Batman: Arkham Knight - 8 Reasons The Joker Should Stay Dead

Fans are divided when it comes to Batman's greatest villain making a return, but maybe him remaining out the picture is for the best?

Sticking to your guns isn't easy, but in the trilogy-capper to Rocksteady's highly revered Arkham franchise, it's the most crucial element to end the series on the highest note possible. More specifically, the decision to kill off The Joker in the climax of Arkham City must be kept in check. If not, we're all going to be playing one disappointing next generation system-seller come this October. In recent interviews the studio have confirmed that The Joker is dead, but can they really be trusted when Warner Brothers Montreal blatantly lied to anyone and everyone with interest in Arkham Origins by swearing up and down that he wasn't in the game, when in actuality he was the main villain? Probably not. This isn't an article meant to bash The Clown Prince of Crime; he's arguably Batman's greatest villain and most certainly the yin to his yang. There comes a point though where the fans and developers have to say "Enough is enough" in unison, realising that what€™s best for Arkham Knight is to keep the legendary character out of the game completely. The only instance that an appearance from The Joker could be accepted is if it comes from an Easter Egg that has nothing to do with the story, or as a hallucinatory during one of the much-anticipated Scarecrow battle sequences. Outside of that, Rocksteady will be diminishing the quality of their own game if The Joker is included further.

8. He Doesn€™t Make For A Good Boss Fight

The Joker has now been featured as Batman's primary antagonist in all three Arkham games, and not a single memorable boss fight has come from it. Any time the story demands for Batman to have a confrontation with the diabolical madman himself, it either ends with a fight that is more Batman against a gauntlet of enemies with The Joker as background noise, or a sequence where he has a much more formidable and powerful villain fight for him. This isn't going to work for Arkham Knight; it's simply a game that needs a definitive final boss fight against a definitive villain and history proves that Joker fights specifically feel unmemorable and unsatisfying. Arkham Asylum has one of the dullest final boss fights in gaming history simply because you're not really fighting The Joker; it's just you fighting goons while a gigantically large version stands around on a platform waiting to have a QTE executed on him. Even the ending to Arkham Origins is just one extended interactive sequence were Batman pummels The Joker. The only reason Arkham City was able to get away with having him as a villain is because Clayface's emergence as the true final boss was a fantastically-executed twist, and because The Joker's surprise death was handled with so much delicacy that it became one of gaming's most unforgettable moments. Killing him twice can't cover up the fact that he makes for a terrible boss fight.

7. It Will Feel Forced

It truly was a shame when Black Mask was revealed to be The Joker in disguise during an early twist in Arkham Origins. Warner Brothers Montreal were - much to the surprise of gamers around the world - actually upping Rocksteady in some ways of the storytelling department. Not only was it darker and much more brooding, but they were using characters that don't often get a chance to be the true villain in a mainstream story arc, and creating a compelling tale of a young and reckless Batman who becomes the methodical and calculated Dark Knight we've come to know and love today. The twist unfortunately felt forced, and came across as Warner Brothers Montreal taking Black Mask as far as they could go, only to bring in a familiar face that is easier to write around. If Rocksteady decides to do something similar - like making the mysterious Arkham Knight secretly The Joker in disguise - it's only going to feel doubly forced. The fact that people are expecting these things so vehemently already is proof enough that this wouldn€™t be a surprise, but an annoyance.

6. Mark Hamill Has Moved On

Before getting into the meat of this entry, this isn't a way of saying Troy Baker delivered a disappointing performance in Arkham Origins. The verdict is actually quite the contrary; he wowed gamers and comic book fans alike, and was the sole redeeming factor of Joker once again weaselling his way into the spotlight. It also made sense to get different voice actors for a prequel that€™s purpose was exploring these characters in their rookie years. Meanwhile, it's already confirmed that Kevin Conroy is returning to voice The Caped Crusader in this climactic trilogy capper. Essentially, it just wouldn't feel right without Mark Hamill reprising his role once more too. That isn't going to happen however, as Mark Hamill has gone on record stating that Arkham City€™s portrayal was his final performance as, and honestly, it's a grand performance to go out on. Nothing more needs to be said or added. It's also worth noting that this isn't the first time that Mark Hamill has stated that he was done voicing The Joker only to cave and do so again, but this time he really seems done. And realistically, maybe it's time for him to give that character an eternal rest.

