Black Ops 2: Is Call Of Duty Just For Idiots?
1. It Sells Too Many
So far, as expected, Black Ops II has sold like delicious FPS hot-cakes: according to Activision, the game made an enormous $500million in its first day of release making it the biggest launch of the year, by their reckoning. Naturally that has led to the intelligent commentary that it's just sheep, under 12s and idiots with no imagination who have flocked to their local retailers to get their hands on a copy - because how else could you explain such a jaw-dropping number of sales on the day of launch? So, does that mean it's for idiots? Verdict: Well, in a word no. No matter how much the cynics, snobs and hipsters will tell you, popularity has never been a sign of a lack of quality. The unfortunate result of Call of Duty's success as a franchise (and indeed most franchises that bring out regular or even semi-regular new additions) and Activision's success in making the games accessible, is that there has been the inevitable push-back that results in any mass popularity. But Call of Duty sells well every year because the games - or at least elements of them - are loved every year. Regardless of what the troll-heavy user reviews you'll find online might suggest, nobody buys games every year from a franchise that repeatedly lets them down just to make sure they're still rubbish: consumerism simply doesn't work like that, and players will simply turn their back on franchises instead. That is why previously successful franchises die, it isn't a trick of the market. It isn't idiots who buy Call of Duty games, it is fans, and the two are not the same thing, regardless of what COD haters might suggest.2. The Campaign/Multiplayer Imbalance
This is probably the only point in this article that really holds some weight. Unfortunately, the compromise in the quality of the campaign, which should by rights be the key mode of the entire package (based on conventional wisdom anyway) is disappointing, and for someone who doesn't buy COD games in order to play online, it feels a little like Treyarch have focused too much on the other modes and lost something from what should have been their main concern. But does buying and enjoying a game that has too much focus on the online portion make its fans idiotic? Are they somehow stupid for investing $50 a year in a glorified online game that comes with limited maps and a comparatively tiny level of depth compared to MMORPGs? Well, not really. For me, it is a shame that Treyarch have put so much focus in the online mode, to the detriment of the campaign, which will always be the first thing I look for - but the campaign is still engaging enough, and I can recognise the general appeal of the online mode to those who are fans of that side of the game. The simple truth is that Call of Duty's online element is a massive part of the industry - it can rightly be considered a phenomenon, and the sheer number of players who continue to play online well after other games (even the most commercially successful) have lost their appeal and the majority of their dedicated fanbase. Catering for that strong community is just a good decision, and the voices of discontent that would greet a lighter-weight online side of the game would have been a lot louder than my own disappointment in the game's current imbalance. Verdict: Activision are creating a supply for a huge demand, and just because they and Treyarch may have focused this time more on online play rather than campaign doesn't necessarily mean they are feeding the needs of idiots. The burgeoning E-Sports community proves that that sort of competitive gaming is a big deal, and simply dismissing something as similar as the online COD gaming as somehow low-brow is just foolish bluster.
3. The Lack Of Realism?
Something that the Call of Duty franchise has faced for years is the accusations from fans of rival games like Battlefield 3 that the games aren't as realistic as competitors (the same basis of most football game fans' criticisms of either FIFA or PES), and that the more arcade-like gameplay (which is the type of massive exaggeration that tends to come with online COD criticism) is somehow evidence of the lesser brain capacity of its players. The presence of the zombies mode - a much-loved new addition in recent games - seems to have added fuel to this particular troll fire. Verdict: Since when do games have to be realistic? Since the likes of Medal of Honor and Battlefield started to square up with Call of Duty in the quest to become the best military/historical shooter on the market, there has been a noticeable shift towards grit and realism, culminating in games such as Spec Ops: The Line that seem to be more invested in a politicised message than in pure entertainment. The fact that COD refuses to sacrifice the element of fun that should always come with gaming in a vain aim to capture as much realism as possible does not mean that it is any less smart than its competitors. After all, war isn't exactly supposed to be fun, so a realistic representation wouldn't necessarily be as entertaining. And zombies, especially in its newly revamped form, is an absolute hoot.
