Batman: Arkham Origins - 6 Major Flaws That Completely Ruined It

Arkham Origins C Paul Dini did the impossible with Arkham Asylum, making a superhero game that was both true to its source characters and fun to play, something that had only been achieved once before in Spider-Man 2. Asylum, along with City, is a love letter to the Batman franchise, using a wealth of characters to bring a truly original story for Bat fans and regular gamers, while at the same time providing some of the best fighting mechanics of the whole generation. They were, in my opinion, near perfect games, and after playing City all I wanted to do is go straight back in and experience it again. Arkham Origins, on the other hand, is a pathetic cash-in that suffers from poorer writing than most internet fan-fiction. This article is up so long after release that I, having stupidly pre-ordered the game in my childish anticipation, have been lying to myself as to the game's quality in order to justify the money I spent on it. However, the final stage of grief is acceptance, and that is where I am now. Warner Bros. have annihilated the reputation of their Arkham franchise and downright insulted both gamers and Batman fans with this game, so without further ado, here are the six reasons you should never buy Arkham Origins...

6. Atrocious Dialogue

Arkham Origins B My oh my does this game have some terrible dialogue. Most of the stinker lines come from Batman himself, with the writers showing him as some angry douche rather than the gallant hero he's supposed to be, mocking surrendering criminals as he cripples them for life: Crook, "Please! I give up, just don't hurt me!" - Batman (who is meant to be the good guy, remember), "Don't worry, it will only hurt when you breathe." Showing Batman with the personality of an angry teenager could be forgiven if it wasn't for the frequent '60s style puns, like when Killer Croc says, "The assassins are coming for you (paraphrased)," and Batman replies (and this is a direct quote!), "At least they won't be ugly." That doesn't even make sense. There is literally nothing more uncharacteristic and juvenile they could have had him say at that point and, as it happens near the start of the game, this establishes how little the writers know about their source material from the off. The only character the writers come close to going justice to is the Joker, and that's only because most of his lines are ripped directly from The Killing Joke (which I strongly suspect is the only Batman story these creators have ever written), but considering this is a franchise built on characterisation, it is inexcusable that only one in twenty major players are given decent representation. Speaking of what the series is based on, let's move over to the second foundation Warner Bros. Montreal took a sledgehammer to...

5. Deteriorated Combat

batman arkham origins As I said in the introduction, Arkham is famous for its brilliant combat, with City building on the firm groundwork placed by Asylum to create a structure more satisfying than a night in the Four Seasons with a Victoria's Secret model. In Arkham Origins however, they not only refuse to add to what was experienced in Arkham City, but actively take away from it. During freeflow the Dark Knight, trained in tens of martial arts styles, will randomly punch the air instead of chaining his blow to another enemy, meaning you can potentially lose your combo at any moment from no fault of your own. On top of this, his countering has also been made worse, as you can no longer cancel a punch to react to an approaching blow behind you, with Batman instead helplessly allowing himself to be whacked in the back of the head like a rabbit caught in headlights. What's even worse is that enemies seem to be further away from you when they begin their attack, often coming from off-screen so you never get an opportunity to counter their blows anyway. This removes the sense of power and fluidity felt in City, leaving you instead feeling like a mentally challenge Panda flailing desperately and relying on your thick skull to lessen the blows rather than simply preventing them. Furthermore, enemies have largely gone back to tacking you one at a time, with me only have to do a double counter about three times during the course of the entire game. While it could be argued this was intentional to demonstrate how Batman isn't as far into his career, enjoyment and gameplay should not be sacrificed for the sake of continuity, especially when there are so many continuity issues later in the game anyway. Speaking of which...

