Battlefield 1: 9 Big Worries We Have After The Beta
Hey DICE? You got some Battlefront in my Battlefield.
Okay, so Battlefield 1 may not be returning to the historic war period that everyone perhaps wanted, but it does still feature bayonets, bolt-action rifles and slower-than-a-snail vehicles, so the only thing we're really missing from that other abhorrent conflict is the ability to mow down endless numbers of fascist, goose-stepping Nazis.
With the pre-release beta period now over, advocates of the shooter's non-futuristic setting have had plenty of time to go hands-on with the Great War setting, but is it all it's cracked up to be?
As a longtime fan of the Battlefield franchise and the FPS genre as a whole, I'm not so sure. There's a great deal of praise to be heaped on DICE for its dedication to authentic sound and visual design, but as my total play time increased, so too, did my concern in regards to the rough nature of its underlying gameplay mechanics and balance.
I've been left with several questions following the conclusion of the beta, some small, others major. If DICE truly wants Battlefield 1 to contend for title of 2016's greatest shooter, it needs to address some of these...
--
9. Snipers, Snipers Everywhere

The abundance of players choosing to deploy into Battlefield 1's Sinai Desert map as the Scout class shouldn't really come as any surprise. I mean, when you're presented with a map that's made up of 90% sand and 10% brick, how could you, or anyone, possibly resist taking advantage of all that open space that serves as a breeding ground for long range combat?
Unless you purposefully refrain from leaving the confines of a small collection of buildings in the north eastern portion of the map, it's almost a given that you're going to get domed as soon as any attempt at relocation is attempted.
Of course, these issues all largely come down to the terribly lopsided nature of the Sinai map rather than the Scout class itself, but if future stages feature the same level of imbalance, expect the same problem to occur with other archetypes.
8. The New Medic System

Mind-boggling, this one.
For whatever reason, DICE decided to mix-up the way in which the Medic class handles reviving downed teammates, making the whole process needlessly frustrating.
As it stands now, instead of being able to offer anyone who's spilled their brains all over the floor an instant second chance at life, dead comrades have to specifically indicate their desire to be brought back by the press of a button.
That may sound pretty inconsequential, but when you're under siege by an entire group of enemy soldiers, the last thing you want to be doing is standing there idle, like a lemon, twiddling your thumbs while fallen teammates decide whether they want to be stabbed in the arm with a medical syringe.
Just revert the system back to how it works in Battlefield 4 and 5 please, DICE.
7. Vehicle Balancing

With how many tools you're provided with in order to kill your enemies in modern shooters, it's hardly surprising that developers find it difficult to strike a perfect power equilibrium between vehicles, weapons and gadgets.
In the right hands, any tool of war can be an efficient one, but it appears as if Battlefield 1's planes, trains and automobiles have no middle ground: they're either devastatingly effective or about as useful as a chocolate teapot.
Take tanks, for instance. If you're unfortunate enough to be beset upon by one while you're on foot, you're basically a dead man walking unless you just so happen to be using the Assault class. Their access to dynamite can make quick work of any armored vehicle, but the nature of Sinai's layout gives little incentive to even pick the class in the first place.
On the flip side, nobody will even bother to bat an eyelid at an enemy tank that only has one person inside, given how laughably weak the driver's seat gun is, combined with several blind spots that are just impossible to cover on your lonesome.
6. Where's My Ticket?

With how fundamental the Conquest game mode is to the overall Battlefield experience, DICE knows they have to tread on eggshells when contemplating making even the slightest tweak to its formula.
Given that fact, it's surprising that the studio decided to completely remove the ticket scoring system that's been in place since, well, forever. Don't change what isn't broken, right?
With the system gone, there's no longer any team-wide penalty to a member of your team biting the bullet, as respawns no longer deduct from the total score. Likewise, capturing and holding points now only causes your team's score to rise at a steadier rate as opposed to putting pressure on the opposing side's counter.
One can only assume the change was made in order to place greater emphasis on objectives rather than racking up kills, but a sense of urgency has been lost in translation.
Here's to hoping DICE isn't averse to considering a reversion.
5. Sinai Is A Poor Choice Of Map