4. The Perceived Lack Of Progression
Scroll through the User reviews on Metacritic (and there are some hilarious, and clearly made-up ones in there), and it becomes immediately evident that a good deal of those reviewers are criticising Black Ops II based on it being the "same garbage as every year." Those same reviews talk of an out-dated engine, poor graphics and the same stunted gameplay as every year, and yet some of the reviews that have appeared online from reputable outlets (more of which later) have praised the game for its intentions to change the franchise, and its pushing of the boundaries of this generation of consoles. For my own money, Black Ops II is a massive achievement, because of what came before it: Modern Warfare 3 was a curiously empty experience that embodied a lot of the problems that regular COD critics drum out every single year, and it was the biggest rallying call for a change to the COD model as Treyarch could have ever wanted. Critics of the franchise (and usually those who critique without playing, or come into the game with impenetrable blinkers) might suggest that we are all idiots for buying a game that never changes, and they would perhaps have a point if it really was the case. But is it really true to say Call of Duty never changes in any other way than its surface? Verdict: The zombies mode is massively expanded, the storyline and setting offer brand new and engaging elements, and the new game modes make Black Ops II a strong contender for this generation's best COD title. It is also a darn-sight more different than MW3, and Treyarch should be commended for their attempts to do something different, and even more heartily for achieving it. I refuse to accept that I, and the game's fans are idiots because COD never changes - because on the evidence of Black Ops II, there is certainly room for change in the world of COD. Hopefully, the next generation will see an even more pronounced change for the next COD title, but for now, I'm more than happy recommending the game as a new, different COD experience.5. The "Hardcore" Opinion Of The Game
Bring any Call of Duty title released after World At War (i.e. the most popular of the franchise) up in conversation in a group of gamers, and you can pretty much guarantee that someone will act disgusted, announcing themselves way too insistently not to be a fan of such a "sell-out" franchise that represents little more than a yearly DLC release campaign dressed up in different, more expensive clothing. They are the type of people who would probably suggest themselves to be so-called "hardcore" gamers, who prefer the likes of Halo, Battlefield and Skyrim for their action thrills - and more power to them for their opinions, as those games are great. But when those opinions are based on nothing - a lot of this type of gamer will admit they haven't played any COD titles since before Modern Warfare - they should be classed as nothing more than the redundant musings of the ill-informed. You can't tell anyone how good or bad anything is unless you experience it, and unfortunately, a lot of gamers use the annual release of a COD title as an excuse to get their outraged flame on and take to the internet to badmouth not only the game, but also the COD gamers. Verdict: Who is the idiot really? The guy willing to give a game a chance, regardless of what some of his snobbier gamer buddies might be saying about it, or the annoying, smug elitist who immediately jumps on a COD game's case simply because of its heritage and title? The answer is pretty clear to me. Here's a tip: base your opinion on time spent playing the game: pre-judgement based on nothing other than the name of a game (as opposed to insightful previews) is of very little use to anyone. Thanks to the age of the internet of course, such a tip will likely fall on deaf ears.
6. The "Professional" Reviews
I have to admit, I'm not one to listen to other reviews - perhaps it's the arrogance of someone deemed a "critic" because of what my job here entails - and very rarely have I ever based a purchase decision on someone other than a friend's opinion. But the huge disparity between some of the user reviews on Metacritic (even ignoring the obvious troll comments), and the so-called professional sites drew my attention - how come reviewers seemed to be enjoying or recommending a game that so many users were giving 0-2 out of 10? Presumably, judging by those user reviews, the professional sites must merely have enjoyed the game thanks to its disposable appeal, and despite its obvious, well-publicized problems? Let's see what they actually said...GameTrailers: "It does so many new things so very well, making it the most groundbreaking Call of Duty since the first Modern Warfare. Shooters simply don't get much more deep, varied, surprising, or rewarding than this." IGN: "Combined with the host of subtle and overt improvements to the array of other systems, the additions to make it more appealing to Esports, and the more fleshed out Zombies mode, this is not just a fantastic Call of Duty game, but one of the best shooters of the last decade." Official XBox Magazine: "Call of Duty's three-pronged attack serves it well in Black Ops II, with the superb online play and Zombies co-op making up for a less-essential campaign this time - though its many changes and occasional high points still warrant a playthrough (or two) to see Treyarch's spin on the well-worn template." Eurogamer: "Ultimately, ambition is the word that best describes Black Ops 2 - and that's remarkable enough in itself. This is still Call of Duty, with all that entails, and anyone who has resisted the series so far likely won't be won over this time either. For the fans, though, Black Ops 2 offers the rare sight of a series at its height choosing to experiment and change rather than stay loyal to a proven, but tired, formula." Edge: "Backed by Activision's fantastic investment and support, Treyarch has succeeded, and made a sort of ultimate current-gen Call Of Duty. Not a reinvention that, hopefully, comes next year, on box-fresh hardware and a new engine but a refinement of the most successful series of its generation. Black Ops II is an excellent Call Of Duty game, then, but it's only a Call Of Duty game, with all that implies."Are these reputable outlets suddenly idiots for enjoying the game? Or could it be, God forbid, that some people actually enjoyed a game that others had been saying since announcement would be a massive failure? The difference with these reviews in comparison with the the majority of the user reviews is that they actually look under the hood of the game, rather than simply slating it in a bite-sized morsel of a review. Verdict: Some outlets might not be quite as taken on the game as others, but with a solid 83 critical score on Metacritic, and some of the most reputable game sites offering shining reviews, it seems that the game actually appeals to the type of people who actually like games. Those reviews are not simply based on the brand's strength and you'd have to suspect that the reviewers are not the kind of fans who come back every year no matter what, so it's extremely difficult to explain it's score as a product as such. Read on for my final thoughts on the matter...
Conclusion
While Modern Warfare 3 upset a lot of Call of Duty fans, and those who enjoyed the game, like myself, but who would never actively call themselves a fan, and despite accusations that the franchise is on its last legs, Black Ops II is a very good game. Yes, it has its problems, chiefly in the occasionally undercooked campaign, but the game offers more than enough to suggest that there is still more than enough life left in the series, and that the next generation of consoles will see further commercially successful COD titles. Because based on the strengths of this game, fans will once more look forward to the next release. So, are we all idiots for enjoying the game? Is Activision at the head of a conspiracy to buy good reviews for their games to dupe the gaming community into shelling out for their latest under-developed annual COD DLC? No, of course we aren't and of course they aren't (I certainly haven't seen any of that money) - even though it is not sufficient to suggest that the massive sales figures imply quality, the reviews don't lie, and Black Ops II will go down for some sites as one of the finest FPS titles of the year. And that's in a market that is a million miles past saturation. As long as almost every point that the so-called haters bring up to suggest that Black Ops II fans are idiots can be addressed intelligently, it seems ludicrous to suggest that their opinions of the COD playing community are correct. So no, in short, Call of Duty is not just for idiots. And shame on you for thinking as much, if you do. Call of Duty: Black Ops II is out now.