4. Huge Continuity Errors

Bane Arghh this stuff is painful. Here the writers not only show they know nothing about the character they're writing for, but also that they've not even paid much attention to what happened in the other Arkham games. If you remember Arkham Asylum in any detail you'll know Bane was transformed from a relatively normal sized man into a hulking monster by the Joker, who seriously overdosed him with venom in order to cause him to be infuriated and attack Batman. Well in Arkham Origins, set many years before Asylum, (*minor spoilers*) Bane transforms himself into the said monstrosity after losing a fight with Batman and injecting himself with a concentrated dose of venom, a change confirmed to be permanent at the end when we see him still huge despite the venom having worn off. This makes absolutely no sense and shows the writers didn't even have a basic knowledge of Bane's continuity in the Arkham universe, presumptuously only having seen a picture of what Bane looked like in the earlier games and thinking, 'Oh that is cool, we should explain how he got like that,' failing to understand the explanation had already been done. Another major issue comes from a tape featuring Quincy Sharp. Those of you who played City will know he was manipulated/hypnotised by Hugo Strange into running for Mayor, yet apparently the writers weren't aware of this, as they suggest (Arkham City *spoilers*) he was recruited by Shiva of the League of Shadows, despite the fact Quincy clearly has no knowledge of the League in the other games. This sort of mistake would be irritating even in a fan produced product, so being present in a game such as this is absolutely pathetic. I should not know more about a franchise than those writing its sequel (or prequel, in this case), so please Warner Bros., if you're going to hire talentless writers, please make sure they are at least familiar with the universe they're writing in. These sort of mistake not only the Arkham games look bad, but both you and the Batman franchise in general.

3. Boring Boss Fights

Firefly Arkham Origins You remember how the boss fights in Arkham Asylum were kinda rubbish? Yeah, and then how they listened to people's complaints and made them original and really fun to play in Arkham City? Well guess how they built on this great standard they set for themselves?! That's right! They didn't. One of the highlights in City was the fight with Solomon Grundy, and even in Asylum the boss fights had a finesse that at least attempted to do something different. Unfortunately, rather than adopting the desire for pleasing fans and creating something original Rocksteady had, Montreal have given us a game where the boss fights are indistinguishable from those found in absolutely any other title in the genre. The vast majority of the boss fights have you simply punch the enemy until you win, performing QTEs every now-and-again to cement the feeling of playing a none-bloody God of War clone. People buy Batman games to play as Batman, not to play as any generic hero, and that is a concept nobody involved in the production of this game seems to have grasped. Admittedly two fights change things up slightly, with the Firefly fight having you use a gadget and the third Bane battle (or perhaps it was the fourth, I lost count) having you do things slightly different to take them down. Saying that, Firefly is possibly one of the most boring fights I have ever experienced, as once you figure out what to do (and by 'figure out' I mean get told by a huge bloody pop-up) it is simply a process of doing that same thing over and over until you win. The Bane fight, on the other hand, could perhaps be considered semi-enjoyable, with a time-limit and feeling of helplessness creating an almost survival horror type felling, yet once you realise how little he takes off that fear evaporates and it becomes dull once more.

2. Money For Old Rope

Batman Arkham Origins 60093 Literally the only new part of this game is detective mode, which consists of the same scanning in the first game but this time what you need to scan has a huge red triangle above it and you can fast-forward/rewind crime-scenes to see how crimes took place. This is fun exactly once, which is during a story mission (during the three mission period where the story is good), and at all other points it is monotonous at best. As I said early, there is nothing new in the combat, and the flight is identical to previous games. Gadget wise there are two new ones, though one is actually just a worse version of the line-launcher from Asylum/City, with you now only able to use it when you see two useless metal blobs sticking out of walls opposite each other. The second are electric gloves which allow you to punch through armour, shields, and electronic batons, which raises another continuity issue as it makes no sense that he would discard such a useful tool in later games. The side missions are all rip-offs of those from City, with Anarky's being identical to Zsasz, Deadshot's (because a bunch of the assassins aren't actually in the main plot) being near identical to the fight with Two-Face, the Riddler has his collectibles but without the hostage situations or any sort of challenge to getting the collectibles, and the rest are the same as Bane's 'find these things and blow them up' levels, with the exception of Shiva and Hatter, who rip off Riddler's hostage situations and Scarecrows hallucinations respectively. Origins may just be a really terrible version of Arkham City, yet you may be thinking, "Wait, he hasn't mentioned the story! Perhaps the game is worth buying for that!" well, my dear, optimistic children, we still have one reason left...

