Batman: Arkham Knight - 7 Past Franchise Mistakes It Needs To Avoid

Where do Rocksteady go for the big finale?

Batman: Arkham Asylum blew both fans and casual gamers away by not only presenting an amazing game, but also revolutionising the superhero genre and proving that a solid title could be produced within it. It wasn't just the engaging story, but also the realistic combat and stealth systems that put players in the mind of one of the greatest superheroes ever created. In a lot of ways, it held the same impact as Batman Begins. The critical and commercial success set up the game's developers, RockSteady, for a surefire sequel which came in 2011 as Batman: Arkham City. Both Arkham Asylum and Blackgate Prison have been shutdown, their prisoners relocated to a mass containment camp called Arkham City. So many great changes were done to make the game feel like a worthy successor, such as the ability to use gadgets in combat and more takedown options during predator. Yet for all its advances, Arkham City did lack a certain spark that Asylum had previously possessed. While some can attribute this solely to the initial power the first game hit us with via its allure, analysing the two games showcases that RockSteady did make some negative choices during the development of City. We can only hope RockSteady noticed them too, and are going in a more nostalgic direction with Arkham Knight.

7. A Fragmented Story

The narrative of Arkham Asylum is what really made the experience of playing more memorable. Every event in the story was connected in a strong way, from the beginning where Joker breaks out, to the revelation that Bane is the source of the Titan formula. It was all one big mystery, full of plenty of action and suspense. In Arkham City we did start off with a solid premise in Strange planning on activating an unknown command called Protocol 10, though not too long after the main thread took a complete one-eighty; Batman was now poisoned and must find a cure. It was disappointing because the whole mystery angle of what Strange was up to took a backseat to having to get the better of Joker in an unconventional method. It wasn't just that, but also the way each arc was connected felt more fragmented than it should have. For example, it never made much sense why Penguin happened to be holding Mr. Freeze captive. Likewise, the antidote for the Titan poisoning just happened to be Ra's al Ghul's blood. Whereas in Asylum, the reasoning came off better executed, such as when Harley and Joker released Ivy to create more trouble for Batman and when she told Batman he would have to go into Killer Croc's lair to obtain the venom roots. City's story was still damn great, but for Arkham Knight's we hope that RockSteady look to what made Asylum so magnificent. The fact that Paul Dini who had penned the previous two games' narratives isn't returning is saddening, but as he told fans, "trust in RockSteady".

6. Underused Villains

Arkham Asylum had a total of six villains in its story (Joker, Harley, Croc, Bane, Ivy, and Scarecrow) compared to the ten in City (Joker, Harley, Penguin, Two-Face, Ivy, Strange, Ra's al Ghul, Solomon Grundy, Mr. Freeze, and Clayface). To clarify, this is not to say that Arkham City had too many villains (we were all very eager to see RockSteady's take on all the classic antagonists), but none of them seemed to be used to their fullest potential. Two-Face for instance, was just a catalyst to jumpstart the plot and didn't appear again until the end with Catwoman. Grundy was categorised as nothing more than just a monster under Penguin's control and Strange himself remained shrouded in obscurity the entire time, with only hints at his grotesque past being revealed. The plot synopsis of Arkham Knight has already lead fans to believe that there will be a plethora of rogues to fight since Scarecrow is going all out against the Caped Crusader with every available resource he has. Let's hope that each villain isn't just reduced to boss fight fodder.

5. Side Missions

I was really excited when I found out there would be side content in Arkham City as that was something I felt Asylum lacked. I'm not just talking about Riddler stuff, but entire tasks dedicated to taking down supervillains that otherwise didn't fit into the story. Sadly that wasn't the case. Out of the 12 side missions, only six were dedicated to a villain, and of those six only two were truly satisfying. Really the problem was the missions were either pointless, disappointing, or time-oriented to the point of being annoying. Pointless missions were the likes of having to collect new gadgets or do small-time challenges reliant on an unknown clock programmed in the game, meaning players would have to wait until the event occurred (as was the case with Deadshot, Hush, and the political prisoners). Then the all-out disappointing missions were where the villain was reduced to all talk and no game such as Zsasz or Bane. In the end, Riddler and Mad Hatter were the only ones that truly stood out as worth completing. For Arkham Knight, surely all of Batman's villains won't make it into the story, regardless of how big RockSteady blows it up to be. We'd like the side missions to really pack some power as some of the Dark Knight's rogues take the opportunity of an evacuated city to reign anarchy and destruction.