5. Harley Quinn Can Take His Place

One of the most enticing prospects of of keeping The Joker dead is that it opens the door wide open for other revered villains to step up and claim a major role. And who better to give a much larger role and further develop as a character than The Joker's squeeze; his equally psychotic and demented girlfriend Harley Quinn? Unfortunately, it has already been confirmed that Rocksteady will not be moving forward with the plot point of Harley having gotten pregnant, which was teased as an Easter Egg in Arkham City.It would've been a great and organic way to further develop a story centred on The Joker, but scrapping the idea doesn't mean there's nothing left for Harley to do. All Rocksteady needs to do is write her as a strong character that is hellbent on avenging 'Mistah J'. If the writers can really play up the fact that Batman took from her the only person she ever really cared about, it could add some complexity and sympathy to her character, despite the nefarious antics she is sure to commit throughout the game.

4. Batman€™s Emotional Stress

By now everybody knows that Batman has one rule, and that rule is to never kill anyone whether it be intentional or accidental. At the end of Arkham City he fails himself and breaks that rule. One of the most bittersweet moments in gaming is the shot of Batman exiting the theatre with The Joker dead in his arms. Bringing him back from the dead in a surprise twist or a random plot point will hurt the story and Batman's character. From the trailer it is already evident that even one year removed from the event, Batman is still in a state of emotional distress from failing to uphold his rule. That tension and consequence is gone entirely if The Joker is brought back, and the story would just turn into another game of cat and mouse between the two rivals that are seemingly intertwined in each other's fate. The central moral theme of the game needs to be about Batman dealing with - and eventually overcoming - the traumatic stress he has endured from killing another human being. And the only way to achieve that is by keeping The Joker rotting in a digital grave.

3. Other Villains Can Shine

Harley Quinn taking on a larger role in the grander scheme of things has already been discussed, but she isn't the only one that can stand to benefit from keeping The Joker off the disc and out of our screens. There are a plethora of classic villains that have already been introduced - and in some cases even have ongoing plot arcs - that can now finally step out of the shadows of side content, or stop having their screen-time buried by The Joker. From what's already known about Arkham Knight, the two primary villains seem to be Scarecrow - whom is apparently unleashing a deadly toxin on the city - and the Arkham Knight. So keep it that way, with semi-important appearances from characters like Harley Quinn and Two-Face. An interesting fact is that Rocksteady is promoting the Arkham Knight as a totally new character built from the ground up by DC. Maybe it's a cynical thought, but that statement feels like a cover-up for hiding the true identity of this mysterious character. Regardless of who it is, it simply cannot be The Joker; the familiarity of him as a villain will completely suck the momentum right out of the titular Arkham Knight; both character and game.

2. He€™s Headlined Three Games Already

It's already been mentioned that The Joker is Batman's greatest and most iconic arch-nemesis. No one will dispute that fact, but it simply gets tiring seeing the same villains headlining the same franchises. Not even Christopher Nolan used the Joker twice, and even if Heath Ledger had not died, he still probably wouldn't have used the character but rather have given him a cameo appearance, much like Cillian Murphy's Scarecrow traditionally got in The Dark Knight Trilogy. Additionally, there isn't a superhero franchise in history that repeatedly uses the same villains in subsequent films. What makes stories centered on superheroes so captivating in the first place is how different villains pose different moral and physical dilemmas to the character, how the hero proceeds to deal with it, and how to inevitably overcome it. Reaching back into an old bag of tricks simply isn't that exciting, and so the cinema counterparts of superhero lore choose to spice the stories up by adapting new baddies and challenging our modern day Greek Gods in new and interesting ways.

1. Rocksteady Should Live With Their Artistic Decision

In the moment, Rocksteady was undoubtedly excited that they were being given the creative freedom to kill off The Joker, and rightfully so. Very rarely are licensed games even good, let alone do they contain very bold creative decisions that pave the way for timeless moments. And so, Arkham City isn€™t just known as a magnificent license game, but the game that had the gall to kill The Joker. If Rocksteady were to undo all of that by bringing him back from the dead, it would honestly be perceived as a spit in the face to the fanbase. Nobody likes a copout, and resurrecting The Joker just because Rocksteady wants to or because his inclusion could guarantee more sales would be the definition of doing so. Whether the narrative is open to proceed on with something special or if it's backed into a corner is up to Rocksteady to decide, but they are the ones that put themselves in this situation. And the best way to deal with this situation - not just for the game but Rocksteady as a development studio - is to make the best out of their past decisions. They will be much more respected if they stick to their word and make a death meaningful by not going back on killing off a major character. Furthermore, sticking to their guns like that would build character as a development studio, sending a message that they don't toy around with the emotions of their loyal fans. Do you agree that The Joker should not be in Arkham Knight? Is he truly necessary? Leave your comments below!

Contributor
Contributor

I write for WhatCulture (duh) and MammothCinema. Born with Muscular Dystrophy Type 2; lover of film, games, wrestling, and TV.