1. The Plot is Nonsensical

Batman Arkham Origins2 I bought this game on the premise we were sold, i.e. that Black Mask was sick of Batman interfering and had hired a bunch of assassins to take him out. Well that plot actually disappears pretty quickly, and what we're left with is a confusing convoluted mess. First off, let's address something basic that needs to be gotten out the way: this game wants us to believe Batman met Penguin, Joker, Mad Hatter, Riddler, and Anarky for the first time on the same night (along with at least seven of the other assassins), which, while not impossible, is ridiculous. Now that minor quarrel is passed, let's move on to the serious stuff. Black Mask, the Falcones, and Penguin are the major powers in Gotham, and Batman has spent the last two years damaging their empires and trying to bring them down, an endeavour that has gone so well the Falcones are pretty much completely gone. Bats has made enough of a name for himself for Anarky, a teenager (which is meant to be a twist but is obvious from his voice), knows all about him and where he can be found, as does Mad Hatter. Despite this, we are meant to believe Penguin has never heard of Batman before tonight, with him calling one of his goons a liar when he claims to have seen a giant bat. This makes absolutely no sense. How could a small time business owner (Hatter) know about Batman and Penguin, who the Dark Knight has spent the last two years sabotaging and supposedly has eyes all over the city, doesn't even know of his existence? Again, this is a secondary problem with the plot, but it does add to the pile of illogical dog turd Warner Bros. are trying to pass off as a story. Another major issue is Bane. Batman doesn't know what venom is, we discover later in the game, yet he has clearly encountered Bane before, as we know from when he first talks about the villain and how Bane says he has been after Batman for a long time. This, again, makes no sense. If they met before, Batman would know of venom, as Bane's entire persona and crime syndicate orientates around the damn stuff, but if they hadn't met Bane's obsession and willingness to damage pursuit of Batman make no sense. In conjunction with this rubbish, Bane continues to go after Batman even when the promise of money is no longer available, showing he must have some deeper motivation to break the bat, yet it is never explained what this motivation is. As a result it becomes very hard to be invested in the plot (I use the term loosely), as there is no way to know why he is doing what he's doing, which is a massive issue given he's one of the game's primary antagonists. Without spoiling anything, there's a section where Bane and Joker work together to kill the Dark Knight. Then, for no reason whatsoever, Bane attempts to kill Joker, a move that, if it was successful, would have been extremely harmful to his own plans. The move makes no sense and is only there to allow a major plot point to follow, though the point could have been achieved in countless other ways that actually DO make sense, so why the writers chose to do this I shall never understand. The main issue is, as I said earlier, the assassin plot disappears half way through. There's a period in a bank and hotel that are genuinely enjoyable and round off the story quite nicely, but after this point the game just... keeps going. The side mission villains say things like, "Don't you have a city to save? Why are bothering with me?" despite the fact Gotham is in no danger whatsoever, and nothing that goes on is particularly interesting or makes much sense. There's a point (*spoiler*) where we are supposed to believe Alfred is dead, which is rather like the point in Valkyrie when they tried to create suspense as to whether Hitler died in 1942 or not, as we all know they lived and there is no chance of any effect taking place. It comes across the writers got past the hotel section and went, "oh darn, this isn't long enough for a full game," so added about ten hours of padding to go after. There is no sense of a plan, no sense of the building tension in previous games, with the plot being even more schizophrenic than the characters it portrays. Moving on, two of the assassins are side-missions, which can be completed well after the point they would know no money can possibly be gained, and the rest of the assassins turn up for about five minutes each in the main story and then get knocked out. Even Deathstroke, who is a major poster boy for the game, makes one brief appearance a few hours in then gets a post credits scene, making his prominence in the advertising completely unjustifiable. Troy Baker said on twitter, "There are moments in this game that I think stand shoulder to shoulder with The Killing Joke", which is a great summary of how oblivious the people involved in this project really were/are, along with how little they have experienced of the Batman comics. The Killing Joke is a stand-out piece of Batman history, Arkham Origins is a convoluted, confused video game that fails to achieve the standards of even a Tim Burton Batman movie. As I don't want to only show one side of the story, I should point out the voice acting is pretty good (though it's undermined by the terrible dialogue) and it's not quite as bad as the Batman and Robin movie. If you think those two points outweigh all the others I've made, buy it, if not, do something less wasteful with you money. Like burn it. What are your opinions on the game? Did we miss any issues? Let us know in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Oldfield is a journalist, reviewer, and amateur comic-book writer (meaning he's yet to be published). He's a man who'll criticise anything, even this biog, which he thinks is a bit crap. For notifications on when new articles are up and game related news, follow him on his Twitter account @DunDunDUH