4. Leaking Too Much Beforehand

By the time Arkham City came out in October 2011, anyone who had been keeping up with the marketing knew every villain in the game but Clayface and Hush. Not only that, but most of the new setting had already been made known through both E3 demos and accidental leaking. While it is obviously very hard to keep leaks on a triple-A project from happening, the problem with Arkham City was that Rocksteady marketed every aspect of the game too much. It lead to too many assumptions and expectations arising to the point where a lot of the game's surprises lost their impact. Arkham Asylum had the advantage of keeping most of its content secret, resulting in many powerful and fantastic moments as players went through the game. With Arkham Knight, we hope that RockSteady takes a page out of WB Games Montreal's book by preventing much information about the game from getting leaked to the public. As much as I respect them, they aren't off to a completely good start considering all the knowledge we now have of the Batmobile.

3. Relying Too Much On In-Game Data

The increased number of villains and the passage of one year between Asylum and City, it left lots of background information necessary for the complete understanding of the game. While writer Paul Dini resolved some of this with a limited-edition series set between the two games, the majority of the setting's background was told through data gathered through various side-quests (mostly completing Riddler content). The problem with this method was that it came off more as lazy than anything else. It seemed as though in order to make their many story points more authentic, the writers wrote these up as an excuse to not include a more in-depth narrative. For instance, I'm sure many of us were very surprised to find this strange place called Wonder City beneath Gotham. If you didn't take the time to discover and read the stories, you would play through the entire story without knowing what it was without Ra's al Ghul's involvement. Same thing applies to Grundy's presence underneath the Iceberg Lounge and many other smaller examples. Arkham Knight is only going to expand on Arkham City's mythology through many more side stories to made up the backstory, however when it comes to key plot points in the narrative the creators should put more thought into fleshing them out wholeheartedly than relegate the majority of their substance to potentially hidden goodies.

2. Catwoman

Before everyone starts jumping on me, note that playing as Catwoman was enjoyable; her different style of fighting was interesting to adapt to and RockSteady got her navigation programming down, more or less. The main problem was how her sections were implemented. They were meant to stall during cliffhanger moments in Batman's story, but the end result just came off as jarringly unconnected to the main storyline. We knew Catwoman was supposed to be doing her own thing, but if you think of it like playing Arkham Asylum, it would be something closer to every few hours of story there being a section where you take control of Commissioner Gordon and solve mysteries for half an hour. Catwoman's tale should've had a structure that paralleled Batman's in some way, not be completely random with a last-minute scenario to tie it all together for the sake of DLC-justification. If RockSteady does decide to include more playable characters in the Arkham Knight story, such as different members of the Bat Family (Nightwing, Robin), their actions should be tied back to the narrative in some way so that it doesn't feel like they're isolated.

1. Riddler Trophies - Quantity Over Quality

Many love that RockSteady took advantage of their larger space in regards to Riddler challenges, as they ended up putting in a total of 440 riddles and trophies to be completed/collected respectively. You'd think this would be fun for players who are fans of side content, and although many did chew through the huge number on offer, the main issue was that there really wasn't much of a challenge to them. To give credit where it's due, some of the trophies took some brainpower to solve; however, for the most part, the trophies were as easy as stepping on a button and using the batclaw gadget. Riddler is already confirmed to be back in Arkham Knight, and there's no doubt that we will have at least as much content from him as we did in City. Let's just hope that RockSteady focuses on making them something that only the World's Greatest Detective could solve instead of a simple collectible.

Contributor

Red Stewart is big fan of the entertainment industry, with insights into film, television, and video games for starters. Despite growing up in the 21st century's era of modernization, he prefers many retro era ideas over the current trends found in many of today's media. Personally he's an introvert who loves reading as much as gaming.