Bioshock Infinite: 10 Important Details You Didn't Notice

Pay close attention to the chords used during a certain sequence...

BIOSHOCK INFINITE
2K

BioShock was always going to be a hard act to follow. In the underwater metropolis of Rapture it produced one of the most iconic locations in the history of video gaming, a beautiful, breathtakingly ambitious dystopia as tragic as it is compelling.

In Andrew Ryan it produced one gaming’s most iconic villains, a brilliant, charismatic, fundamentally flawed visionary whose ultra-capitalist philosophy set the stage for one of the most penetrating examinations of capitalism and scientific ethics yet attempted by the medium.

Infinite was compelled to do better, and so it went big. Its setting is a floating metropolis even more beautiful than Rapture, its villain a man more dangerous and of far more horrifying charisma, and its themes of prejudice and predestination versus free will even more layered and complex.

That complexity resulted in a dense, often obtuse, experience of such mind-blowing detail that players never had a hope of finding, never mind comprehending, all there was to see, with the unfortunate result that many a fascinating bit of foreshadowing, subtext, and even common sense consequences, flew under the radar.

Well, no more. Time to take a deep dive into ten details that slipped by players but make the experience far more rich, far more rewarding, and prove there’s a lot more down the Infinite rabbit-hole than you thought.

--

Warning: Spoilers abound.

10. Booker And Comstock Are The Same Age

Bioshock Infinite Booker
2K Games

Now yes, fans will call nonsense on this. After all, Comstock is a man easily in his sixties, while Booker looks to be, at most, in his early forties. How can they be same age?

Well, it’s true. And, want to hear something really surprising? Booker – and Comstock – was sixteen when he fought at Wounded Knee.

How so?

According to Booker’s Pinkerton contract he was born in 1874. The Wounded Knee Massacre, also known as the Battle of Wounded Knee (a real-world tragedy), took place in 1890, placing Booker at the tender age of sixteen (yes, historically sixteen-year-olds were in the military).

Comstock, after his baptism, went on to launch Columbia in 1893. It was also at this time that he used the machine designed by Robert and Rosalind Lutece to look through tears into other universes.

Overuse of that machine led to rapid and severe ageing, not to mention cancer.

The events of Infinite take place in 1912, putting Booker’s age at a relatively young thirty-eight. Likewise, though physically he is at death’s door, the same is true for Comstock.

So next time you feel old, think of how much worse it could be.


9. Cornelius Slate Did Not Recognise That Comstock Was Once Booker

Bioshock Infinite
2K Games

Being a complex, dense, at times overwhelming beast of a game, it should come as no surprise that Infinite confused some people, and one of the most confusing details revolves around Cornelius Slate.

A staunch supporter of Comstock until Comstock painted himself as the hero of Wounded Knee and the Boxer Rebellion, Slate, citing the fact that Comstock did not fight during the Rebellion and was not present (as he believed) at Wounded Knee, quickly grew disillusioned, leading to him launching a full blown uprising.

But Booker DeWitt became Comstock, and he was at Wounded Knee, so why doesn’t Slate recognise him?

Because by the time Slate becomes his follower, Comstock had already suffered the rapid Tear-induced ageing that would render him unrecognisable.

The brilliance of this detail is that the contradiction only exists on a second play through: players who don’t know the truth don’t see the problem, but returning players do, which leads to confusion.

Confusion echoed by any person who travels from one universe to another and who, quote, “desperately struggle(s) to create memories where none exist…”

Whether this was intentional on Irrational Games’ part is up for debate, but one thing is certain: it’s not only Booker’s mind that is being messed with.


8. The Opening Quote By ‘R. Lutece’ Is From Robert, Not Rosalind

Bioshock infinite ending
2K

Infinite opens with this enigmatic quote:

“The mind of the subject will desperately struggle to create memories where none exist…” ― R. Lutece, Barriers to Trans-Dimensional Travel, 1889

As with much of what happens in Infinite this is a case of foreshadowing and thematic depth all in one, setting up both the reveal of Comstock as an alternate universe Booker and explaining the mechanics of the game’s infinite universes.

