Battlefield 1 Review - 6 Ups & 4 Downs
Your move, Call of Duty.
Arriving with a combination of excitement and hand-wringing over whether or not it can top the better entries into the series while learning from the worst, Battlefield 1 is nothing if not a singular FPS experience.
In short, it's a cracking game that, despite a few issues, is probably the best FPS title to hit stores in 2016 so far, and certainly the most entertaining when it comes to the beyond-reproach multiplayer suite.
All in all, BF1 is a pleasant surprise, refusing to coast on formula and putting paid to that disappointingly uncommon World War 1 setting. While there's still Titanfall 2 and Call of Duty: Infinite Warfare to come, short of a miracle it looks like BF1 already has the year won.
Here are 6 ups and 4 downs from Battlefield 1...
--
Downs
4. Spawns Are A Mess
This probably shouldn't be too surprising considering it's a frequent issues with DICE's games, but yes, spawns in Battlefield 1 are not great (if I'm being kind), perhaps even a total clusterf*** (if I'm not).
While chaos is both expected and desired given the 64-player mayhem that ensues, it's still immensely frustrating spawning in the heart of combat only to be peppered with rifle rounds two seconds after you materialise.
Though there is a lot to be said for the ability to spawn on your squadmates to get right back into the action after dying, sadly conventional spawning is wildly inconsistent and frequently infuriating.
3. The Brutal Loading Times
You're going to want to have an iPad or phone nearby while playing BF1, because boy, the loading times sure are long as Hell.
Now, PC players may fare a little better here depending on their rig, but on consoles, loading times routinely pass the minute mark while trying to start a match.
While this frustration is lessened somewhat by the fact that matches can last up to an hour before you need to sit through another long load, they still feel excessive and stamina-drainingly dull if you've got nothing else to amuse yourself with.
Sadly there's not really much of a way to fix this, given how clearly the game is putting a technical strain on the PS4 and Xbox One.
2. The Tone Is All Over The Place
There's always that inherent discussion when it comes to games based on actual wars: Should gamers feel bad that they're basically being entertained by the real-life massacre of millions of people?
Well, to its credit, Battlefield 1's campaign engages fully with the idea of 'war as Hell', and mostly downplays the fist-pumping heroism that's popular in the genre.
However, there is an undeniable tonal dissonance between the more muted nature of the campaign and the bombastic mood of the multiplayer, which is all about awesome set-pieces and slaughtering a fleet of enemy soldiers in the coolest fashion possible.
Now, this is somewhat unavoidable given the nature of the game, but the mood differs substantially between the two modes, which can make switching between them feel a little weird for a short while.
1. "Return To The Combat Area"
A long-time frustration of DICE's games is the "Return to the combat area" warning screen if you venture out beyond what the game deems the bounds of battle.
The problem isn't that the game creates artificial restrictions on where you can move, but how transparently it does it, shooting you as a "deserter" if you linger beyond an invisible line for more than 10 seconds.
It's a lazy way to funnel players into a specific zone and is immensely immersion-breaking given how frequently you'll end up seeing the screen.
Thankfully the game is electrifying enough that these flaws can be overlooked. Here's everything Battlefield 1 totally nails...
Ups
6. The Campaign Is Surprisingly Good
The Battlefield franchise has historically either not even bothered with a proper campaign (beyond skirmishes against bots) or may as well not have, given how thoroughly tedious and piecemeal they've typically ended up.
Well, DICE finally got it right with BF1's collection of War Stories, telling a number of hour-long tales from WW1 with memorable characters, actual emotion, strong set-pieces and excellent voice acting.
It's not perfect by any means (the stealth sections aren't great), but it's a major step-up from the usual fare, and actually tries to do something ambitious with the standard war game campaign.
By compartmentalising the action and shifting perspectives, it ensures that staleness doesn't have much of a chance to set in. If this were the formula for all future BF campaigns, that'd be no bad thing.
5. War Pigeons Brilliantly Reinvents Capture The Flag
Arguably the most ludicrously enjoyable new mode is War Pigeons, a Capture-the-Flag-esque mode where teams attempt to keep hold of a pigeon long enough to write a message that calls in an artillery strike on the opposing team.
While the likes of Conquest and Operations are more epic and slow-paced, War Pigeons points all players towards a single target, resulting in a marvellously intense push-and-pull that's much more fast-moving than most other modes.
The tension and frantic insanity add up to make a potentially silly mode a boatload of fun, somewhat ridiculous though it is.
4. The Weapons Are Awesome
Last year's Star Wars Battlefront was almost universally derided for its rather lame selection of weapons and the utter lack of diversity between them.
Thankfully BF1 returns to the more considered loadout of the Battlefield games with an extremely varied selection of WW1 weapons, such as the ultra-satisfying bolt-action rifles and sub-machine guns of the era to name just two.
While it's a bit disappointing that customisation is rather on the limited side once again, it nevertheless perfectly captures an old-school feel for the most part, and gunplay is nothing if not ludicrously satisfying in the moment.
3. Operations Is The Most Battlefield Mode Ever
The new Operations mode mashes Rush and Conquest together in four battles taking place across several inter-connected maps, complete with pre-match cut-scenes and a generous dollop of historical context regarding the meaning of the fight.
It is, simply, one of the most epic multiplayer modes in the history of the FPS genre, touting a gigantic scale, excellent tug-of-war feel and undeniably addictive "just one more game" quality, even despite Operations matches potentially lasting around an hour. Before you know it, it's 4am and you're brushing your teeth while waiting for the next round to load.
And that's without even mentioning the brilliantly bonkers Behemoths. Speaking of which...
2. Behemoths Are Totally Insane
Behemoths are gigantic "super vehicles" which show up for a losing team when they're significantly trailing the other. They include a gigantic zeppelin and an armoured train, and can easily turn the tide of battle given how effortlessly they can mow down infantry (to the point that some have deemed them over-powered).
While they do prevent a substantial challenge to the team they're being inflicted on, it is extremely satisfying taking them out, especially the zeppelin, which will crash-land and devastate a significant chunk of the map (and anyone foolish enough to stand near it).
The game would still be excellent without this feature, but it's a fun flourish that can give the losing team a substantial morale boost while ensuring the winning team doesn't get too cocky.
1. It's Visually Gorgeous & Sounds Amazing
And of course, Battlefield 1 is yet another stylistic masterwork from DICE. Though the console versions do admittedly suffer from glaring frame-rate drops during intense combat and aren't remotely as good-looking as the PC version, it's still a gorgeous-looking title whatever platform you play it on.
Sound has also always been a strong suit of these titles, and BF1 is no exception: the gunfire and explosions have a real kick to them (especially if you're wearing headphones), the music fits the mood perfectly, and most surprising of all, the campaign voice acting is awesome.
A few minor quibbles do abound, though: some of the gun noises are blatantly recycled from previous games, and the voice-over announcer gets annoying after a while (especially in War Pigeon mode), but at least she can be turned off in the options menu.
--
What do you think of Battlefield 1 so far? Shout it out in the comments!