay. Gameplay Rating: 5/5
Style
Arkham Asylum One feature often mentioned in comparisons between these two games is the apparent more attention to detail in Arkham Asylum; and it is visible. Though both games take quite a film noir style to their environments and storytelling style the differences are there and it is perhaps better in Arkham Asylum. The smaller world gives more depth to the environments and more differentiation for each area and boss which is more stimulating than consistent darkness. Although it being set in one complex depicts that the architecture stays similar the game does manage to differentiate its styles for the villains; Scarecrow and Poison Ivy are particular standouts as well as the Botanical Gardens. Style Rating 5/5Arkham City
The spectacular open world displayed in Arkham City brings with it the drawback that more often than not areas of the city are dull as they resemble so greatly the rest of it. The advantage Arkham City should have over Arkham Asylum when it comes to the style of their environments is the wide scope should give them the freedom to design new areas with different styles and very rarely do they actually do it. The smaller area in Asylum helps give them consistency which they build upon and develop however the environments in City are too similar when they should differ. Some areas, like the Mr. Freeze mission, Ras Al Ghul mission and the docking area near the old steel mill are visually outstanding and lift the game above its predecessor; however so many of the boss battles are told with the same uniform style that they become difficult to differentiate and gives the game less stand out moments than Asylum. Style Rating: 4/5
Quality of Villain
Arkham Asylum Tightly honed is needed to be used again here as its significantly less villain count than City helps elevate it to higher levels; as they give more strength and devotion to each one. The Joker above all else is superior in Arkham Asylum where there is the advantage of no split focus to keep him a constant and captivating threat. Part of Asylums brilliance comes from the fact that The Joker is always the top of the tree and every other villain is seemingly being orchestrated by his elaborate plot and Batman needs to defeat each one to uncover more of the mystery and help further his goals. Scarecrow as well is an exceptional addition to the fray who consistently elevates this game to new heights and feels like a constant threat; and the sporadic nature of his arrivals keeps you constantly on edge. Villain Rating: 5/5Arkham City
Where tightly honed is the best description for Arkham Asylum it can be constantly said that Arkham City suffers from Over reach and this is consistently applicable; especially with its villains. Theres just. So. Many. Of. Them. Where this should have made the game more interesting and more challenging; it just deadens the novelty of seeing these great individual villains. The people who suffer the most are Two-Face and Penguin who really offer very little to the proceedings. Penguin feels like an uncharismatic and threatless Joker you just want to squish with your massive Bat-boot. Similarly making both Hugo Strange and The Joker major players at the top is handled so poorly that at times you forget about the other one as a threat. It tries so hard to be a bigger game than Arkham Asylum that it negates the great aspects of the focused villains in the first one. Villain Rating: 3/5
Standout Sections
Arkham Asylum http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D9aibilbJrU Is there any other section worth thinking about than every Scarecrow one? Such harrowing, visually beautiful sections that appear quite randomly and are all the more scary for it. More importantly though, one of these things that elevate these games above others is how you continue to connect with Bruce Wayne as Batman and the relationship with his family is how they do this and its used to great effect here as it moves you just as much as it elevates the quality of the game. Standout Section Rating: 5/5Arkham City http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CLl7WuDcvDg The omission of Scarecrow from Arkham City is a glaring one but one that only promises great things for the inevitable sequel. Citys standout sequence is, if anything, an homage to the Scarecrow ones from Asylum. Featuring cracking visuals, Batman in a desperate situation, Bruces parents and Talia Al Ghul in a tight outfit this entire sequence is the most memorable in Citys short story and by far the most interesting in terms of Batman mythology and gameplay. Dont take my word for it; see it yourself. Standout Section Rating: 5/5Story
Arkham Asylum Arkham Asylum is a compact, story focused mystery and chase game that benefits from how much emphasis they put on the story they craft. Very little feels fruitless and everything is about stopping The Joker and the threat you must uncover. By maintaining this overall focus it gives you drive and purpose throughout every mission and the bonus features are well and truly optional; not a staple. The story as well plays on the intertwining of the villains to make them a real united front against Batman, Killer Croc is a horror and the titan formula surrounding the mythology of the Arkham Asylum complex is one that intrigues and makes you believe youre fighting for something very important. Story Rating: 5/5Arkham City
The split focus that hampers how well the villains are utilised is what undermines the story of Arkham City, starting off with Hugo Strange and Protocol 10 perks interest, but then you shoot straight to the Joker and the search for an antidote. Having more than one plot isnt a negative thing however the handling is horribly unbalanced and by the time you finish one; the other rears its ugly head and you struggle to remember why thats important. Furthermore Hugo Stranges mentioning of a greater master is as predictable as it is a cop out to not giving a great villain more of a presence than just being someone elses worker. As well as that the game really misses a trick with the inner gang politics that would prevail through Arkham City, its talked about by common thugs but never really built upon as part of the narrative. At the end of the day all these criminals in one place will develop clear structures and unsettling them as each head honcho develops plans for destruction could have been an incredibly interesting to deal with and make the game as expansive story wise as it is by just sheer size wise. Story Rating: 3/5
Overall
Both games are outstanding and are up there with the best games Ive ever played however Arkham Asylum, quite simply, wipes the floor with Arkham City which chooses open world over the brilliant features of the original and fails to really engage us as much as the predecessor. Both are visually stunning and enjoyable games to play however the level of engagement in Arkham Asylum just outstretches Citys attempt to overawe you with wide eyed size and spectacle. Even though the expanding of City leads to, at times, more interesting game play and improvements of the gadgets and array of things to compete with; this is what is expected when a hugely successful game has a sequel. However where it improves on some of the more superficial aspects its wider scope makes it a poorer article to the lovingly made and perfectly made Arkham Asylum. So what do you think? How would you rate these two games? Comment below!