The mystery of who ‘R. Lutece’ is seems to be solved early on. Both the audio logs we discover and the kinetoscope shorts focus on Rosalind with no mention of a Robert Lutece, and with both sources drawing deliberate attention to her scientific prowess we naturally assume that she is the R. Lutece in question.

Instead, the quote originates with her alternate universe counterpart, Robert Lutece. When the Luteces pull Booker into Comstock’s universe his mind struggles to reconcile old memories with the new, prompting Robert to say that this confirms his theory, and in turn confirming that the quote came from Robert.

It’s an answer that comes late but lends enormous weight, and helps makes sense of Infinite’s climactic revelation of infinite doors and infinite universes.


7. The Ambush In Battleship Bay Contains A Clue Everyone Missed

bioshock infinite
2K

Early in the game players face a particularly brutal combat segment where Booker is ambushed by Columbian soldiers posing as civilians in an attempt to recapture Elizabeth.

It is a fight telegraphed in as blindingly obvious a manner as is possible. Players enter an area filled with strangely tense people whose hostile scrutiny is as glaringly unsubtle as only people desperately trying not be obvious are capable of. Some of the attempts are hilarious, such as two people awkwardly pretending to be a hot dog vendor and his customer.

Others are less so, with the cashier’s ominous and threatening dialogue on the phone.

But the vast majority of players would have missed the most obvious clue:

The white man sweeping the floor.

In modern society this would pass without comment, but in 1912 Columbia, where minorities such as Irish and black people do all the menial work, this is a dead give away.

That realization, once it sets in, hits hard and it is a credit to Irrational Games’ clever use of modern norms that they were able to hide a giant red flag, and the cutting indictment of Columbia’s racist society that comes with it, in plain sight.


6. Booker And Comstock Are Not The Same Person, Literally And Thematically

zachary hale comstock bioshock infinite
Irrational Games

The reveal that the Booker you’ve been playing as and the Father Comstock you’ve been fighting against are one and the same is one of gaming’s most mind-bending moments, earning it a guaranteed entry on many a gaming list.

But there is an important sub text being missed, one that ties intimately into Infinite’s themes of predestination and free will.

See, Booker and Comstock are two possible results of a choice a young Booker DeWitt makes after the Wounded Knee Massacre. If he is baptised he becomes Comstock. If he rejects the baptism, he becomes the Booker DeWitt we know.

It is Comstock’s meddling with reality that leads to the game’s multiple universe-spanning mess, which the Luteces in turn attempt to fix, which in turn results in a loop, which sees Booker after Booker failing to defeat Comstock.

But the Booker we play as is the one who ultimately succeeds in his mission to stop Comstock by choosing to die. Thematically, psychologically and physically, this makes them two very different people.

It is a subtle, but profound distinction, one that highlights the primacy of choice over predestination. It is, after all, variables that change the outcome of an equation, not constants.


5. Booker Rains Hell Down On Those Below

Bioshock Infinite
Irrational Games

As a city set among the clouds Columbia is naturally one of gaming’s most exotic locations, with bright sunshine overhead and stunning views below.

But its that very altitude that becomes a problem, because with Columbia’s flight path taking it over major population centres, including New York, Chicago, and Portland, Maine, all those enemies you punt overboard, all those cargo containers knocked off of skylines, the thousands of rounds of ammunition expended, not to mention the stories-tall metal chunk of Elizabeth’s wrecked tower, all plummet to the ground killing, tens, perhaps hundreds of people.

What’s worse are the Handymen and Motorized Patriots which also fall to the ground. Should they survive (and both are tough) you now have crazed iron gorillas and Terminator-esque walking machine-gun platforms rampaging through a terrified populace.

And even if people aren’t crushed by falling debris or murdered by twisted abominations the horror of coming across tens of mangled corpses would be just as bad.

It’s a simple thing to miss but as with many things in Infinite there’s a sting in the detail, one that ensures you wont’ look at the game, and high-rise fights in any other, in the same way again.


4. Every Song Has Intended, Hidden Meaning

Bioshock Infinite Elizabeth Dancing
2K Games

Many games use licensed songs to set a mood appropriate to the period they’re depicting. But Infinite, like BioShock before it, goes further, using music not only to set the mood but also to build the world.