This has already been touched on in previous entries, but the observation deserves much more scrutiny than a passing mention. Sinai Desert isn't a good map - that's not just a subjective statement - it's plagued by issues involving imbalance and blandness.
The windswept and blood-soaked dunes of the Egyptian peninsula may look fantastic rendered in DICE's Frostbite engine, but what use is a gorgeous vista if you're not enjoying the time spent there?
As is the nature of deserts, a large portion of Sinai is devoid of anything other than sand and open space, so attempting to cross it on foot will likely achieve nothing other than a bullet in the head.
Yeah, you're best off just hiding among that small cluster of ruined buildings in the corner. Good idea, that way, enemy vehicles can just roll up to the front door and lay waste to your entire crew.
Don't bother trying to escape, there's a battalion of snipers just waiting for you poke your head out.
4. Bullet Sponge

Look, I hold my hands up - I'm no expert on military-grade weapons systems, especially when it comes to those used during the Great War.
With that said, I'm willing to go out on a limb and say that, in real life, it wouldn't take upwards of 20 shots from an anti-infantry turret to injure a single person, let alone kill them.
Now, I'm not suggesting that a single shot from any source should be an instant kill (that's what Hardcore is for, after all), but let's keep it at least somewhat realistic, eh?
Heavy-duty weapons shouldn't be something you just stroll past and ignore, they're sole purpose is, after all, to suppress attackers and defend objectives.
The same goes for horses, by the way. If I manage to lodge a sniper round firmly in the leg or head of one, I expect it to buckle and send its rider flying, not for it to continue galloping leisurely into the sunset.
3. Unwieldy Weapons

Credit where credit's due, DICE has so far done a bang-up job of making Battlefield 1 feel like an authentic, historic shooter. Weapons sound monstrous with each pull of the trigger, the stunning visuals give way to an unrivalled sense of spectacle and performance is top-notch.
But all of those positives seem to come at the expense of solid, finely-tuned gameplay.
As of now, it's already difficult to down enemies due to the relative weakness of most firearms, but not helping the matter is how alien some feel when placed in your hands.
For one reason or another, projectile spread seems to be all over the place, with bullets flying far wide of whatever target you happen to have in your iron sights; the issue being especially noticeable with single-shot weapons like the Medic's rifle.
I remain hopeful that DICE intends to take a second look at Battlefield 1's armoury in order to improve aim assist for the full release.
2. Know Your Enemy

I get it, Battlefield 1 takes place during a period in history where advanced radar technology and unmanned surveillance drones were the stuff of dreams for the military but, believe it or not, human beings still had ears during the dawn of the 20th century.
Right now, Battlefield 1's minimap is a borderline useless feature that does little to give players feedback on what's happening around them, as weapon fire no longer causes a red blip to pop up to designate which direction you're getting shot from.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not getting all bent out of shape over DICE's reluctance to be historically inaccurate; the inclusion of UAVs or satellite scans would be absurd - but our own auditory senses can easily pinpoint the direction from which a sound is coming.
1. Battlefield 1: Battlefront Edition

There was always bound to be some overlap between Star Was Battlefront and Battlefield 1, as besides the obvious that both games were crafted by the same developer, each runs on DICE's Frostbite engine.
That being the case, it's not at all surprising that DICE has decided to reuse various different texture assets and character skins for the latter. After all, what would be the point of making new sand and rock textures for Sinai Desert when plenty were already created for Battlefront's Jakku and Tatooine maps?
No, the worry here lies with everything else Battlefield 1 has borrowed from the galactic shooter. However inconsequential the similarities may appear to be at first glance, several generic character models have been lifted directly from Battlefront, and the user interface - along with the main menu - are almost identical.
The result has been a beta for a title that doesn't really have a heart or identity of its own. Lasers may have been replaced with bullets and lightsabers with swords, but Battlefield 1 feels very much like a game I've already spent countless hours playing since 2015.
--
What did you make of the beta? Let us know in the comments!