As an example, when Elizabeth first opens a Tear we hear Tears For Fears’ “Everybody Wants To Rule The World.” The meaning is plain enough: fears at the sight of tears – pronounced ‘Tears,’ as in rip – is exactly what Booker feels at that moment. More ominously in hindsight is the fact that an alternate universe Elizabeth does bring New York, and possibly the world, to its knees.

Another example is “Bonnie Blue Flag.” A favourite among Confederate soldiers during the American Civil War, it is heard outside of the Hall of Heroes ...a propaganda exhibit absolutely drenched in racism.

Yet another example comes from Battleship Bay where a calliope is playing a cover of Cyndi Lauper’s “Girls Just Wanna Have Fun.” This is where we see Elizabeth dancing, finally free after having escaped her tower.

Every song in Infinite is a similar rabbit hole of meaning and it is attention to detail like this that has made BioShock one of gaming’s classic franchises.


3. The Plot Is Foreshadowed, And Explained, Within The First Three Minutes

Bioshock Infinite
2K

Unlike BioShock’s fiery arrival at its lighthouse, Infinite’s sedate row through gloomy seas is far less dramatic. The drama, however, is not in the arrival, but in your companions’ conversation.

One, a man, insists that experiments can fail, to which the other, a woman, retorts that one does not undertake an experiment knowing one has failed. The conversation continues, with the man complaining about have to do the rowing, being told that he should ask Booker for help, and responding by saying that Booker never does.

The first time through, this is completely incomprehensible. But the second time you understand exactly what is being said.

We learn that the Luteces have sent 122 versions of Booker against Comstock, only to see them all try and fail. That means that a version of Booker has been in that same boat, taking that exact same journey, over one hundred times, and not once does he ever help with the rowing.

Booker, like the player, knows none of this until near the end of the game.

It’s a ballsy move to wave your plot under player’ noses, but that Irrational Games pulled it off shows just how much thought went into the game and provides ample motivation for experiencing Columbia a second time.


2. There Is Subtle, Early Hint That The Lutece Twins Are Not Quite Alive

bioshock infinite
2K

The eccentric Lutece twins are one of the game’s many highlights, a witty, deceptively powerful duo with a love of things philosophical who guide Booker and Elizabeth through their adventures in Columbia and who are central to the game’s plot.

And in a stunning end-game reveal you learn that they are both dead...in a manner of speaking.

When you first meet them in Columbia, the duo rope you into a game of heads or tails, a game where the coin always comes up heads.

This is a reference to the play, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Dead, where an equally eccentric, witty and philosophical duo, in a play with similar themes of predestination and free will, play a game of heads and tails with the exact same result.

Come the end of the play Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are both executed, echoing what has already happened to the Luteces.

Though no doubt lost on the vast majority of players, this slick bit of exposition will be obvious to those who enjoy their theatre, offering a delightfully clever insight into exactly how the Luteces are able to do the seemingly impossible, and what is truly going in Columbia.


1. There’s More To Bird And Cage Than Simple Choice

Bioshock Infinite
2K

Well received as it was, Infinite took some flack from players for offering seemingly intriguing symbolic choices but failing to follow up by having those choices come to nothing.

The most glaring example is the brooch players are asked to choose for Elizabeth, one in the shape of a bird and the other a cage, a choice with a straightforward, if still mind-bending, cosmetic consequence.

But there is far more here than a simple choice.

An early 20th century toy (the game is set in 1912) featured a card on a string with a bird printed on one side and a cage on the other. Twist the string and the card flips rapidly back and forth, creating the illusion of a bird in a cage.

Near the end of the game, Songbird, Elizabeth’s jailer, is used to destroy the remains of her tower, thus giving her full use of her powers and allowing her to kill him.

Now, the notes she uses to control him? C-A-G-E. And the tower? Her own former cage. Ergo, the bird flew into the cage, ironically un-caging her powers, and allowing her to crush them both.

The choice was less about a brooch, and more about what was coming.

It’s a brilliant bit of foreshadowing, and provides ample proof that Infinite should never be taken at face value alone.


Contributor

Marcellus Huisamen hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.